Design of Hydraulic Scissor Lift PDF
Design of Hydraulic Scissor Lift PDF
Design of Hydraulic Scissor Lift PDF
College of Engineering
School of Mechanical Engineering
(Production Department)
Prepared by:
1. Amr Awadelkarim Mahmoud
2. Elsadig Mahir Ali Salih
3. Hassan Motwakil Hassan Moneer
Supervisor:
October 2017
اآلية
ii
Dedication
Our brothers, sisters and our best friends, without them none of
our success will be possible.
iii
Acknowledgement
All praise and thanks to Allah who provide us with the ability to
complete this work. We are thankful to our families who are always
Their patience and advises on our research and writing this thesis
have been invaluable.
iv
ABSTRACT
v
المستخلص
يركز هذا البحث بشكل اساسي على فعل القوة المؤثرة على الرافعة الهيدروليكية المقصية عند
التمدد واالنقباض.
بصورة عامة ,تعمل الرافعة الهيدروليكية المقصية على رفع وحمل االحمال الثقيلة .اختيار المواد
يلعب دو ار رئيسيا في تصميم المنظومة والتاثير على عوامل عديدة مثل :التحمل والمقاومة والموثوقية التي
تعمل على امكانية الرفع.
والتحليل SOLIDWORKتم التصميم على ان تكون االحمال متوسطة ,وذلك باستخدام برنامج
بواسطة برنامج االنسيس لحساب جميع االحمال واالجهادات ,وكذلك حساب جميع المعامالت لضمان
انسجام المنظومة.
vi
Table of Contents
اآلية........................................................................................................................................................... ii
Acknowledgement ................................................................................................................................. iv
ABSTRACT............................................................................................................................................ v
المستخلص.................................................................................................................................................. vi
Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................. vii
List of tables:.......................................................................................................................................... ix
List of figures: ......................................................................................................................................... x
Chapter One ............................................................................................................................................ 1
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................................. 1
1.1 Introduction: ............................................................................................................................... 2
1.2 Problem Statement: .................................................................................................................... 3
1.3 Scope of the Study:...................................................................................................................... 3
1.4 Objective of the Project: ............................................................................................................. 3
1.5 Significance of the Study: ........................................................................................................... 3
1.6 Project Layout:............................................................................................................................ 4
Chapter Two............................................................................................................................................ 5
CHAPTER TWO .................................................................................................................................... 6
LITERATURE REVIEW ....................................................................................................................... 7
2.1 Introduction: ................................................................................................................ 6
2.2 Upright’s Scissor Lift: ................................................................................................... 6
2.3 Scaffold: ....................................................................................................................... 7
2.4 Boom Lift: .................................................................................................................... 9
2.4.1 The Straight Boom Lift: .......................................................................................... 9
2.4.2 Articulated Boom Lift: ...........................................................................................10
2.5 Mechanical Scissors Lift: ..............................................................................................11
2.6 Hydraulic Lift:.............................................................................................................12
2.7 Hydraulic Scissors Lift: ................................................................................................13
Chapter three ......................................................................................................................................... 14
METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................................................... 15
3.1 Methodology Flow Chart: ............................................................................................16
3.2 Design Theory: ............................................................................................................16
3.2.1 Mechanical System: ...............................................................................................16
3.2.2 Hydraulic system: ..................................................................................................17
vii
3.3 Assumptions of the design: ...........................................................................................21
3.4 Material Selection: .......................................................................................................22
3.4.1 Choice of stainless and mild steel: ...........................................................................22
3.5 Cylinder Selection: .......................................................................................................23
3.5.1 Single Acting Cylinder: ..........................................................................................23
3.5.2 Double Acting Cylinder: ........................................................................................24
3.6 Mathematical Model: ...................................................................................................24
3.6.1 Mechanical Design: ................................................................................................24
3.5.2 Hydraulic Design: ..................................................................................................24
CHAPTER FOUR................................................................................................................................. 29
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ........................................................................................................... 29
4.1 Design Calculations:.....................................................................................................29
4.1.1 The force: ..............................................................................................................29
4.1.2 Cylinder diameter:.................................................................................................29
4.1.3 Velocity of the piston: ............................................................................................29
4.1.4 Rod diameter:........................................................................................................29
4.2 Mechanical Analysis: ...................................................................................................29
4.2.1 Mesh (Moderate Mesh): .........................................................................................29
4.2.2 Simulation Results .................................................................................................30
4.3 Hydraulic circuit: ........................................................................................................35
4.3.1 Cylinder Configuration: .........................................................................................35
4.3.2 Configure Way Valve:............................................................................................40
4.3.3 Hydraulic Resistance: ............................................................................................40
4.3.4 Pump Unit: ............................................................................................................41
4.3.5 Reservoir:..............................................................................................................41
4.3.6 Fixed Displacement Pump: .....................................................................................42
4.3.7 Operation of the circuit: .........................................................................................42
4.4 Discussion:...................................................................................................................44
Chapter Five .......................................................................................................................................... 45
Conclusion and Recommendation ........................................................................................................ 45
5.1 Conclusion:..................................................................................................................46
5.2 Recommendation: ........................................................................................................46
5.3 References: ..................................................................................................................47
viii
List of tables:
Table1 .1 project layout (Gantt chart 2016-2017) .............................................................................. 4
Table 2 Standard values of cylinder diameter, rod diameter. ........................................................ 26
Table 3 Standard values of cylinder diameter, rod diameter, force and flow rate, ...................... 27
ix
List of figures:
Figure 1 (Upright scissors lift) ............................................................................................................. 7
Figure2 (scaffold) .................................................................................................................................. 8
Figure 3 (Straight Boom Lift) ............................................................................................................ 10
Figure 4 (Articulated Boom Lift) ....................................................................................................... 11
Figure 5 (Mechanical Scissors Lift) ................................................................................................... 12
Figure 6 (Hydraulic Lift) .................................................................................................................... 13
Figure7 (Hydraulic Scissor Lift) ....................................................................................................... 14
Figure 8 (Methodology Flow Chart)................................................................................................. 16
Figure 9 (System Parts) ..................................................................................................................... 17
Figure10 (Mechanical Assembly Sketch) ......................................................................................... 19
Figure 11 (Hydraulic Circuit Components)...................................................................................... 21
Figure12 (Mesh) ................................................................................................................................. 30
Figure13 (Total Deformation) ........................................................................................................... 31
Figure14 (Maximum Principe Stress) .............................................................................................. 32
Figure15 (Minimum Principle Stress) .............................................................................................. 33
Figure16 (Maximum Principle Elastic Strain) ................................................................................ 34
Figure17 (Minimum Principle Elastic Strain) ................................................................................. 35
Figure18 (Configuration) .................................................................................................................. 36
Figure19 (Parameters) ....................................................................................................................... 37
Figure20 (External Load) .................................................................................................................. 38
Figure21 (Force Profile) .................................................................................................................... 39
Figure22 (Configure Way Valve)...................................................................................................... 40
Figure23 (Hydraulic Resistance) ...................................................................................................... 40
Figure 24 (Pump Unit) ........................................................................................................................ 41
Figure 25 (Reservoir) .......................................................................................................................... 41
Figure 26 (Fixed Displacement Pump) .............................................................................................. 42
Figure27 (The actuator is in the initial state) .................................................................................. 42
Figure28 (The actuator is undergoing) ............................................................................................ 43
Figure29 (The actuator in maximum extension) ............................................................................. 43
x
Chapter One
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction:
2
1.2 Problem Statement:
With the limitations encountered in the use of ropes, ladders, scaffold and
mechanical scissors lifts in getting to elevated height such as the amount of load
to be carried, comfortability, time consumption, much energy expended etc. the
idea of a hydraulically powered scissors lift which will overcome the above stated
limitations is used.
The design of the hydraulic scissors lift is to lift up to a height of 3.7m and
carrying capacity of less than 500kg (500 kilograms) with the available
engineering materials.
The design of a hydraulic scissors lift is to lift a worker together with the
working equipment comfortably and safely to a required working height not
easily accessible. It may be used without a necessary external assistance or
assistance from a second party due to the concept of the design. This project will
be an important engineering tool or device used in maintenance jobs. Changing
3
of street lights, painting of high buildings and walls. Also in workshops or
factories.
This project consist of five chapters shown the stages of work, the schedule
of work is shown below.
Gantt chart
Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
Ch. 1
Ch. 2
Ch. 3
Ch. 4
Ch. 5
4
Chapter Two
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction:
Mans quest for improvement has never been satisfied. The drive towards
better and greater scientific and technological outcome has made the world
dynamic. Before now, several scientists and engineers have done a lot of work as
regards the scissors lift in general. A review of some of that work gives the design
and construction of a hydraulic scissors lift a platform.
6
expanding the versatility of instant span towers with aircraft docking and faced
system, you will find upright products, especially the scissors lift, as standard
equipment for a variety of application it is now a visual application in numerous
fields and locations.
2.3 Scaffold:
7
Scaffold is cross section of pipes, irons or woods which are arranged in
such a way that workers or operators can climb on the arranged pipes to get to
elevated heights.
Scaffolds cannot be adjusted automatically and they only can remain fixed
the way it is arranged unless rearranged. The tubes are either steel or aluminum,
although composite scaffolding using filament wound tubes of glass fiber in a
nylon or polyester matrix. If steel, they are either “black” or galvanized. The tubes
come in a variety of length and a standard diameter of 48.3mm. The basic
difference between the two types of tubes is the lower weight of aluminum tubes
(1.7kg/m as opposed to 4.4kg/m) and also a greater flexibility and so less
resistance to force. Tubes are generally bought in 6.3m length and can be cut
down to certain typical sizes.
Boards provide a working surface for users of the scaffold. They are
seasoned wood and are very strong. Scaffolds for increased height are preferably
made of hardened materials like metal pipes. After arranging the pipes, a flat
materials usually made of wood is placed on top so that the worker can stand
comfortable on top.
Figure2. 2 (scaffold)
8
2.4 Boom Lift:
Boom lifts are used for lifting materials especially on construction sites,
they are designed to carry heavy equipment and materials from one place to
another. They are usually connected to cars or trucks that move from one place
to another.
Boom lifts can lift materials and equipment high to height so great that
carrying this equipment by other means will almost be impossible.
According to material handling equipment from ask search engine, Boom lifts
can move vertically, horizontally and sideways and some can even rotate
depending on the circumstance. Boom lifts are very complex iron design and the
jointed parts should be lubricated to reduce friction and improve efficiency.
Boom lifts are formed mainly in construction sites and building sites. They are
also utilized by Electrical companies and firms. They are very expensive and are
not available in crude or semi mechanized type of production. Boom lift possess
advantage over other types of lifts because it can lift heavy materials, keep them
at elevated heights for a long period of time; rotate and the lift span of the
equipment is long. Boom lift can fold together to become compressed and
portable.
There are two basic types of boom lifts: straight boom lift and articulated
boom lift. These units are often hydraulically powered.
Straight boom lifts are generally used for jobs that required a high reach
without obstruction. The machines turntable can rotate 360 o with an extensible
boom that can be raised vertically to below horizontally. The operator can
maneuver and steer the vehicle while the boom is fully extended. It is available
in gas, propane or diesel-powered models with two or four wheel drive.
9
Figure 2.3 (Straight Boom Lift)
Articulated boom lifts are used for jobs that require reaching up and over
obstacles to gain access to a job not easily achieved by a straight telescopic boom.
This lift is nearly identical to the straight boom lift in every aspects; except in the
boom’s ability to articulate. Articulation points on the boom allow it to bend in
any number of different directions enabling it to maneuver around various
obstacles on a job site.
Boom lifts can be equipped with out riggers to stabilize the unit while the
boom is fully extended.
10
Figure 2.4 (Articulated Boom Lift)
11
Figure 2.5 (Mechanical Scissors Lift)
2.6 Hydraulic Lift:
Hydraulic lift is a device for carrying persons and loads from one floor to
another, in a multi-store building. The hydraulic lifts are of the following types.
Direct acting hydraulic lift and
Suspended hydraulic lift.
The direct acting hydraulic lift consist of a ram sliding in a cylinder. A
platform or a cage is fitted to the top end of ram on which goods may be placed
or the persons may stand. As the liquid under pressure is admitted to the cylinder,
the ram moves up and the cage is lifted. The lift of the cage is equal to the stroke
of the ram. The cage moves in the downward direction when the liquid from the
fixed cylinder is removed.
The suspended hydraulic lift is a modified form of the direct acting
hydraulic lift. It is fitted with a jigger which is exactly, same as in the case of a
hydraulic crane. The cage is suspended by ropes. It runs between guides of hard
wood round steel. In order to balance the weight of the cage sliding balance
weights are provided.
12
Figure 2.6 (Hydraulic Lift)
2.7 Hydraulic Scissors Lift:
Scissors lifts has developed overtime, and at each stage of its development,
critical problems are solved.
The hydraulic type, but this time, the load screw is replaced by a hydraulic ram
powered by a pump and on electric motor and generator. One outstanding feature
about this design however. Is its independent operation and increased efficiency.
Fluid power is one of the greater form of power where small input results in a
very large output. This scissors lift can be handled by one person to a place of
use, and power the generator. The lift does not lifting immediately, the operators
climbs on the platform and switches open the hydraulic circuit thereby leading to
an upward extension. When the required height is reached the circuit is closed,
and lifting stops the control panel or station is located on the top frame. When
work is done, the scissors lift is folded by hydraulic means and handled back to
the point of collection.
13
Figure 2.7 (Hydraulic Scissor Lift)
14
Chapter Three
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Methodology Flow Chart:
Design
documentation
16
3.2.2 Hydraulic system:
Is used to control and transmit power. A pump driven by a prime mover
such as an electric motor creates a flow of fluid, in which the pressure, direction
and rate of flow are controlled by values. An actuator is used to convert the
energy of the fluid back into mechanical power. The amount of output power
developed depends upon the flow rate, the pressure drop a cross the actuator and
its overall efficiency.
Arm Actuator
Bearing Pump
17
3.2.1.2 Scissor Arm:
This component is subjected to buckling load and bending load tending to
break or cause bending of the components. Hence based on strength, stiffness,
plasticity and hardness. A recommended material is stainless steel.
3.2.1.3 Bearing:
This component is the element that constrains relative motion to only the
desired motion, and reduce friction between moving parts. In this system it
tends to transmit the horizontal motion of the actuator to a vertical motion of the
scissors.
18
Figure 3.3 (Mechanical Assembly Sketch of Hydraulic Scissor Lift)
19
3.2.2.1 Hydraulic Valve:
A hydraulic valve properly directs the flow of a liquid medium, usually oil,
through your hydraulic system. The direction of the hydraulic flow is determined
by the position of a spool. A hydraulic system can only function – as per
requirements – by using valves.
3.2.2.2 Actuator:
The actuator is the mechanism by which a control system acts upon an
environment. The supplied main energy source may be electric current, hydraulic
fluid pressure, or pneumatic pressure.
When the control signal is resaved, the actuator response by converting the
energy into mechanical motion.
20
Figure 3.4 (Hydraulic Circuit Components of Hydraulic Scissor Lift )
21
3.4 Material Selection:
Contains 0.05 to 0.3 percent carbons it has for almost all purpose replaced
wrought iron, its greater strength giving it under viable advantages. Mild steel
can be rolled, wielded and down. It can even be cast, though not very successfully.
22
Among its application are plates for ship building, bicycle frame tubes, mesh
work, bolts, nuts, studs etc. solid and hollow constructional sections, sheet metal
parts and steel castings such as flywheels and locomotive wheel centers.
This is steel with high rust and corrosion resistance to meet specific
application requirements. They also have high strength and toughness.
It is an alloy of iron with about 11% chromium and other metals like nickel,
molybdenum etc. the properties of rust and corrosion resistance, toughness and
strength, aesthetics and how coefficient of friction were considered to meet all
requirements and the choice of stainless steel for the scissors members.
Single acting cylinders use hydraulic oil for a power stroke in one direction
only. The return stroke is affected by a mechanical in one direction only. The
return stroke is affected by a mechanical spring located inside the cylinder. For
single acting cylinders with no spring, some external actin force on the piston rod
causes its return.
23
3.5.2 Double Acting Cylinder:
Double acting cylinder uses compressed air or hydraulic fluid to pour both
the forward and return strokes. This makes them ideal for bushing and pulling
and pulling within the same application they are suitable for full stroke working
only at slow speed which results in gentle contact at the ends of stroke.
F: force [N]
m: mass [Kg]
g: gravity [m/s²]
3.5.2 Hydraulic Design:
To determine the diameter of the cylinder:
D: diameter [m]
F: force [N]
P: pressure [bar]
η: efficiency (0.9)
24
π: constant (3.14)
To determine velocity:
V: velocity [m/s]
Q: flow rate [L/min]
A: area [m²]
A: area [m²]
d: diameter [m]
π: constant (3.14)
25
Table 3.1 Standard values of cylinder diameter, rod diameter.
26
Table 2.2 Standard values of cylinder diameter, rod diameter, force and
flow rate,
27
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.1 Design Calculations:
4.1.1 The force:
F=m*g
F = 500 * 9.8 = 4900 N
At D = 40 mm
29
Figure 4.1 (Mesh)
Min = 0
30
Figure4.2 (Total Deformation)
The deformation is very low among the scissors
Min = -9.9173
31
Figure 4.3 (Maximum Principe Stress)
The maximum stress pointed on the platform and it increases towards the ends.
Min = -49.721
32
Figure 4.4 (Minimum Principle Stress)
The minimum stress decreases towards the middle of platform.
Min = -2.9953e-6
33
Figure 4.5 (Maximum Principle Elastic Strain)
The maximum elastic strain pointed on the ends of platform and scissors and it
decreases towards the joints.
Min = -0.00028745
34
Figure 4.6 (Minimum Principle Elastic Strain)
The minimum elastic strain is pointed on the base platform and it decreases
towards the joints and the top platform.
35
4.3.1.1 Configuration:
36
4.3.1.2 Parameters:
Figure 4.8(Parameters)
37
4.3.1.3 External Load:
38
4.3.1.4 Force Profile:
39
4.3.2 Configure Way Valve:
40
4.3.4 Pump Unit:
4.3.5 Reservoir:
41
4.3.6 Fixed Displacement Pump:
42
Figure 4.17 (The actuator is undergoing)
43
4.4 Discussion:
In the above circuit, when the unit power switch on, the hydraulic fluid is
pushed under pressure through a hydraulic pump, tubes, hoses, and hydraulic
motor. If the valve is closed, the fluid will get back to the tank. And if the valve
is opened, the hydraulic fluid is pushed through the cylinder to move heavy loads.
44
Chapter Five
CONCLUSION
AND
RECOMMENDATION
5.1 Conclusion:
Hydraulic scissor lift is designed to lift heavy loads to different heights
using a hydraulic system.
The design of a portable work platform elevated by a hydraulic cylinder
was carried out meeting the required design standards. The portable work
platform is operated by hydraulic cylinder which is operated by a motor. The
hydraulic scissor lift is simple in use and does not required routine maintenance.
It can also lift heavier loads. The main constraint of this device is its high initial
cost, but has a low operating cost. Savings resulting from the use of this device
will make it pay for itself within short period of time and it can be a great
companion in any engineering industry dealing with rusted and unused metals.
5.2 Recommendation:
The scissor lift can be design for high load also, if a suitable high capacity
hydraulic cylinder is used.
46
5.3 References:
GUPTA S.C (2006). Fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines.
47