Explosion at Refinery
Explosion at Refinery
Explosion at Refinery
This incident occurred due to weaknesses in the refinery’s process safety management system. These weaknesses led
to operation of the FCC unit without pre-established safe operating limits and criteria for unit shutdown, reliance on
safeguards that could not be verified, the degradation of a safety-critical safeguard, and the re-use of a previous
procedure deviation without a sufficient hazard analysis.
To identify & define safe operating limits for all modes of operation, operating parameters that only indirectly
provide information on critical process parameters, can lead to the inability to identify an unsafe condition.
When implementing a deviation from an existing procedure, it is critical that the company conduct a
management of change to also verify and authorize the technical basis, the implementation time period, and
identify any new or affected hazards and associated mitigation strategies. If the procedure deviation is saved
for future use, before implementing the procedure the company should verify that the underlying conditions,
activities & technical assumptions that were the basis for the initial authorization are in place & are still valid.
It is essential to schedule and perform maintenance of safety-critical equipment so that the equipment is
available to perform its safety-critical function.
It is important to consider all modes of operation—including non-routine operations such as unit standby—
when performing PHAs. Incident scenarios could be possible during non-routine modes of operation that may
not have been considered when analyzing process hazards for normal, continuous operation.
Companies should develop operating procedures for all modes of operation—including unit standby—that detail
safe operating limits, consequences of deviating from those limits, and specified actions to implement in the
event the process deviates outside of its safe operating limits.
Robust management of change practices are needed when making changes to procedures. Similar to PHAs,
conducting management of change as a multidisciplinary group—composed of individuals with different areas
of expertise—can assist in identifying hazards introduced by the procedure change.
Control valves typically should not be used as block valves because fluid flow through a partially open control
valve can cause damage to the valve that can limit its ability to fully seal.
Uncombusted hydrocarbons that are not accompanied by carbon monoxide have the potential to reach FCC
unit electrostatic precipitators (ESPs). Refining companies should evaluate their FCC units to determine
whether there are sufficient safeguards to prevent an ESP hydrocarbon explosion.