2010 Maison Canopy ARCHIVE Competion
2010 Maison Canopy ARCHIVE Competion
2010 Maison Canopy ARCHIVE Competion
Housing
2010-2011
and
Health
Design
in
Haiti
International
Competition
Key e Sante nan Ayiti (Creole for Housing and Health in Haiti) solicited ideas on housing prototypes that work to reduce the transmission of tuberculosis for a community in St. Marc, Haiti. ARCHIVE (Architecture for Health in Vulnerable Environments) encouraged ideas that vary in size, scale, layout, grouping, building construction methods, structural responses, materials, and form. Five winning designs where selected to build five single-family units.
Maison Canopy
Design Team: Brook K. Sherrard, US Architect, LEED AP Lilian M. Sherrard, US Architect, LEED AP Jury 1st Round Jury 2nd Round
1. Hector Altamirano; 1. Leopold Blanc; Researcher at the 'Healthy Coordinator, Stop TB Infrastructure Research World Heath Organization Centre; London UK. Geneva, Switzerland 2. Peter Guthrie Obe; 2. Esther Boucicault; RedR Founder; Cambridge, Founder of FEBS England FEBS (Foundation Esther 3. Rodney Harber; Boucicault-Stanislas), Haitian Professor of Architecture, and AIDS Organization Principal Architect/Urban St. Marc, Haiti Planner at Harber & Associate; 3. Jo da Silva; South Africa Director of International 4. Fabrizio Gallanti and Development ARUP Group; Francisca Insulza; London, UK Urban Designers; Milan 4. Rod Escombe 5. Marco Poletto and Claudia Honorary Research Fellow Pasquero; Division of Investigative Founders of EcoLogicStudio; Science, Imperial College EcoLogicStudio; London, UK London, UK 6. Paul Pholeros; 5. Zaha Hadid Architects Adjunct Associate Professor, Founding Director Director, Healthabitat; Zaha Hadid Architects University of Sydney; Sydney, London, UK Australia 6. Edward Nardell 7. Tiziana Rossetto; Associate Professor Director of MSc in Earthquake Harvard Medical School, Engineering with Disaster Harvard School of Public Management; Health, Partners in Health "Department of Civil, Boston, MA Environmental and Geomatic 7. Graham Saunders Engineering, University College Head of Shelter London; London, UK International Federation of Red 8. Juan Carlos Sanabria; Cross and Red Crescent Director of School of Societies; Geneva, Switzerland Architecture, Veritas 8. Kenneth Yeang University; San Jose, Costa Chairman; Llewelyn Davis Rica Yeang; London, UK
46 m
Maison Canopy
S3
6m
[canopy house]
S2
The site is organized in groups of four houses. Each two housed share a garden area and
S1
14.6 m
S5 S1
S5 S1
Larger avocado and are located on the and coconut trees define the "outdoor" between the units.
Just like the mango tree, so prevalent in the Haitian landscape, Maison Canopy rises over the land, to offer protection from the elements, the city, and the stigma of living with AIDS. This sanctuary offers a place to heal the body and spirit. Beneath the protective canopy of the main roof, the house lies in the shade and offers a cool and fresh place in which to reconnect with the prospects of a new future. The open plan of this home creates a protected yet open place from which to engage new neighbors and build friendships that will last a life time.
S8
S1 S5 S1 S4
S1 S5
SITE LEGEND:
S7 S9 S8
S7 S9
S1
S6
S1. Maison Canopy S2. Future Education Building S3. Future Building for Organization Use S4. Possible Location for Communal Water Pump S5. Garden Area for small vegetables S6. Communal Garden Area S7. Avocado or Mango Trees S8. Coconut Trees S9. Plantains or Banana Plants
0m
3m
6m
12m
275.39 m
SITE PLAN
0m 12m 24.4m 48.7m
LEGEND:
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
35.5 6m
Metal roof on wood joists Heavy timber posts Masonry walls Windows: Wood operable louvers with screens Raised wood floor on wood joist Concrete footings Field stone wall
8. Cistern w/ filtration system for household use 9. Cistern for garden irrigation 10. Composting toilets 11. Compost tank 12. Gas burner 13. Air flow 14. Solar panels 15. Electrical panels and solar power system 16. Undercounter refrigerator
946.65 m
CONSTRUCTION TECHNOLOGY:
The 'maison' is designed to be built in phases. The main roof structure or "canopy" is built first and shelter elements are built beneath as needed. The canopy provides shade for workers while constructing the rest of the unit and also temporary shelter for families that are still working to finish their permanent homes. The seperated roof also allows for maximized natural ventilation to cool the living spaces below. This unique architectural approach provides an example of how design can impact the health of the occupant by creating a comfortable environment that can help reduce the spread of tuberculosis by minimizing stagnant air. The simple plan allows for different plan configurations dependent on family size and needs.
13
3m
.2 m 1.82 m
.6 m
D
1.93 m
VARIES
SECTION A
ROOM LEGEND:
15.8 m 15.2 m 3.5 m 3m 1.2 m 1.5 m 3.2 m 3.2 m 10.67 m 1.2 m 3.5 m A.LAKOU B.COOKING C.CORE/LIVING D.CORE/BATH E. PRIVATE/SLEEPING
3.5 m
3m
7.6 m
8.2 m
1.2 m
1.5 m
13
3.5 m
3m
A B 12
Health
FLOOR PLAN
Natural Ventilation
Construction
Water Conservation
Energy Efficiency
Community
0m .61m
2.44m
4.88m
t C i 3 k t p B
The transmission of tuberculosis in confined spaces: an analytical review of alternative epidemiological models; C. B. Beggs, C. J. Noakes,* P. A. Sleigh, L. A. Fletcher,* K. Siddiqi
tCi3ktpB
concentrations of airborne infectious particles and thus minimizes the spread of TB. The cooking area has also been pulled towards the corner not only to keep heat outdoors but to keep any fumes in a well vented space. The residential units are also spaced out on site to minimize the spread of disease between units. Natural Light: Openings on every wall also maximize natural daylight, eliminating the need of electricity during the day, and helping to minimize the growth of mold inside the units.2
Overcrowding: The units can be size according to family needs, easily allowing the addition of rooms for a growing family after the main roof is in place. Water: A rain water catchment system and ground water (if available) are the sources of potable water. A simple filtration system attached to the potable water tank ensures the collected water is clean. Additionally if ground water is available, water can be piped to the core of each residence. A secondary water tank is located on the garden side for agricultural purposes. Each water tank also has an external water valve for other uses such as laundry and other house cleaning chores. Sanitation: The design calls for the use of compost toilets for black water and the separate piping of gray water (from sinks and bathtubs). Gray water is then gravity fed towards the garden and used for plant irrigation. The compost toilet holds a separate tank for the treatment of effluents that creates compost material that can be used as fertilizer in the garden. Hygiene: The design provides for two toilet rooms, one of them containing a bathtub, toilet and sink. The secondary bathroom houses a shower, toilet and sink for the children or other adults. In case of lack of water pressure at least one bathroom can be use for bathing at any time. The project also calls for cement plaster on the interior of all living units. By utilizing mold resistant stucco, the units can be kept clean and free from any issues. For economy purposes the exterior of the units can be painted with an elastomeric paint to prevent moisture to penetrate the block wall. If budget allows both sides could received stucco and finish with paint. This will provide the easiest way to keep the walls clean.
Base on experiments by Jim Mauch and George Lyle and research by Albert Dimond and B. M. Duggar (Some Lethal Effects of Ultra-Violet Radiation of Fungus Spores; 1941).
tCi3ktpB
Electricity: A small solar power array can accommodate a small refrigerator to keep necessary medicines and other perishable goods. Trash Removal: In the absence of municipal trash collection, a central location is provided on site for compost and allow for collection of other items that can be reutilized on site (such as plastic or glass bottles). This centralized location can be beneficial if garbage collection is provided in the future. Any items not easily turned into compost or re-used can be burned up in a corner of the site away from the residential structures.
Overall Design Descriptive The project has been conceived with the idea of providing housing that can be adaptive to the various needs of the PLWHA. The flexible plan and structure can be built in phases. This allows FEBS organization to accommodate various family sizes, and to build only what is needed or to expand living arrangements in the future. This is achieved by building the separate main roof which in turns also maximizes natural ventilation. This method is the most economical way to provide maximum thermal comfort. The structures below have their own separate metal roof for waterproofing. The house elements have been deconstructed to allow maximum ventilation and minimize the spread of TB. The sleeping rooms are designed exactly the same to make it easy for construction. This allows for the standardization of the parts and ease of construction by unskilled workers. Operable louver screened doors and windows provide for maximum natural ventilation, privacy and protection from the elements. The core building is designed to centralized all plumbing and make the buildings more economical. The building is also conceived as a raised floor structure to navigate the changes in topography without disturbing the site. Also this allows for rain water to wash down the site without affecting the living spaces. More over this design minimizes the amount of earth displacement and the need for heavy equipment that is might be lacking in Haiti. It is important to note that the overall plan can affectively be implemented with different construction techniques. It is conceivable that the structures can be made with panelized walls instead of masonry and the results will be the same. Either concept can be utilized depending on budget and available materials. Due to possibility of wind storms and other related weather, we feel that a concrete structure will be the most durable and still be easy to construct. Especially since local labor is already familiar with this construction technique. In addition another option can be to do a slab on grade in lieu of the raise wood floor. For this option to be feasible we feel that major grading will be needed to keep water runoff from the central portion of the site away from the houses. It is important to note that regardless of the different construction options for the units the main design concept and spatial qualities are achieved. The building occupies 113 m of site with a large amount being a semi-outside space. Indoor areas comprised of 59 m of space. The area allocation for each canopy house is a follows: Core: 32 m o Core Living: 22.2 m o Core Baths Main: 3.76 m o Core Toilet Room: 2.46 m o Core Electrical Pump Room: .74 m Sleeping Rooms: 9 m each Lakou: 23.23 m (Covered outdoors area) Circulation: 29.73 m (Covered outdoors area)
tCi3ktpB
Garden Area: 60.5 m (per unit); 121 m total share per each two units The site is arranged in repeated sets of four units. Although the competition guidelines call for five units on site, we feel that given the site constraints and the need to establish a strong visual connection between units, that four units will be the ideal number to create a sense of community. This is especially true at the beginning of the site development. As the site continues to be developed, sets of two units will expand the sense of community already established in the site. Within this framework, each two units will share a garden area that is irrigated by gray water coming from two units. The four unit arrangement can be repeated across the site as need it or as funds for additional units become available. We have identified a central area in the site for a future communal garden area. This area is naturally elevated allowing the opportunity to create a terraced garden without the use of heavy earth moving equipment. A possible location near the garden has been identified for a ground water pump. This location is tentative and might need to be relocated depending upon actual ground water availability. If ground water is available, it can be piped to the core section of the buildings for potable water consumption. Rain water collection can still be used for the compost toilets and garden irrigation. The rest of the southern site has been explored to maximize the amount of units that the property can accommodate and are tentative base on future FEBS needs and available funds. Technical Information Given the lack of municipal utilities on site, this design entry includes the use of several well know technologies that helps the units function independently. These technologies address the following areas: Water: According to researchers the minimum acceptable water needs are typical 100 liters (26 gallons) per person per day3 for basics needs (drinking, sanitation, bathing, and cooking). A family of four will require an average of 400 liters per day (104 gallons/person/day). Besides personal use, the project also requires water for irrigation. To meet these needs the designs calls for two possible strategies. o Ground Water Strategy: If ground water is available on site, this would be the most effective and reliable way to provide water. Ground water will be piped to each unit and provided at each faucet. To conserve water resources it is recommended that rain water be used for irrigation in conjunction with grey water. Rain water will be also be used for flushing toilets. o Rain Water Strategy: In case ground water is not available on site, one of the tanks can be designated as potable water and be attached to a filtration system for potable water use. The recommended water tank size shall be no less than 12,000 liters (1,057 gallons) to meet the demands of a family of four for a month. Typical rainfall in Haiti averages 121 mm per month4 allowing for rainfall to keep the water tank at adequate levels. The secondary tank will be utilized for irrigation.
Base on recommendation to developing countries by Falkemnark as listed in Population Reports; Volume XXVI, Number 1, September, 1998; published by the Population Information Program, Center for Communication Programs, The Johns Hopkins School of Public Health (http://info.k4health.org/pr/m14/m14chap2_2.shtml) 4 According to AQUASTAT from the Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations, the average annual precipitation in Haiti is 1461 mm/year.
tCi3ktpB
Sewage: Separate black and grey water systems allows for the reuse of water and the production of fertilizer for garden use. o Black Water: Two compost low water toilets are provided and connected to an external tank for compost. The closed system requires low water use, little maintenance and produces free compost material. The design is base on a Centrex 200 NE, a non electrical compost tank, which has a capacity for 3 adults or a family of 5 of continual year round use and needs only to be emptied once per year. This system comes with a 1 pint low flush toilet (.56 liters) that minimizes the water usage. This low maintenance system is less expensive than building a septic tank. It also is more environmentally sensitive as it avoids future ground water contaminations from poorly maintained tanks. Given the widespread ground and surface water contamination due to improperly maintained sewage systems, we think an above ground small compost tank will minimize leaks as any problem will be more visible and easily accessible. o Gray water: Water from bathtubs and sinks is gravity fed down to the garden area and distributed throughout the garden by small perforated hoses. Power: A small 320 watt solar power system can produce enough electricity to run the essential items like a small refrigerator, one low voltage light fixtures in each space, and small water pump to circulate water from the storage tanks. In addition to addressing the infrastructures need of the site, the project seeks to show local workers a new way in which produce their own louvered doors and windows with simple inexpensive materials. This proposal is explained in the diagram below.
5cm x 10 cm (2x4) wood frame with steel angles for easy assembly
Insect Screen 2.5 cm x (1x) wood material with 6 mm PVC pipe with PVC coupling for hinges
Open Panel
Conceptual Structural Proposal The overall structure is designed with simple materials that can be found locally or shipped from abroad. The main roof is supported on wood poles with independent footers. The corrugated metal roof deck over wood rafters is designed as a hip roof with a 2:12 slope for maximum strength against hurricane winds. The roof structure is designed with
tCi3ktpB
4x12 (5 cm x 10.2 cm) wood members and can be fabricated onsite without the need of cranes or heavy equipment. Hurricane ties shall be use at every joist to the main perimeter beam. The wood poles are set in 1 meter deep concrete footers and wood braces help stabilize the structure against lateral forcers. Corrugated metal sheets are used for roofing material. The housing structures below are designed as concrete structures with raised wood flooring. The concrete walls are place on spread footers independent from the main roof structure. The lakou corner wall is designed to be made with field stones or any other locally found rough stone. This will anchor the corner of the lakou floor. Once the building core and at least one of the sleeping units is in place the entire raised floor can be laid out over 2x wood members. As additional sleeping structures are built the wood floor can be expanded as necessary. Rebar shall be use at corners of masonry structures, in footer and on concrete lintels over windows and doors. Outline Description of Construction Method The main construction materials used for the project are as follows: Wood Poles: 130.5 cm in diameter Corrugated Metals Roof Deck (for main roof and individual structures) Pour-in-place Concrete: for footings and lintels Masonry Units: 15x40x20 cm Rebar: 5/8 (1.58 cm) Dimensional Lumber: o Main roof rafters: 4x12 (10.2 cm x 30.5 cm) o Main roof perimeter bracing: 2x10 (5cm x 25.4 cm) o Wood nailers: 2x4 (5 cm x 10.2 cm) o Wood frame for windows and doors: 2x4 (5 cm x 10.2 cm) Wood Louver Door and Windows: Built locally with 2x and 1x wood material. 1/2 PVC and hangars can be used to make louvers slats operable. Cement Plaster: for plastering the interior of the units (min. requirements). Initial Budget Base on initial estimates this design can be built for $52,417 per unit. This price is base in building one unit and could potentially be reduce with bulk purchases. Due to excessively high prices for some goods and the lack of certain materials this design proposes the shipment of certain material and or equipment where such makes more economical sense. The budget outline below notes which items are priced locally. All labor cost is base on local fares provided by Archive. Shipping cost from the United Sates to Haiti is included in the budget. All prices are show in US dollars.
tCi3ktpB
Construction Estimate Maison Canopy, Bois L'Etat - Saint Marc, Haiti Qty Craft Hours Unit Material Labor Equipment Total
Base on Revised Building 2 bed 1 bath layout (conc. Interior floor and wood outdoor deck) Cost Estimate A - Masonry Construction Mix (Local labor; imported material cost for most expensive like wood, cement, metal accessories, and specialty equipment) Local prices on masonry units, sand, rebar, roof metal deck, local stone) Local Labor Calculated as follows - Skilled labor: $11/day or $1.4/hour -Unskilled labor: $6.25/day or $0.78/hour
1. General Conditions A. Transportation Cost Shipping Cost Using a 40' Enclosed Dry container (Shipping from Port Everglades, FL discharge at Port Au Prince, Haiti) 0 -0 Ea 0 0 0.00 B. Miscellaneous Transportation Cost Allowance from Port Au Prince to St. Marc 0 -0 Ea 0 0 0
$0.00 $0.00
2. Site Work Landscape Irrigation 200 -Earth Fill Utilized earth found on site 24 3. Concrete
0 SF
100
50
100.00
$250.00
100 CY
78
48.00
$126.00
A. Concrete Spread Footing for structures Spread Footing 1.5'x2' (0.45 m x 0.61m) - Concrete Placement Only w/ US prices (Local Materials will run around $218/CY; US Cement Bags, and Sand bags and local gravel will run concrete at $72/CY) 17.4 W4 120 CY 1252.8 93.60 0 Trenching for spread footing 12" diam., 1274.58 CF per column, .327 CY per column 186 BW 372 LF 290.16 0 B. Concrete Footing - 610 mm [24"] diameter for wood pole Concrete Footing placement only 24" diam., 0.35 CY/column footing 0.34 BW 0.51 CY 24.48 0.3978 Trenching -- hand excavation only 24" diam x 3' deep, (.074 CY per footing) 16 CL 32 E.A. 0 223.44 C. Mortar Fill Wall Cells Concrete fill for walls per structural drawings - US cement, sand, local gravel) 0.73 W4 120 CY 52.56 93.60 D. Concrete Slab at Interior Rooms 4" [10 cm] concrete slab with wire mesh 4 BW 16 CY
$1,346.40
$290.16
$24.88
$223.44
$146.16
288.00
12.48
$300.48
4. Masonry A. CMU Walls - 20cm (8") Concrete block, hollow, standard weight, (local block + labor) 8" block (8"x 16"x 8" [20x40x20 cm])
tCi3ktpB
Construction Estimate Maison Canopy, Bois L'Etat - Saint Marc, Haiti Qty Craft 1833 M1 Hours Unit 1000 SF Material Labor Equipment 1374.75 1400 0 Total $2,774.75
B. CMU Wall - 15 CM (6") Concrete block, hollow, standard weight, (local block + labor) 6" block (8"x 16"x 8" [15x40x20 cm]) 15 M1 150 SF 11.25 C. Stone Wall (filed stone ~ 8" [15cm] wide) 61 M1 150 SF
210
$221.25
30.5
210
$240.50
D. Cement mortar 8" wall, 1140.90 CMU 127 bags 60 lb Type S mortar US price 1511 M1 269.5 SF 800.83 377.3 E. Rebar (No. 5 ) 480
$1,178.13
LF
324
$324.00
5. Metals
6. Wood / Carpentry A. Roof Structure - Dimensional Lumber Roof Joist - (US prices for material + local labor for assembly out of 2'x10') 2x10x12 Wood Joist (US price) @ 18" O.C. 469 C8 117.25 LF 525.28 234.5 B. Wood Floor Decking: (25 x 152 [1"x6"] wood boards + attachments) Wood Decking 6" Wide planks 3/4" thick 522 SH 80 SF 626.4 62.4 C. Floor Structure: Dimensional Lumber 51 X 305 @ 406 O.C. FLOOR JOIST 300 W1 150 LF 336 210 51 X 203 @ 406 O.C. Floor Joist 85 W1 42.5 LF 95.2 59.5 D. Misc. Lumber 2X8 Nailer Plate 156 SH E. Nails SIMPSON STRONG-TIE Nails 6 -F. Attachments - Straps
$759.78
$688.80
$546.00 $154.70
80 LF
174.72
62.4
$237.12
0 Ea Allowance
79.3 350
0 0
0 0
$79.30 $350.00
G. Wood Poles (305 mm diameter [12" diameter]) Price 11/ft from American Pole & Timber (US Price) 224 W1 300 LF 2464 H. Misc. Plywood 1/2" 0 7. Thermal & Moisture A. Metal Roof (Corrugated) Corrugated aluminum roofing -- preformed (local price) .024" thick 1464 N5 120 SF 117.12
234
$2,698.00
SF
168.00
$285.12
tCi3ktpB
Construction Estimate Maison Canopy, Bois L'Etat - Saint Marc, Haiti Qty Craft B. Metal Gutter 156 N5 Hours Unit 120 LF Material 156 Labor 168.00 Equipment 0 Total $324.00
8. Doors & Windows A. Doors (metal with jalousie inserts and jalousie transom) door frames & louver transom 3'4" x 8'2" hinge door + 3'4" x 1'10" transom 5 C8 14.13 Ea 1,000.00 B. Windows (Jalousie windows with glass panes) Type A (typical) 3'4" x 6'8" opening (with pair of shutter 18"x80") 9.5 C8 25.12 Ea 950.00
28.26
$1,028.26
50.24
$1,000.24
9. Finishes A. Paint elastomeric (2 coats at interior & exterior walls) 6152 P1 75 SF 406.032 B. Sealants 3200 P1
105
$511.03
75 SF
211.2
105
$316.20
C. Portland Cement Stucco 2 Coat system (brown coat and finish coat) Interior walls only basis of design 1243 P2 200 SF 658.79 280
$938.79
10. Specialties 11. Equipment A. Kitchen Appliances 1. Refrigerator - (Allowance) by owner 1 -0 EA 2. Small Gas Stove (Allowance) by owner 1 EA 12. Furnishing / Residential Casework A. Base Cabinet 8.75 200 LF B. Counter Top 8.75 c. Upper Shelving 8.75 15. Mechanical / Plumbing A. Plumbing Fixtures 1. Water closets (Compost) Sunmar ComPost Toilet (Model Excel NE) 1 PL 6.4 Ea 1800 8.96 2. Pedestal Sink, vitreous china lavatory + faucets Lavatory, trim and valves (Add rough-in) - American Standard 1 PL 6.6 Ea 198 9.24 3. Shower Head & Valve American Standard & Bradley 1 P6 5.6 Ea 332 11.2 4. Kitchen sink + faucet Stainless steel, single basin with all fittings + faucet 0 $1,808.96
140.00
$140.00
200
$200.00
175
280
$455.00
200 LF
218.75
280
$498.75
200 LF
218.75
280
$498.75
$207.24
$343.20
tCi3ktpB
Construction Estimate Maison Canopy, Bois L'Etat - Saint Marc, Haiti Qty Craft 1 P6 Hours Unit 6.1 Ea Material Labor Equipment 128 12.2 0 Total $140.20
B. Piping 1. 1/2" PVC Piping for water supply 30 200 LF 60 2. 1/2" PVC Piping Overflow Drainage for Compost Toilet 40 200 LF 80 3. 3" PVC Piping Gray Water Waste Line 35 200 LF 105 C. Water Tanks (300 & 400 gallons) + Fittings 6 16 EA D. Water Filter 1 E. Water Pump 1
0 0 0
60
22.4
600
$682.40
10 EA
50
14
200
$264.00
12 EA
50
16.8
250
$316.80
16. Electrical A. Solar Power System: (5) 135 watt PV panels DC/AC inverter + Batteries Complete System (for remote off-grid location) 1 -16 -100 22.4 4847 B. Ceiling mounted Light fixtures Surface mounted Light Fixture 7 CE 14 Ea C. Electrical Wiring (100 FT Roll) Allowance for wiring for lighting 1 80 allowance
$4,969.40
210
28
$238.00
500
160
$660.00
Total Man-hours, Material, Labor, and Equipment: Subtotal 5101.71 16,694.71 Contractor Supervisation & Execution @ 10% Estimate Total:
6,815.48
6,385.00
Total Material + Equipment Only Labor by % (15%) Contractor OH&P @ 10% Total
tCi3ktpB