No 8-The 33rd Division Along The Meuse October 1918
No 8-The 33rd Division Along The Meuse October 1918
No 8-The 33rd Division Along The Meuse October 1918
Study Number 8
U.8. ARMY CHEMICAL CORPS
HISTORICAL STUDIES
196a
~ I
The 33rd Division Along t h e Meuse
October 19l.8
Prepared by
with
t i o n of an approved history.
H u r a t iw
Gas Disaipllne. . . . . . . . . 2
Plan of Attaok. . s . . . . . . . . . . 7 -
The Halt on the Corps O b j e o t l w - . . . . . 12 &
Aoross t h e Meuse o .. e 0 o o . S0
HS~tuation....untenabls...oondit~onof men...deaperaten. . . 58
ModestQalne . o o o a . . 66
. . .
0 9 0 0
3na o f t h e Cempalgn . . . , . 68
Bnalysia
GesandIIEShelle * * - o e e o a 86
Map No. 2
- .
Area o f Operations, 331.6 Division,
LO Sep 20 Oot . . 10
Yap No. 4
30 8- * . . .
Approxhte Msposltion of 3Srd Division.
10
. . .
1
Map Bo. 6 -
Patrol Yap, 130th Infantry. 2 S Oot 29
Sketch of Brleulles . . . . . . . 30
Map No. 6 - . .
Bituation Ysp, 129th Ideatry, 2 8 Oot 53
Map No. 7 . . .
Sltuation des Poroes bumies, 8 O o t 40
Mnp No. 8 - . .
F i f t h Qsrmen Army Legenlcorto. 8 Oot 41
Map No. 12
.
Yep t o A o o ~ s n yField Bofer...8aSt
Yeuse
Or the
. 66
Yep NO. 13 Fifth Oe- Lagenkarfe, 11 OOt . . 65
. On the seoond day t h e corps was t o oross t h e riwr and outflank t h e enmy
a r t i l l e r y and observation positlons on t h e heights e a s t of t h e Meuse. -
When t h e left and center of 111 Corps delayed halhray t o t h e Army
r
Objective on t h e f i r s t day, t h e enemy recovered f r o m h l s f l l g h t and iroln
- 1 -
Despite, or, possibly beoause of, t h e leva]. of gas d i s o i p l l n e t h a t seems
1
Gas Dlsolpllne
prlsed the 129th and 130th Regiments, 66th Brigade, under Brlg. Gen. Edward
Lo King; t h e 151st snd 15216 BerlmeAs, 88th Brlgade, under Brig. Gen. Paul
B o l f r t h e 58th FA Brigade (whloh dld not join the d l r i s l o n ln &MOO untll
2-
i Xaj. Gene Robert 1. Eullard, P e r s o n a l i t i e s and Bemlnlscenses of t h e Uar
(Bern York, 1926). pe 268.
- 2 -
b a t t l e conditions of t h e A l l i e d western f r o n t . " 3
was placed under t h e XVII French Corps, Seoond French Army, and entered
+
Frederio L. Huidekoper, The H i s t o r y of t h e 33rd Division. A.E.F.
(Springfield, 1921). I, 21. h e H i s t o r by t h e Division Adjutant, comprises
four volumss in t h e series, Illino s n t h e World War, t h e f i r s t wlrnne of
which is t h e n a r r a t i v e h i s t o r y . The documentation is oomplete, but t h e h i s -
t o r y i s s l n g u l a r l y devoid of any opinion o r judgment. Nowhere in t h e h i s t o r y
P i s t h e Division Gas O f f i c e r , ls4 Lt. 'A. E. Vawter, mentioned, nor does any
record of h i s appear among t h e documents.
4
Histor -
I, 30, 35 49; Col J. B. Sanborn, CO 131st Inf. Rpt on Opus
of 8 d g . 18 Aug (33rd Div Box 17, 20.1). SOIS, 131st Inf, 10 19 -
bug (same f i l e ) i n d i o a t e t h a t phosgene and/or mustard gas was f i r e d on 131st
Inf p o s i t i o n s on e v e r y one of t h o s e days.
- 3 -
t h e line along H i l l 304-ylort Hme-Cumieres, n o r t h r e s t of Verdun, oompleting
mando
joke and, having been under fire s e v e r a l times, t h e y were wise enough now
5
FQs 32 and 33, 132nd I d , 7 and 9 Sep (33rd Div Box 20. 92.1)- Such
oarelessness in d i s c i p l i n e had been general throughout t h e d i v i s i o n earlier,
See l t r Col E. Do Ardery, CGO 11 Corpe t o Asst CofS 0
Tng in 33rd Div (33rd Div Box 11. 5 5 ) .
-
3. 24 Jul, sub, Gas
- 4 -
ID
. .:
.
,.
FO~G.ES SICT-, US..,-, Oc:t
,
given an e x t r a hour of gas mask d r i l l d a i l y and had read t o them a t eaoh as-
F;, h z a , rsoeived very s t r i o t orders from youi offioe t o keep quiet, out o f
6
Ltr, CO Bty D 106th FA t o CO 106th FA, 13 Sop, subs Gas Diao of Inf.
and 10 I d s (33rd D i r BOX 46, 400.73)-
'I
History, I. 50 - 59.
*
8
Memo, B r i g Gen King t o CofS 33rd Div, 18 Sep (3316 Div Box 13, 32.15).
- 6 -
Fortunately, as t h e d i v i s i c h i s t o r y said, most of the week m s marked by
t h e order f o r t h e attaek.
Plan of Attack
The First Army p l a n was t o a t t a o k in t h e d i r e a t i o n of Busaaoy and
9
Tng Ciro 177 (33rd Div Box 10, 50.9). There i a no reoord t h a t t h e of-
f i c e r and 30 NCOs per week authoriaed t o attend AEF and I Corps Gas Schools
beginning 6 Oot, d i d soo By then. oimumstances a e r t a i n l y a i l i t a t a d against =
it. (Ltr, TAG AF.F t o CG 33rd Div. 21 Sap, sub$ Instru in 0.8 Do?. 33rd Div
Box 47. 565.2).
- 7 -
33rd division wheeling and organizing t h e west bank of t h e Mmse as quiokly
f i r s t day.
10
Hietoly, 61 - 62. 65 - 67.
11
M 20, F i r s t Army, 15 hrs. 20 Sop, par S(X)S (U. 5. Army in the
World Wars 1917-1919 (1948). I& 87; F i r s t &my Box 32).
- 8 -
do Raffecourt) and t h e Meuse, and i n one bound t a k e D r i l l a n c o u r t and t h e Bois
down t o Cote de l'Oie (Kap No. 2 ) The a t t a c k was t o be made by t h e 66th Brig-
forced by Company A, 1st Gas and Flame Regiment, and accompanied by nine
7 t h Reserve Divisions. -
A 1 1 r e s e r v e s were east of t h e Ibeuse, s i n c e FiPth
be made i n t h a t s e c t o r (Zap No. 3). The rolling ground before I11 Corps
s o m concern about p o s s i b l e enemy observation and fire from Hill 382, be-
_-
FO 23, 33rd Div. 9r00 a.m., 24 Sep, esp p a r 3(h)8 (33rd Div Box 5,
32.1). "In c a s e of an advance Bois de Forges would undoubtedly be gassed.
It should be cleaned up q u i c k l y and vaoated." Addenda t o I n t e l E u l 2,
33rd Div. 2 0 Sep (33rd Div Box 3, 20.6). But t h e enemy d i d not g a s t h e -
Hood during t h e a t t a c k .
- 9 -
::.
:
jl
. M.AP .1"40. 5
M ~ n t a g n e . ~A S~ a r e s u l t , )[vII Renoh corps was d i r e c t e d t o join in the pre-
marsh through which Forges Brook rau. using 12.000 faeoinee It had pre-
_.
C - 3 Rpt, F i r s t Army, 7 Sep (USA i n the HU, Ix, 73 - 74).
14
Po 20, F l r s f Army, 15 hrs, 20 Sep, para 3(C), 3(H)6; Amex 1, bploy-
ment o f Army Arty. 19 Sep ( U U in t h e W, 4 85, 86 - 87, 96).
15
Of t h e 80,OOO rounds f i r e d by 111 Corps t h a t day, 3Srd Div a r t i l l e r y
fired 36,000 75-mm and 5.000 155-mm rounds (SO1 16, 33rd Div, 25
in 33rd Div BOX 2, 2001).
26 Sep, -
- 12 -
t h e enemyrire and trenches, m e t l i t t l e opposition, and between 1,000 and
1,330 had flanked the Bois de Forges and reached t h e Corps and Army Objeo-
had stopped and manned his defensive positions in t h e rear, as nearby re-
17
I, 76, 80; Brig Oen Wolf, Opns in the Mort H o m w SeoCor,
Box 15, 33.6); r p t , 13lst Z n f Sugsgsment in Forges Woood,
26 Sep (33rd Div Box 19, 33.6).
- 13 -
were s e t In motion. 18
-
117th and 7th Reserve D l v l a l o n s i n t h e event of attack, had arrived a t
the &is du Fays. A t IBW, i t s 12th Regimnt had attaoked t h e 4 t h and 80th
Dlrislona oomlng through t h e Bola de Septsarges. 1 9
18
Too l a t e , Fo 27, B i r d A r q , 29850 hra, 28 Sep, was t o say t h a t corps
were t u advance within t h e i r zones of m t i o n without renard t o ob.iectives.
See o r i g i n a l p a t t e r n of objeotives, USA in t h e RW, IX, il. Cf. Liddell
Hart, The Real War, 1914-1918 (Boston 1931) ppa 465 666- -
19
-_
5th Bav Be8 Dlv WD, 2 6 Sep (5th Bnv Res Div IIDdcA, 25 Sep
German F l l e a Box 14$, f o l 11. ppe 2 JI. - - 10 l o r ,
20
1x1 corps ppt of opus, 9 Sep - 11 NOT (111 Corps BOX 4, 11.4)*
- 14 -
scattered forceR of the d i v i s i o n halted. t h e 6th Bavarian Reserve Division
-
Division (KuK) was direoted by Maas O s t " t o support with a l l means the
21
German-
Ark0 95 RD, 26 Sep (7th Be8 Div-Sub Units-WAU, 23 Sep
Box 156. f o l XI, p e 51J. Arko 17 WD, 26 - -
11 Oat,
SO Sep (5th Bay
Re8 Div-Sub Units-WDlA, German F i l e s B o m f o l IIIa. pp. 210 -- ,-
m a t a flanking group remained on the east bank under t h e 7th Bes Dlv,
t h e rest of i t s b a t t e r l e s moving t o t h e B o i s de Cunel and Clery 10 (trende,
t h e i r prinolpal t a r g e t s t h e Bois du Fays, Bois de Brieulles, and Bois Cote
hmont.)
22
26 Sep, and Maas Olrt Opns 0 5803, 26 Sop
l8 Sep x, German M l e s B o x 116,
- 15 -
in t h e Bois d e Forges," t o p r e v e n t enemy orossing of t h e Meuse i n t h a t seo-
e i t h e r s i d e of t h e river t h a t t h e r e m a "adequate t i m e t o g e t o u t o r d e r s
23--
l~aasO s t mi, 26 Sop (German Piles Box 116, f o l I, p. 22); Mnns O a t
I(pt 1651. 27 Sep (German P i l e s Box 116. fol 11, ppe 14 16). -
24
24 Sep
Maas Neat 21at Co s Orders 501, 516, 27
9 Nov. w s Box 60, f o l 11. pp. 34, 36, - n
4
-
29 Sep (Maas West =A,
25
b a s Ost Order 3917, SO Sep (German F i l e s Box 48, f o l 810/SZe1S). A
p r i s o n e r on t h e 28th was t o r e p o r t t h e arrival o f 3 or 4 d i v i s i o n s on I11
-
Corps front. along w i t h much a r t y on t h e e a s t bnnk, i n c l u d i n g long naval
guns (SO1 19, SSrd Div, 28 29 SOP).
- 16 -
Harassing Fire w i t h HE and Gas
next day 43 men of Company A, 1st Gas Regiment, and 3 men of t h e 131st
13, 32.16).
-
It was probably t h e 8 0 t h Div t h a t reoeived t h e "ordered oontaminatlon of
t h e v i l l a g e of D~MOVOUX and Bois des Moriaux w i t h yellow croas...carrled
h i l l E of Villeneuve &g early t h i s morning
d a i l y r p t , I t a l i a n Files Box 2. f o l I, p.
139)
- 17 -
Infantry, in t h e Forges area, were evaouated w l t h severe synptoms o f ohloro-
been made from oonteminated shell- hole rater, sinee t h s KP who had baen
o i o u a l y s h o r t time.27
-
c h l o r o p i o r i q during t h - d g h t pf 29 - 30 September7 in t h e Bola de Forges
area.' The Divislon Gas Officer wae t o r e p o r t only a s i n g l e episode ln t h e
28
The a r t y o f the 1st A-H Dir. in p o s i t i o n between t h e Bois de l a Orande
Montagne and the Bois de Consenvoye, kept t h e areas around Danaevoux md
opposite Consenvoyu and Erabant under gas and BE fire. See 1st A-FI Div
order 470/8. 28 Sop a d r p t e 29 Sop ( I t a l i a n P i l e s Box 2, fol I, pp. &,
149 -
SO).
- -
18
. 'I...-..,
APPltO,lf"IA"tt D"PO~ITIOM
.,.
CW .,.,... l)N111... foaCII
'!!,o,t"'"*ll
Cu"",.
St.11,- .. 11w-
SOI "' ,:,Oij
.
l)I
t o H Company headquarters dugout in t h e Bois de Forges, r e p o r t e d l y produced
had been t o t h e gas 8ohOOl a t St. Valery and should have known b e t t e r , re-
dugout and at once went over and ordered ilanediate evacuation of the area.
T9
L t r , Aotg DGO t o COO I11 Corps, 7 Oct. Rpt B-2 (CM-33rd Div). Cf.
n
d CO 132nd Inf t o G - 3 33rd DIv, 1 2 ~ 2 0porn., 30 Sepr Last night my
l e f t b a t t a l i o n was h e a v i l y s h e l l e d w i t h gas. One s h e l l broke i n front of
hq a t Coo H. Company Comdr, Capt Dauberfield, L t Heath, t h e 1st Sgt, and
16 men gassed and evacuated during t h e night (33rd Div Box 6. 32.16).
Notes Despite t h e d a t e on Itr above, t h e 111 CCO received no r p t s of g a s
a t k from h i s DGOs u n t i l after 9 Oct. See memos t o DWa 4 t h , Bath, 35rd
Divs, 5 and 9 Oct, re no g a s a t t a c k r p t s 26 Sop t o d a t e (I11 Corps Box
39, 63.33).
- 20 -
Cierges-Brieulles on 28 end 29 September, t h e a t t a o k i n g p m r of I11 Corps
30
Rpt o f Opns, 111 Corps, 28 Sep (111 Corps Box 4, 11.4); 0 3 Memo,
F i r s t Army. 29 Sep (USA i n t h e VW, IX, 149); 33rd M v P l a n of Defense,
-
Vilosnes-Consenvoy b o t o r , 29 8ep (33rd Div Box 8. 32.8); Opus Orders 6,
7, 130th I d e 2 and 5 Oot (33rd Div Box 17, 92.12, 3 3 e l ) e i
31
SOI, 130th I d , 29 Sep - 6 Oot (33rd Div Box 17, 20.1).
- 21 -
continued through the next day, as t h e 68th Brigade t o t h e south r e p o r t e d
gas end shrapnel on Forgb- .wood a t the rate of four rounds p e r minute
32
33ru Div,
DOR, 66th Brig, 30 Sep
1 - 2 Oat. - 1 Oat (3Srd Div Box 16, 33.1); 801 22,
33
Div Orders, 1 Oct (7th Re8 Div WL&A, 18 Sep
Box 155, Pol 1, pp. 127, 133).
-
19 O c t . Oe- Files
- 22 -
t h e gas i n t o t h e zone of t h e 4 t h Division." I n t h e 129th I n f a n t r y s e c t o r ,
_-
SO1 22. 33rd Div, 1 - 2 Oat; History, I, 90. 111 Corps Opus R p t ,
1 - 2 Oct (USA i n t h e WW, IX, 208) s a i d about 300 sneering and phosgene
g s s s h e l l s were f i r e d Lnto t h e r a v i n e and valley.
35
Msg. 0
Prosser t o G
--
2 65th Brig t o G
3 33rd Dfv. 6854
- 3 33rdYsg,Div.65th5r26Briga.mo,t o 233rdOat;Div.Msg.7812L t
.%em.-;
aomo (33rd Div Box 6, 32.16).
36
Ltr, Actg bco t o CGO I11 Corps. 7 Oot. Rpt B-28 FM Osborne ROO 129th
Inf t o Do0 33rd Div, 9130 aomo, 2 Oot (33rd Div Box 15. 32.16). r p t d "Dlo
or three casualties."
37
Msg, G -
2 65th B r i g t o G -
3 S3rd Dlv, 4850 pOme, 2 Oct; Msg, CO
65th Brig t o CG 33rd Dlv, 9800 p a a , 2 Oat (33rd Div Box 6, 32.16).
- 23 -
A s w i l l be shown later, both t h e German o r d e r s and t h e 33rd Divlsion
c u r r e d . 38
,
- 24 -
Except for a b r i e f HB bombardment, there was no immediate r e p r l s a l by
-
p a l l y from t h e 125th Infantry and t h e 123rd MG Battalion. in t h e 66th Brig-
ade aeotor.
Ark0 95 order f o r 7 pama 2 Oot t o 7 aDmo3 Oot (7th Re8 Div-Sub Unlts-
W A , 23 Sap-11 Oat, Arko 95 annexes, German Files Box 155. fol X I , p. 61).
Fol I in t h i s f i l e conl;ainsdivisional morning and noon reports a d i n n i n g
these f i r e missions.
40
2 - 3LOct
t r , Actg W t o CGO I11 Cor
(USA in t h e W, IX, 210!,
a, 7 O c t , Rpt 8-2. I11 Corps Opns Bpt,
reported 200 gas s h e l l s in Bola Jure
and on H i l l 294.
- 25 -
Renuaption of the Adqnnoe
On t h e evsning of 3 Ootsbor, t h e SSrd Division reoeived t h e F i r & h y
order resuming t h e nttnok, ln m effort t o pieroe t h e Kriemhilde Stellung.
the north edge o f the h i s de Foret and then east t o t h e river. The 39rd
n
Fo 33, F i r s t noon, 1 O o t t PY) 22, I11 Corps, 9800 8.m.. 3 Oat;
SU 26, 33rd Div, 10115 P.Q., 3 Oot.
42
aistory, I , 92 - 98.
- -
26
harassing f i r e w i t h surprise b u r s t s of gas and HE a t i r r e g u l a r i n t e r v a l s
on... m o d s of Dannevous, Moriaux and Jure, on Dannevoux and Geroourt,
and on roads running from Dannevowr t o Septsarges. Vilosnes and G e r c a ~ r t . ~ ~
43
Arko 95 order f o r 7 p a . 3 Oot t o 7 a.ma 4 O O t (7th Res Dive above,
po 6 2 7
45
Ltr. Actg DGO t o CGO I11 C, 7 Oot, Rpt B-2.
- -
27
might have said t h e same f o r t h e seotor of the 66th Brigade. south of
46
Daanevouxs
which had got i n t o the Bois du Fays, &om intense flanking maohin8 gun
fire. 47
A t 1800 on the night Of 6 Sotober. 20 A l l i e d planes oamisd out a
sion
-.l is going t o throw gas inte.Brieulles a t 4 A0M0348 Beglnning a t
01100, 80th Division 75's f i r e d 1,000 phosgene s h e l l s i n t o Brleulles.
46
See &ialysls, p - 92.
47
See 65th Brigade memo orders, 4 - 6 Oct (33rd Div Box 13, 32.13).
4e
gag, COO Emerson t o G - 3 33rd Div, la00 adrio. 7 Oct.
- -28
A-
MAP NO.5
29
,/ I I . I
%
put i n t o t h e tom. A 1 1 divisions in t h e v i c i n i t y were n o t i f i e d " t o take
with enemy troops pressing on both flanks and with strongly entrenohsd
49
Memo, Robbe COO 111 Corps t o C CIlS A t t Def Dlv, 8 Oot (W-111
Corps); ltr, CCO I11 Corps t o C CWS A t t Def Div, 27 Oot, subs Reoord
of Gas Atks ( F i r s t Army Box 340, I11 COO); Itr, COO I11 Corps t o C m,
12 Nov. s u b t Rpt on Gas A c t i v i t i e s for Oot. This oorresp indicates
t h a t t h e 4 t h and 80th Diva f i r e d considerable pa8 s h e l l s during t h e
period. t h e 33rd D i v none.
50
Ysg, Prosser G s t Lt, I11 Corps I 0 a t 65th Brig-/ t o G 3 SSrd Div,
9s16 aa., 7 Oct (33rd Div Box 6, 32.16). reported o&pletion of t h e gas
-
missiono "Satire front now very quiet."
51
Msg, CG 65th Brig t o G
BOX 6, 32.16,)
-
3 33rd Div, 1 2 ~ 2 5porne. 7 O o t (33rd Div
52
Histor& I. 96 - 97. 100.
- 31 -
Gas Attaok on t h e Bois des Moriaux
and 03% rhen approximately 1,500 green, blue, and yellow oms8 77 aad
105-mm s h e l l s mre f i r e d i n t o the Bois den Moriaux, opposite Vilosnes, an
into the rood nub again evaouation was blocked by fol-low-up HE fire. At
53
Msg, 3rd Bn 131st DIf t o CO 131st hf, 2r65 a.m., 5 O o t ( 3 r d Div
Bsx 18, 32.16, )
- 32 -
.
/
/ Sit11tlo 11 Mat No. 4
l'l, ... \It...,,
33
Altogether, it was estimated t h a t between 5,000 and 7,000 s h e l l s hnd been
shells. Forty men -re evaouated with lung oomplloations, the remalader
w i t h sye o r body burnr. The most serious oases, t h o s e w i t h lung ompli-
-54--
No a r t y order has been f a d f o r t h i n atk in the rsoorda or t h e 7th
Bee Mv, 5th Bar Div let A 4 Div. M M ~ oet o r Yaas Ueet. Ark0 96 o r d e r
r n 0 m - 7 a a o . 5 Oot 1
-9 for the u s u a ~ s l n n I
-
2 aeems not t o have been aware Of t h i s gas attaok, but in a r a r e
detailed aooounting it d i d report on 4 5 00%"Heavy intermittent shell-
ing with HE and gas of areas Bois Are, Bola Septsarges, Gercourt*; 169
gas s h e l l s between 1140-1155. 4 Oat, on t h e Forges-Cumieres road; 96 gas
shells on t h e s n m road at 2315; 24 gas s h e l l s on Forges a t 0300, 5 Oot;
and heavy shelling wlth 200 HE and gas rounds on t h e front l i n e area from
Danneooux t o Bois de Forges between midnight and 0230, 5 Oat (SO1 25, 33rd
Div, 4 5 - -
There is no mention of the atk in SO1 26, 5 6 O o t , either.
-34-
next day t h e b a t t a l i o n was
Divislon Gas Ql'fioer was t o say t h a t no real gas attacks oocurred, although
56
Chron Re0 o f Events of 65th Brig, 5
History, I. 97; 11, 597.
- 7 Oot (3Srd Div Box 13, 11.5)~
57
Memo, PO Pinetree &9th 14,6 Oct (33rd Div Box 15, 32.13).
- 35 -
considerable amounts of gas were used each day in harassing f i r e . % On 6
October, he reported t h a t 75 77- mustard gas s h e l l s oaused 27 eye casual-
Bond. The next day, M estimated 175 rounds of mustard gas, with 6-0
phosgene, landed among 425 men in t h e BOls Jure. Moat of t h e 150 oaaual-
under guard. Lut during t h e next three days, "25 men...managed t o pass
t h r o u g h t h e area" and a l l were subsequently evaouated t o t h e gas hospital. 59
-59
Ark0 95 orders f o r nights of 6 6 Oct, 6 - -
7 O h , and 7th Be8 Dlv
order t o a r t y on 7 Oot all oalled for "harassing f i r e and suhden coneantra-
tions of gas" on t h e wood;, ravines, villages. and roads i n t h e 33rd Div
seotor (7th Bes Div-Sub Units-Ark0 95 kmeree, tieman File Box 155, i o l 11,
ppo 67. 69; 7th Re8 Mv llDM, m f o l I, p. 175).
59
Ltr, Do0 t o CQO I11 Corps, 13 Oot. subs Gas
Chron Re0 of Events of 12Sth Id. 7 Oot (S3rd Div
11, 645) says t h a t on the 7th, 3 o f f i c e r s and 106
atchd machine gun cbmpany w r e wounded and gassed
Rpts (GAF-SSrd Div).
men o f t h e 3rd Bn +
B o x 15, 11.5 and Histor
60
Chron Rec of Events of 129th 8 Oct; Histor 11, &95; Porning R g t ,
7 t h Res Div, 9 Octr " A t 10 p.m. Oog 0 h d
n s t a l h n t s o f oontanina-
%ion f i r e on Dannevous" (7th Res 6 v rmkA, German Files Box 155, f o l I, p.
182) 0
- 36 -
s h e l l i n g , t h e 129th I n f a n t r y a l s o s u f f e r e d from i n d i r e o t bassing i n the Bois
pointed outr
With t h e 129th in t h e Bois des Moriaux was t h e 102nd Trenoh Mortar Battery,
Moriaux. 62
OL
S i t u Rpt, 130th Inf, 9 Oct, subs s/s Dannevoux (33rd Div Box 17,
33.1) 0
62
Brief History, 102nd TM Bty. nod. (33rd Div Box 13, 33.2).
- 37 -
h d t h e next days
doross t h e Xeuse
With t h e f a i l u r e t o p i e r o e t h e Krlemhilde S t e l l u n g in t h e a t t a o k on
t h e s t a r t of t h e offensive, was a l e r t e d t o p r e p a r e a f r o n t a l a t t a o k on t h e
63
Memo, 129th Inf to bn and spec u n i t comdrs, 8 Oot, subs Eva0 of Gas
Cases; memo, E.. 9 Oct, n e e e (33rd Div Box 16, 64.4).
. 4
FO 39, F i r a t hrty. 14 h r s , 5 Oot; SO 546-S/3. X V X X Corps. Srd Rw, 6
O o t ; FO 24, I11 Corps, 17830 o'clock, 7 Oct.
-38-
t h e 1st Austro-Hungarian Division, soon t o be reenforced b y t h e 32nd Divi-
-
s i o n and elements of t h e 228th Division (Maps NO. 7 and 8).
t o p r o t e c t t h e orosslng a t Consenvoye. 66
65
History, I, 100 - 02, and Pos. above. Also, Plan d'Engagement du
i 1 7 t h -0ct (33rd Div Box 5, 32). See Hap 57 i n E i a t o r y , IV, f o r
33rd Div o b j e c t i v e s .
66
FU 27. 33rd Div. 6 ~ 0 0p.m., 7 Oat.
- -39
. I
eL OIV6UYON
40
:P
-;s:J .
f . .~ . BE t1111l/COIJttT
. 3.
.
rn
,....,
SITUATION des fORCfS fNN MI fS :P
OtVANT LE /RONT OIi /7.eC/l. ~
.
le 8 Octobre /918
SiWrce, 33..i Dw 8011, 14 c>
MA.P No.1
. ,, ,. ..
, ... t ..... .
\. ........... 1". . ...
5. AT ... &&
' .
'Si'"' ...... a. ,o.1a.
\) , ..,_; ...,.
s.........
. aG-A-,
.,..,,. Ge- fl ... a.~ 7'"'
\ D ID)
'o/1. Ir\.~
\YI
rnon 5. Q S r.
L 1/,
)
(,[\
~
/ - ,_,,,
MA.? N0.8
41
1 .~
e.0,11 ....
.s.....n
...
- t '""'"'II, ..~
~
V1th1,111I,
... .. J8:1iwi11a
- '" ...
...
... &rE..ur,1
...
... ... ...
Bou ... &011 d'cur.)' "
'" Har.a1u>\ol\~
'It'"
.., ...
...
..... ,. ...
s.,""rs hit
'-
G""t1"t
-... 1-
Dnl_.,,
...
"" .,
........ ,
...
Bou
.
...
...
.. ...
I I.IS clT&s N MUIJH. j
...
... - "
...
...
MAP N0.9
42
On 7 October, two of t h e machine gun oompanies and t h e t h r e e b a t t e r i e s
_.
67
repor&gas
Histor
e
I, 98 - 99. DOB, 33rd Div. 7 -
8 Oot (33rd Div Box 8. 33.1)
s h e l l s in the Forges a r e a between 2200-2345. w i t h 150 HE
s h e l l s in t h e B o i s d e Forges. Two c a s u a l t i e s were reported.
68
--
Hj.i'%w I, 104 - 05.
- 43 -
Despite flaalcing fire from t h e 301s de Conssnvoye, t h e o b j e o t i v e was
69
DOR 33rd Div. 8 - 9 Oot. CP Mag, CO 132nd Inf, 8 r 2 0 p a - , 8 Oot;
" A t 4 ~ 4 0 , l e f t b a t t a l i o n adranoe elsment about 700 yards n o r t h of Consea-
voye....G"rpped by standing b a r r a g e till d a r k and dug in for nlght. Bo
word f r o m r i g h t battalion. Capt Kendall, surgeon, j u s t oeme in, r e p o r t s
abcut 75 c a s u a l t i e s ; some gas, some b u l l e t s , and some artillery, appar-
e n t l y p r e t t y well m i r e d " (3Srd M v Box 20. 32.11).
70
F'O 28, 33rd Div, 11846 p a . , 8 Oot; H i s t o r I, 107 -
08. The 12
Ti?
b a t t e r i e s of t h e 52nd Brlg f i r e d 13,000 rou 8 in support t h a t day and
during t h e next two days were t o fire as many more (Dog 39rd Div, 8
Oct) e
10 -
71
Biatory. I, 109 - 13.
-44-
In stubborn r e t r e a t b e f o r e t h e advance of t h e Franco-American f o r c e s
-
c o u n t e r a t t a c k a g a i n s t XVII Corps f o r m s . t h e 177th and 102nd I d a n t r x of
72
Maas O s t Order 4163, 8 Oct (Maas O s t Qns Orders t o Oct 18. German
Files Box 48, f o l 810/32.13). M a a s O s t WD, 9 Oct, said i n confirmetion
t h a t "our a r t y held t h e Yeuse c r o s s i n g s as w e l l as assembly p o i n t s and ap-
proaoh r o a d s under heavy fire mixed w i t h gas" (German F i l e s Box 115, Pol
Ia, po 34).
- 45 -
t h e 32nd Division, nhioh had come f n b e s i d e t h e 1st Austro-Hungarim Divi-
-
sion d u r i n g t h e night, a s s a u l t e d t h e 58th Brigade f o r o e s a t t h e t o p o f t h e
Bois de Coasenvoye, driving them hPak through the woods and exposhg the
on the r i g h t Plsak, as the 232nd Reserve Infant- end 105th Storm Battal-
-
ion of t h e 1st Austro-Hungarian D i v i s i o n s t r u c k the b a t t a l i o n s of t h e
73
Msg, Maj Chipenfield BE, 33rd D i g w i t h 18th Fr D i p , 8r50 a.m.,
9 O c t ; Msg, Huidekoper, 9~15.a.m., 9 Oot; Mag, Adj 58th Brig, 10~10
aom., 9 Oct (33rd Div B OX 6. 32.16).
74
P a r t i c u l a r Order 8@/3, XVII Corps. 1Z50 hrs, 9 a c t , r e p o r t i n g Mag,
Huidekoper a t 2r20 p.m. (with Msgs in Box 6. 32-16).
75
These erroneous i d e n t i f i c a t i o n s mf t h e 1st A-H u n i t s involved ap-
pear in a number of 33rd Div records. The 1st A n l v had a 106th 8t.
-
Bn. but not a 105th. and t h e 232nd Rss Inf was -107th
on t h i s front.-Seeap
Dlv end n o t
No. 10 f o r t h e more probable u n i t s . There a r e
-
Div u n i t involved.
-
a l s o d i s c r e p a n c i e s between t h i s map end the r s o o r d s concerning t h e 32nd
- 46 -
\.. l,
,,,
..
COM1R-A1TAQUE
ALLEMA~DE
9 Oct o b r 19 1 8
Secteu,, de
!l~.tffe)
CoNJIEIIIVOYI!
. " "
poor shape. "76
Hagen and Volker Stellungen and were a t t h e Giselher Stellung when they were
The Division Gas O f f i c e r was t o say there were no rpeoial gas attrrolur
"
1 3
77
I, 115. Ltr. CO l32nd Inf, 15 Bov, above, said t h e casual-
e 9th were 2 o f f i c e r s and 34men k i l l e d , ? officers, and 191
m e n wounded.
Notes The Histor (I, 115, 362) reports t h e s l l l ~ bcasualty t o t a l s f o r
the bn o f the d o n t h e rest bank as f o r the two bns on t h e e a s t
bank. See p. 57 below. Ltr, 15 Hop, i s probably oorreot.
- -
48
o p e r a t i o n under Colonel Davis had slowed down, s a i d Lieutenant Vawter, and
on t h e 9th a l l those men who -re thought t o have been gassed were s e n t t o
50 percent of t h o s e examined.78
78
L t r , Dco t o C CWS. 22 Feb, subs Gas Atks (GAF-33rd Div). H o s p i t a l
admission l i s t s show 251 gas c a s u a l t i e s and 115 rounded evaouated on 9
O c t (see h a l y s i s ]
79
S i x gas c a s u a l t i e s were r e p o r t e d in one of t h e MG companies when it
t r a v e r s e d a contaminated a r e a i n t h e Boie J u r e t h a t n i g h t (Ltr, WO t o
COO I11 C. 13 Oot. subs Gas Rpts).
80
H i s t o r 6 I, 116 - 17. Aotually, t h e 3 r d Bn, 129th Inf, orossed on
t h e n i g h t of t h e 9th. t h e o t h e r two t h e next day (Chron Be0 of Events
of 65th Brig, 10 Oot, 33rd Dlv Box 13, 11.5).
- 49 -
The mowpent aoross t h e river had been osrried out under contirmal
t h e e a s t benkr
Map No. 2)- The 58th Brigade of t h e 29th Divlsion and t h e 18th French
Be;Ls
81
&ko 95 RD, 10 Oct (7th Rae Div-Sub Unita-WDU, 23 Sep 11 Oot, - *
G e r m a m Box 155, f o l 11, p. 52); Morning Rpt, 7th Res Div, 10 O o t
(fol I, p - 188). The Morning R p t for 11 Oct (p. 19'6) said t h a t during
t h e night gas and HE had again been put on troop assembly areas. roads.
draws, and t h e bridgeheads on t h e Ueuse.
82
Mag. C O B XVII Corps. 9145 p-m.. 9 Oot; P a r t i o u l a r Order 864/3, 9
Oct (3Srd Div Box 6, 32.16).
- 50 -
I '
-
Unless r t h e 58th B r i g a d e l h e l p s us on t h e r i g h t , we w i l l be o n l g throwing
away men-to a t t a c k t h e German f o r c e s in t h e woodsx. Bader E a p t 9 u).
French M i s s i o g t h i & u n l e s s t h e y w i l l help us we should withdraw t o t h e
-
normal o b j e c t i v e q O e o nConsenvoye-top o f Bois de Consenvoya.
General B e l l r e p l i e d s
R3
Msg (Conv). n o h D s 9 Oct (33rd Div Box 6, 32016) r e c o r d s a s e r i e s o f
conversations between Bader, Wolf, and B e l l t h a t night. One conv i n d i -
c a t e s it was 2040 when Gen B e l l ordered t h e two bns of t h e 129th and one
of t h e 130th t o r p t t o Cen Wolf on t h e e a s t bank, and t h a t t h e y were t o
lead t h e a t t a c k a t d a y l i g h t . B u t t h e 131st I n f . u n i t s , preceding them
acrosa t h e river, mnde t h e a t t a c k .
The r e f e r e n c e t o Mag H a m l e t C o Ridgway (2nd Bn, 131st hf) meems explained
i n Rpt, 131st Inf Engagement a t B o i s de Chaume (33rd Div Box 19, 33.6)s
"One r e c e n t l y assigned Major who had never been in a c t i o n before was in-
c l i n e d t o be panicky, and more o r less d i s o r g a n i z a t i o n e x i s t e d i n some of
t h e t h r e e Regimental Detachments and Machine Oun Companies s c a t t e r e d as
t h e y were through t h e woods." Major Ridgway, however, was w i t h t h e d i v i -
sion when it a r r i v e d i n France, The " r e o e n t l y assigned Major" has not
otherwise been i d e n t i f i e d .
- Sl -
& hour l a t e r he signalleds
1st Battalion hung on, for ht 1400 t h e oomander of the 131st Infantry re-
Chene woods, w i t h o u t any slgn of the 58th Brigade on h i s flank. Ten min-
u t e s later. t h e 1st Battalion signallads
84
Msg, CO 3rd En l31st Inf @a3 F r m o i s Y. Allea t o CO l3lst Inf,
65
Historx, I. lt8 - 21.
06
Mag, CO 131st I d E o l Jos B. t o CO 115th Inf m t h Bria.
1400, 10 Oat; Mag. CO 1st Bn. 131.t CoadyI t o CO 131st Inf,
1410, (33rd Div Box 6, 32.16. )
Although Ysg. CO 131st Inf t o CO 1st Bn. 1 S l s t Inf, 1356, 10 Oot (33rd Div
Box 18. 32.16) ordered Capt Walter H. Magner of 2nd En, 1313t Id' t o replaoo
Coady as 1st Bn comdr. t h i s does n o t seem t o have taken place until 13 Oot.
See b s l o w , p 610
- 52 -
Advance elements of b o t h t h e 3 r d and l a t B a t t a l i o n s , 131st I n f a n t r y ,
talionr
87
Ysg and map dropped by L t Borden. 90th A i r Squad, 1520, 10 O c t ; Af,
CO 1st Bn 131st Inf t o CO 131st I n f , 1600 (33rd Div Box 6, 32.16).
88
HiBtory. I, 122 - 240
- 53 -
up t h e l i n e , but i n d i v i d u a l u n i t s dug i n t h e b e s t t h e y could.n89
89
History, I, 124.
90
Msgs, Coady CO 1st B n t o CO 131st Inf. 2016. 2246, 2400, 10 Oat (33rd
D l v Box 6 , 32016).
91
Msg, IdD t o CO 131st Inf, 2400, 10 Oct (33rd Div Box 18, 32.16).
- 5 4 -
S\tiaa.t,- Ma.f Mo.5
l'I., ... , .. , ....... ,.,
-.-'IO Oc~'M9
,...__
3'1. D\ .... ,,. 11,t
D.,., \es
-rt.I'''
~ , u(t1
~, o~~
~, Oct .,.1,.
t'\A P N.O. ll
55
MAP TO ACCOMPANY FIELD NOTES
ON 33 D1V1510N E 1tt.ST uF MIUSE
-
I
U
OVEULAY T O
M A P NO. I \
.
.
"
du Cable and above Consenvoye, posses8od anything l i k e t h o coho8ion indi-
oated on t h e s e mapso
92
I i l p t O ~ , I, 1250
93
I, 125, 130, 362. L t r , CO YO Co 132nd Inf t o CO 132nd Inf,
30 J G subs p R p t on Aotion...in Bois du Fays, 6 -
12 Oot (33rd Div
Box 20, 33.6).
Cf Msg, MaJ Bullington CO 3rd Eb 132nd I n f t o 0 -
3 33rd Div. 5110 p a e .
10 O o t (33rd Div Box 6 , 32.161% I have had 9 o f f i c e r s an3 about 163 m e n
o a s u a l t i e s . Located in Bois de Fays. My dootor and first a i d people were
all gassed and have gone t o t h e hospital.
- 57 -
-
"Situation...untenaS~e...c3Jditlon of menqo.desperate"
units. "95
94
H i s h r x , I, 126.
95
FO 29, 3 3 r d Div, 9r00 Fern., 10 O c t , ; PM, CG 66th Rr!g t o Opns 0 131st
Inf. 2025. 10 Oct(33rd Div Box 18, 32.16).
Troops " d r i f t i n g t o t h e rear i n l a r g e nuubers upon small excuse"
lem i n t h e St. M i h i e l o p e r a t i o n --
became a r e a l t h r e a t on t h e whole Army
--
a prob-
- 5 8 -
Throughout t h e n i g h t of 10 - 11 October and t h e following day incea-
ings "Am being flanked on r i g h t by heavy machine gunsa Can't hold 011
95 (oont inued)
Box 18, 32.11) quoted a l t r from Gen Bullarda "In t h e f i g h t expect from
even good c f f i o e r s r e p o r t s of t h e i r losses g r e a t e r t h a n e v e r occurred i n
any battle...oExpeot t h e r e f o r e h y s t e r i c a l o u t c r i e s f o r reenforcements long
b e f o r e t h e y a r e neoessary....Make big p r o v i s i o n s f o r m i l i t a r y p o l i c e t o
push men back i n t o t h e f i r i n g line. Search r e a r echelons and k i t c h e n s
96
Msgs. 1st En 131st Inf t o CO 1 3 1 s t Inf, 1000, 1100, 11 Oct (33rd Dlv
Box 16. 32.16; Box 6, 32.16).
- -59
reserve f o r c e s in t h e t r e n c h e s n o r t h e a s t of Consenvoys comprising t h e 1st
and l i t t l e r e o r g a n i z a t i o n of u n i t s or p r e p a r a t i o n of defensive p o s i t i o n s
And he added8
Of t h e messages e x t a n t in t h e records of t h e d i v i s i o n , t h o s e of t h e
1st Battalion, 131st Infantry, a r e most complete. In a f l n a l exchange
with Colonel Sanborn on t h e 12th. Major Coady reported6
51
I, 128
13mhii;zy -
33; YSg, co 131st Inf t o UaJ B i t t l e
1100, 11 Oct (33rd Div Box 18. 32.16).
E
O 3rd En,
The remains of t h e 1st and 3rd Ens, 129th Inf were ordered oonsolldated
in t h e e a r l y morning of t h e 12th (Ysg, PC 130th Inf t o 3rd En 131st Inf
C--
s i c l . 2 ~ 2 0aomo. 12 Oot. 33rd Div Box 18. 32.16).
98
131st Inf Engagement a t B o i s d e Chaume, 10
1 9 ~33.6); Histor& I, 359.
- 14 Oct (33rd Div Box
-.60 -
They c a n ' t p o s s i b l y stand it any longer. [Only 2 o a p t a i m and 3 l i e u t e n a n t s
a r e len.3 t h e o t h e r o f f i o o r a being k i l l e d or rounded. I have approximately
250 men leftt. Moat of them when t h e y g e t out of hero rill be p h y s i c a l
wrecks. Can't something be done t o relimo t h i s s i t u a t i o n t
Colonel danborn r e p l i e d $
S t a y where you a r e and hold the line u n t i l you h e a r f u r t h e r from m0. You
are no worse off t h a n t h e r e s t of t h e troops r h o are holding on and making
no oomplaints.99
The nest day, Major Coady of t h e 1st B a t t a l i o n r a m replaoed by Captain
vanoed its 75's from t h e Bois do Forges t o t h o Bola Jure, with 8eWral
99
Mas, 1st Bn 131st Inf t o CO 131.t Id, 1215, 12 Oot; Mag t o co 1st
Bn. 131at Inf. 1220 (33rd Div Box 18, 32-16),
100
Mag, CO 131st I d , 1500, 13 Oot (33rd D ~ vBOX l8, 32.16).
101
Hiatory, I, 128, 132, 136.
- 61 -
reduced t o defensive c l u s t e r s of exhausted mena A ten-page o p e r a t i o n s re-
Jamet; (Map No. 13), t o reorganice new combat units from it and be ready
I n s p i t e of mmy d i r e c t i o n s in c o r p s o r d e r s on 2, 5, 6, 8, 9.
Octobea t h a t gas -nition l a r g e amounts be fired...
t h e ammunition consvmDtim survey of 10-11 October showed t h a t nothing ap-
proaching t h i s o r d e r wn8 achieved. According to t h i s survey o n l y 2.262
rounds of gas a g a i n s t 29,843 rounds of HE were fired i n t h e e n t i r e group
areao I ask a l l headquarters w i t h all t h e i r means t o o a r r y out t h e glven
- 62 -
~ . ,...... ..,
L'\" ....... t . . ...
s. "~ ...... .
'9+.... ..,_ \\. '0 ,I.I
" '"'" .,,.,..,;tt.,,
Sew ~"'6o..- ,._,,
,.,...,.':~.... ...... ~. Gt"' .......
fOu 'f'ilA
Sltu.atio ,,Oct
63
o r d e r s regarding the expenditure of g a s emuunition. lCM
TAM-
Opns 0 4268. Maas O s t . 12 Oct (German Files Box 48, f o l 810-32.13).
Of t h e s e five orders, only t h a t of 8 Oat h a s beea found i n t h e German
files. Maas West Order 759. 12 Oct, s i m i l a r l y ordered more "generous
use of gas" and "more gas t h a n shrapnel," but p v e no anuo sumnary.
-
West lPneAI 24 Sep -
11 Nov, German F i l e s Box 50, f o l 11, p. 61).
(Maas -
Notes T h i s is t h e only German document giving p r e c l s e f i g u r e s on g a s
ammo emended. Presumably t h e period of time over which t h e 2.262 zas
shells ;ere f i r e d by t h e a r t y o'f t h e 7 t h Res Div 1st A-I Div,-32nd-Div,
and 228th.Div
to. 2 -
12 Oct.
--all of Maas Ost -- -8
w a a t of t h e o o r p e orders r e f e r r e d
105
Div Orders 127/10 and 135/10
German F i l e s Box 155, Pol I, pp.
WDU, 1 3 Sep - 19 Oat,
106
L t r , COO I11 Corps t o COO F i r s t Amy. 27 Oct, sub6 Weekly Rpt, 2 1
Oct (1st Amy Box 340. 111 CW).
-64-
I t w a s t h e n i g h t of 13 - 15 October before p a r t i a l l y regrouped u n i t s
on t h e e a s t bank moved i n t o t h e defense, support, and r e s e r v e p o s i t i o n s
h a r d e s t h i t in t h e c o u n t e r a t t a c k on t h e 9th, remained i n t h e t r e n c h e s
107
near t h e r e s e r v e s a t Consanvop.
11) D
Meuse.
Ti)7
Box :m 2).
I, 136 - 37. Sea Opns 0 10, 130th Inf, 1 9 Oot (33rd Div
for t h e f i n a l defensive organization.
108
Opns o f 2nd En, 129th Inf. History, 11, 657.
109
801. 129th Inf, 13 - 15 Oct (33rd Div Box 16, 32.16).
- -66
Yodest Gains
In e x t e n u a t i o n of t h e Pailure o f t h e 33rd D i v i s i o n t o p u t i t s
-
thefiivry-Villeneuve -
Ferme roadlover-looking t h e r i d g e and eaoh t h e had
110
ppo 413, 442 - 43. N o t q u i t e a t a l l c o s t s . When, about 20 O c t .
t h e 1st A-H Div learned t h a t Maas West had o r d e r s t o withdraw t o t h e
Senta S t e l l u n g (below Aincrev'i1le-DOu~COn) if' a f u l l s c a l e a t t a c k was
made on t h e h i l l s n o r t h of B r i e u l l e s , the d i v i s i o n u r g e n t l y requested
d i r e c t i o n s f o r i t s own withdrawal i n t h a t event (Opns Sec Heekly F@t
3043, P r e p a r a t i o n s f o r Withdrawal and Morale of Troops, 21 Oot, I t a l i a n
F i l e s Box 2, A-H Army Hq).
- 66 -
i n t e r f e r i n g with troops...attempting t o come forward. ... This report
and 597 men wounded, and 643 o f f i c e r s and men evaouated a8 gas and ex-
113
h a u s t i c n cases, a t o t a l of 1,302 b a t t l e c a s u a l t i e s .
ALL
131st Inf Engagement at Bcis de Chaume. 10
19, 33.6).
-
14 Oat (3Srd Dlv BOX
Word t h a t t h e 1 3 1 s t I n f had reached t h e o b j e c t i v e three times
VBB r e p o r t e d Ln a s i n g l e Msg, Opns Off 1 3 1 s t Inf t o Opns O f f 66th Brig.
1550. 10 Oct (33rd Div Box 18, 32.16).
112
In 33rd Div Box 5, 32.12 Opns 0 , is an o v e r l a y w i t h o v t d a t e , i d e n t l -
f i c a t i o n , or explanation, showing s i x c i r c l e d t a r g e t s i n l a Grande Montagne,
including H i l l s 377 and 375, and a seventh c i r c l e around a l l Sivry-Sur-
Meuse. Gas or smoke on t h e s e areas might w e l l have a i d e d t h e advance on
t h e 33rd Div.
113
I. 145. Brig Gen Wolf, Opns on E a s t Bank of t h e Yeuse. 20
F%F
Nov ( r d v Box 15, 33.6). t h e souroe of theme f i g u r e s , aaid of t h e
643 gassed and exhaustion cases t h a t 152 were evacuated on 1 6 Oct. 4 2 9 on
1 7 Oct, and 62 on 16 Oot.
Rpt, 131st Inf Engagement a t Bois de Chaume. 10 -
14 Oot (33rd Div Box
19, 33,6), claimed t h a t 131st Inf o a s u a l t i e s alone were 14 k i l l e d and an
incomplete t o t a l of 141 wounded. It a l s o claimed = t h e 43 gas and ex-
h a u s t i o n c a s e s , Else-&ere in t h e same r e p o r t , i n a o o n t r a d i o t o r y set of
f i g u r e s , t h e 131st Inf claimed i t s s t r e n g t h on 8 Oct w a s 57 o f f i c e r s and
2,164 men, and t h a t it l o s t 1 9 o f f i c e r s and 406 men in t h e B o i s de Chaume
operation.
- 67 -
Apparantly it was solely in an e f f o r t t o s t r a i g h t e n out t h e tangle
n4
Add 1 t o FO 29, 3Srd Div, 6900 P?d, 1S Oats Histor
-+I. 139.
reqson whatever is o f f e r e d i n t h e Xistory for t h e ransfer.
No
115
Under d a i l y s h e l l f i r e and b u r s t s of gas f r o m t h e north, northeast,
and e a s t bank of t h e Yeuse, t h e 130th Inf reported t o t e l c a s u a l t i e s a t
t h e time of i t s r e l i e f as 27 men k i l l e d , 9 o f f i c e r s end 135 men wounded
( L t r . CO 130th Inf t o CG 33rd Div, 15 Nov, subs Rpt of Opns, 33rd D l r
BOX 17, 11.4).
116
Historxl. I, 158 - 42.
-68-
117
a g a i n s t t h e Grande Idontagnee
I."
LII
History, I, 145 - 46.
118
History, I, 145 - 49; S O 1 35, 33rd Div, 14 - 15 Oot.
119
History, I. 149. DOR, 15 -
16 Oot r p t d 50 g a s & HE r d s a t t h a t
hour on t h e road east of Consenvoye, w i t h " shelling. in t h e Bols d e
Chaume.
120
History, I. 152 -
55. See G -
2 Plan of Defense. S e c t o r E a s t of
Mause t o Grid Line 24, 17 Oct (33rd Div Box 8, 32.8), which r p t d t h a t
t h e ensmy s t i l l held a l l t e r r a i n above Grid 83 e a s t o f t h e Meuse. Be-
tween Vilosnes and Sivry, s a i d G -
2, were elements of t h e 106th Land-
s t u r m Div and 1st A-I, and from Sivry e a s t . elements o f t h e 1 5 t h Div,
7 t h Res Div. and 228th Div.
- 69 -
With American t r o o p s comprising almost two-thlrds of h i s corps forces,
General Claudel had for some time been conoerPed w i t h t h e serious losses
--
a Note do S e r v i c e on 11 October. "has made, d u r i n g sewral c o u n t e r a t t a c k s ,
t o i n s t r u c t t r o o p s in gas defense.
Analysis. below.
12' Notes do S e r v i c e 9361/H, 11 Oct; 946 C/3, 17 Oct (33rd Dlv Box 7,
32.7)
The 33rd Dlv o a s u a l t l e s on t h e 17th may have r e s u l t e d f r o m t h e 45 gas
and HE rounds on t h e 129th Inf i n t h e Bois de C h a w a t 1525 on t h e 16th.
f u r t h e r gas and HE on t h e road above t h e Bois de Cons~nvoyea t 1615, and
three "heavy gas" fires a t 2150, 2400, and 0130, 17 Oat, on t h e road west
of Consenvoye rood.
The 129th I d ' reported nheavy gas" t h l r t e e n times in t h e five- day period,
13 - 18 Oot. See SOIS. 129th Inf (33rd Dlv Box 16, 32.16). Chron R w of
Events of 129th Inf, 19 O O t (33rd Dlv Box 15. 1L05) says t o t a l o a s u a l t i e s
of t h e r e g t , 29 Sep -
19 O O t , were 37 k i l l e d , 1041 wounded or gassed.
- 70 -
Through each of t h e s e days of waiting, from 14 t o 19 October, t h e
previous day's f i r e s
122
SO1 35 - 40, 33rd Div, 14 - 20 O o t .
- 71 -
ell lONCUYOtl
~
:, .
f
J
I 6'~
L
~
"
72
On 16 October, Xliener S t e r n s e l o n M o l l e v i l l e FermeI and Schaumbergmulde
f-
i h e r a v i n e between t h e B o i s de Chaume and B o i s de ConsenvoyeZ]were re-
only i n s l i g h t amounts."
123
32nd Div-Sub Units-WDkA, 8 - 20 O c t (German P i l e s Box 184, f o l 111,
ppo iTT=TTj=e
- 73 -
a t t a o k s , b u t t h e eighth, against t h e 1st Battalion, 129th I n f a n t r y , on t h e
s a i d only 4 9 men, inoluding t h e gas 8COs, were waouated. There had been
124
L t r , 3W t o CGO I11 Corps. 20 Oot, subs
H i s t Box 300, 3306).
Weekly Rpt, 13 - 2 0 O o t (WD
125
DOR, 33rd D i v , 18 - 19 Oat.
. 126
L t r , D W 33rd Div t o C (35, 20 Oot, sub& S p e c i a l apt, g r i d l i n e s 7
24-80 Bois de Consenvoye (WD H i s t Box 300, 33.6, Rpts on Gasqtlcs).
- -
74
Beginning t h e n i g h t of 19 - 2 0 October, as t h e two b r i g a d e s completed
127
FC 30, 33rd Div, 6r15 pame. 19 Oct (33rd Div Box 5, 32.1); H i s t o r
I, 157, 151. Fo 76. F i r s t Army, 18 hr, 19 Oct (USA Fn t h e W, d
s a i d t h e 33rd Div was r e l i e v e d "for t h e purpose of r e l i e v i n g t h e 7 9 t h Dlvv."
128
FO 31, 33rd Div, 8rOO perno, 2 3 Oct.
129
Rpt on Gas Atk (33rd Div B o x 12, 63.33); ltr, DQO 33rd Div t o C CRS.
3 Nov. subs Weekly Rpt (GAF-33rd Div); Note de Servioe. 31 Oct ( S r d Div
Box 7, 32.7); Opns Rgt. 130th Inf,
Spencer's account (History of Gas
quoted i n History, I. 390
Attaoks upon t h e A.E.F..
91. -
11, 367) covers
only p a r t o f t h e a t t a c k .
Following t h i s a t k t h e d i v i s i o n issued Tng Clro l88, nod., on "New Gas
Discipline," Tng Circ 189, 4 Nov. on t h e handling of n u s t a r d g a s oasual-
t i e s , and d i r e c t e d a t t e n t i o n again t o Tng Circ 177, 19 Sep, on m s t a r d
gas defense. C f . Hlstorx, I, l84, 188.
- 75 -
and 11 November, t h e 33rd Division s u s t a i n e d 329 gas c a s u a l t i e s . 130
ANALYSIS '
The B a t t l e C a s u a l t i e s o f t h e S3rd D i v i s i o n
130
33rd Div WO Monthly Rpt of Gas Casualtien, N o r e m b e r 1918 (Om-
33rd Div). T h i s r p t inoluded 166 gas oases for t h e l a t t e r p a r t of Oot,
not r p t d on t h e Oct summary. and 174 betreen 1 13 Nov. -
131
Hiator& I, 216 - 17; 111, 127.
132
I. 296, 460- Cf. Ayres. The W a r w i t h Oermanyr A S t a t i s -
114, 117.
- 76 -
seem excessive (though unchallengeable a t t h e moment) in t h o l i g h t of d i v i -
133
H i s t o r & I, 166 - 67; III> 368.
134
Rgt, B e l l t o G
(33rd Div Box 45, 314.7).
- 3 F i r s t Army, 28 Deo, subs Rpt of Opus of 33rd Div
135
Chart i n F i r s t Army Box 342-COO Misc Corresp, r h a s 1,807 gaa oasual-
ties in t h e 33rd Div for 27 Ssp
See also p. 90 , b e l a .
-
10 Oot and 2.016 for 27 Sop 17 tkm. -
- 77 -
The Qas Casualties
A comparison of Diviaion Oas Offioer and Corps Qas Offioer daily gas
mission l i s t s is as fo110rsr1R6
-
DOO
26 Sop 14
27 Sep 1
28 Sep 3
29 Sop 4 19
30 Sep 20
1 Oot 4 25 29 34
2 Oot 12 6 4 13
3 oot 18 17 21 15
4 Oot 29 6 22 37
5 Oct 377 12 161 17
6 Oot 48 $22 381 12
7 Oot 10 179 2 2
8 Oot 3 40 5 11
9 Oat 4 65 74 261 115
10 Oot 134 294 106 97
11 Oot 183 59 91 292
12 Oot 33 162 85 85
13 Oot 14 76 18 24
14 Oot 37 21 37 21
15 Oot 63 53 65 19
16 Oot 120 63 169 5
17 Oot 325 174 306 13
18 Oot 387 58 142 4
1 9 Oot 84 62 14
20 Oot 9 12 5
21 Oot
- - -
2,357
2
1,641f3 1,978
5
-
892
136
DGO d a t a from FQt of Gas C a s u a l t i e s . 33rd Div. Oot 1918 (QAF-JJrd
Div).
CGO dnta from Rpt of @as C a s u a l t i e s , I11 Corps. O o t 1918, ( F i r s t A m y Box
340-111 C). The r p t a l s o shows t h a t the Corps' 4 t h Div ha8 897 gas oasual-
t i e s Ln O o t , t h e 8 0 t h had 1,328, t h e 90th 395, t h e 3rd Div 602, and t h e 5th
Div 507. f o r a oorpa t o t a l of 5,323 in Oot, e x o l u s i v e o f 3 gas d e a t h s i n
t h e 331.6 Div (in f i g u r e s above) and 9 in t h e 90th Div.
Both gas and BE c a s u a l t y data in t h e l a s t tm oolumns are from t h e admis-
slun l i s t s of FHs 129 and 132 (33rd Div, M e d Dept Boxes 5711, 3714), FB 318
(80th Dive Med Dept Box 3883). and FA 114 (29th Div. &d Dept Box 3650).
- 78 -
k breakdown by units of tbe daily gas casualties recorded by the m and LLLI found i n the f i e l d hospital lints n r s a l s :
26 Sop
27 Sop
28 SOP
29 Ssp 2 2 4
30 sep
1 oct 2 2 29 4 29
2 oct 4 4 3 1 1 2 1 1 2 4
3 OCt 1 2 17 18 1 la 21
4 OCt 8 8 1 2 1 2 1 19 7 1 29 22
s oct 555 w8 9 1 6 e 1 3 1 311 161
6 Oot 36 502 1 2 1 8 5 2 4 1 4s 581
?act la
~~ e 10 2
8 oct 1 1 1 1 2 3 5
9 oct 251 116 1 3 39 142 51 I2 1 2 465 251
10 O C t 2.9 31 1 8 Lo 85 51 6 3 2 l34 106
11 O C t 26 26 15 3l lza 19 4 6 la 91
l2 O C t 3 85 2 9 22 l8 25 33 85
13 Oct v 5 S 1 5 14 la
u OCt ; 3 1 9 6 20 21 1 1 3
11
31
63
31
65
w OCt 10 23 1 2 13 14 31 10 1
1 E UO
16 Oct 44 E6 14 29 133 2.5 e I 4 l69
11 O C t 42 51 2 2% 240 26 7 16 6 17 325 ?a6
l8 O C t 97 65 27 11 182 5s s1 1 6 16 24 1 387 1u
19 Oct 83 52 6 2 1 2 84 62
20 oct 1 5 8 5. 1 1 9 u
-_ 1 2 2 5
- - -- - - - - ---
21 oct 2 1 1
_ c - - - T
- -
1,014 996 83 51 10 7 549 540 540 240 90 66 23 0 8 I 40 $4 2,351 1.978
-79-
I.
The f i g u r e of 1,978 gas C a s u a l t i e s compiled from h o s p i t a l admission
The h o s p i t a l p i c t u r e is f u r t h e r complioatsd by t h e h o t t h a t t h e
'137
Medical Dept of t h e U S Army i n t h e World War (Washingtonr
1925), VIII. 625 27. - GPO,
138
apt of Gas C a s u a l t i e s . 33rd Div, Sep 1918 (OAF 3Srd Div), DOR,
- -
33rd Div. 28
-
29 Sep (33rd Div Box 8 . 33.1) r e p o r t s t o t a l c a s u a l t i e s
of 4 o f f i c e r s end 329 men between 26 29 Sep.
- 80 -
n e v e r t h e l e s s a p p a r e n t l y operated as a gas h o a p i t a l f o r a s h o r t t i m e ,
139
M s 11, 1 2 , 108th S e n T r , 33rd D l v , 3, 6 Oot (MS. Msdioal H l s t o r y
of t h e 33rd Dfv, Ued Dept Box 3704. f o l I).
140
Memo for Dllv Surgeons fr OCS XI1 Corps, 7 Oot (Medloal History,
above) a
141
F i r s t Army Box 342, CGO Miso Corresp.
- 81 -
for October, Lieutwozit Vawter ex2iaclLeat h a t t h e f i g u r e s had been
-
on Dowb.;-A* "7th one rsginent evacuetsd over 600 men as gassed. T h i s
regimeat hsd i m n out .3i'ttie a c t i v e area 48 hours. P r a c t i c a l l y every
man who was exaninec was found C3t t o be gassed b u t s u f f e r i n g from m-
hwustioa end cord. The r e c o r d s of c a s u a l t i e s are based on hon a is
P
tagged BI; tu goes back s a d not PS tire ccse is a c t u a l l y foullii. A 1 1 of
t h e o e meti wm-3 oack ?or duty in a few days. '
the 18Ck r u ZSth t h e 131st Irfeniry h%i some 400 men evacirated as
gassed, w:d L C \as found laeer t h a t tha men were suffering frm Golds
E 3 - d exhrrusxion~ Tho Division Medical Gcs Officer s t a t e d t h a t
p o s s i b l y 303 t o 400 cf t h e o t h e r s mre evacuated t h e same wayo If gas
was n o t used t h e s s would not ba bvacuatsd but due t o t h e b e u e f l t of t
doubt tha-c the men must h w e , it l a n e o e s s a r y t o c a l l them gas case*. Pa2
142
Ltr, DijO TO C C W , 2 Nov, s u b r Casualty Rp%; ltr, DGO t o C CWS, 22
F& 13. subs Gas A t k s (OAF-33rd Div). NO correipondenoe Of t h e WGO has
been found.
7
Rpt. Surg. 1 Y 1 ? r %led H i s t or l 3 r d Div, p o 23.
had'been gassed," and t h a t t h e r e were "more v e s i c a t i n g than asphyxiating
7
Rpt. mBD,
130th Inf. Med H i s t of t h e 39rd Div. ppe 21 - 220
145
Med H i s t o f t h e 33rd Div, pp. 15. 16.
- 83 -
determined," and 28 "mixed gas." T h i s d i s t r i b u t i o n appears t o agree with
t u a l exhaustion-
- 84 -
c l e a r from t h e n a r r a t i v e (pp. 50 - 54, - 61).
60 Furthermore, t h e Division
but these men had been i n t h e line f o r almost five reeks, without rest
and under constant harassing fire, and were " dirty, t i r e d . and with a
-
e a s t o f t h e Meuse should be mentioned, even though it has proved negative.
L t r . Do0 t c CGO 111 Corpa, 13 Oct, sub, @as Ftpts (OAF-3Srd Div).
- 05 -
concern would be found i n t h e reoords when 33rd and 29th D i v i s i o n t r o o p s
Gas and HE S h e l l
600 mixed gas and HFia The a o t u a l count of OMmy HE s h e l l comes t o 5.481,
f l a n k i n g fire," e t c .
147
Ltr, COO F i r s t Army t o CG 111 C o r p s , 5 Oct. aubr Mustard gassed s
areas n o r t h of Verdun (GAF-1st A). See Cole J. !?W. . Schulm, 1st Army GO,
6 -
lecture Execution of Gas P l h n s for the.+.A-M Opn, 17 Jan 1919. p a 19 (GHQ
3 R p t s Box 3153, f o l 1090-4)s "Our 33rd and 29th Divisions, with-
o u t any r e s u l t i n g ill e f f e c t s , b e r a t e d a c r o s s t h e Meuse3 over ground
t h a t had been mustard gassed up t o six days beforehand."
- 86 -
h i l e a mere 4.201 rounds were f i r e d i n t o t h e s e c t o r i n t h a t period by
t h e GWUM a r t i l l e r y o r d e r s f o r t h e n i g h t l y h a r a s s i n g misslona w l t h .
gas and HE are fairly complete, none of them, w i t h t h e exoeptlOXl Of t h e
5
32nd Division orders ln t h e l a t t e r p a r t of October, l n d l o a t e s t h e n u -
- 87 -
known t o have been k i l l e d t h a t day, by exploding gas s h e l l fragments dur-
ing t h e g a s attack-
33rd. --
Maas West a r t i l l e r y . for which m have no d a t a , also f i r e d on t h e
-
s e c t o r alone during t h e t e n days between 2 - 11 Ootober.
Betw-een 2 - 12 October. t h e D i v i s i o n Gas Offioer r e p o r t e d a t o t a l
- 88 -
On t h e b a s i s o f 935 gas c a s u a l t i e s , t h e 2,262 gas rounds produced a
f o r each round c a s u a l t y .
.
The D i v i s i o n Gas Officer's e s t i m a t e of 1,885 gas s h e l l s f a l l i n g in
:
ualty.
s u f f i c i e n t l y pronounced f o r o e r t a i n diagnosis.
gas E i t h o u t any
3 s p e c i f i c gas a t t a c k made, although d a l l y c a a u a l t i e s
- 89 -
from gas occuro" Gas c a s u a l t i e s could n o t t h e r e f o r e be a s c r i b e d t o spe-
c i f i c gas a t t a c k s , and h ~ 8 v e rl a r g e t h e i r numbers, could o n l y be summed
up ekch week and so r e p o r t e d . 148
I11 Corpsr
-
Gassed Other
I_ -
TOTAL
3rd Division 602 1,106 1,708
4th Divislon 9lFl 1.909 2.827
5th Division 565 3,510 4,075
32nd Division 16 116 131
33rd Division 1,716 + 3 deaths 8 96 2,612
80th Division 1,462 2,750 4,212
90th Dlvision 449f 9 deaths
5,727 +12 doathe
-1.650
11,937
2,099
G 149
The figures c o r r o b o r a t e t h e Cistinction achieved by t h e 33rd Division in
:28
L t r , CGO I11 Corps t o C clls A t t Def Div, 27 Oct, subr Reaord cf Gas
Atks ( F i r s t A W BOX 340, XI1 CO).
149
Ltr, CGO I11 C t o COO F i r s t Amy. 19 NOV, subs Rpt on Gas A o t i v i t i e s
from Sep 9 t h t o Nov 1 1 t h ( F i r s t Army Box 340). The estimate of 111 Corps
+ h a t 35,000 gas s h e l l s were f i r e d i n t o i t s area during t h i s p e r i o d would
i n d l z z t e a gas o a s u a l t y f o r e w r y six s h e l l s .
A similar c h a r t i n Itr. CGO 1 x 1 Corps t o C CWS, 12 Nov, subr Rpt on Gas
A c t i v i t i e s for October (Box 340 and OAF-I11 Corps) shows t o t a l s o f 5,323
gas o a s u a l t i e s ( i n c l u d i n g 12 deaths) and 9,214 o t h e r c a s u a l t i e s e
S t i l l a t h i r d c h a r t . in I11 Corps Rpt on Prisoners, Caeualties...from 26
Sep t o 11 Nov. 18 Nov ( 5 t h Div B O X 4, 16,l) shows t o t a l s of 6,041 gas
c a s u a l t i e s and 15,167 warnded. In t h i s c h a r t , 38 o f f i c e r s and 1,963 men
in t h e 33rd Div were gassed and 8 o f f i c e r s and 1,169 men were wounded.
- 90 -
s p e c i a l i n t e r e s t is t h e c l o s e agreement between oorps' " o t h e r " f i g u r e of
896 and t h e h o s p i t a l wounded t o t a l of 892 through 21 October. (No expla-
t h a t Corps. As was shown i n Study No. 4, 'Vhe 26th Divislm in the Aisne-
Marne Campaign" (pp. 63 - M), t h e French, under e i m i l a r or even h e a v l e r
American d i v i s i o n , t h e d i s p r o p o r t i o n a t e c a s u a l t y f i g u r e s below i n d i c a t e
t h a t ,herloan d i v i s i o n s were lndeed e i t h e r inexperienced or carelesst 151
i 1 5 t h Col. 1 0
33rd Div 186 49 17 20 5 37 3 11
29th. Div 2 12 93 193 264 41 35 10 46
26th Dfv 13 11 24 11
18th Fremh 50 15 13 57
26th Frenoh 89 21 12 3 3 4 2 a
1 0 t h Col. 9 12 0 6
o f f i c e r s and gas o f f i o e r s .
151
33rd Div Box 2, 20023.
- 92 -
o r g a n l e a t i o n , d e s p i t e t h e f a c t t h a t t h e d i v i s i o n w a s t o prove unique i n
g a s d e f e n s e of t h e Division.n152
r e g i m e n t a l h i s t o r i e s r e p o r t f i r i n g l a r g e q u a n t i t i e s of E
3 b u t no amoke
or g a s s h e l l s . 153
LJL
Ltr, Capt T. II. Balfe, OCGO F i r s t Army t o CCO F i r s t Army, 27 Oat,
sub8 T r i p t o 33rd Div f o r ACofS G -
4 ( F i r s t Army Box 339, 470). N e i t h e r
Col Vandervater nor h i s h e a d q u a r t e r s h a s been i d e n t i f i e d .
153
R e p o r t s and h i e t o r i e s in 33rd Div Box 11, 44.6; Box lS, 44.6; Bas
12, 32.12,
- 93 -
The Division Gas Officer explained t h i s reoord o f t h e 52nd FA Crigade
But t h e time had passed when it might have been e f f e c t i v e l y used, and pre-
out.
-
The Yellw Cross Division
154
Memo, 15 Oot, n e e e (WD H i s t Box 300, 35.6, Use of Gaa by Arty),
165
Memo, 111 Corps t o a l l d i v i s i o n s , sub) T a o t i o a l Defects (90th Div
Box 6. 32.15).
-94-
c
.*
.
-
- 95 -
L
~
-
i
i
..-
.