PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY

Author(s): Collier Cobb

Source: The North Carolina High School Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 4 (OCTOBER, 1910), pp. 152-
160
Published by: University of North Carolina Press
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/43822424
Accessed: 29-06-2017 22:08 UTC

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted
digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about
JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms

University of North Carolina Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
The North Carolina High School Bulletin

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
152 The North Carolina

PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY

Collier Cobb, Professor of Geology .

PURPOSE OF THE COURSE - TRAINING FOR SERVICE.

The study of the earth sciences is designed not merely to

give the pupil a knowledge of facts regarding the earth, bu
to give him some insight into the laws of nature, and to trai
him in such a way in field observation and laboratory practic
as to fit him for effective service in whatever field of labor
he may find himself.
It is the same old story with all effective education, which
comes through seeing, thinking, doing. No other subject serves
this purpose so completely as geography, which Herbart has
called the associating science.
The common American greeting, ' ' How do you do ? ' ' should
bring teachers to a realization of the demand of the land and
the times for education through doing and education for
doing ; and geography in its various aspects has more relations
to human activity than any other study in the curriculum.
Its intimate connection with history was long ago recognized ;
and all of us are what we are largely because we are where
we are. Yet man, through a knowledge of his surroundings,
may gain a mastery over nature or adapt himself to his envi-
ronment. That education is best which gives one this power.
PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY DEFINED.

It is only within recent years that geography could pro

erly be called a science, consisting a generation ago of litt
more than a bald "description of the earth, its phenomena,
countries, and its inhabitants. ' ' Then physical geography
had a fairly well recognized field of knowledge, not clearly
delimited it is true, and having to do chiefly with nature 's more
spectacular phases, volcanoes, earthquakes, tides, tornadoes,

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
 High School Bulletin 163

glaciers, races of men, but dealing in nowise

way with the causes or effects of these phys
phenomena. The knowledge it presented was w
ing, and much of it is too often overlooked in
work today ; but its methods are now open to cri

From being a mere description of the ear

today includes not only the phenomena perta
but their areal distribution, and causes theref
of geography had its origin in America, and began in the
energetic study of topographic forms, involving their genesis
and classification. This new science became known as physi-
ography, a name borrowed from England, where the term is
still used in its etymological sense, and includes the whole
realm of nature.

With the rebirth of physiography came the introduction

into it of the laboratory method of teaching, thus putting
it on the same basis as other physical sciences. Today both
physical geography and physiography are clearly recognized
as distinct phases of earth science, and of very unequal diffi-
culty; physical geography should be taught to all pupils as
the geographic course preceding the high school, or in the
first year of the high school; physiography is to be offered
toward the close of the high school course. Advanced physi-
ography is distinctly a university study.
The confusing of two ideas and the effort to adapt the more
specialized course to young pupils who need a broad, interest-
ing, unspecialized introduction to earth science, has deprived
the pupil in the grammar grades of an interesting study and
a distinctive stimulus to the imagination, which President
Eliot has spoken of as the greatest of human powers, no matter
in what field it works. True, advanced physiography demands
a well-ordered imagination in the university student, which
does not come at his bidding unless he has had proper training

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
 154 The North Gasolina

in the grammar gradee ; but the subject as

leges is powerless to develop this imaginatio
pupils of the schools.
PRESENTATION OP THE SUBJECT.

In presenting the subject of physical geography, the teach

should have constantly in mind that he is training the pu
for life, for a proper appreciation and understanding of h
surroundings, rather than fitting him for college. He sho
bring himself to a realization of the meaning and scope
his subject, dealing with real things, and touching life at ev
point. Physical geography is coming more and more to be
the study of the earth in relation to life; and the earth is to
be looked upon as a field for the development of organic life.
Mackinder, of Oxford, has defined geography as a study
of the present in the light of the past. When thus conceived
it forms a fitting complement to geology, which, as defined
by the same author, is the study of the past in the light of
the present. The studies are inseparable, and, up to a certain
point, their physical aspects may be well followed together
under some such name as physiography. (Davis.)
But geology is the science which investigates the history
of the earth, and the rocks of the earth's crust contain the
records of this history. Geological study shows, too, that forces
similar to those of the present have been operating in the past,
and most naturalists believe that they are sufficient, given
ample time, to account for all the changes that have taken
place in the earth's crust. But geography is only geology in
the making. It is to geology what the daily newspaper is to
history.
STUDYING THE MATERIALS OP THE EARTH'S CRUST.
There is no reason, then, for deferring until the college
years the study of common rocks. The child, even in the kin-
dergarten, may gain a speaking acquaintance with them, may

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
 High School Bulletin 155

know them when he meets them in the road. The characters

by which they may be recognized, and something of their his-
tory, he may learn by direct observation and simple experi-
ment. To let a single example suffice: he may learn readily
that sandstone is simply grains of sand cemented together,
and the size and shape of the grains as well as the nature of
the cement he may discover for himself, if the teacher will
direct as well as guide the pupil's interest. Similarly, the
child should learn at first hand something of plants and of
animals.

Now all of this may not be physiography, but it does lie

at the very foundation of the study of physical geography,
and is within the comprehension of the children in the gram-
mar grades, certainly within the comprehension of pupils in
the first year of the high school.
field-work.

The larger physiographic processes, requiring direc

servation out of doors and on a larger scale than the
tory study of rocks, are a little more difficult ; but th
of weathering, the protective or destructive work of
of earth-worms, of ants, of the wind, the work of fr
all be noted in any neighborhood. The teacher may no
very far afield with his pupils, but an interest in reg
geography may be developed and lead to valuable resu
a department of geography just now too much neglec
All this leads to a knowledge of the simpler fact
physical geography, of which there is such inexcu
norance, even among persons otherwise well educated,
French geologist De Launay recently published an a
La Nature (Paris, June 25), calling attention to the in
able ignorance of these subjects shown by authors of r
and often even where their departments of learning d

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
156 The North Carolina

such elementary knowledge. De Launay c

it is just as truly physical geography.
The effort made a few years ago to wr
down to the comprehension of our publ
nigh destroyed the interest in physica
sequence of this there is now a strong tende
plan of giving "a broad, unspecialized but vivid course in
physical geography.' ' Such a course is already represented
in our schools, but it needs to be brought more in accord with
modern needs and modern scientific methods. It is with the
problems of such a course that we are immediately concerned.
The choice of subject matter, the topics to be treated in
this introduction to earth science, may be regarded as an open
question. "If the subject matter now given in physical geog-
raphy be ranged in the order of difficulty, beginning with the
easiest, it would probably divide itself somewhat as follows:
(1) common rocks and simple dynamics, subject to direct obser-
vation and experiment; (2) unobserved but spectacular forms
and processes, the descriptive material such as constituted the
bulk of physical geography twenty years ago; (3) genesis and
classification of land forms.' 9 (Fenneman.)

COMMON MINERALS AND ROOKS.

"The subject of common minerals and rocks is not

relatively easy of comprehension, but calculated to hold
interest of children. The subject is eminently concrete
needs little imagination. The facts need pointing out ra
than explaining. ' ' A number of years ago (1883- *84) the
writer gave a course in the common minerals and rocks to
seventh and eighth grade pupils in the Wilson Graded School,
who took the course with enthusiasm, and made and cared for
a fine collection of the common minerals and rocks of the
ounty, a county not supposed to possess any minerals. Cros-

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
 High School Bulletin 157

by 's Common Minerals and Bocks (60 cent

nection with the study. Though now decid
this little book is still the best for the pu
teacher should make constant use of such a manual as Pirs-
son's Bocks and Bock Mineral ($2.50). The subject is far
simpler and easier than the systematic study of land forms,
and is certainly adapted to younger minds.
GEOGRAPHIC PROCESSES.

I can not do better than to quote again from Professor

Fenneman: 4 4 Probably a little more difficult than the stu
of rocks is that of those processes which may be subject t
direct observation or experimentation. It is assumed here
that, in the main, each process can be watched while it makes
appreciable progress, as, for example, evaporation, or the solu-
tion of limestone in water carbonated by the breath, or trans-
portation along a beach ; or the process, if not watched, may
be one which appeals to the imagination as a single act, as the
breaking of rock by frost; or one whose evidences are vividly
concrete, as the oxidation of a rock with change of color. Of
this nature are most of the weathering processes. Consider
the natural sand blast, the making of caves, the work of plant
roots, of earth worms, etc. ; the issuance of spring waters, etc. ;
the rounding of stones and the production of sand and mud by
attrition ; the undercutting of stream banks ; transportation in
solution, in suspension and at the bottom of the streams, etc.
All these and many others are so simple that they need point-
ing out rather than explaining, and once consciously observed,
they will offer a constant allurement to the observation of
natural processes, preparing the mind for more technical
studies. * * * It is certainly easier than the study of
land forms, and -fitted to interest younger minds. The strain
on the imagination begins when the topographic effects of these
processes are considered. That much of this study of processes

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
158 The North Carolina

is commonly called geology, and left to

name, can not be considered as a matter o

BOOKS AND APPLIANCES.

The Maury's Physical Geography of the seventies pre-

sented in a way unsurpassed in its time the kind of descriptiv
geography best suited for informing the pupil of the world
about him and stimulating his imagination. The earth as a
planet, the air, the ocean, and the land, the life of the products
of the earth, with the geographic distribution and physical
relations, all recognized today as the principal themes of a well-
ordered geography course, receive there a treatment stimulat-
ing to the pupil and fully in accord with the best knowledge
and pedagogical methods of the last generation. The pity is
that such an admirable book has been revised out of existence
in an effort to incorporate in it material and methods properly
belonging to a college course, and just beyond the reach of
the average high school pupil. It is fortunate for the pupil
entering on this part of the study if his grammar school work
has been done with some such book as Frye's Complete Geog-
raphy y or the Natural Advanced Geography of Redway and
Hinman, or the Tarr and McMurry geographies. But a suit-
able book for the course in physical geography here outlined
has yet to be written ; and this is doubtless best for the teacher,
as it forces him to go to original sources of information, to
geographical journals, and to the discussions of men actively
engaged in geographical investigation and instruction.
The genesis and classification of land forms is a far more
difficult subject. An acquaintance with the common rocks
and some knowledge of nature's processes gained by first-hand
study will gradually lead the pupil to trust his own eyes "in
matters where process is revealed by its steepness, or the
splitting of a ledge by frost is known by the presence of a talus,

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
 High School Bulletin 159

or the weathering of a limestone is shown by a

rounding a blue interior. It is easy to find m
in almost every locality. It is practicable t
many specimens to be used in a similar way,
is thus obtained by observing nature itself,
used for the same purpose.,, (Fenneman.)
Then the better known land areas may be
cordance with the knowledge thus gained at
the guidance of a skilful teacher ; or, if the
one year, this work had best be confined to o
tal area. Some attention should be given to modeling and
map drawing. The proper use of topographic maps should
be learned. The little book on Governmental Maps , by Davis,
King and Collie, will be a great help with this part of the
work. Professional paper No. 60, of the U. S. Geological Sur-
vey, on The Interpretation of Topographic Maps is indispens-
able to the teacher, and may be purchased from the Superinten-
dent of Documents at Washington. Map Making and Map
Reading , by Robert M. Brown, in the Journal of Geography,
February, 1904, will be found very helpful. Goode's Sun
Board is a simple instrument which is invaluable to the teach-
er who would make geography something real to his pupils.
It may be used for a variety of purposes, among them to es-
tablish the true meridian of the observer and to determine his
latitude. It is manufactured by the Central Scientific Com-
pany of Chicago, and sold by them for $12.00 net.
Enough practical use should be made of the weather maps
ing of the general principles of weather changes and forecasts.
Davis's Practical Exercise in Physical Geography is a valuable
little book. But the teacher, having thoroughly acquainted
himself with his subject, must work out his own methods in
the field and laboratory. The best books are full of excellent
illustrations, and hev also furnish many reference to the

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
160 The North Carolina

literature of the several subjects. Fairbanks Practical Phy-

siography is especially worthy of note on account of its illus-
trations.

The teacher should own a copy of Salisbury's Physiog-

raphy. He should, of course, be a subscriber to such a periodi-
cal as the Journal of Geography (Madison, Wisconsin, $1),
and can get much help with the second part of the course from
the National Geographic Magazine (Washington, D. C., $2.50).
He should own some standard text-book of geology. LeConte 's
Elements of Geology ($4) presents the subject in the most at-
tractive way, but it has not been kept fully abreast of geolog-
ical progress. The College Geology of Chamberlain and Salis-
bury ($3.50) is very valuable, and every geography teacher
should begin his professional library with The New Basis of
Geography ($1.50), by Jacques W. Redway. A suggestive book
for the teacher is Sutherland's The Teaching of Geography ,
and every teacher should own a copy of Hodge's Nature Study
and Life (Ginn & Co.).
Above all, the teacher should prepare himself to teach such
a course. He may get much help by attending a good summer
school where physical geography is taught. He will find a
magic lantern an invaluable aid in his work. Text-book illus-
trations should be supplemented by diagrams, photographs,
lantern slides, etc., and should be further enforced by fre-
quent trips to points of interest out of doors. Is such a course
as that here indicated possible in the high schools of North
Carolina ? Clearly, yes ; but we cannot come to it immediately,

but must work up to it carefully and by degrees.

This content downloaded from 148.231.10.114 on Thu, 29 Jun 2017 22:08:53 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms