The Role and Importance of Internship Programs As Part of Formal Education: Students' Perceptions - The Case of College of Tourism
The Role and Importance of Internship Programs As Part of Formal Education: Students' Perceptions - The Case of College of Tourism
The Role and Importance of Internship Programs As Part of Formal Education: Students' Perceptions - The Case of College of Tourism
Abstract: As one of the fastest growing part of their formal education. Through anal-
industries tourism is in increasing need for ysis of the survey distributed among students
well educated and skillful employees on both of the College of Tourism it will be shown how
operational and managerial level. Institutions students perceive the internship programs and
of higher education are requested by tourism importance of these programs for their future
industry to produce quality human resourc- employment. Also, it will be shown the level
es able to respond immediately to their needs of their satisfaction with tourism companies
and to be involved in working processes as fast where they are performing internship pro-
as possible with low or without any addition- grams and the level of their satisfaction with
al costs for future employees’ initial job train- activities of the College of Tourism in com-
ing. With inclusion of training and internship munications during the internship, program
programs into, primarily vocational, but also, management and implementation of the in-
into bachelor studies students will be trained ternship programs.
for their future jobs through real business sit-
uations and environment. Key words: education, tourism, intern-
This paper focuses on students’ percep- ship programs, formal education, student ex-
tions of internship and training programs as perience
and Theocharous (2013). 166 students from nally, 11th attribute is about students’ overall
Cyprus who have participated in at least satisfaction with the internship.
one supervised internship experience were For the questionnaire is very im-
included in this study. The results of this portant to determine its reliability or inter-
study shows strong correlation between nal consistency. Reliability test determines
perception of perceived benefits during the the consistencies of the results obtained
internship and level of positive students’ ex- through the test and ensure that the use of
periences and overall satisfaction with the different items in the measurement of vari-
internship. One more study was by Yafang ous constructions delivers consistent results.
and Gongyong (2008) measuring students’ In theory, more than one method is used
satisfaction towards their internship experi- for determining the reliability of test such
ence conducted among 124 students of tour- as re-testing when the test is repeated after
ism and hospitality schools in Hangzhou in a certain time and its results are compared
China. The study involved 24 internship var- with the results of the first test, then the
iables covering perceptions or satisfaction of methods of parallel test forms and methods
students related to “job itself ”, “supervisor”, of internal consistency. For the purpose of
“training and development”, “pay and wel- this research was used method of internal
fare” and “peer relationship”. consistency within which we used different
techniques among which the most used are
split-half Reliability Coefficient, Kuder-Rich-
Research metodology ardson Formula, and Cronbach Coefficient
Alpha. Kuder-Richardson formula is used
For research purposes a questionnaire for the tests containing questions with two
was created and distributed among students possible answers, while split-half Reliability
of the final year of the College of Tourism. Coefficient is conducted by treating a test as
As explained earlier, several models of stu- two tests dividing the issues into two sub-
dents’ perception of the importance and sets.1
performances of internship programs dur- However, one of the most popular sta-
ing education for tourism industry were cre- tistical techniques in determining the re-
ated, but we produced for this research new, liability of the test is Cronbach Coefficient
adjusted model. This model takes in consid- Alpha which determines internal consist-
eration students’ perspectives about value ency or average correlation of items in the
and performances of internship programs survey in order to assess reliability. It is used
they have attended during their education in for surveys with questions with two possi-
College of Tourism. ble answers and for tests with value-answers
The questionnaire created for this re- (using Likert scale with common values of
search consists of two parts. The first part scale from 1 to 5). The value of the Cronbach
of the questionnaire relates to the socio-de- Coefficient Alpha is in the range 0 to 1 and
mographic profile and socio-demographic the higher the obtained value is the test is
characteristics of respondents. The second more reliable. Generally accepted reliability
part has 11 variables or determinants of limit of the test is ≥0,70, but in some cases
which 4 are related to students’ perception lower values of Cronbach Alpha were ac-
of necessity and professional advantages of cepted (≥0,50 or ≥0,60). (Reynaldo, Santos,
internship programs, another 4 are related
to process if internship and cooperation be-
tween students and employers, 2 attributes 1 More about mentioned methods you can
are related to communication between stu- find at www.experiment-resources.com/
dents and College and coherence between internal-consistency-reliability.html and www.
theoretical knowledge and practical skills creative-wisdom.com/teaching/assessment/
they have learned during internship. And fi- alpha.html.
Broj 19, jun 2017 55
1999; Qu et al., 2000; www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/ account only those completely filled. This
spss/faq/alpha.html) way we achieved response rate of 78% and
In this research for the assessment of approximately 25% of all students of the fi-
attributes was used Likert scale with values nal year participated in this survey. Thus, the
from 1 to 5 for each attribute in form of con- sample size is quite satisfactory and we can
firmative statement.2 This is why we used say that the sample is representative.
Cronbach Coefficient Alpha for determin-
ing the reliability of the questionnaire which
was confirmed since Cronbach Coefficient Characteristics of respondents
Alpha has value of .809.
The questionnaire was distributed di- When it comes to characteristics of re-
rectly to the students and on this occasion spondents into consideration were taken fol-
100 questionnaires were distributed. Of this lowing characteristics: gender, occupation
number, 83 questionnaires were returned (place of employment) and type of company
filled with 78 questionnaires filled in com- or organization where students had intern-
pletely and for the processing we took into ship.
As shown in Table 2 mean values for variables, therefore students have positive
all 11 variables are in range from 3.04 for perception about the role and importance of
“staying in contact with an employer after internship program as part of formal educa-
internship was finished” to 4.92 for “stu- tion.
dents’ perception of necessity of internship When it comes to standard deviations
as integral part of learning process”. Also, there is strong agreement among students
students’ “interest in internship” (4.53), “ac- about “necessity of internship program as
quiring of knew knowledge and practical integral part of their formal education” and
skills through internship” (4.22) and “influ- their “interest in internship”, since these
ence of internship on improvement of stu- two variables have lowest standard devia-
dents’ biographies” (4.09) are variables with tions. Highest values of standard deviation
very high mean values. Beside “contact with have “contact with an employer after intern-
an employer after internship” lowest mean ship” and “overall satisfaction of students
values of 3.36 has “students’ perception of with expectations considering internship”,
coherence between theoretical knowledge thus there is medium to high disagreement
acquired during studies and internship”. All among students about these two variables.
other variables have mean value over 3.50 In order to check if there were any dis-
which could be considered as satisfactory or crepancies between students based on their
very satisfactory. Overall “satisfaction of stu- sex or place of internship, independent
dents with expectations considering intern- samples T-test was conducted. Independent
ship” is 3.56. All variables with mean values samples T-test compares the differences be-
over 3 are considered as positively rated tween the means of two unrelated groups of
58 Turističko poslovanje
respondents on the same dependant varia- nants according to the sex of respondents
ble. So it will be determined whether there and place of internship.
are differences between means of determi-
Based on data from independent sam- among the students of different sex in the
ples T-test based on gender of respondents, evaluation of the role and importance of
which are shown in Table 3, the assump- internship as part of formal education has
tion that there are no significant differences been confirmed.
Also, as shown in Table 4, when it comes nessing frequent and increasingly massive
to place of internship there are no signifi- involvement of inadequate human resources
cant differences between respondents and in tourism as part of pursuit for profit which
in this case the assumption is confirmed too. can result in dissatisfaction of guests in the
For the purposes of this paper, difference already tense economic situation which cur-
of mean values between students who had rently exists in the world economy and some
their internship in travel agencies/tour op- tourist destinations.
erators and those in hotels was tested since Adequate theoretical knowledge provid-
these two groups of students were the ma- ed by higher education institutions in the
jority of the respondents. world and Serbia represent only one part of
overall knowledge and skills necessary for
students to find a job after studies. Apart
Conclusion from theoretical knowledge practical skills
and abilities are required in order to meet
Quality human resources are the basis demands of tourism industry and tourists.
of future development of service industries, Tourism industry is looking for employees
including tourism. The need of the tour- prepared to immediately engage and become
ist industry for quality human resources is a part of service process, all that to prevent
indisputable, especially because we are wit- additional costs of training and employment
Broj 19, jun 2017 59
of new workers and to reduce overall oper- tourism and during internship they were
ating costs. This problem was recognized by mainly engaged in operational activities.
higher education institutions and, in their Operative skills acquired during internship
teaching curriculum, has involved practical are significant addition to theoretical knowl-
training or internship programs conducted edge and vice versa, and that will allow stu-
by tourism enterprises under the supervi- dents a comprehensive understanding of
sion of tourism professionals and lecturers business in tourism and adequately prepare
in charge of their internship. By including them for possible managerial positions.
practical training or internship, particular- However, because determining the cause of
ly in vocational studies, students are offered disagreements in the perception of the stu-
assurance that they will poses all necessary dents considering this particular problem
knowledge and practical skills and abilities was not specific subject of this research it
for employment at operational and manage- would be needed to conduct more detailed
rial positions in tourism industry. research in the future. It can be concluded
In this paper, a research was carried that overall research results are in line with
about perception of students of the Col- similar surveys conducted in World about
lege of tourism in relation to the role and students’ perceptions of internship and its
importance of internship as part of formal role during education for tourism.
education. Based on the results of the re-
search it is possible to draw some important
conclusions. Students of College of tourism Literature
are aware about the need of inclusion of
internship as part of formal education and Amoah V.A. & Baum T. (1997). Tourism
they show a significant interest in an in- education: policy versus practice, Inter-
ternship during their studies. Also, students national Journal of Contemporary Hospi-
percept that internship has contributed to tality Management, 9(1), 5-12.
strengthening their résumé and that dur- Chen T.L. & Shen C.C. (2012). Today’s in-
ing internship they have acquired practical tern, tomorrow’s practitioner?—The
knowledge and skills useful for future em- influence of internship programmes on
ployment. In addition, students are gener- students’ career development in the Hos-
ally satisfied with the contact and treatment pitality Industry, Journal of Hospitality,
by an employer who has managed to make Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education 11,
them a part of the team. However, most stu- 29-40.
dents failed to immediately achieve such a
Dale C. & Robinson N. (2001). The them-
level of contact with employer to secure cer-
ing of tourism education: a three-do-
tain employment after the studies, which is
main approach, International Journal of
somewhat understandable because tourism
Contemporary Hospitality Management,
in Serbia is still insufficiently developed and
13(1), 30-34.
demand for employees in the tourism in-
dustry have seasonal character. Overall im- Donina A. & Luka I. (2014). The compliance
pression of the students about internship is of tourism education with industry need
satisfactory and positive, but there is a space in Latvia, European Journal of Tourism,
for further improvement of this impression. Hospitality and Recreation, Special Issue,
We can conclude that perceived differ- 303-330.
ences between theoretical knowledge and Hjalager, A-M. (2003). Global Tourism
practical skills acquired during internship Careers: Opportunities and Dilemmas
are somewhat expected. These differences Facing Higher Education in Tourism,
are probably the result of the curriculum Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport and
which educates students for managers in Tourism Education 2(2), 26-38.
60 Turističko poslovanje
Horng-Huey P. & Mojdeh J. (2014). Practi- Reynaldo J., Santos A. (1999): Cronbach’s
cal Learning in Tourism Education: A Alpha: A Tool for Assessing the Reliabil-
Hands-on Bidding and Planning Prac- ity of Scales, Journal of Extension, 37 (2).
tice, Journal of Education and Practice, Ruhanen L., Robinson R. & Breakey N.
5(13), 35-41. (2013). A tourism immersion intern-
Hughes K., Mylonas A. & Benckendorff P. ship: Student expectations, experiences
(2013). Students’ reflections on industry and satisfaction, Journal of Hospitality,
placement: Comparing four undergrad- Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education 13,
uate work-integrated learning streams, 60–69.
Asia-Pacific Journal of Cooperative Edu- Sevillia S.F., Lhea C.R., Jourell E. & Sumanga
cation, 14(4), 265-279. Dexter R. B. (2014). Internship Perfor-
Juran J., Godfrey M. & Blanton A. (1999). mance of Tourism and Hospitality Stu-
Managing Human Resources and Quali- dents: Inputs to Improve Internship Pro-
ty, McGraw-Hill/Professional Book, Co- gram, International Journal of Academic
lumbus. Research in Business and Social Sciences,
Koc E., Yumusak S., Ulukoy M., Kilic R. & 4(6), 42-53.
Toptas A. (2014). Are internship pro- Spowart, J. (2011). Hospitality students’
grams encouraging or discouraging?-A competencies: Are they work ready?
viewpoint of tourism and hospitality Journal of Human Resources in Hospitali-
students in Turkey, Journal of Hospitality, ty and Tourism, 10, 169-181.
Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education 15, Štetić S. & Šimičević D. (2013). Značaj do-
135–142. datne edukacije studenata Visoke tu-
Lam T. & Ching L. (2007). An exploratory rističke škole za hotelsko poslovanje na
study of an internship program:The case Micros Fidelio programskim rešenjima,
of Hong Kong students, Hospitality Man- Cogress Proceedings – Contemporary
agement 26, 336–351. Trends in the Hospitality Industry, Hotel-
Lam T. & Xiao H. (2000). Challenges and plan 2013., 487-494.
constraints of hospitality and tourism Yafang, B. & Gongyong, F. (2008). A study
education in China, International Jour- on hospitality students’ satisfaction
nal of Contemporary Hospitality Manage- towards their internship: a case from
ment, 12(5), 291-295. Hangzhou, China. School of Tourism
Mekawy M.A. & Abu Bakr M.A. (2014). and Health Zhejiang Forestry University.
Planning internship programs: Tourism Retrieved January 20, 2016 from http://
students’ perceptions, Tourism, 62(1), www.seiofbluemountain.com/upload/
41-61. product/200910/2008glhy12a2.pdf.
Pang J.M. (2010). Perceptions of the tourism Zopiatis A. & Theocharous A.L. (2013). Re-
and hospitality industry by Singapore visiting hospitality internship practices:
polytechnic hospitality students: An A holistic investigation, Journal of Hos-
exploratory study, UNLV Theses/Disser- pitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism Educa-
tations/Professional Papers/Capstones. tion 13, 33-46.
Paper 700. https://explorable.com/internal-consisten-
Qu H., Li L., Chu G.K.T. (2000): The com- cy-reliability (20.01.2016.)
parative analysis of Hong Kong as an www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/spss/faq/alpha.html
international conference destination in (20.01.2016.)
Southeast Asia, Tourism Management www.creative-wisdom.com/teaching/assess-
21, 643-648. ment/alpha.html (20.01.2016.)