Chapter 15
Chapter 15
Chapter 15
Data from W. A. Russell, Annual Corn & Sorghum Research Conference 29 (1974): 81.
Heritability
• Broad-sense heritability (H2): The proportion of
phenotypic variation in a population due to all
genetic effects combined:
– H2 = sg2 / sp2 = sg2 / (sg2 + se2)
• Narrow-sense heritability (h2): The proportion of
phenotypic variation in a population due to additive
effects of individual alleles:
– h2 = sa2 / sp2
Estimating H2 from Twin Studies
• Twin studies are often used to assess genetic
effects on variation in a trait.
• Identical twins arise from the splitting of a single
fertilized egg = genetically identical.
• Fraternal twins arise from two fertilized eggs =
only half of the genes are identical.
• Theoretically, the variance between identical
twins would be equivalent to se2, and between
fraternal twins – sg2/2 + se2.
Sources of Error in Twin Studies
• Genotype–environment interaction increases
the variance in fraternal twins but not identical
twins.
• Frequent sharing of embryonic membranes by
identical twins creates similar intrauterine
environment.
• Greater similarity in treatment of identical twins
results in decreased environmental variance.
• Different sexes can occur in fraternal but not
identical twins.
Estimating Heritability from
Artificial Selection
• M = Mean of starting
population = 70
• M* = Mean of selected
breeders = 81
• M' = mean of progeny = 77
• Selection differential (S) =
M* – M = 81 – 70 = 11
• Response to selection (R)
= M' – M = 77 – 70 = 7
• h2 = R/S = 7/11 = 0.636
Limits and Correlations
• Selection limit at which successive generations
show no further improvement can be reached
because either
– All alleles have been fixed or lost, or
– Natural selection counteracts artificial
selection due to indirect harmful effects of
selected traits (e.g., weight at birth versus
viability)
• Correlated response: Effect of selection for one
trait on a nonselected trait (e.g., number of eggs
and their size)
Inbreeding Depression and
Heterosis
• Inbreeding depression:
Decrease in fitness due
to harmful recessive
alleles that become
homozygous
• Heterosis (hybrid vigor):
Superior fitness of
heterozygote; often used
in agricultural crop
production
Data from N. P. Neal, Agron. J. 27 (1935): 666-670.
Data from J.-H. Park et al. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108 (2011): 18026–18031.
Why the “Missing Heritability”
• Epistatic effects not detected
– Physiological epistasis: Interactions between genes
that affect molecular, cellular, or organismal
phenotypes
– Statistical epistasis: Interactions between genes that
are dependent on allele frequencies in populations
• Rare variants are not represented in the sample
population.
• Effects of some variants are too small to be
detected.
Additional Challenges for GWAS
• Many QTLs have pleiotropic effects.
• The effects are dependent on
genotype–environment or genotype–sex
interactions.
• The effects can be population-specific.
• Very few QTLs have large phenotypic effects.
• A “QTL” often is a cluster of functionally related
genes.
• It is often difficult to associate a particular gene
associated with a QTL with a phenotype-related
function.
The “Candidate Gene” Approach
• Identify genes whose products have a
demonstrable role in determining the phenotype.
• Identify polymorphisms affecting the structure or
regulation of that gene.
• Determine whether different genotypes are
associated with phenotypic differences.