Apqp - DR SHFT
Apqp - DR SHFT
Apqp - DR SHFT
Design FMEA
Reliability results
II PRODUCT DESIGN &
Design Review(s)
DEVELOPMENT
Diagnostic guidelines
Design for Manufacturing and Assembly
Design Verification
Subcontractor APQP Status
Engineering Drawings and Specifications
Product error proofing, as appropriate
Material specification
Drawing and Specification changes
PHASES
Process F.M.E.A
Measurement Systems Analysis
Pre-Lauch Control Plan
Product Tracebility.
Work Instructions
Packing Specifications
Production Control Plan ( Charecteristic matrix )
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
APQP TEAM PLAN
BNR Exports,Bangalore
Part description : DRIVE SHAFT Original date : 02.05.09
Drawing no : C0713250 Rev no / Date : NIL
Rev no / date :ISSUE -10 / 24-10 - 2008 Page no : 1 of 1
Customer : MONOPUMPS Application : PUMP
CROSS FUNCTIONAL / MULTI DISCIPLINARY TEAM
International Day
1.2 APQP Team formation G Ambi Daniel 4.05.09 4.05.09 4.05.09 4.05.09
Lekshman/
Prepare Product Information
1.3 G Shivakumar/ 5.05.09 5.05.09 5.05.09 5.05.09
Data
Neelakantan
1.4 Team Feasibility Commitment G Rajesh 5.05.09 5.05.09 5.05.09 5.05.09
2.1 Process Flow Diagram G Dinesh / Lokesh 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09
2.11.1 Work instruction for cutting G Neelakantan 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09
Work instruction for CNC
2.11.2 G Neelakantan 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09
Turning
Work instruction for CNC
2.11.3 G Neelakantan 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09
Milling
Work Instructions for
2.11.4 G Neelakantan 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09
Conventional
2.11.5 Work Instructions for Packing G Neelakantan 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09 13.05.09
Nataraj /
2.13.5 Assembly and Try out G 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09
Prakash
Prakash /
2.13.6 Inspection and ready for trial G 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09
Muthukumar
Nataraj /
2.14.5 Assembly and Try out G 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09
Prakash
Prakash /
2.14.6 Inspection and ready for trial G 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09
Muthukumar
Tool Manufacturing - Drill jig
2.15
-2
Nataraj /
2.15.5 Assembly and Try out G 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09
Prakash
Prakash /
2.15.6 Inspection and ready for trial G 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09 11.05.09
Muthukumar
3.1 Trial I
C.Prakash/
3.1.6 CNC Turning 4 th operation 23.07.09 23.07.09 23.07.09 23.07.09
Muruganantham
Page 8 of 60
C.Prakash/
3.1.7 CNC Turning 5 th operation 28.07.09 28.07.09 28.07.09 28.07.09
Muruganantham
3.1.6 Cross hole drill and Reaming G Jaganath 28.07.09 28.07.09 28.07.09 28.07.09
C.Prakash/
3.1.7 CNC Turning 6 th Operation G 29.07.09 29.07.09 29.07.09 29.07.09
Muruganantham
3.1.8 Rethreading G Lokesh/Nataraj 30.07.09 30.07.09 30.07.09 30.07.09
LEGEND
S.NO STATUS DESCRIPTION Colour Revision Details: DESCRIPTION
1 G- GREEN - COMPLETED 1 Rev 1 : APQP Timing plan is updated to the Micro Level
Can Engineering Performance Specifications be met as written? Product Drawing, Customer Specific
Requirements if any,
2 Contract Review check list Y
Can the Product be manufactured with Cpk’s that meet Customer Drawing
requirements Special Characteristics List
3 Contract Review Check List Y
SPC Study Reports
Is SPC used on similar products and when SPC used are the Customer Drawing
processes in control and Stable ( Cpk’s greater than 1.33) Special Characteristics List
4 Contract Review Check List Y
SPC Study Reports
Is there adequate capacity to produce product? Capacity Matrix
5 Y
Can the product be manufactured without incurring unusual cost Customer Drawing
for capital equipment / tooling alternative manufacturing methods Customer Specific requirements if any
6 Contract review check list Y
Capacity Matrix
Is Gauges / test equipment are compatible to meet the product Tool andControl
Existing Equipment
Plan,List
requirements Bill of material
Gauges and Test Equipment List, MSA
7 Study reports Y
CONVENTIONAL
4 DRILLING & 5 machines 1885 754 AVAILABLE
REAMING
Note:
0-2008
REMARKS
mbi Daniel
Page 13 of 60
Date : 04 / 05 / 09
RISK ASSESSMENT CHECK LIST
BNR Exports Bangalore
1 QUALITY HISTORY :-
1.1 Does the products application have a high warranty or things gone Wrong on
current model or similar models?
1.2 Are there frequent quality rejects at the receiving plant for similar products?
2 SUPPLIER PROFILE :-
2.2 Is the product or manufacturing technology new to the supplier and his
manufacturing location?
2.3 How is the supplier’s earlier performance is satisfied in the similar materials?
3 ENGINEERING PROFILE :-
3.3 Are similar products subjects to numerous design changes that threaten program
timing?
Page 14 of 60
Date : 04 / 05 / 09
RISK ASSESSMENT CHECK LIST
BNR Exports Bangalore
3.4 Is there high product or process complexity?
4 POTENTIAL – PROFILE :-
4.1 Does it require higher investments for development and regular production?
Justifiable?
4.4
Technological obsolescence possibility is there?
Page 15 of 60
Date : 04 / 05 / 09
RISK ASSESSMENT CHECK LIST
BNR Exports Bangalore
5.1 Will the design goals (functional performance) and reliability goals be difficult to
achieve?
5.2 Will the quality goals (warranty, scrap rates, rework PPM etc.) be difficult to
achieve?
5.5 Manufacturing productivity targets justifiable and achievable in-line with volume
requirements?
NATURE in No.s
HIGH RISK : 0
MEDI RISK : 13
LOW RISK: 7
20
CONCLUSION BY C F T : Moderate risk item if not handled carefully during the process might get
Date : 04 / 05 / 09
SSMENT CHECK LIST
√
Page 17 of 60
Date : 04 / 05 / 09
SSMENT CHECK LIST
√
Page 18 of 60
Date : 04 / 05 / 09
SSMENT CHECK LIST
in No.s in %
0 0
13 65
7 35
100
dled carefully during the process might get converted to high risk item.
BNR Exports CUSTOMER SPECIFIC REQUIREMENT SHEET
Customer: Mono Pumps Ltd., UK
Date: 22.09.2008
Requirements Originator
DRAWI
S.NO NG DESCRIPTION SPECIFICATION INSTRUMENT REMARKS
S.NO
CUSTOMER MONOPUMPS
METHOD OF
INCOMING SOURCE OF OPERATION
PROCESS FLOW MACHINE MOVEMENT IN OUTCOME
VARIATION DESCRIPTION
STATION
RECEIPT OF RAW
--- - - -
01 MATERIAL
Visual defects
Bar Diameter O/S & U/S . 02 RAW MATERIAL Correct Raw material
- -
Qty -Weight/ Nos / INSPECTION inward
Spec are not matching
04 Accepted premachined
Dimensional / Visual deviations PRE-MACHINING Conventional lathe BINS
components
Variation in Hole sizes and CNC Fifth ( Second Accepted components for
Positional dimensions / 09 Cross hole ) 108 / 01 BINS Conv drilling & Reaming
Dimensional / Visual deviations. Operation operation.
18
Wrong mode of despatch / Acceptable Assemblies for
DESPATCH Manual Wooden Crates
Improper documentation Customer.
LEGEND
LEGEND
INSPECTION OUTPUT
SHEET 1 OF 1
Shiva kumar.B Neelakantan Ambi Daniel
Wrong shipment /
Delay in production and Machining
Visual Defects 7 Improper handling from 4 Educate the suppliers
difficulties
supplier end
Machining difficulties and reduced Improper stopper setting Operator training / Set
Cutting length O/S
tool life, Increased Process time / Loading up approval
3 CUTTING 8 5
Improper stopper Operator training / Set
Cutting length U/S Cannot be used
setting / Loading up approval
CNC SECOND
6.00
OPERATION
Machining difficulties and reduced
Work Instructions /
Dimensions O/S tool life, Increased Process time /
Set-Up Approval
ID oversize cannot be used.
Machine capability
8 5
wrong program / setting
Cannot be used / ID undersize
Work Instructions /
Dimensions U/S Machining difficulties and reduced wrong tooling
Set-Up Approval
tool life, Increased Process time
Machine capability
Machining difficulties and reduced
OD - 69.80 /69.75 oversize tool life, Increased Process time. /
Fitment problem at customer end Wrong program / setting Work Instructions /
CNC SECOND
6.00
OPERATION *** / Tooling / Machine Set-Up Approval /
Cannot be used / Fitment problem at capability PPk / CPk studies
OD - 69.80 /69.75 under rsize
customer end.
8 5
Cannot be used / Fitment problem at
Bore dia - 51.08 /51.13 oversize
customer end. Wrong program / setting Work Instructions /
Machining difficulties and reduced *** / Tooling / Machine Set-Up Approval /
capability PPk / CPk studies
Bore dia - 51.08 /51.13 undersize tool life, Increased Process time. /
Fitment problem at customer end
11.00
CNC SIXTH *** / Tooling / Machine Set-Up Approval /
OPERATION Cannot be used / Fitment problem at capability PPk / CPk studies
OD - 64.98 / 65.00 under rsize
customer end.
Rev No NIL
s Control
D Actions Results
R
E Recom- Responsi-
P
T mended bility & Target Actions S E O C D E R P
Detection Action(s) Date
N Taken V R T N
Verification of test
certificate with
external lab
Inward Inspection 2 96
Inward Inspection
Inward Inspection 2 56
Hourly inspection
2 80
Hourly inspection
80
Setup approval and
hourly inspection 2
report
Hourly inspection 64
2 80
2 80
Setup approval and
hourly inspection
2 80
2 80
Hourly inspection 2 64
80
Hourly inspection 64
2 80
Hourly inspection 2 64
2 80
Hourly inspection 2 64
Hourly inspection 64
2 80
80
Setup approval ,hourly
inspection and Control 2
chart.
Hourly inspection 64
Gauge checking /
Hourly inspection
80
2
Gauge checking /
Hourly inspection
Hourly inspection 64
80
Hourly inspection 2
64
Final inspection 2 64
3 72
Hourly inspection
2 64
All calculations are based upon predicting 5.15 sigma (99.0% of the area under the normal distribution curve).
K1 is 5.15/d2, where d2 is dependent on the number of trials (m) and the number if parts times the number
of operators (g) which is assumed to be greater than 15.
AV - If a negative value is calculated under the square root sign, the appraiser variation (AV) defaults to zero (0).
K2 is 5.15/d2, where d2 is dependent on the number of operators (m) and (g) is 1, since there is only one range calculation.
K2 is 5.15/d2, where d2 is dependent on the number of parts (m) and (g) is 1, since there is only one range calculation.
d2 is obtained from Table D3, "Quality Control and Industrial Statistics", A.J. Duncan.
PART APPRAISER AVERAGE CHART
DEPT. OPERATION DATE CONTROL LIMITS CALCULATED ENGINEERING SPECIFATION PART NO.
QA OD TURNING
MACHINE NO. DATES OF STUDY CHARACTERISTIC SAMPLE SIZE FREQUENCY PART NAME
LT 25/1 02.07.09 OUTER DIAMETER 10 DRIVE SHAFT
NUMBER OF APPRAISERS APPRAISER A APPRAISER B APPRAISER C
3 JOEL MUTHU BALARAM
x= 43.3236 UCL = 109.8042 LCL = -23.1571 AVERAGES (X BAR CHART)
120.000
100.000
80.000
60.000
40.000
20.000
0.000
-20.000
-40.000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
180.0000
160.0000
140.0000
120.0000
100.0000
80.0000
60.0000
40.0000
20.0000
0.0000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
NUMBER 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
DATE/TIME
R 1 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000
E
2 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.980 64.980 64.980 65.000
A
D
3 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
I
N
4
G
S 5
SUM 129.960 129.980 129.980 129.970 129.960 129.960 129.980 129.960 129.960 130.000 129.960 129.980 129.980 129.980 129.960 129.960 129.980 129.960 129.960 130.000 129.960 129.970 129.970 129.980 129.960 129.960 129.970 129.960 129.960 130.000
SUM
X 43.320 43.327 43.327 43.323 43.320 43.320 43.327 43.320 43.320 43.333 43.320 43.327 43.327 43.327 43.320 43.320 43.327 43.320 43.320 43.333 43.320 43.323 43.323 43.327 43.320 43.320 43.323 43.320 43.320 43.333
NUM
HIGH-
R 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000 64.980 64.990 64.990 64.990 64.980 64.980 64.990 64.980 64.980 65.000
LOW
SUPPLIER PLANT : BNR EXPORTS UNIT SUPPLIER CODE OTHER APPROVAL/ DATE (IF REQD.)
5 Corner radius ** R1
6 Groove dia ** 56.02 / 56.08
9 CNC 5 TH OPERATION CNC Turnning M/C 1 Hole dia Drilling & Boring *** 19.09 / 19.12
10 Cross Hole Drilling & Conventional 3 C / Hole dia 2 Drilling ** 14.22 / 14.29
Reaming 4 Ref length ** 38±0.10
37 Chamfer * 45º
38 Concentricity ** 0.1 wrt A
SETTING APPROVAL = New setting, Change of Tool, Collet, Jaws, Speed, Feed or any other change in Process / Setup -----VISUAL: Rust, Cracks, Pitting, Bend, Dents, Burrs & Damages are not allow
QUARANTINE: Apart from rejected batches, batches produced / received should be kept separate till decision on the batch is taken. Ex. Batch produced between tool changes, batch received from supp
Prepared by
Checked by
Approved by REV
ONTROL PLAN
3420 DATE(ORG): 24.12.06 DATE(REV):
METHODS
SAMPLE RECORD
EVALUATION / MEASUREMENT
CONTROL MATHOD REACTION PLAN
TECH
SIZE FREQ
Vernier caliper 100% Every lot Self inspection report Reset the blade Self inspection report
Micrometer
Bore gauge
Vernier caliper
Vernier caliper
Bore gauge 2 Nos 1 hr Self inspection report Reset the tool Self inspection report
Bore gauge
Vernier caliper
Bore gauge
Vernier caliper
Micro meter
Vernier caliper
Profile projector
Radius gauge
Depth Vernier
Profile projector
Bore dial gauge
Depth vernier
Micro meter
Dial with stand/CMM
Vernier caliper
Bore dial gauge
Depth vernier
Bore dial gauge
Depth vernier
Plug gauge
Vernier caliper
Profile projector
PP/Radius gauge
PP/Radius gauge
Blade micrometer
Depth Micrometer / PP
Profile projector
Micrometer
Dial with stand
Profile projector
Profile projector
Profile projector
Profile projector
Profile projector
Blade micrometer
Reset the insert check
Dial with stand 1 Nos 1 hr Self inspection report Self inspection report
the speed and feeds
Profile projector
Roughness tester
Bore dial gauge
Reset the insert check
Micro height /Vernier caliper 1 Nos 1 hr Self inspection report Self inspection report
the speed and feeds
Dial with stand
Plug gauge
Vernier caliper
Venier caliper
PC
Depth vernier
Micro meter
Plug gauge
Vernier caliper
PP/Radius gauge
PP/Radius gauge
Blade micrometer
Depth Micrometer
Profile projector
Profile projector
Blade micrometer
Slip gauge/PP
PP/Radius gauge
PP
PP
Profile projector
Blade micrometer
Profile projector
Venier caliper
Profile projector
Dial with stand
Roughness tester
Thread plug gauge
Plug gauge
Micro-hite / Vernier caliper
Vernier caliper
Plug gauge
Dial with stand
Micro-height / Vernier caliper
Visual
BNR /CP/186
CUSTOMER MONOPUMPS
PART NO C 0713250
CUTTING
W.O. No 320
C.N.C. OPERATIONS
W.O. No 320
CONVENTIONAL
W.O. No 320
OPERATIONS
FINAL INSPECTION
W.O. No 320
ASSEMBLY
W.O. No 320
DESPATCH
XXX / YYY / ZZZ 1 / 5 To 2 / 5 / BNRE /1344
Note:
BOX NO.
W O XXX
WORK ORDER
OPERATION: WORK
CUTTING INSTRUC
PREPARED BY OPERATION
OPERATION
1) Receive the cutting slip from planning/p
Issue No:01
2) Clean the machine job holding area w
Rev No:00
PREPARED BY
Issue No:01 ` Date:15-06-05
Rev No:00 Date:15-06-05
clarify
2) Check the route card/ job card/ control plans are provided as per latest issue no.
5) Check and record the dimensions in the self-inspection report format at regular
intervals
14) Clean the Machine after use and keep your m/c surrounding clean.
Issue No:01
Rev No:00
OPERATION: DEBURRING
WORK INSTRU
OPERATION S
Issue No:01
Rev No:00
Requirements Originator
Delivery Requirements:
1 Wood packaging material must be fumigated before despatch
by Freight forwarder Customer
2 Each case must be pasted with a label consisting PO Number Logistics
3 Delivery Terms: Incoterms 2000: Ex Works Logistics
Documentation Requirements:
1 Submit GSP certificates for each consignment Logistics
PROCESS NO
PARAMETER SPECIFICATION
SL NO 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
1
OUT SIDE DIAMETER Φ 65 / 64.98 X
2
BORE DIAMETER Φ 40.03 / 40.03 X
3
CONCENTRICITY 0.03 with respect to A X
4
BORE DIAMETER Φ 51.08 / 51.13 X
5
BORE DIAMETER Φ 29.99 / 30.03 X
6
OUT SIDE DIAMETER Φ 69.75 / 69.80 X
7
BORE DIAMETER Φ 19.09 / 19.12 X
PPK1
Page 53
PPK1
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
Page 54
PPK1
98
99
100
Page 55
BNR Exports Process Cpk Study Report
Customer : Ref. No.
MONO PUMPS 1
30
25
20
Frequency
15
10
0
84.97
84.97
84.98
84.98
84.99
84.99
85
85
85.01
85.02
85.02
85.03
85.04
85.01
85.03
Dimension
No. of Class : 3
Observed beyond Specification : Target Nominal :
0.00% 84.99
Estimated beyond Specification : Average (X) 84.989
0.00% Process Std. Dev. (Sigma):
0.0024
Remarks : Name
Tolerance : 0.02
TARGET NOMINAL 2:
if LSL=0: 0
if USL = ~: FALSE
Cpk value 2:
if LSL=0: 0
if USL=~: FALSE
Cp = ----
Page 57
PPK3
sum of X =
X bar =
Page 58
PPK3
frequency
0
0
2
0
33
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-35
Page 59
PPK3
Page 60