Rej 9

Renewable
Energy
Journal
TARGETING
12%
IN
EUROPE
2010
N9 - NOVEMBER
1999
The Netherlands: Campaign for

500 photovoltaic Take-Off: Immediate
Boarding
homes
Wind energy
in Spain
>2000 MW in 2000
W ith the June launch of Campaign for Take-Off, 1999

heralds the return in strength of renewable energies in
Europe. Dynamized by the target of covering 12% of
energy consumption of the fifteen member states in 2010,
promoters of energies from the sun, the wind, underground heat, water and biomass have never been as invenEDITORIAL
tive and active as they are now. Partnerships are being

signed, technologies are progressing and costs are decrea-
sing, and the States are committing themselves to renewable energies.

This new momentum deserved a dynamic and enterprising journal. Thats why weve
transformed Renewable Energy Journal. Both in content and form. Less institutional
than in past issues, its now become more attractive and varied, and more consistent
as well. Its 40 pages are just as many windows opened on to the Europe of renewable
energies. Just like all the energies that it highlights, the journal has opted for diversity.
It features reports and commentaries, discovery of remarkable new achievements,
news briefs, and facts and figures on the situation of the different sectors.
A communication tool with a circulation of 20 000 copies throughout all of Europe,
Renewable Energy Journal means to both accompany the actors in development of
their activities and help create new vocations. With Renewable Energy Journal in
Immediate
boarding
hand, take your seat in the Europe of renewable energies. Boarding for 2010 has begun.
ALAIN LIBARD, PUBLISHING EDITOR
R E N E WA B L E E N E RG Y J O U R N A L N 9
Renewable Energy Journal n9

six-monthly/November 1999
CONTENT
18
4
REPORT
Wind Energy in Spain

2 000 MW in 2000
11
OUTSTANDING PROJECTS
A Housing
estate of
500 photovoltaic
homes
ECONOMY UPDATE
Green certificates:
The Netherlands
shows the way
Austria: Companies catch up
to a market settled
by aficionados
20
AROUND EUROPE
14
2
Germany: Guaranteed Solar Results

Greece: Simplified steps for independent producers
Coming events
The european Investment Bank: 770 million euros
for renewables in Europe
Ireland: New wind farm in Connemara
Wales: Wind and sun to solve traffic congestion
Renewable Energy Journal

is published by
SYSTMES SOLAIRES
146 rue de lUniversit
75007 Paris - France
Tl.: + 33 1 44 18 00 80
Fax: + 33 1 44 18 00 36
TS
Publishing Editor: Alain Libard

Editor-in-Chief:
Yves-Bruno Civel
Editors: Monique Trancart,
Maylis Gaillard
Translator: Jeffrey A. Raymond
Designer: Linette Chambon,
Grafibus
Advertising Manager:
Thierry Plault
Administration: Simone Lger
24
Distribution: Franklin
Consultants Company Ltd.
192, Franklin Road
Birmingham
B30 2HE - United Kingdom
Tel.: + 44 121 459 4826
Fax: + 44 121 459 8206
Printing: Imprimeries de
Champagne
Copyright registration: 1999
(fourth quarter)
ISSN 1276 - 7573
EUROBSERVER
BAROMETERS
>
>
>
>
Illustrators: Pei-Sin & Alexis,

Patrick Taron, Luc Maillet
Geothermal Energy
Photovoltaic Energy
Microhydraulic Energy
Wind Energy
33
Picture credits:
Bertrand Bodin/Foc photo
(cover) - Systmes Solaires/
Monique Trancart (p 4/5, 6,
8, 9, 11) - Ecotecnia (p 7) Fondation Energies pour le
Monde/Rmy Delacloche
(p 11, 12, 13) - Greek Tourist
Office/Paris (p 14) - Dulas
(p 17) - Jan van Ljken (p 18,
19, 20) - AEE (p 20, 21, 22) Ecowatt (p33) - Alain Joseph
(p 34/35) - ObservER/
Bertrand Bourgenot (p 39).
PROJECT UPDATE
A 13th century
water mill connected to the grid
First wind turbines in Croatia
36
34
ON LINE
Renewable Energy Journal is
available on line
www.systemes-solaires.com
EUROPEAN COMMISSION NEWS
Campaign for Take-Off

Evaluation of the Thermie programme
from 1995 to 1998
Altener 1998 > 203 proposals ranked
from good to excellent
The European Directive is back on the tracks again
Implanting 200 000 m2 of solar collectors in Wallonia
Renewable Energy Journal

is published in the framework
of a joint action between
SYSTMES SOLAIRES and
Franklin Company Consultants Ltd., with financial support of EC DGXVII-ALTENER
programme.
2 000 MW IN 2000
Wind energy in Spain

Spain ranks third in terms of wind
energy in Europe. Its wind power capacity has been soaring for the past five
years. Two regions are at the forefront
in this, Galicia and Navarra. Each
autonomous region has its own way
to develop wind energy.
n Navarra, theyre called molinos de
viento (wind mills) and in Galicia, they
call them aerogeneradores (aerogenerators). Two different autonomous regions with two different ways of naming
wind turbines and two different methods of
developing wind energy in a same country Spain - where the sector is in full expansion.
At mid 1999, nearly 1 000 MW of wind energy
had been installed or were under construction,
and more than 1 834 MW are expected for the
I
4
end of the year. The National Energy Scheme

(Plan energetico national) which had planned on wind capacity reaching 2 000 MW in
the year 2000, is likely to be surpassed. In 1998
alone, more wind power - 535 MW - was installed than in any previous years (455 MW).
A decree thats helping this progress
Wind energy has been boosted by the Spanish Electric Sector Law (November 27, 1997).
This law guarantees that electrical energy produced by renewable energies be purchased at
a price which ensures its economic viability.
In keeping with this law, a decree published
on December 23rd, 1998 sets out conditions
regarding prices. For instance, one kilowatthour produced by wind energy is bought at
11.20 pesetas (0.08 euro). This is nearly twice
the price of a kilowatt-hour produced by traditional energies (thermal, nuclear or large
hydroelectric). Consumers pay around 14 pesetas (0.11 euros) for one kilowatt-hour (1).
REPORT
coal thermal plants (2 500 MW) and one oil
thermal plant (500 kW), but local brown coal
reserves are nearly exhausted. The region imports oil and coal, and it has recently begun to
buy gas from abroad. But it is well provided
with renewable energy sources such as hydraulic, wind and biomass. Wind in itself is
on its way to reaching 14% of total energy
consumption and 50% of electric consumption
in the year 2010.
50% of electricity consumption
supplied by wind
In the mountain of Barbanza,

a capacity of 29 MW is produced
by 86 Made turbines.
Situated at the very North-West of corner of

Spain, with a jagged coastline (1 300 km),
the region is a very windy one. A study, called Ordenamiento eolico de la comunidad
autonoma de Galicia, was made in 1995. It
evaluated a wind capacity of 5 500 MW in
Galicia and made the first map of the main
wind areas taking environmental protection
into account.
Development of renewable energies is seen as
a way to stimulate economy and employment.
One of the criteria of selection of wind projects
by the Xunta of Galicia is that 70% of investments induced by wind energy be injected into
local companies or activities. At the same
time, energy savings are promoted. An economic boom accompanied by soaring energy
consumption makes no sense for the government of Galicia.
The first turbines were installed on the North
coast, at Estaca de Bares, in 1987. But wind
energy was not seriously considered until
1995, and new sets of turbines were built in
1997. In mid-1999, a capacity of 257 MW provided 800 GWh per year. Around 550 MW
should be working at the end of 2000.
The Strategic Wind Schedule (Plan eolico estratgico) foresees 2 800 MW in 2005. By this
time, 5 600 GWh per year should be produced
through wind energy. How has Galicia succeeded in setting up such large scale wind farms
so quickly?
The autonomous region of Galicia comes in

first for wind energy with 257 MW functioning
(accounting for one third of Spanish wind poAn opportunity for all reliable candidates
wer). It has recently overtaken Navarra which
was the leader of all the autonomous commuThings started in November 1993 with a Euronities with a capacity of 237 MW until 1998.
pean meeting on wind energy which took plaWhy are these two autonomous regions above
ce in Santa Maria harbor. This meeting
all of the others? Galicia wants to increase its
stimulated existing Spanish projects and atlocally available energy capatracted foreign investors. At
city. Through its Chamber of The Spanish Electric
the beginning of 1995, 33 proCommerce and Industry, the Sector law guarantees
jects amounting to 850 MW
Xunta de Galicia (Galician that electrical energy
were ready to go ahead, waiRegional Government), set produced by renewable ting for permits. This strong
up a special institution in energies be purchased
interest forced the regional ad1983 to analyze the energetic at a price which
ministration to begin an orgapotential of the region, to ensures its economic
nization and planning process.
study technical solutions, viability.
On July 6th, 1995, the Xunta
and to design and manage
of Galicia issued a decree creaprojects. Gestenga (Gestion
ting the concept of the Strateenergtica de Galicia) was born as a result of
gic Wind Schedules (Planes eolicos
this. Its capital is mainly public and it is focuestrategicos). Within this framework, candised on renewable energies. Local electricity
dates wishing to invest in wind farms must
production exists in Galicia thanks to three
submit an application file indicating the wind >>
Wind
turbines
compete
for
fame
capacity is dealt with
>> potential of the site
When the schedule
they wish to develop
in three three-year
and the investments comes to an end, more long phases from 1997
they plan to make. If than 2 000 jobs will
to 2005.
their project is accep- have been created
ted by the Xunta, they for an investment of
26 wind farms in 2000
receive
investment 33 500 million pesetas
How is the schedule
(258 million euros)
priority for this site.
working? More than
This acceptance is ai- in Galicia.
257 MW are now in
med at securing the infull operation (1999).
vestment and offering
For instance, on the
an opportunity to every reliable candiSierra de Barbanza (40 km south of
date. At the beginning of 1999, 13 wind
Santiago, the capital of Galicia), there
schedules had been approved by the
are 86 turbines (Made machines) for a
Xunta, totaling 3 070 MW divided up
total capacity of 29 MW, and in Paxaover 123 different sites. This important
reiras, on a hill over a beautiful ria,
there are 40 MW connected to the grid
Pilgrims on their way to Santiago
de Compostella have the closest view of
(Eurovento). In 2000, 900 MW should
the El Perdon wind farm (Navarra).
be either tested or in operation in 26
wind farms. Over the period from 1993
to 1999, ten factories have been set up
for manufacturing or assembling components. Several existing plants have
thrived on this new market. Around
300 jobs have been directly created.
When the schedule comes to an end,
more than 2 000 jobs will have been
created for an investment of 33 500
million pesetas (258 million euros) in
Galicia. It is no surprise that, regarding
wind capacity, the Northwestern autonomous community has finally gone
beyond the community of Navarra.
There are 2.8 million inhabitants in Galicia compared to half a million in the
latter.
But the Northern region, Navarra, had
started building significant wind farms
several years before. The first molinos
de vientos were installed at the end of
1994, on the crest of El Perdon, a hill
near Pamplona (capital of Navarra).
One can easily see them from the town
and its even possible to tell the ones
which are not working from the others.
Plane travelers can see them from above when landing. But pilgrims on their
way to Santiago de Compostella have
the closest view. Their path crosses the
line of turbines and a sculpture is dedicated to them. The row of 40 turbines, >>
6
The Xunta de Galicia (Regional

Government) is planning to
manage an unusual wind farm.
Turbines of each different
wind turbine technology
operating in the region will
be installed and put into
competition. This was
included in the original
decree regulating the implementation of wind farms
in Galicia, issued in 1995.
The Xunta, through Sodiga
(a public company) and
Gestenga (a public research
department) aims at evaluating the working conditions
and ease of maintenance
of these various machines.
It is a way of encouraging
technical progress while
initiating competition
between wind turbine
manufacturers and operators.
The experimental wind farm,
to be called Sotavento Park,
will be located on land
belonging to two local
communities: Monfero and
Xermade. The project includes
construction of a center
for promoting renewable
energies and stimulating
interest for environmental
conservation.
Opening date
of the park: 1999.
> NEW PLAN FOR RENEWABLES TO BE ISSUED
In 1999, wind energy capacity has soared in Spain. In just one year, 1 000 MW are now under construction, whereas
only 135 were installed last year. By the end of 1999, Spain should reach a capacity of 1 834 MW, either functioning or under
construction. In the meantime, the cost of wind energy has been nearly cut in half over the period 1986-1999, dropping to
145 000 pesetas/kWh (1 115 euros). The bulk of turbines are manufactured locally. Three manufacturers use Spanish technology
for this: Made, Ecotecnia and Desa. The other three manufacturers have transferred foreign know-how: Gamesa-Vestas,
Taim-Neg Micon and Bazan-Bonus. More than 175 Spanish companies are involved in the wind energy sector. Investments in
wind farms will total 144 000 million pesetas (1 108 million euros) in 1999. The National plan for energy savings and energy
efficiency - Plan nacional de ahorro y eficiencia energetica (1991-2000) - is now coming to an end. A new plan, setting wind
energy capacity for 2010, was to be implemented in November, following Spains determination to cover 12% of its primary
energy consumption through renewable energies by that year (vs. 6.5% in 1997).
< The 30 MW wind farm

in Cabanillas (Navarra)
>> each with a 500 kW capacity (Gamesa

Eolica), is also interrupted along several meters to leave space for passing
birds.
First site and the best site
This location was not chosen by chance. It allows inhabitants of Pamplona to
get used to wind turbines. The site has
been visited by 275 000 people. It was
the first to be exploited in the region,
and it is still the one providing the largest quantity of kilowatt-hours compared to all the more recent ones. In the
beginning, only one company was involved in implementing renewable
energy sources in the region: Energia
Hidroelectrica de Navarra. EHN, which

was set up in 1989, first devoted itself
to micro-hydraulic energy. But since
1997-1998, the turn-over made by micro-hydraulic energy has been overtaken by wind energy. EHN is a
semi-private company. 38% of its capital belongs to Sodena (representing the
government of Navarra), 37% comes
from the Iberdrola group, a utility company, 15% has been invested by Cementos Portland and 10% by a bank,
the Caja de Ahorros de Navarra. The
reasons why this community wanted to
develop wind energy differ only slightly from those of Galicia: reduction of
greenhouse gas emissions, increased
autonomy in terms of energy sources -
Navarra is 86% dependent on outside

resources and would like to lower its
dependency to 70%, and participation
in the European policy moving towards
12% of energy needs being covered by
renewable sources in 2010.
In respect with the environment
The El Perdon site was followed by
other sites which have been equipped
since 1996. Two other companies have
joined in: Eolica Navarra and Derna
(subsidiary of EHN and Dersa). But
EHN remains leader with 11 wind farms
on 5 sites, i.e. 248 MW (May 1999).
They produce 680 GWh a year, representing 22% of the regions electricity >>
Below: The wind farm of Paxareiras is located

near a beautiful ria.
Page 9: in Leitza (Navarra), restoration of the
landscape after the work of setting up the turbines is one of the environmental rules of
Energia Hidroelectrica de Navarra.
>> consumption. This production has

been installed according to a regional
scheme called Proyecto sectorial de
incidencia supramunicipal de infraestructuras de produccion de energia eolica en Navarra approved in 1996.
This project foresees that, in 2010,
wind energy will cover 45% of the regions electricity needs in a context
where renewable energies will provide
100% of these needs. It was drawn up
following a study made on wind potential which indicated that 72 sites were
windy enough. Among them, 43 were
eliminated mainly due to obvious environmental reasons. The remaining 29

sites were scrutinized. A multi-criteria
scale was applied to them in which
energy potential accounts for 50% and
respect of environment for 50%. In this
way, a site with a very good wind potential but with a detrimental effect on
the environment, could be ranked below a less windy location having a lower environmental impact.
The final project selected 16 wind sites
for the short term. By 2010, wind power will produce 15 000 kWh, repre-
Rapid landscape restoration

is one of the environmental
rules of EHN. The impact of
wind farms on the landscape
and wildlife has to be kept
to a minimum.
senting an investment of 92 billion pesetas (707 million euros).

179 turbines on one site
After having lived with wind farms for
several years now, the government of
Navarra thinks that bigger farms with a
large number of turbines are preferable
to many small farms with only a few
turbines. A new project will include
179 turbines on a single site. In fact, a
big farm can be seen as being much
smaller than it really is if its implanta-
5 TO 6%
HIGHER
EFFICIENCY
echnological progress is a key

component of the development of wind energy in
Navarra as it is, in a different way, in
pesetas (54 million euros) turn-over in

1998 and we expect 10 000 million
(77 million euros) in 1999.
Local communities are also taking advantage of wind turbines. Land taxes
and rental fees provide consistent incomes. Six billion pesetas (923 million
euros) are expected to flow into the
coffers of the Navarra region.
The Plan eolico de Navarra had forecasted the creation of one thousand
new jobs in the region. EHN, for its
part, estimates that 2 000 jobs have
been generated by its activity in Spain.
This is a number of new jobs which is
not to be neglected in a country where
unemployment reaches 17% (2).
Galicia as well. Energia Hidroelectrica

de Navarra (EHN), the main operator
in this autonomous community, has
been continually striving to upgrade
efficiency of turbines of more than
1 MW. It supported the development
of Ingecon W, a synchronous genera-
tion is well taken care of. For instance,

when one visits the site of Alaiz (49.5
MW, 1998), one cannot see all of the 75
turbines (EHN machines) at a single
glance. One discovers the extent of the
wind farm while progressing through it
and discovering more turbines as the
landscape unfolds.
This farm is very quiet and its electricity transformer is hidden in the backyard
of a building, a replica of a traditional
old structure with fake old-fashioned
iron fittings and woodwork.
tion system associated with varying

speed, designed by Ingeteam.
This device improves the efficiency
of an aerogenerator by 5 to 6%.
It is now systematically used in
turbines that EHN is in charge of.
The first turbines to be equipped
(1) Operators can also opt for a sale to electricity companies at the average price of electricity plus an additional extra-cost of 5.26
pesetas (0.04 euro).
(2) Unemployment rate according to the study
made on the active population by the Spanish
Institute of Statistics which takes into consideration those persons who wish to work. The
unemployment rate recorded for unemployed
persons inscribed at Spanish Unemployment
Agencies is 10%.
in this way are installed in the

mountains of Guerinda.
With the Ingecon W system, the
blades of a wind turbine adjust their
Existing roads have priority

On a former site, in Leitza (19.2 MW,
1996), cattle are found grazing at the
foot of a 45 meter high turbine (Gamesa
Eolica). Three years after its construction, the vegetation has grown back.
Rapid landscape restoration is one of
the environmental rules of EHN. The
impact of wind farms on the landscape
and wildlife has to be kept to a minimum. During turbine installation work,
for instance, existing roads and paths
must be given priority over new ones,
and are reinforced if necessary. Once
work is completed, the sites environmental follow-up continues and opinion polls are carried out.
What are the effects of wind energy on
the economy of Navarra? Without any
profit and benefit, wind energy would
have never have seen the light, claims
Jos Arrieta Ollo, Communication Director of EHN. He adds: Our company
earns money very quickly thanks to the
law on electricity. The banks support
our activity. We had a 7 000 million
rotating speed to the speed of the

wind. The former models turned at
the same pace whatever the wind
speed, and the machines were worn
out by strong winds. For the same
reason, and when the wind speed
is higher than 15 m/sec., the blades
turn on their axle offering less
surface to the wind. At a wind speed
of 25 m/sec., they stop for security
reasons. The synchronous generation
turbines provide better quality electricity than the asynchronous ones do.
EHN has fostered other improvements
as well; such as the integration
of transformers inside the towers of
the turbines instead of housing them
in little buildings outside, a better
anchorage in the ground, new wind
stations and remote control systems.
ECONOMY UPDATE
Green certificates,
which allow an electricity
company to offer its
customers green power
without producing it
itself, help calm tensions
created by the high price
purchase of electricity
produced by renewable
sources.
Green certificates
The Netherlands
shows the way
he green certificates have now been

adopted by certain countries. Above
all, they offer market stability beneficial to industrialists and allow rational management of renewable
energies on a European scale. This system has
been in operation in the Netherlands for over a
year, and has now been adopted by Denmark
and Belgium and is being considered by the United Kingdom, Germany and Italy. A European
market for green certificates could well become
reality in coming years. Heres the example of
the Netherlands.
Green certificates adopted in the Netherlands to
support electricity production from renewable
sources correspond to a new regulation model
currently emerging in Northern European countries. The purpose of the Dutch system is to allow the 19 regional electricity distribution
companies to reach a target level of electricity
supply of renewable energies origin to residential and tertiary consumers, at lower cost. This
objective was set after concertation between
the distribution companies association, EnergieNed, and the government. It is set at 1.7 TWh
for the year 2000, i.e. approximately 3% of residential and tertiary sector sales in 1995, with
individual objectives assigned to each company.
RULES, PROCEDURES AND INSTITUTIONS
HAVE BEEN CREATED
The Dutch system works in the following manner. Each producer receives a certificate for every production of 10 MWh of green electricity,
which guarantees the power origin. This producer
then valorizes its electricity by selling it to the

grid (on the base of wholesale market price) and
by selling its certificates to distributors which
need them. This concerns distributors which must
subscribe to a minimum green electricity quota
in the scope of the collective objective of 1.7 TWh
in the year 2000, as well as distributors who
develop green pricing programmes (1).
This certificate system also makes it possible to
certify the origin of all electricity produced from
renewable sources to meet this collective objective or to meet demand of consumers subscribing to green pricing programmes.
Rules, procedures and institutions have been set
up for good market functioning. This includes
attribution and monitoring of certificates,
control of transactions and verification of the
accounts of each market actor. Sanctions and
penalties are also provided for fraud or non-satisfaction of the objectives assigned to each distribution company. This organization was
established by EnergieNed, under Dutch government control. The Dutch government
decides which renewable energies can receive a
green certification. KEMA, an independent engineering office, is responsible for routine, everyday system management. Rules have also
been implemented guaranteeing EnergieNed >>
11
France returns to renewable energies

after sleeping 16 years
nce a leading country in renewable energies in the early

eighties, Frances development in this field was put to
bed by a governmental choice exclusively favoring nuclear power. Renewable energies are now getting more attention from public, politicians and government. French public
funds for research and development amounted to 0.09 euro per
year per inhabitant in 1996 whereas they reach 0.28 euro today*.
Within the framework of the Commissariat Gnral au Plan**,
a think-tank body where many public issues are debated and
worked on, a small group has helped to increase the awareness >> impartiality on standard, normal transactions, because EnergieNed represents
of French policy makers to renewable energies***. This group
the interests of the distributors which
included industry representatives such as Elyo, Dalkia, Totalfina,
are, until further notice, the purchasers
of the certificates as well.
Electricit de France, government bodies such as the Ministry
of Industry, the French agency for environment and energy maFOLLOWING
nagement (Ademe), academia such as the Ecole polytechnique
THE NETHERLANDS EXAMPLE
and non governmental organizations. It was led by Georges
The green certificate market has been in
Dupont-Roc, who started up Shell International Renewables
place since January 1st 1998 in the Nein 1997 and who is now working at the Totalfina Strategy and
therlands. In particular, this has resulted
Planning Department.
in a pick up in investments in renewable
energies and green kilowatt-hour valoriThis group reviewed the effectiveness of stimulation policies in
zation is made at a price ensuring good
a number of European countries and in the United States, and
return on investment. The stability of
has made recommendations for stimulating the emergence
this system and the visibility which it offers potential investors permits optimism
of a renewable energy market in France. Among these policies,
in terms of the future, even if there are
green certificates have been seen as a very effective way for
still problems and disputes to be settled.
developing such a market while meeting realistic targets
The best proof of this is the systems extension to Denmark and Belgium, as
for renewable energies over time, at minimum cost for the
well as creation of a pilot market at the
community. Many rural parts of France, with vast renewable
scale of five European countries (Germany,
resources available at lower costs than in the more densely
Belgium, Denmark, Netherlands and the
populated areas of Northern Europe, could benefit from this.
United Kingdom).
* In comparison, Japan, the United States and several northern European
countries allocate 0.92 euro/year/inhabitant.
** Think-tank attached to the Prime Ministers Office.
***This group belongs to a larger one working on general energy questions.
12
With green certificates, a Dutch electricity producer valorizes its kilowatt-hour

in three distinct ways: by the sale of its
electricity to the local distribution company, by the discount granted by the
government on the CO2 tax to certain green

productions and by the sale of certificates corresponding to the amount of electricity produced.
In the Netherlands, distribution companies repurchase the electricity produced by independent producers on the basis of the regional price
paid to the SEP, association of the four Dutch
electricity producers (Epon, EPZ, EZH and Una),
for their supplies. This is an obligation inscribed
in the 1989 Electricity Law and renewed in the
new Electricity Law of 1998. This purchase price, based on the price of electricity on the wholesale market, is subject to modification every
year as a function of constraints weighing on
supply and demand.
HOW MUCH DOES
A GREEN CERTIFICATE COST?
Beginning in the year 2000, this electricity price

will be displayed at the Amsterdam Power Exchange (opened on June 1st 1999). In 1998, all
independent production, whether of fossil or renewable energy origin, was purchased in this
way at an average price of 0.036 euro/kWh.
The government only grants a CO2 tax discount
to certain renewable energy sources such as
wind, photovoltaic, micro-hydraulic (less than
10 MW), wood, paper and biogas. This amounts
to approximately 0.0135 euro/kWh. Benefiting
from this discount is one of the green certification access condition.
We have not received any information about the
price of green certificates. This information is
considered confidential by each market operator, and no stock exchange exists as yet. For its
EUROPEAN STUDY
ON GREEN
CERTIFICATES
A study on green
certificates is under way
in the framework of the
Altener programme
(European Commission).
Findings are expected
to be available
for the end of this year.
part, the KEMA engineering office estimates

that the minimum price at which green current
should be bought is the Netherlands to allow exploitation of a 1.7 TWh potential with a return
on investment rate higher than 10%, oscillates
between 6.75 and 7.35 cents euro/kWh, i.e. a
green certificate price to the order of 0.018 to
0.0225 euro/kWh, to which the 3.6 cents
euro/kWh repurchase price and the 1.35 cents
euro/kWh discount must be added.
PURCHASE OBLIGATION ON PRICES
AND QUANTITIES
The green certificate system implemented in the

Netherlands is interesting in more than one way.
Its principal interest is an economic one.
By analogy with tradable emission reduction
systems (2), it makes it theoretically possible to
reach a collective objective (share of green electricity) at lowest cost for the collectivity. In practice, it engenders cost savings vs. a regulatory
approach which would impose the same green
electricity quota to all the power companies in a
context where there are several distribution
zones and a geographical disparity in renewable
energy resources, including a natural inequality of costs of their exploitation. EnergieNed evaluates that the Dutch system induces savings at
approximately 22 million euros/year.
Another interest of the green certificate system
is to conjugate the advantages of both buyback
price and quotas approaches: a guaranteed return on investment (price advantage) and an
equivalent monitoring of renewable energy
costs (quota advantage). Green certificates have
other advantages which do not present an approach by prices nor one by quantities.
The system follows the evolution of the price of
electricity on the wholesale market and offers
the legibility needed for investors (with a known
and displayed collective volume, with a minimum share of 1.7 TWh in the year 2000 in the
case of the Netherlands). Above all, it adapts
itself to the constraints born of the liberalization
of the Dutch electricity system: consumer liberty to procure power with the producer or supplier of his choice.
The first world

conference of
the Renewable
Energy
Supply & Trading
Structures took
place on the
27th May
of 1999,
in Amsterdam.
150 000 PEOPLE CONSUME

GREEN ELECTRICITY
Lastly, this system is perfectly adapted to the

green electricity market, on which consumers
sign a contract with a supplier to consume electricity of renewable energy origin. Its an ideal
certification tool which guarantees the exact
origin of the green electrons.
Today, everything indicates that this market,
which is only at its beginnings, is going to undergo important development in the years to
come. In the Netherlands, green pricing programmes began in 1996. In the first half of
1999, there were more than 150 000 green
electricity consumers out of a total of 7.5 million consumers, vs. 120 000 at the end of
1998 and only 15 000 at the end of 1996.
Today, these consumers represent an annual
volume of 365 GWh.
(1) These consumers

agree to pay more for
their electricity in return
for the assurance that it
is produced, either totally
or partially, from renewable energy sources.
(2) Negotiable emission
permits are found in the
framework of the campaign to reduce greenhouse
gas emissions.
13
GERMANY
GUARANTEED
SOLAR RESULTS
leven German
electricity companies have
grouped together to test a
method for
evaluating production of
thermal solar collectors.
This method makes it possible to guarantee building
and home owners of the
quantity of energy that is
supplied by the collectors.
The method has been used
on 19 solar installations
(2 100 m2 and
620 MWh/year) in the
scope of the European
Thermie programme, and
has proven to be reliable.
The rule is the following.
If, after the first year
of measurements, a solar
installation produces less
energy than was foreseen,
the group of companies
involved in this installation
must reimburse the customer for a percentage of the
investment made equal
to the performance deficit.
A consultant ensures the
guarantee in the name of
the companies which designed, installed and manufactured the equipment.
The aim of this project is
to promote thermal solar
energy by removing
barriers to, and increasing
confidence in, these techniques. The advantage
of the guaranteed results
is that at the same time
as production is measured,
installation functioning is
also inspected. In this way,
installation failures have
been quickly detected and
solved, leading to equipment production at highest
possible level.
14
GREECE
Simplified steps
for independent producers
n Greece, the share of renewable energies in energy
consumption was 5.4% in 1996 and should reach 8.5%
in 2010*. At the end of 1999, wind power will account
for 43% of the 128 MW capacity installed of renewable
energy origin. Micro hydraulic power plants will ensure
24% of this amount. The Greek national electricity company - Public Power Corporation - is buying the kilowatthours supplied by renewable energies. It has signed a ten
year contract with independent producers. The purchase
price is calculated according to rather complex rules depending on whether it concerns a system which is connected to the grid or not. For example, the steps necessary to
obtain a licence to operate a wind farm have been recently
simplified. Energy demands keep on increasing in Greece.
Demand was multiplied by a factor of from 10 to 15 between 1976 and 1996. Local energy supply can not keep up.
Various programmes dealing with energy and lowering CO2
emission (greenhouse gas) offer subsidies, tax exemptions
and reduced interest rate loans in the name of greater energy efficiency and the use of renewable energies.
* According to the speech given by Dr. A.D. Koras in Amsterdam

(Sustain, 26-27 May 1999) entitled: Effective legislative and
political measures for the private sector in Greece.
COMING EVENTS
Biomass and Development
22-26 November 1999
Abidjan, Ivory Coast
Contact: Francine Bolduc
Tel.: + 1 418 692 5727
Fax: + 1 418 692 5644
E-mail: [email protected]
Enkon - Industrial energy
and environmental technology
24-26 November 1999
Nuremberg, Germany
Contact: Nrnberg
Messe GmbH
Tel.: + 49 911 86060
Fax: + 49 911 8606228
Future strategies and
technologies for development
of thermal power
15-17 December 1999
New Delhi, India
Contact: Council of Power
Utilities
Tel.: + 91 11 611 5984
Fax: + 91 11 611 6347
E-mail:
[email protected]
Environment and Energy
Congress and Exhibition
24-29 January 2000
Geneva, Switzerland
Contact: Clean Energy 2000
Secretariat
Tel.: + 41 22 910 30 06
Fax: + 41 22 910 30 14
E-mail:
[email protected]
Web Site:
www.cleanenergy2000.com
Erneuebare Energien 2000

International Exhibition
and Conference
18-20 February 2000
Boblingen/Stuttgart, Germany
Contact: Erneuebare Energien
Renewable Energy for
the New Millenium
8-10 March 2000
Sydney, Australia
Contact: The Meetings Manager
Tel.: + 612 9241 2955
Fax: + 612 9241 5354
Web Site:
http://www.esaa.com.au
>>
The Changing Land of Europe

The First European conference
of renewable energy and
agriculture
12-14 March 2000
Nordwijkerhout, Netherlands
Contact: European Media
Marketing
Tel.: + 44 181 289 8989
Fax: + 44 181 289 8484
Web Site:
www.emml.com/changing-land
World Geothermal Congress

2000
28 May - 10 June 2000
Kyushu-Tohoku, Japan
Contact:
Web: www.wgc.or.jp
Biomass for Energy
and Industry
5-9 June 2000
Seville, Spain
Call for papers
Contact: Energia TA - Florence

Tel.: + 39 055 5002 174
Fax: + 39 055 57 34 25
E-mail: www.etaflorence.it
Web: www.wip.tnet.de
Eurosun 2000
The 3rd ISES Europe Solar
Congress
19-22 June 2000
Copenhagen, Denmark
Contact: Eurosun 2000
Congress
THE EUROPEAN INVESTMENT BANK
Green-Tech 2000
International Conference and
Exhibition on sustainable and
renewable raw materials
3-5 April 2000
Utrecht, Netherlands
Contact: Europoint
Tl.: + 31 30 693 34 89
Fax: + 31 30 691 73 94
Web: www.europoint-bv.com
Owemes
Offshore Wind Energy in
Mediterranean and Other
European Seas
13-14 April 2000
Syracuse, Italy
Contact: Dr. Ing. G. Gaudiosi
Tel.: + 39 6 3048 3994
Fax: + 39 6 3048 6315
E-mail:
[email protected]
16th European Photovoltaic
Solar Energy Conference
and Exhibition
1-5 May 2000
Glasgow, Scotland
Call for papers
Contact: WIP
Tel.: + 49 89 720 1235
Fax: + 49 89 720 1291
First international conference
on renewable energy resources
9-12 May 2000
Mauritius
Call for papers
Contact: Mr. C.V.J. Varma
Central Board of Irrigation
and Power
Tel.: + 91 11 611 5984 /611
6567
Fax: + 91 11 611 6347
770 million euros

for renewables
in Europe
The European Investment Bank is supporting the implantation of renewable energies in the world and it is willing to
do more. But it is hard to be competitive on a market which
is still subsidized.
he European Investment Bank (EIB) is financing 38.5%

of the first big wind farm in the north of Morocco.
Construction of 84 turbines began there at the start
of last June. This is a good example of what the EIB can do
for renewable energies in the world. In 1998, the financial
institution of the European Union lent 770 million euros for
implantation of new sources of energy in Europe only.
88% of this amount is devoted to big or small hydroelectric
power stations. Wind energy only represents 8% and geothermy, 4%. These individuals loans are only attributed
to projects costing over 25 million euros. A group of small
projects such as the refurbishing of ten micro-hydraulic power
stations in Sweden, was recently considered as being an
individual case because this made the total amount of
money involved high enough.
For small projects too
Another type of loan can be granted to smaller projects
through global loans made by the EIB but diffused by other
banks. For instance, wind turbines and solar power stations
were supported in this way by the EIB in Germany, as well as
micro-projects of hydraulic, biomass and wind energy in
Spain, etc. This amount of 770 million euros is little compared to the total sum of new loans granted by the bank in
1998: 30 billion euros. The EIB invests in renewable energies
in keeping with its energy policy which aims at securing energy supply in the European Union. This includes diversified
and reliable access to energy sources, development of energy
sources, energy savings and interconnected distribution of
energy between member states. The bank also supports projects of cooperation in development of non European countries such as the wind farm in Morocco mentioned above.
In competition with subsidies
The European bank would like to increase its financial assistance
to renewables because the future looks bright: technologies >>
Tel.: + 45 45 87 76 11
Fax: + 45 45 87 76 77
World Renewable Energy

Congress VI
1-7 July 2000
Brighton, Great Britain
Call for papers
Contacts:
> Prof. Ali Sayigh (conference)
Tel.: + 44 1 189 611 3 64
> Reed Exhibition Companies,
Rob Schulp (salon)
Tel.: + 44 1 81 910 79 76
Fax: + 44 1 81 910 79 89
E-mail:
[email protected]
28th IEEE Photovoltaic
specialist conference
17-22 September 2000
Anchorage, Alaska,
United States
Contact: John Brenner
Tel.: + 1 303 384 6496
Fax: + 1 303 384 6481
High Wind Power Penetration
in Electrical Networks
25-27 September 2000
Kassel (Germany)
Contact: Frdergesellschaft
Windenergie
Tel.: + 49 40 27 80 91-82
Fax: + 49 40 27 80 91-76
World Conference Sustainable
Building 2000
22-25 October 2000
Maastricht, Netherlands
Contact: Novem
Tel.: + 31 46 42 02 326
Fax: + 31 46 45 28 260
Solar millenium congress
25-28 October 2000
Toulouse, France
Contact: ObservER
Tel.: + 33 1 44 18 00 80
Fax: + 33 1 44 18 00 36
15
The EIB has offered a loan for

38.5% of the cost of the first large
Moroccan wind farm.
(Computer simulation, Cabinet Germa)
>> are improving, prices are

going down, favorable
public opinion is growing
and the sectors market is
approaching maturity. But,
unlike the World bank, the
EIB does not bring up projects. The demands comes
from outside.
The minimum amount necessary to have access to
its direct loans -25 million
euros- does not make things
easier. But even within its
system of global loans, the
bank faces strong competition, i.e. national subsidies
and loans at very low rates.
84 AEROGENERATORS
FINANCED IN MOROCCO
The Al Koudia Al Bada wind

farm has been under way
since June 1999 on the
north coast of Morocco,
along the Strait of Gibraltar.
This is the first Moroccan
wind farm of this size
(50.4 MW).
The 84 wind turbines
(Vestas manufactured) form
a 10 km-long line on a crest.
The average wind speed
is 9.5 m/sec. The turbine
towers are of electric pylon
type. The equipment costs
330 million francs (51 million euros), 30% of which
has been invested by the
Compagnie olienne du
dtroit (CED). The European
Investment Bank offered a
credit for 38.5% of the cost
and the Proparco brought
26%. The rest is financed by
the Crdit Agricole Indosuez
and a group of other banks.
16
IRELAND
New wind
farm in
Connemara
new 2.64 MW
wind farm was
opened in April
in the West of Ireland.
It was developed by
a local family enterprise, Fuinneamh
Gaoithe Teoranta, as
part of the European
Thermie programme.
The farm is a cluster
of four 660 kW turbines (Vestas), located
in Inverin, a rural area
on the coast near
Galway (Connemara,
County Galway).
The site has an average annual wind speed
of 8.7 m/s. The farms
annual energy production is expected to
reach 9 million kWh.
This could prevent
nearly 7 000 tons of
carbon dioxide from
being released into the
atmosphere each year,
by replacing the need
to burn fossil fuels in
a conventional power
plant. The total cost
for the development
was in the neighbourhood of 2.6 million

Irish pounds (3.3 million euros), of which
the EU provided about
0.5 million (0.63 million euros) in support
through the Thermie
programme. Success
in the Thermie programme also allowed
the company to obtain
a long-term power
purchase contract
(twelve years) from
the national electricity
supply company,
Electricity Supply
Board (ESB).
At present, ESB buys
each kilowatt-hour at
0.0434 Irish pound
per kWh (0.055 euro).
Full costs of a new
fossil fuel powered generating plant are of
the order 0.025 to 0.03
Irish pounds per kWh
(0.032 to 0.038 euro).
Within the framework

of the Irish governments Third Alternative
Energy Requirement
Competition, announced
in April 1998,
contracts were awarded to wind energy
projects representing a
total installed capacity
of 137 MW. A good
proportion of this total
should be commissioned by 2000. As part
of this competition,
small wind energy
projects will be granted an average price
of 0.02975 Irish pound
per kWh (0.0378 euro)
whereas large projects
will be granted
a lower price at
0.025 Irish pound
(0.032 euro).
At present, Ireland
already has 63 MW
installed capacity from
wind energy.
WALES
Wind and sun

to solve traffic
congestion
enewable energies are very suitable for remote places.

In Wales, traffic monitoring equipment works thanks
to wind and solar power systems.
Dulas, a Welsh renewable energy company, recently designed
and supplied solar and wind systems to power traffic monitoring equipment on approach roads to the new Severn bridge
which links South Wales (not far from Newport) to Bristol (England). In 1997, the United Kingdom government chose this
area to test a traffic monitoring device powered by renewable
energy, because it is a bottleneck in the south of Wales in the
midst of a very busy industrial area. The mouth of the Severn
river is several miles wide at this point and the bridge is a useful shortcut. Increasing density of traffic on the roads is causing congestion on major routes across Great Britain. Part of
the answer to this problem is monitoring traffic levels so that
action can be taken before congestion occurs. Warning motorists of the delays ahead and offering alternative routes will increase road safety, decrease pollution and reduce need for
new road building programmes. Traditional methods of traffic
monitoring rely on sensors beneath the road surface which are
costly and inconvenient to install. The solution is the use of
Above Ground Vehicle Detection (AGVD), using microwave
sensors installed on roadside masts. The collected data is
transmitted to the control centre by means of a radio link. Power supply is a limiting factor, as these systems can be a long
way from the national grid and the cost of a mains connection
may be prohibitive.
Six schemes for the approach to a big crossing
Renewable energy offers a good solution to the problem of
supplying modest amounts of power away from the national
grid, and is ideal for this application. The Welsh Office (*)
(*) The Welsh Office represents the UK government in Wales.
proposed six such schemes on the approach to the second

Severn crossing, and the contract for the supply of the power
supply equipment was awarded to Dulas. A Marlec FM1800
wind turbine was chosen because of its proven reliability record and good performance at the low wind speeds predicted
at these sites. Additionally, two 75 Wc photovoltaic modules
are wired in series to form the 150 Wc array. These are mounted to a separate tubular steel structure bolted to the same
concrete foundation as the tower. Wind and sun are associated in order to get as much renewable energy as possible.
Solar energy is scarce in winter. The variable nature of wind
and solar power means that a storage battery was required, sized to give sufficient storage for periods of insufficient power
generation.The control equipment has to perform various
functions, including photovoltaic and wind input regulation
and load disconnection in the event of a discharged battery.
Wind, sun, and... a good radio signal
Three of the systems have recently been installed on the approach to the second Severn Crossing. Two are on the A449
road between Usk and Newport and the third is between the
toll booths and the bridge itself. The most difficult part of
placing these systems is achieving a compromise between
three main constraints:
where the best wind/so- Wind and sun are used in order
get as much renewable energy
lar sites are, where the to
as possible.
Welsh office wants to
count cars and where
there is a good radio signal to link the monitoring equipment to the
control centre, states
Ian Tansley, the engineer
in charge of the project.
Another problem is theft.
In order to prevent it, a
brick enclosure has to be
built around the back of
the photovoltaic panels.
One system was destroyed in the first few
months as someone tried
to rip out the meters on
the control system.
17
OUTSTANDING PROJECTS
Thanks to their roofs and walls, 500 houses

are being used as a power station in
Nieuwland/Amersfoort (Netherlands).
This project, well under way, is far from
being just a beginning for the electricity
company involved. It comes after several
other constructions using various solar
techniques in the same area.
A HOUSING ESTATE OF
500 photovo
In 19 luxury owner-occupied
houses, the solar equipment belongs
to the electricity company.
he largest solar powered

housing development in Europe is located in Nieuwland, a recent expansion of
the city of Amersfoort, in
the south-eastern region of
Amsterdam (Netherlands).
Construction of 500 solar powered
houses in the Waterkwartier district begun in November 1997 and should be
completed before the year 2000. More
than 12 000 m2 of solar panels for a total capacity of 1 MW, will generate
1 million kWh per year. This outstanding project is an initiative of REMU, a
Dutch power company operating in
Central Netherlands, in collaboration
panels should remain unshaded. The residents of this half will be remunerated
by REMU for the use of their roofs: 20%
of the energy generated by the panels
will be paid for at the normal domestic
consumer tariff. For the other half of
installations which are owned by residents, the solar power generated will be
fed to the REMU mains and the residents will receive the corresponding
amount of money estimated at the normal domestic user tariff in return.
The solar power installations are monitored at the overall level (total daily generation, for instance). The system also
detects failures or malfunctions. In addition to this, fifteen installations are mo-
ltaic homes
500 houses are to provide
1 million kilowatt-hours
per year in 2000.
with Novem (the Dutch agency for renewable energies), the Amersfoort local
authority, Overeem (developers) and the
Boom environmental research and design agency. Through this project, REMU
is seeking to illustrate the impact of
using solar power at a district level.
It wants to answer questions such as
What social and architectural consequences solar power on a large scale has
for a district? What demands does largescale solar energy make on the urban
development structure of a district? How
do residents experience the use of solar
energy on a large scale? etc.
Residents will be paid for having
their roofs used
The urban development of the Waterkwartier district was structured in order
to ensure maximum access to the sun.
The land was parceled out in such a
way as to render as many roof surfaces
as possible suitable for installation of
solar panels. Nine developers are still
working on the different sectors of the
district. Houses have already been sold.
To be able to monitor the effects of the
various forms of ownership and management, approximately half of the installations will remain the property of
REMU. Agreements have been made
with the developers which, among other
things, establish arrangements made
concerning accessibility of the installations and liability for damage incurred.
It has also been stipulated that the solar
nitored in detail in order to provide

more information on their efficiency and
to allow investigation of the effects of
the various integration methods on the
production of electricity.
Overall monitoring of the 500 houses
A social monitoring programme will
also be established in order to ascertain
how the residents experience this form
of utilization of solar energy. The 1 MW
These 50 rented houses, located in
another area of Nieuwland, use thermal solar energy, passive solar energy
and photovoltaic energy.
project of Waterkwartier is not the only

solar installation in which REMU is involved in Nieuwland. The electricity
company has implemented a policy stimulating the use of energy from sustainable sources. Through its various
experiences, it is trying to acquire more >>
19
Solar
partners
I n o r d e r t o r e a c h a p owe r
c a p a c i t y o f 1 M W, t h e r e
i s a n ave r a g e o f 2 0 m 2
of solar panels on each
house, with a peak capacity
o f 10 0 W / m 2 .
Nearly 80% of the panels
we r e p u r c h a s e d f r o m
Shell Solar Energy
a n d 15 % f r o m B P S o l a r.
M ov a b l e s u n b l i n d s a n d
p a n e l s i n t e g r a te d i n
t h e w a l l s we r e s u p p l i e d
by C o l t i n te r n a t i o n a l
Prefabricated elements to lower costs
(Netherlands). Solar roof
In another part of Niewland called

Lage Hoven, where Thomasson Dura
built 28 luxury owner-occupied
houses (1995-1998), REMU has installed solar roofs on 19 of them and
owns them. In this implantation, the
electricity company is observing the
relationship between the owners of
the house and itself, the owner of the
solar panels. As the cost of solar power remains a significant obstacle to
large-scale use in residential construction, REMU is also investigating one
possible way of reducing the cost of a
solar roof by using prefabricated elements. In a more recent project (19971998), various solar techniques were
combined in two semi-detached
houses where energy consumption
equals energy production (balanced
energy houses). One of the two
houses is inhabited and an extensive
measurement programme is being carried out with regard to it. The other
half is equipped as an information
center for sustainable energy open to
the public. One object of this project is
to demonstrate how comfortable a
100% solar house is, not to mention
that it can be run at low cost.
t i l e s we r e p r ov i d e d
by R B B ( N e t h e r l a n d s ) .
>> knowledge in this field. In the background of its policy, there are the
agreements which have been signed
between the Dutch central government and power companies which
aims at reducing carbon dioxide emissions (green house gas). Through these agreements, 3.2% of the electricity
supplied in the country should be generated by sustainable energy sources
by the year 2000.
Using solar energy in three ways
Although wind energy is currently the
most competitive sustainable energy,
it is scarce in the zone where REMU
operates. So are water power and biomass. Solar energy and heat pumps
are more adapted for the area. REMU
uses solar energy in three ways - passive,
20
thermal and electrical - and wishes to

gain experience in various situations:
rental housing, owner-occupied housing and non-residential buildings. It
wants to divulge these technologies as
often as possible in order to lower
prices.
Most of the projects were financially
supported by Novem and some also
received European Union support. In
the southern part of Niewland,
50 houses among 114 owned by the
SCW housing corporation have been
made available for the use of solar power, combined with solar collectors
and passive solar energy. They were
built between 1994 and mid-1996.
In 1995-1997, two schools of Nieuwland were fitted with solar panels. The
roof of De Wonderboom is covered
with 192 operational solar panels producing electricity which is then fed to
the grid. The roof of De Border has
124 modules. Both schools are provided with Shell Solar Energy panels.
This article
partially repeats
the speech
made by
Werner Weiss at
the Sustain
Conferences held
in Amsterdam,
25-27 May 1999.
The companies success in Austria means

the opening up of export markets and their
participation in European research and
demonstration projects.
Page 20: Faade integrated solar collector.
AUSTRIA
COMPANIES CATCH UP
TO A MARKET SETTLED
BY AFICIONADOS
strategy is based on research and development
of adjusted systems and
system
components,
wide-spread information
campaigns with up to 50
seminars and conferences a year and close
co-operation with the solar industry in most of
the projects. Here are four successful
examples of dissemination.
Companies working in the thermal

solar field are very active in
Austria and abroad. All this began
in 1983 when a net of solar aficionados took hold of this market.
heir work ended ten years

later, in the creation of a real
market for the companies
which joined in, and is continuing in research for reducing costs. In recent years, the
sensational rate of growth in Austria in
the use of solar collectors for domestic
hot water heating has shown that thermal solar systems are both mature and
technically reliable. By the end of 1998,
a total collector surface area of 1.9 million m2 had been installed in Austria.
This figure puts Austria amongst the leaders of the European countries for the
amount of newly installed collector surface area per inhabitant and per year.
Moreover, the solar city of Pichling (part
of Linz) - 1 500 dwellings - is planned
for the year 2001. One of the main reasons for the upward trend in the field of
solar installations has been the activities
of the Arbeitsgemeinschaft Erneuerbare
Energie (AEE) which is a non-profit organization working on renewable, mainly solar, energies (1). AEEs dissemination
350 000 M 2 OF SOLAR DEVICES
In 1983, at a time when Austrian solar

technology was experiencing a decline
after the first boom of the mid-seventies, the first self-build groups were
formed by AEE. Self-build and assembly
procedures were optimised, technical
and organisational material prepared,
and a chain of advisory centres established throughout Austria, with support
from the Federal Ministry for the Environment. Through development of this
assembly procedure for solar devices
and AEEs comprehensive technical and
organisational assistance, it was possible
to install 42 000 solar devices with a
total collector area of about 350 000 m2
by the end of 1998.
In the beginning, the companies were
sceptical and presumed that the selfbuilding groups would destroy the small
market. The sceptical attitude changed
more and more into a positive one,

when the companies recognised that the
groups were carrying out information
campaigns for solar energy in general all
over Austria. Induced by the self-building
activities, companies saw the expanded
potential of the market. The increasing
demand initiated by the exemplary experience and information campaign motivated more and more companies to
produce and to offer thermal solar systems. Since 1993, their activity has been
more important than the private installations. There are now 35 companies
producing solar systems in the country.
Installations are 20%-30% subsidized.
More than 60 different types of collectors are currently being offered on the
Austrian market by 35 manufacturers
and importers (2). These are mainly flat
plate collectors. The overall turnover of
solar companies has reached approximately 110 million euros/year as in 1996,
with a yearly installed collector area of
about 200 000 m2. Around 2 200 jobs
have been created.
AUSTRIAN COMPANIES ARE GOING
BEYOND THEIR BORDERS
Some companies are also very successful

when it comes to exporting plants.
In 1998, the export share of flat collectors manufactured in Austria was 21%
(41 514 m2) and 37% for swimming pool
absorbers, i.e. 16 000 m2. By comparison, imports totalled 8 707 m2 for flat
collectors and 5 455 m2 for plastic absorbers (3). This new orientation towards larger markets which extend
beyond the borders of Austria is illustrated by the fact that since 1995, some
companies have begun taking part in European research and demonstration projects. These are concerned with the
development of new tank and collector
technologies within the framework of
the Joule programme as well as the participation in large demonstration and
know-how transfer projects.
The largest community project of this
kind is currently being jointly carried out
by Solpros AY in Finland, the AEE and
Messrs Sonnenkraft in Helsinki. Within
the framework of this project, which is
jointly financed by the European Union,
solar plants are being erected in the
Ekoviikki district of Helsinki in houses >>
21
160 (1000 m2)
compagnies
140
120
100
80
60
40
self build groups
20
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
1990
1989
1988
1987
1986
1985
1984
SOL AR MARKET IN AUS TRIA 1984-1997 (FL AT PL ATE AND VACUUM TUBE COLLECTORS)
>> for several families and with a total area

of 1 250 m2. Another example is the
company Doma-Solartechnik which has
successfully carved out a slice of the solar market in Austria and abroad for itself by specialising in new niche
markets. This company manufactures
exclusive solar walls which have attracted the attention of both Austrian and
foreign architects.
A THERMAL SOLAR PLANT

FOR 232 DWELLINGS
sioning of these plants is subject to

considerations, i.e. how to reach the highest possible solar fraction and attain
the lowest possible energy price. Favourable price-performance ratios are obtained with solar fractions of between
40 and 60% and specific annual yields
of 300 to 500 kWh. If plants are dimensioned in this way, the energy price
is competitive with fossil sources of
energy. From the beginning of the
1980s, and up until the end of 1997,
about 300 biomass district heating networks were built in Austria. These biomass plants are now being equipped
with solar collectors, which produce hot
domestic water in the summer. In order
to be able to assess such plants, AEE has
been surveying them since the beginning of 1995.
The results obtained are used to further
improve and optimise system design of
these plants. Up until now, 12 solar assisted biomass district heating networks
have been erected with collector areas
of between 350 and 1 250 m2. These
systems offer whole villages the possibility to switch to renewable energies
without having to change the houses
connected to this system.
Apart from the clearly obvious market

potential, almost half of the Austrian
population lives in multiple family dwellings. These buildings favour the installation of large central solar plants since
they are of a compact structure and
have a large volume. Large plants offer
greater potential to reduce CO2 emissions than small-scale plants, which
would mean a reduction in costs. By
January 31, 1998, 232 multiple family
dwellings in Austria were equipped with
a thermal solar plant to prepare warm
water and support heating. The dimen-
(1) AEE has five thousand members.

Its main activities are information,
research, and technical advice (12 salaried
employees).
(2) Purkarthofer G., Marktbersicht
Thermische Solaranlagen, Arbeitsgemeinschaft Erneuerbare Energie,
Gleisdorf, 1998.
(3) Faninger G., Solarmarkt in sterreich,
Bundesverband Solar, 1999.
(4) Arbeitsgemeinschaft Erneuerbare
Energie (Hrsg.): Heizen mit der Sonne,
Gleisdorf, 1997.
crease the share of solar combisystems

up to 40% of the total systems installed.
This signifies 3 500 solar combisystems
with 60 000 m2 in the 1998.
One project between the AEE and the Austrian
Federal ministries aimed at developing solar
combisystems for houses and at evaluating,
comparing and optimizing them in co-operation
with companies.
SOLAR COMBISYSTEMS:
40% OF INSTALLED SYSTEMS
The demand for solar combisystems,

both for hot water and for space heating, is increasing rapidly. The combination of thermally well insulated
buildings, low temperature heating systems (wall or floor) and solar systems
with short term storage, allows up to
70% of the heating requirements of a
single or multiple family dwelling to be
provided at acceptable cost. In 1994,
AEE carried out a project supported by
the Austrian Federal ministries to develop and evaluate solar combisystems.
The aim of this project was to develop
solar combisystems for one and two family houses and to evaluate, compare
and optimise the systems in co-operation with companies.
Current practical systems consist of
15-30 m2 of collector area in combination with storage volumes of 1 to 5 m3,
which are dependent upon the heat distribution system and the thermal quality
of the building. Systems using this
concept and of reasonable cost, can readily achieve very high (20 - 70%) total
solar fractions. The results of this threeyear project were published in book
form (4) and in specialized magazines.
Together with the help of seminars all
over Austria, it has been possible to in22
International interest in solar combisystems is increasing, and so is a new research task for the International Energy
Agency (IEA). Task 26 is a major research project of the IEA Solar heating and
cooling programme. The task involves
25 experts from 9 IEA member countries and 11 solar industries. Austria is
the operating agent of this task.
23
for electricity production and 10% for

heat production). Moreover, the sector
indicators, in terms of the potential to
be exploited and the new technologies
applied - binary electricity production
and Hot Dry Rock projects -, augur a
prosperous future.
Supported by a solid domestic market,
today Japan leads the geothermal industry in the world. Japanese firms
hold more than 70% of a world market
whose annual turnover is estimated at
1 360 to 1 600 million euros. The industrial sector of heat production is
much more difficult to identify.
All in all, it is estimated that 40 000
people throughout the world work in
geothermal energy. Following the
example of wind power, these essentially local jobs play an active role in
achieving balanced national and regional development.
The economic and environmental advantages of geothermal electricity augur strong development of this sector >>
GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
BAROMETER
MODEST BUT STEADY GROWTH
otential for heating by geothermal
energy is still high in Europe. Developing countries will probably increase their use of this renewable
energy for generating power as well.
Even though geothermal power gets
less media coverage and exposure than
wind power or photovoltaic energy, it
is still the third most important renewable energy source in the world.
Nearly a century after its first commercial applications, geothermal energy
reached 8 340 MWe for electricity production (1998) and 9 963 MWth for
heat production (1997).
The growth of the geothermal capacity
has been modest but regular for the
last 15 years (annual progression of 5%
1990
1995
1998
627
718
958
America (North and South)
3 606
3 766
3 963
Asia
1 270
1 980
3 000
283
286
365
49
49
53
5 835
6 799
8 339
Europe
Oceania
Africa
Total world
1 - Geothermal capacity installed for electricity production (MWe)

in 1990, 1995 and 1998 in different parts of the world
Ormat 2%
Others 11%
Fuji 14%
Ansaldo 17%
Mitsubishi 21%
Toshiba 35%
2 - Market share of main firms for geothermal power production

worldwide (1971-1997)
24
>> in short and medium terms, especially

in developing countries. Estimations of
future capacities dedicated to electricity purposes are of 18 767 MWe installed by the year 2010.
Heat production should also experience a sustainable development, especially in Europe where potentials are still
far from depletion. In Europe, estimations of future capacities dedicated to
heat purposes are of 14 607 MWth installed by the year 2010.
MWth installed in 1995
MWth installed in 1997
Europe
3 711.7
4 611
America (north and south)
1 876.6
1 908
2 233
3 117
264
264
144.2
71
8 229.5
9 971
Asia
Oceania
Africa
Total world
3 - Geothermal capacity installed for heat production (MWth)

in 1995 and 1997 in different parts of the world
PHOTOVOLTAIC
ENERGY BAROMETER
10% INCREASE
IN 1999 PRODUCTION
upported by ambitious public programs, photovoltaic energy seems
to be following the same development
pattern as that of wind energy. At the
end of 1998, 380 MWp were installed
in the developed countries.
As was the case in 1997, production of
photovoltaic cells and modules had a
double-digit growth rate in 1998. Production increased by 17.7% with respect to the year before, establishing
itself at 149.2 MWp (see graph). In
1998, Kyocera captured the leadership
from Siemens Solar and Solarex (respectively with 20 and 18.1 MWp).
In 1998, the total of photovoltaic applications in the developed countries
reached a capacity of 371 MWp (compared to 303 MWp in 1997). A top
trio composed of Japan, United States
and Germany have clearly pulled away
out in front of the other nations
(table). Supported by ambitious public
programmes, photovoltaic applications
in these three countries alone represent 75% of the capacity installed in
1998 in the main developed countries.
Cumulative
capacity in 1997
(in kWp)
Cumulative
capacity in 1998
(in kWp)*
Growth
1997/1998
(in %)
Germany
41 890
58 550
+ 40
Italy
16 577
17 316
+4
Switzerland
10 124
11 455
+ 13
6 120
8 000
+ 30
Spain
7 300
7 800
+3
Netherlands
4 068
5 067
+ 25
Austria
2 208
2 766
+ 25
Other european countries
6 911
8 246
+ 19
95 198
114 640
+ 20
United States
108 000
127 840
+ 18
Total North America
122 505
140 308
+ 14
Japan
64 705
91 956
+ 42
Korea
2 475
2 800
+ 13
18 700
22 030
+ 18
303 583
371 734
+ 22
Country
France
Total Europe
Australia
Total
1 - Total Photovoltaic capacity installed

by country (kWp) in 1997 and 1998
* Estimations
Industry concentration
In 1997, the top ten worldwide PV cell
production companies generated a turnover of 1.1 billion euros, with a 56%
increase in comparison to 1996. This
growth can be seen by an increase in
jobs at every level of the sector and by
important industrial concentration movements. The most recent being the >>
25
125,6 MW
149,2 MW
57,9 MW
60,9 MW
69,4 MW
77,6 MW
88,6 MW
150
100
installed capacity of 9 705 MW

for a production of 38 287 GWh
for all the European Union
countries combined. The main
producer countries are Italy
(2 186 MW), France (2 004 MW),
Spain (1 414 MW) and Germany
(1 370 MW). These four countries alone represent 72% of
total installed capacity in SHP
in Europe. European manufacturers of small hydraulic turbines
are very present on this competitive international market.
Today, these companies represent nearly 10 000 jobs essentially located in Northern
Europe. Their combined annual
turnover exceeds one billion
French francs. The European
Union has shown its support
of the SHP sector in its White
Book on renewable energy
sources. The expressed target is
to reach 14 GW of installed
capacity by the year 2010 for an
MICROHYDRAULIC
ENERGY BAROMETER
50
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
A NEW YOUTH FOR THE SECTOR
2 - Evolution of world PV cell

and module production from
1992 to 1998
>> creation of BP Solarex, a new PV in-
dustry giant. BP Solarex, which pooled

the activities of BP Solar and Solarex,
will probably be the future PV cell production leader in 1999 with expected
production to exceed 30 MWp.
10% growth is expected in PV cell and
module production for 1999, compared to 1998, which will place production at nearly 165 MWp. The outlook
for the future European Directive on
electricity from renewable energy
sources and for solar electrification programs in the developing countries, will
make photovoltaic power a industry
with bright short and medium term
prospects.
mall hydraulic plants are

characterized by small
sized dams which are
most often installed
along a current. This sector is
at the origin of the world electrical industry. Its presently
undergoing renewed interest
and favour, supported in this
by the European Union and
the governments of numerous
developing countries.
Worldwide annual electricity
production of Small Hydroelectric Plants (SHP) is in the
neighbourhood of 85 TWh,
i.e. 3% of worldwide hydroelectric production. In 1997, small
hydraulic plants represented an
Country
Capacity
installed in 1992
(in MW)
Capacity
installed in 1997
(in MW)
Production in
1997
(in GWh)
Italy
2 047
2 186
8 124
France
1 900
2 004
6 754
Germany
1 291
1 370
6 772
Spain
1 090
1 414
5 290
Sweden
964
969
4 368
Austria
774
812
4 404
Rest of E.U.
677
950
2 566
* 8 743
9 705
38 278
Total E.U.
1 - Small hydraulic plant installed capacity

and production in Europe
26
* Total excluding the United Kingdom
expected production of 55 TWh.

In the rest of the world, sizeable
SHP programmes are underway
which perfectly respond to the
needs of non electrified rural
populations. This is notably
the case in India, Nepal and
Indonesia. More generally, the
potential for small or big
hydroelectric installations is
considerable in the developing
countries. In this way, Africa
should total 4 793 MW of supplementary capacity by the year
2010, and Asia should reach
126.8 GW of installed capacity
at this date as well, taking both
small and big hydro plants into
consideration. The old lady
of the electricity industry is
experiencing a new youth.
Company
Nationality
Noell
German
Kvaerner Energy AS
Norwegian
Litostroj Turbine Factory
Slovenian
Gilbert Gilkes & Gordon
British
Bouvier Hydro
French
Sulzer Hydro
Swiss
Kessler
Austrian
Voith GmbH
Danish
Alstom Minihydro
French
2 - Main small hydraulic turbine manufacturers in Europe
Regions
In project stage (in GW)
Africa
4.8
Asia
126.8
Middle East
13
Latin America
23.6
North America
3.2
Europe
5.3
3 - Hydraulic capacity currently under construction

or in project stage (in GW)
WIND ENERGY
BAROMETER
31 500 MW EXPECTED FOR 2003
Rest of the world 7,8%
ind power capacity increased by

27% in 1998 and by nearly 15%
in the first part of 1999. Wind industry
turnover was up 31% in 1998 compared
to 1997. More than 65% of the wind power capacity is installed in the European Union. Global wind power is
likely to be multiplied by three by the
year 2003, and reach 31 520 MW.
Years go by and they go on being positive for wind power. Cumulative wind
power capacity worldwide increased by
26.8% in 1998, to reach 9 840 MW. In
1998 alone, 2 260 MW were installed vs.
1 430 MW in 1997 and 1 350 MW in
1996. At the end of June 1999, the
cumulative capacity installed reached
11 285 MW. It has increased by 14.7%
since the end of last year. Reflecting this
steady growth, the wind industry >>
Asia 10,7%
US 12,5 %
Europe 69%
1 - Cumulative wind power capacity expected in different parts

of the world in 2003
27
>> annual turnover reached 1.7 billion

euros in 1998. These sales figures represent a growth of 31% compared to
1997 (1.3 billion euros).
Nine out of the ten top
manufacturers are European
The wind industry has created 35 000
jobs worldwide and most of them are
located in the European Union.
Amongst the top ten wind manufacturers, there are four from Denmark, two
from Germany, three from Spain and
one from the United States. Today, the
Danes NEG Micon and Vestas are the
two giants of wind energy.
Just as in 1997, the wind power boom
in 1998 was pulled by the European
Union member states: 1 687 MW out of
2 260 MW were installed last year in
the European Union. By the end of
1998, the EU represented 65.3% of the
wind power capacity installed worldwide, the United States 19.6%, and India,
9.8% (table 2).
In 1998, the leading ten countries in
terms of installed wind power capacity
were Germany, the United States,
Denmark, India, Spain, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, China,
Italy and Sweden (table 3). France is
making up for lost time with the Eole
2005 program with the objective of
500 MW installed in 2005.
Regarding short-term development
prospects, the wind power projects in
progress or planned throughout the
world between now and the year
2003 amount to 21 680 MW of installed
power. This should raise worldwide
wind power to 31 520 MW near the end
of 2003.
Europe should keep its leadership (approximately 21 750 MW), far ahead of
Asia (3 374 MW) and the United States
(3 952 MW), with the rest of the world
totaling 1 911 MW for the end of 2003
(table 4 and pie-chart 1 page 27).
Country
Cumulative capacity
at the end of 1998
(in MW)
7 195
35.5
12
United States
1 927
2 482
21
28,8
India
968
983
1.9
1.5
Rest of the world
493
625
58.5
26.8
9 814
11 285
29.6
14.7
Total world
2 - Cumulative wind capacity in several parts of the world

in 1998 and 1999
Country
Cumulative capacity
(end 1998)
(in MW)
Cumulative capacity
installed (end of
June1999) (in MW)
Growth
1998/1999
(in %)
2 874
3 126
8.8
Germany
United States
1 927
2 482
28.8
Denmark
1 450
1 560
7.6
968
983
1.5
Spain
834
1 100
31.9
Netherlands
363
372
2.5
United Kingdom
334
345
3.3
China
224
233
4.0
Italy
180
223
23.9
Sweden
150
187
24.7
India
3 - Cumulative wind power capacity (in MW) by country

at the end of 1998 and at the end of June 1999
Canada
Total Europe
28
Growth since
the beginning
of 1999 (in %)
6 426
United States
Growth
1997/1998
(in %)
European Union
Country/Continent
These barometers were prepared

by ObservER in the scope of
EurObservER project which groups
together ObservER, Eurec Agency
and Eurofores, with the financial
support of the Ademe and DG XVII
(Altener Programme).
Cumulative capacity
installed by the end
of June1999 (in MW)
MW installed
1999/2003
MW
at end 2003
2 000
3 952
450
533
15 280
21 749
China
900
1 116
India
950
1 900
Total Asia
2 180
3 374
Rest of the world
1 770
1 911
21 680
31 519
Total world
4 - Forecast wind power development 1999-2003 in different parts

of the world
Source: Wind Directions
29
PROJECT UPDATE
The mill of Rotselaar, east of Brussels

(in Flanders), is first spoken of in the 13th
century. Before 1217, four waterwheels supplied
power for a sawmill, a grain mill, a malt mill
and an oak bark mill. Today, the new turbine
has a nominal capacity of 0.075 MW. It has
been producing electricity since May 1994 at
the rate of 560 MWh per year (running time:
8 000 hours/year) and it is connected to the
public grid. The mill already produced electricity in the past, from 1902 to 1968. The energy was used by the Van Doren family and by
the town of Rotselaar. In the twenties, electricity companies took over this production.
In the late fifties, some of the stator blades
and most of the rotor blades had to be replaced. Eventually, lack of proper maintenance
caused a major machine breakdown in 1968.
The turbine was abandoned and disappeared
under the mud.
There has been a water mill on the site

of Rotselaar from as far back as the 13th century.
The buildings and the turbine were restored
in the early 90s. Today, the overhauled
turbine supplies 560 MWh per year.
A 13th century water mill

connected to the grid
Here is an example of a water
mill being restored and its electrical production being connected to the power grid in Belgium.
ater mills make people dream because

they have often managed to survive
over several centuries to still exist today. This
historical dimension of small hydroelectric
plants distinguishes them from other renewable energies. Water mills were replaced by
turbines which began producing electricity at
the start of the 20th century. Later on, these
plants often became obsolete and fell into disuse before undergoing todays renewed interest. In its White Book on renewable
energies, the European Union has committed
itself to increasing small hydraulic plant production capacity from 9.7 GW (1997) to
14 GW in 2010. Heres a striking example of
this revival in Belgium.
In 1983, the entire site was classified as a historic monument. The new owner, Tsap, a nonprofit organization specialized in industrial
heritage sites, decided to start restoration
work on the buildings (dating from the 16th
to 20th centuries) and the machine. Work on
the turbine began in 1993. They were carried
out by Ecowatt, a Belgian company involved
in development and exploitation of small >>
33
hydroelectric power stations and Viry,

a French turbine manufacturer. The turbine was dismantled for a complete
overhaul. It has a cast iron wheel with
40 cast iron rotor blades screwed on to
it. It has a diameter of 2.80 m. The water head height in Rotselaar
is 2.20
m and the maximum flow through the
turbine is 5 m3/second. In the beginning, farmers were surprised by the higher level of water. A new fish passage
had to be built by the authorities. Ecowatt, the Flemish region of Belgium,
the province and the municipality all
co-financed the project which amounted to a total of 188 400 euros.
A COMPLETELY
AUTOMATIC PLANT
In 1990, Ecowatt, a Belgian
company specialized in
small hydroelectric plants,
purchased a water mill
and its accompanying dam
located at Hoegaarden
near Tirlemont (southeast
of Louvain) in Belgium on
the Grote Gete River.
The oldest traces of the
mill go all the way back
to 1249. Even quite recently,
it was used to deviate
water which was then
pumped to wash beets at
the Grand Pont Sugar
Factory and Refinery.
In 1996, a new turbine
was installed with
0.03 MW capacity. It now
supplies approximately
138 MWh per year.
Completely automated,
it can be remotely
controlled and monitored.
First
wind turbines
in Croatia
Wind power is getting
started in Croatia.
In time, it could supply 400 to 800 GWh
each year on 29 sites.
The first wind farm
should be installed by
the end of 1999 on an
island in the south
of the country.
oon Italy will be able to see the
first wind turbines in Croatia,
its eastern neighbour on the
other side of the Adriatic Sea.
Eight machines of 750 kW capacity
each (NEG Micon) are going to be installed on the southwest part of the
Island of Vis (Dalmatian archipelago
on the southern coast). The Island of
Vis has 4 400 inhabitants. It is currently
34
supplied in electricity from the continent by means of a submarine cable.

Future production from the wind farm
is going to exceed the islands needs.
Therefore, it will also serve for the
neighbouring Island of Hvar. Average
wind speed is 6.8 m/second (at 10 m
from the ground).
Teradur, the Croatian engineering office
with foreign partners and the Institute
of Energy (Hrvoje Pozar), charged
with institutional co-ordination of this
programme, are involved in this realization. The HEP, the Croatian national
electricity company, is also concerned
by the project. It wants to develop the
electrical grid on the Island of Vis. It
may agree to pay a part of the cost of
the transformer needed for electricity
production by the wind turbines. The
installation should cost a total of 6.5
million euros. This project is part of the
second phase of the Croatian Programme for Use of Wind Power (Enwind)
a map of zones to be excluded was

drawn up. It lists national parks, protected ecosystems, areas of artistic or
cultural value, cities, rivers and lakes,
zones reserved for village expansion,
tourist or leisure activity sites, airports,
military zones, etc. The second phase
is determination of the sectors where
wind power could be developed, taking
into consideration occupation of land
and environmental protection. Eightynine macro-zones were selected in this
way.
MINIMUM 5.5 M/S WIND
and will serve as a pilot project for future wind turbine installations.
A NEW ENERGY POLICY
Enwind was launched in 1997, at the
same time as nine other programmes
to give form to the new Croatian energy policy. These programmes also
concern other renewable energies (solar, small hydraulic, biomass and geothermal), as well as intensification of
the use of natural gas, energy efficiency, energy networks, cogeneration,
waste recuperation, etc.
The primary purpose of the wind power programme is to estimate the
countrys wind potential and to offer
measures and organization to establish
conditions for an effective and profitable use of wind. Enwind also includes a part dealing with promotion of
wind power technology and its applications. A board formed by 92 represen-
A wind simulation programme (Wasp)

calculated that average annual wind
speed on these sites is between 3 and
8 m/s (at 25 m above the ground). Only
zones with a minimum wind speed of
5.5 m/s, i.e. 29, were finally chosen,
and were then classified according to
their value. The best sites are found on
the southwest coast of Croatia, between
Dubrovnik and Split, and on the neighbouring islands.
Criteria other than wind speed were taken into account, such as grid proximity, existence of roads, number of wind
turbines possible on the site, type of terrain, distance of ornithological protection zones, and position and distance to
inhabited areas. A computerized simulation calculated that 200 to 400 MW capacity could be installed in the 29
macro-zones, corresponding to an annual production of 400 to 800 GWh.
However, according to the Institute of
Energy, these estimations must be finetuned during the second phase of the
Enwind programme. In the future, priority shall be given to new wind measurement stations and more detailed
analysis of each macro-zone.
The Institute of Energy is going farther
Moreover, and in addition to construction of the Vis wind
farm, complemenEight machines of 750 kW capacity each are going
tary actions have
to be installed on the Stupisce peninsula
been proposed by
in the southwestern part of the Island of Vis.
the Institute of Energy. They concern
development of a
framework for rational use of wind power. This includes
using wind power
to supply water on
the different islands
and a combination
of wind and photovoltaic power on
Lastovo Island. Electricity distribution
tatives of the different ministries (Ecosystems will also be the object of a stunomy, Foreign Affairs, Construction,
dy. Proposals shall be made with a view
Science and Technology, Development
to establishing a legislative context
and Reconstruction) and the environand providing incentive measures.
mental protection administration, the
Towns and villages, companies and inmeteorological and hydrological deternational subsidies and assistance
partments, and the HEP (National Elecshall all be mobilized for wind power
tricity Company) is supervising
development.
programme fulfillment.In a first period,
35
European Commission news
Four Renewable energy organisations have already

signed a partnership declaration within the framework of
t h e E u r o p e a n C a m p a i g n f o r Ta k e - O f f . A n d a l u s i a a n d
Seville in Spain, and Malm and Vxj in Sweden were
the first to get involved into such voluntar y RES politics.
One hundred partnerships are to be signed.
The Renewable
energy
partnership
is under way
Campaign for Take-Off

T
he Renewable energy partnership is a

key tool of the Campaign for Take-Off,
which was officially launched by the
Commission at the Sustain Conferences in Amsterdam (25-27 May 1999). Remember that
the Campaign will run for a period of five
years (1999-2003) and was set up to complete the objective of covering 12% of European
energy consumption by renewables in 2010
(White Paper).
The Renewable Energy Sources working group
drew up a paper setting out the next steps to
launch this partnership and describing the role
and involvement of member state programmes in the Campaign. Joining this partnership would require strong commitment and
a substantial contribution to the Campaign
objectives. This would proceed via a declaration. Depending on the nature of the partner,
contributions could take the form of investment or promotional programmes in the sectors forming part of the campaign, or other
measures aimed at raising industry, investor
and public interest, and increasing market penetration of Renewable Energy Sources (RES).
The partnership is open to public or private
structures over all of the entire campaign period. However, some eligibility criteria have
been developed in the form of guidelines, and
criteria fulfilment will be verified.
Relevant partners will be able to use the logo
of the Campaign for Take-Off and their activities may be included in other related promotional activities, such as awards, catalogues,
advertising activities, etc. A hundred possible
partners are closely in touch with Mariangels
Prez-Latorre, head of the section of Renewable Energy Sources and Rational Use of
36
Energy at the EC DGXVII (Energy). Four declarations were already signed in early October:
two came from Spain and another two originated in Sweden.
Two partnerships in Seville
In Spain, the two partnerships are taking place
in the town of Seville. The first one was signed
with Abengoa, a private company specialised
in applied engineering. Abengoa declared its
willingness to contribute to the implementation of the Campaign for Take-Off by way of
four programmes or actions: 60 MW of solar
thermoelectric, 300 MW of wind turbines,
70 MW of biomass and 180 000 tons of biofuels (bioethanol).
The second Spanish partnership involves two
structures. First, the Junta of Andalusia (regional government) through the Consejeria de
Trabajo e Industria (Industry and Job Force
Council) of the Direccion General de Industria,
Energia y Minas, and second, Sodean, Sociedad para el desarollo energetico de Andalucia
(Company for Andalusia Energy Development). They are willing to contribute to the implementation of the Campaign by way of the
Prosol programme. Prosol promotes renewable
energy by subsidizing interest rates more than
final installation costs, financing procedures
(agreements with banks), promoting technical
standards and quality control of RE installations, controlling local installers (quality and
responsibility) and organizing training courses
for them, contacting the press, radio and TV
for programme coverage, monitoring, opening
an internet access, and planning remote
control of installations by installers through
IMPLANTING 200 000 M2

OF SOLAR COLLECTORS
IN WALLONIA
Solar 2010 is an example of
what the Altener II program can
help support. Solar 2010 aims
at facilitating the installation
of 200 000 m2 of thermal solar
energy in Wallonia and
20 000 m2 in Luxembourg.
the internet network, etc. Two Swedish cities

aiming at 100% RES supply. In Sweden, two
cities are involved in the Renewable energy
partnership: Malm and Vxj. In Malm, several programmes are being set up in this framework. The local council is applying for
a nomination under the 100 communities programme for a new residential and office area,
formally occupied by the citys western port,
to be inaugurated in May 2001. The European
Housing Exhibition (Bo01), presenting worldwide ecological sustainable information, will
be held in this area. The Bo01 will include real
buildings designed to continue being used
after the show.
The area will be supplied with 100% locally
produced energy from renewables including
cool and heat storage. The project provides
the opportunity to try out new technologies,
new forms of energy services, and advanced
techniques for measuring and controlling energy consumption. Five structures have signed
the partnership: the City of Malm, Svenska
Boprojekt, organizers of the European Housing
Exhibition, the University of Lund, the Sydkraft
Group, an energy company, and the Swedish
Energy Administration. The City of Vxj is
also willing to be part of the 100 communities programme. It aims at a 100% locally produced RES supply for the town, according to
the Vxj plan for a fossil fuel free city. It commits itself to take action to cut CO2 emissions
in half per capita over the period of 1993 to
2010. The partnership was signed by three
people from the City, one from Bioenergy
Group, a group of companies involved in bioenergy, a professor belonging to the Bioenergy
Research Group of Vxj University and the
president of Energy Agency for Southeast
Sweden.
These four partners are only the first of a long
list currently being established. We will keep
you informed about new signatures in the next
issues of Renewable Energy Journal. But we
can already tell you that to stimulate the involved actors, a competition will be organized
every two years to select the most outstanding
actions accomplished.
>>> Contact: DGXVII Energy,

tel.: +32 2 295 03 69, fax: +32 2 295 58 52.
EIGHT
TARGETS
The Campaign for
Take-Of f will run
for 5 years (19992003) and will act
as a catalyst for the
development of key
Renewable energy
source sectors, sending clear signals
for greater use of
renewable energy
sources and encouraging investment.
The objectives are:

> 1 000 000
PV systems,
> 15 million m 2
solar collectors,
> 10 000 MW
of wind turbine
generators,
> 10 000 MWth
of combined heat
and power biomass installations,
> 1 000 000
dwellings heated
by biomass,
> 1 000 MW of
biogas installations,
> 5 million tons
of liquid biofuels,
> 100 communities with goal of
100% renewable
energy sources
supply.
hree Walloon partners - Institut Wallon,

Apere, Fondation Universitaire Luxem bourgeoise - and the Luxembourg Energy
Agency are working together on a project
to promote thermal solar energy. The first
meeting of the work group should take pla ce in November and a larger gathering of
people involved in the project is expected
to be held in March 2000.
This project, supported by the Altener II
program (1998), the Wallonian region and
the Luxembourg government, is part of a
twelve year plan of action aimed at instal ling 200 000 m 2 of solar collectors in
Wallonia and 20 000 m 2 in Luxembourg by
the year 2010. The objective of the
so-called Solar 2010 program is to create
favourable conditions for development of
the solar collector market. The program is
beginning its first phase.
First, the policies and strategies for thermal
solar energy implemented in other European
countries, i.e. in the Netherlands, Austria,
Germany and France, will be analyzed.
From this analysis and from consultation of
market actors, recommendations for policies
and other measures will be established for
decision-makers. Town planning legislation
in Wallonia and Luxembourg will be scruti nized from the perspective of solar collec tors installation. From this analysis, a
vademecum will be published. This docu ment is intended for town planning officials
in order to explain the specific characteris tics of solar collectors and how they can be
properly integrated into architectural design
while respecting regulations and strategies.
Good practice guidelines will be drawn up
for installers, technical consultants, manu facturers and system managers. An extensi ve market study will look into the existing
potential know-how and offer of equipe ment in Belgium, Luxembourg and Northern
Europe. A database will be set up to create
a professionnal address book and yellow
pages for the general public.
10 000 SOLAR SYSTEMS PER YEAR

The program plans a thermal solar energy
promotion campaign geared at consumers
and market actors. It will include an upda teable brochure and a web site aimed at
a wider public. It will give general informa tion on technical, financial and environmen tal aspects of solar collectors illustrated >>
37
>> with case studies.

Finally, training
sessions for installers
and architects will be
set up to help ensure
solar installation
quality. The Solar 2010
program is expected to
generate the installa tion of 10 000 solar
systems per year. This
figure corresponds to
1% of the number of
existing houses and
to one half of new
housing being equip ped every year.
The 220 000 m 2 of so lar panels will produce
110 million kWh (heat)
per year. After 2010,
the installation rate
should be maintained
at this same level.
ccording to the assessment of the programme from 1995 to

1998, the European Thermie programme has contributed to reducing European Union energy intensity by 2%. From 1995
to 1998, the Thermie programme backed 500 demonstration
projects and 715 associated measures (studies, workshops, publications, etc.). This corresponds to total assistance of 525.6
million euros, including 110 million euros for the year 1998 alone. It should be
remembered that the Thermie programme supports actions of demonstration, dissemination and market development for clean and efficient energy technologies.
The purpose of Thermie is to facilitate the passage from research phase (supported in the scope of the Joule/DG XII programme) to market stage.
EVALUATION OF THE THERMIE PROGRAMME

FROM 1995 TO 1998
Industry is consuming its energy better. The 1998 call for proposals gave priority
to industrial groups and to networks, in particular via that of Opet (organizations
for the promotion of energy technologies). The General Administration for Energy (DG XVII) of the European Commission which is responsible for the Thermie
programme, also endeavored to improve its administrative functioning and intensify communication to the outside.
Is it possible to measure the impact of a programme such as Thermie on the
environment to which it contributes its support ? Even though, for example, industry remains the biggest consumer of energy with 35% of primary energy
demand, the new technologies have, nevertheless, contributed to more efficient
use of energy resources, according to the DGXVII in its report on the programme
from 1995 to 1998. Energy intensity - the ratio of energy consumption on gross
domestic product - dropped by 1.4% per year from 1975 to 1995 in the European
Union, and will have dropped by 2% more recently.
In the field of renewable energies, Thermie has probably favored, by its support,
the halving of photovoltaic solar cost between 1994 and 1998. The programme
has contributed to increasing yield and efficiency in terms of wind power. Concerning rational use of energies, it seems that more and more often, economical
equipments are now arriving at the same price levels as other standard equipment. This is the case in the building industry.
38
ALTENER 1998
>203 PROPOSALS
RANKED FROM GOOD
TO EXCELLENT
he 1998 Altener call for proposals encountered a remarkable echo, resulting in a total of 600 proposals. Among
these, 203 projects were accepted firs t
according to their quality. All proposals
were evaluated by representatives from
DGXVII and two external exper ts. Only
projects classified as excellent, ver y
good and good were shor t-lis ted.
Among proposals considered as excellent, some involve networking such as
C i t y R E S n e t wo r k ( Fra n c e ) . O t h e r s
concern education and training such as
the European Mas ter Degree in Renewable Energy (Belgium) or the developm e n t o f i n f o r m a t i o n , t ra i n i n g a n d
demons tration s tructure in the technological park of Lavrion (Greece). Some of
the proposals are s trongly linked to the
take-of f campaign of the European Community White Paper for Renewable Energies. For ins tance, there are the projects
called Implement the campaign for
take-of f, Business plan (Great Britain)
or Towards 100% renewable energy on
small islands (Denmark).
In the sector of targeted market penetration activities, one project was presented
by Denmark -Solar business opportunities-,
and another by Greece -Integrated regional action plan for the development and
exploitation of Euboeas small hydropower
potential. Proposals submitted in the monitoring field were scarce even though
The French city of Besanon

was one of the outstanding
proposals which were granted
support for involving networking.
they are considered a priority by the European Commission. Beacuse of this,

77% of proposals related to this field
were granted.
GREAT BRITAIN SCORES FIRS T
Looking more closely at these fields, it

can be seen that the larges t number of
projects proposed for suppor t concerns
dissemination of knowledge at local, regional or national levels (43 projects),
followed by local and regional plans
( 3 5 ) , a n d c o o rd i n a t i o n o f n e t wo r k s agores (32). One third of the selected
projects dealt with more than one form
of renewable energy. Biomass was a priority (29% of the selected proposals)
among the dif ferent sectors. The building sector attracted the mos t projects
(12%) in the three solar energy sectors.
Three selected proposals deal with policies and schemes for promoting electricity generated by renewable energies in a
deregulated European electricity market.
Regarding the number of projects per
member state on the main list, the largest
number of selected projects was submitted by Great Britain (30 projects), followed
by Germany (26), Spain (24), Greece (21)
and France (18). A significative number of >>
39
>> proposals from international associations

and organisations
were among the best
projects as well.
A NECESSARY MOVE
TOWARDS BIGGER
PROJECTS
In the future, the

DGXVII would prefer
fewer, larger projects
with greater impact,
rather than a profileration of smaller
projects. This would
ensure ef ficient management and control
of the Altener program. In the 1998
call for proposals,
more than half
require suppor t of
less than 108 000
euros, 38% need
grants of between
108 000 and
216 000 euros for
execution, and only
9% would have to
be suppor ted
with more than
216 000 euros.
The next call for
proposals will close
at the end of
November.
THE EUROPEAN
DIRECTIVE IS BACK ON
THE TRACKS AGAIN
Following a first working

document issued at the
beginning of the year and
largely amended by the
different European actors of
the renewable energy sector,
the Commission should soon
be publishing a new text
presenting a draft project
of the European Directive.
Here are some explanations.
t the start of this year, a working document was published

on the future European Directive for renewable energy source
access to the electricity grid.
This document was a non official one. In substance, it required that each member country reach a green
electricity quota in its global electricity
consumption (a 5% share of internal electricity consumption) in the year 2005 by means of
market mechanisms (with calls for proposals
being preferred to purchase prices).
The underlying idea was not only to guarantee
renewable energies a prime position in a liberalized electricity context (as the Kyoto Summit would have it), but also to ensure their
competitiveness and prevent commercial dumping between member countries. We know
what happened then. There was a general outcry and the Commission disowned the document. It was reproached for violating the
principle of subsidiarity, of not taking the real

dynamics of renewable energies in Europe
today into account (sectors drawn by purchase prices and not by calls for propositions) and
of excluding big hydraulic plants from its scope of action. On this last point, the utility companies threatened not to renew the large dams
if they were excluded from the Directive. In
light of this sectors share in the production of
renewable energy source electricity (approximately 12% of total electricity production in
the European Union in 1998), and in view of
Community commitments in terms of greenhouse gas reduction, it can be supposed that
this argument must have weighed heavily in
the balance.
MORE FREEDOM
FOR THE MEMBER STATES
People have calmed down since then. The
Council of Energy ministers which took place
on May 11th in Luxembourg contributed greatly to this. The ministers requested that the
Commission prepare a new directive before
the end of the year. In this way, Christos Papoutsis committed himself to present a draft
project at the end of September (not communicated as yet), the date on which he will be
replaced by the new Energy Commissioner,
Mrs. Loyola de Palacio.
This directive should leave the States free to
choose the renewable energy support mechanisms that they judge to be most appropriate,
with or without displayed quotas, but while
keeping in mind the White Book objective
(12% in 2010) and in trying to favor mechanisms compatible with trade between countries. In particular, this signifies the
establishment of institutions capable of supporting development of green certificates and
the disappearance of subsidies that will distort
competition.
SHOULD YOU WISH TO RECEIVE RENEWABLE ENERGY JOURNAL ON A REGULAR BASIS (FREE OF CHARGE), PLEASE
FILL IN THIS ORDER FORM AND SEND IT TO: SYSTMES SOLAIRES - 146, RUE DE LUNIVERSIT - F 75007 PARIS.
NAME........................... COMPANY......................................
ADDRESS..............................................................
.......................................................................
40

Rej 9

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Rej 9

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Rej 9

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Renewable

The Netherlands: Campaign for

W ith the June launch of Campaign for Take-Off, 1999

tive and active as they are now. Partnerships are being

sing, and the States are committing themselves to renewable energies.

Renewable Energy Journal n9

Wind Energy in Spain

Germany: Guaranteed Solar Results

Renewable Energy Journal

Publishing Editor: Alain Libard

Illustrators: Pei-Sin & Alexis,

EUROPEAN COMMISSION NEWS

Campaign for Take-Off

Renewable Energy Journal

Wind energy in Spain

end of the year. The National Energy Scheme

In the mountain of Barbanza,

Situated at the very North-West of corner of

The autonomous region of Galicia comes in

The Xunta de Galicia (Regional

> NEW PLAN FOR RENEWABLES TO BE ISSUED

< The 30 MW wind farm

>> each with a 500 kW capacity (Gamesa

Hidroelectrica de Navarra. EHN, which

Navarra is 86% dependent on outside

Below: The wind farm of Paxareiras is located

>> consumption. This production has

eliminated mainly due to obvious environmental reasons. The remaining 29

Rapid landscape restoration

senting an investment of 92 billion pesetas (707 million euros).

echnological progress is a key

Navarra as it is, in a different way, in

pesetas (54 million euros) turn-over in

Galicia as well. Energia Hidroelectrica

tion is well taken care of. For instance,

tion system associated with varying

in this way are installed in the

Existing roads have priority

rotating speed to the speed of the

he green certificates have now been

then valorizes its electricity by selling it to the

France returns to renewable energies

nce a leading country in renewable energies in the early

With green certificates, a Dutch electricity producer valorizes its kilowatt-hour

government on the CO2 tax to certain green

Beginning in the year 2000, this electricity price

part, the KEMA engineering office estimates

The green certificate system implemented in the

The first world

150 000 PEOPLE CONSUME

Lastly, this system is perfectly adapted to the

(1) These consumers

* According to the speech given by Dr. A.D. Koras in Amsterdam

Erneuebare Energien 2000

The Changing Land of Europe

World Geothermal Congress

Contact: Energia TA - Florence

THE EUROPEAN INVESTMENT BANK