UCA Thesis Dissertation Guide Rev. 12-8-2014
UCA Thesis Dissertation Guide Rev. 12-8-2014
UCA Thesis Dissertation Guide Rev. 12-8-2014
Preparation Guide
RESPONSIBILITIES
The thesis or dissertation represents a capstone project for many graduate students. Although the
graduate student must assume primary responsibility for content and format of the thesis or
dissertation, faculty members are expected to provide guidance.
The University of Central Arkansas offers many avenues of help for the graduate student
writing a thesis or dissertation. Accesses to computers and printers, Torreyson Library,
laboratory equipment, and assistance from the thesis or dissertation committee are available to
students who choose to take advantage of these opportunities. The responsibility for maintaining
a high level of scholarship and writing and for producing a quality document rests with the
student as the author of the thesis or dissertation.
Departments offering a PhD must prepare handbooks for PhD students and faculty advisors of
dissertations that codify the departmental and disciplinary expectations of graduate education in
general and the dissertation in particular. Guidelines should focus on the mutual responsibilities
of advisors and students and on a time-frame for completing each major stage of doctoral
studies. Similar handbooks are recommended for master's programs, particularly those with a
thesis option.
The goal of the Graduate School, as well as the students thesis or dissertation committee, is to
ensure that a manuscript has been produced that will reflect positively on the student, the
students committee and department, the Graduate School, and the University of Central
Arkansas.
GENERAL INFORMATION
Departments determine whether they require, or provide an option for, masters students to
submit a thesis. All PhD candidates will complete a dissertation. The following sections outline
the general time line, policies, and procedures for producing a thesis or dissertation at the
University of Central Arkansas. It is important to read and understand fully the contents of this
manual. The student must allow sufficient time for the logistics of conducting the research and
writing the thesis or dissertation.
Graduate School Deadlines
It is the students responsibility to complete the following requirements according to the
established schedule:
Masters Degree Candidates
a notice of intent with the department chair. This will also initiate the appointment of a
major research advisor and thesis committee by the department chair. (Sample
Document page 10)
The student must then file a Petition for Admission to Candidacy with the Graduate
School. This includes a formal declaration of the students Program of Study and will be
used later by the Graduate School as a check-sheet for graduation. The Petition for
Admission to Candidacy is filed between the completion of the ninth and eighteenth
hours and will indicate the students intention to complete a thesis and the proposed title.
A thesis proposal (generally containing the first three chapters of the thesis) should be
completed and filed with the department chair as early in the thesis process as
possible, but at least by the end of the first semester in which the student registers for
thesis credit.
Continuous Enrollment: Masters students must register for at least one hour of
graduate thesis credit each semester (Fall, Spring, and Summer) after enrolling in
their first thesis course, whether the student is in residence or away from the campus.
Application for Graduation is a separate step from filing the Petition for Admission to
Candidacy and must be completed by the deadline set for each term. (This is typically
very early in the term and includes payment of a graduation fee at the Business Office or
the Graduate Office.) The Application for Graduation specifies the title of the students
thesis.
The thesis, in final form with signatures of all committee members, must be
submitted to the Graduate Dean at least two weeks prior to the date of graduation.
One routing form (Sample Document page 41) signed by the Thesis Committee
Chair, Department Chair, and College Dean must accompany the two final copies
of the thesis.
Two final copies of your thesis must be submitted to the Graduate School and
electronic submission to Proquest must be complete before your degree can be
awarded.
PhD Candidates
A dissertation research proposal will be prepared and presented before the students
dissertation committee. Following successful defense of the dissertation proposal and
completion of other departmental requirements for candidacy, the student submits a
Petition for Admission to Candidacy to the Graduate Office. This includes a formal
declaration of the students Program of Study and will be used later by the Graduate
School as a validation of fulfillment of degree requirements. The Petition indicates the
proposed title of the dissertation. The petition must include the positive
recommendations of the candidates major research professor and the department chair.
Continuous Enrollment: Doctoral students must register for a least one hour of
dissertation credit each semester (Fall, Spring, and Summer) following approval of
dissertation proposal until the work is completed, whether the student is in residence or
away from the campus.
Application for Graduation is a separate step from filing the Petition for Admission to
Candidacy and must be completed by the deadline set for the term in which the
dissertation is expected to be completed. (This is typically very early in the term and
includes payment of a graduation fee at the Business Office or the Graduate Office.) The
Application for Graduation specifies the title of the students dissertation.
The dissertation, in final form with signatures of all committee members, must be
submitted to the Graduate Dean at least two weeks prior to the date of graduation. One
routing form (Sample Document page 41) signed by the Dissertation Committee Chair,
the Department Chair, and the College Dean must accompany the two final copies of the
dissertation.
Two final copies of your dissertation must be submitted to the Graduate School and
electronic submission to Proquest must be complete before your degree can be
awarded.
Selecting a Topic
Selection of a thesis or dissertation topic is the responsibility of the student. The student is
advised to consult with an advisor and other faculty members to explore possible fields of
interest and available resources and expertise that may exist within the discipline and the
University. The potential contributions of faculty members to the development of the students
thesis or dissertation should be thoroughly investigated before the topic is selected.
The thesis or dissertation topic must be approved by the major professor and committee. The
student will submit a written statement outlining the scope of the proposed study and procedures
to be followed for approval. These procedures must be in compliance with University policies
regarding research and the use of human subjects, animals, and radioactive materials in
research. The original approval statement and outline are to be maintained in the department
office with copies distributed to the Graduate Dean, college dean, major professor, and student.
Selecting a Committee
Every graduate student who is writing a thesis or dissertation works under the direction of a
committee of graduate faculty at the University of Central Arkansas. The committee should be
selected within the time-line of the particular degree program in which the student is enrolled.
The student should investigate the interests and abilities of faculty and their ability to assist in the
particular project which the student proposes to undertake and may suggest faculty for
consideration as members of the committee. Appointments are made by the chairperson of the
academic department after considering the students recommendations.
Masters Thesis Committee. Before the student earns more than fifteen hours of
graduate credit (thirty in Counseling and Psychology programs), an intent to write a thesis is
required to be filed with the department chair who will approve a major research faculty advisor
for the candidate. This professor will become chair of the students thesis committee. The
committee shall be composed of a minimum of three members: the major professor, a second
member of the graduate faculty of the discipline involved, and a third graduate faculty member
who may be from outside the student's department. Following approval of the thesis committee
by the department chair, the form, Notice of Intent to Complete a Master's Thesis (Sample
Document page 10) will be submitted to the Graduate School.
Doctoral Dissertation Committee. The dissertation committee shall be established
according to departmental guidelines. The committee will consist of a minimum of five members
of the graduate faculty, at least one from outside the students department. Following appointment
of the committee, the form, Notice of Appointment of Dissertation Committee (Sample
Document page 11), will be submitted to the Graduate School.
Table 1
Sample Outline for Quantitative Research Proposal Using a Chapter Format
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
interpretation)
G. Assumptions/theoretical limitations
H. Definition of relevant terms
(subparts E - H are sometimes contained in a single chapter)
CHAPTER II
Table 2
Sample Outline for Qualitative Research Proposal Using a Chapter Format
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER III
METHODS
B. Site and population (description of site for study and population to be used)
C. Sample (description of sample and its selection)
D. Data collection process
E. Data analysis (techniques to be used to analyze data)
F. Study budget and timetable (might be located in appendix)
REFERENCES
APPENDICES
Sample Documents
http://uca.edu/graduateschool/thesisdissertation/
http://uca.edu/graduateschool/thesisdissertation/
The chart below provides a summary of page assignments for components of the thesis or
dissertation.
Page Assignment
Lower Case Roman Numeral
(Assigned, Not Typed)
Table of Contents
List of Tables [if applicable]
List of Figures [if applicable]
List of Symbols and/or Abbreviations
Main Text of Thesis or dissertation
Bibliography or Literature Cited
Appendices
Arabic Numerals
Starting with 1
(First page of each chapter and
Subsequent pages - bottom center.
Suppress page numbers on title pages for
appendices)
* Denotes components that are optional. All other components are mandatory.
Please note: Sample Documents are for margin and spacing guidelines only. Typeface should
match your thesis or dissertation.
Type Face
The type face is to be clear, non-distracting, and consistent throughout the thesis or dissertation.
Note that although there are specific formats to follow for title pages, appendices, etc., the FONT
MUST BE CONSISTENT THROUGHOUT THE TEXT. Exceptions to the selected type face
are allowed for graphs or other illustrations and appendix materials. Script, Old English or other
decorative typefaces are not acceptable. A 10 to 12 point font size is required. Italics may be
used, consistent with the style being followed.
Margins and Justification
To allow for binding, all left hand margins, including those of appendices, must be 1 inches
wide. The other margins should conform to the recommendation of the discipline style being
followed. If margins are not provided in the selected style guidelines, use 1 inch for each of the
top, bottom, and right margins. Right hand justification is not allowed. Full or left justification
may be used, following the selected style guide. Justification must be consistent throughout the
manuscript. Hyphenating words between lines is to be avoided.
Line Spacing
The body of the text must be double spaced, except for blocked quotations, references, footnotes,
and similar elements. In the case of these elements, follow the selected style manual. If the
selected style manual does not specify line spacing for references, single space within the item
and double space between items. Do not split an item from one page to the next.
Ink Color
Black ink is to be used for the thesis or dissertation. Though colored ink may be used for graphs
and illustrations, it will fade over time and so is not recommended. If used, it must be used for all
copies.
Paper
The Graduate School requires two (2) copies be submitted, one on twenty (20) pound weight
acid free or equivalent bond paper, 8 by 11 inches and one copy may be good grade photocopy.
The thesis or dissertation may either be printed initially on this type of paper or may be
professionally photocopied onto it. Consult your department to determine whether the copies for
committee members and the departments copy must be on the same paper or if a good grade
photocopying paper will be acceptable. Erasable paper is not acceptable, nor is carbon copy.
Illustrations
Follow the selected style manual for the titling and formatting of illustrations, including tables,
graphs, figures, drawings, and photographs. In theses or dissertations using a chapter format,
illustrations are normally placed in the text as close as possible to the first narrative referencing
them.
Main Text
Text is a generic term to refer to the main body of the thesis or dissertation. The manuscript
must be divided into a logical scheme that is followed consistently throughout the work.
Chapters are the most common major division, but sections and parts are also permissible (see
Alternate Format Guide Section page 25). Any logical system of subdivision within chapters or
sections may be used, but the scheme must be consistent throughout the manuscript.
Bibliography/List of References
The thesis or dissertation must include a list of materials used in the preparation of the
manuscript. This may consist only of references cited in the text (List of References) or it may
include works consulted as well (Bibliography). The format for citations is determined by the
style guide selected by the department.
Appendices
In carrying out any research endeavor, many activities are conducted that may not be reported as
part of a formal manuscript but may provide additional insight as to the completeness of the
project. The number and type of appendices that are to be included should be determined by the
thesis candidate in consultation with his/her thesis advisor and advisory committee. The title
page for each appendix should include a brief explanatory bridge statement that links the
information contained in the appendix to the main text of the thesis. The format of the appendices
should be consistent with that used throughout the remainder of the text.
Discipline- and Project-Specific Appendices. The following example appendices are
listed to illustrate instances where the inclusion of additional information in the thesis/dissertation
may be mandatory. This list is not comprehensive and should not be used to justify the omission
of information required by a particular discipline.
1.
Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee. All protocols involving the use of
warm-blooded vertebrate animals must receive approval from this committee prior to
the initiation of the experiments. Include the approval letter.
2. Institutional Review Board for the Use of Human Subjects. All research involving
human subjects must be approved by this committee. Do not include materials that
would allow human subjects to be identified. Include the approval letter.
3. Letter of Permission to Collect Data. (If privacy/confidentiality needs to be maintained,
white out the site name, address, etc.)
4. Data Collection Instruments.
5. Others as required by discipline and/or by unique characteristics of the individual study.
Sample Documents
by
William Harold Robert
Master of Science
in
Biology
Conway, Arkansas
May 2009
Title in all
CAPITALS,
double
spaced,
same font size
as main body
1 inch
left margin
(for binding)
1 inch
left margin
(for binding)
Title
Department
Biology
Degree
Master of Science
1 inch
left margin
(for binding)
center on the
page vertically
1 inch
left margin
(for binding)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................................... iv
Vita................................................................................................................................................................. v
Abstract ........................................................................................................................................................ vi
List of Tables .............................................................................................................................................. ix
List of Figures ............................................................................................................................................. xii
Chapter 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 1
Chapter 2 Review of Literature ................................................................................................................ 13
Chapter 3 Methodology............................................................................................................................. 24
Chapter 4 Results ....................................................................................................................................... 54
Chapter 5 Discussion and Conclusion ..................................................................................................... 71
Chapter 6 Summary ................................................................................................................................... 89
List of References....................................................................................................................................... 94
Appendices ................................................................................................................................................. 99
Appendix A................................................................................................................................................. 98
Appendix B............................................................................................................................................... 100
-After all corrections requested by the thesis or dissertation committee have been made, the
student must submit the following to the Graduate School:
1) Two copies of the movie on a playable DVD-R.
2) Two unbound copies on bond paper of the production proposal and script with original
signatures of the thesis committee on the approval page.
3) The signed routing form (Appendix A).
Formatting guidelines, samples of the approval page and other documents, and relevant forms
such as the routing form can be found in the Thesis and Dissertation Handbook.
E
A
U
Exceptional
Acceptable
Unacceptable
All MFA graduates should achieve at least the acceptable level for all criteria. For the
exceptional level, the target is 30% of all Creative Writing MFAs.
Thesis Rubric
Criteria
Demonstrate
proficiency as
critical readers of
Creative Writing
texts
Unacceptable
Student exhibits
Acceptable
Student exhibits
Exceptional
Student exhibits
inability to employ
appropriate
vocabulary to
describe the
features of
passages in poetic,
prose, dramatic,
nonfiction, and
mixed-media texts
ability to employ
appropriate
vocabulary to
describe the features
of passages in
poetic, prose,
dramatic, nonfiction,
and mixed-media
texts
exceptional ability in
breadth and depth to
employ appropriate
vocabulary to describe the
features of passages in
poetic, prose, dramatic,
nonfiction, and mixedmedia texts
inability to use
such observations
to formulate and
support interpretive
positions and offer
suggestions for
revision where
appropriate
Demonstrate
inability to write
competency in
original works
forms of poetry,
including: poetry,
fiction, nonfiction, fiction, nonfiction,
scriptwriting, or
dramatic scripts, or
mixed-media
mixed-media
material
Demonstrate
inability to grasp
competency in
professional
being acquainted
expectations of
with the culture of several forms
several specific
pertaining to
forms outside the
literary
classroom
submissions,
publishing markets,
manuscript
formatting,
performance
possibilities,
technological
innovations, and
pedagogical
theories
exceptional ability in
breadth and depth to use
such observations to
formulate and support
interpretive positions and
offer suggestions for
revision where appropriate
exceptional ability in
breadth and depth to write
original works including:
poetry, fiction, nonfiction,
dramatic scripts, or mixedmedia material
exceptional ability in
breadth and depth to grasp
professional expectations of
several forms pertaining to
literary submissions,
publishing markets,
manuscript formatting,
performance possibilities,
technological innovations,
and pedagogical theories
Alternate Formats
A department may choose to allow students to submit a thesis or dissertation in a format such
that it is ready for submission to a journal in the discipline. A student using this format must also
include information and forms required by the University, as outlined in this manual. This
approach to the preparation of a thesis differs from the standard format in that the student will
select the journal to which the paper is to be submitted and will follow the journals guidelines
for its publication style. This may result in a re-ordering of the contents of the thesis/dissertation.
The literature review, for example, may appear in the appendices, while the body of the
thesis/dissertation (article) appears immediately following the appropriate section (title page,
acknowledgment, abstract, table of contents, list of tables, and list of figures).
It is the responsibility of the student and his/her research advisor to ensure that the thesis
or dissertation adheres to the particular requirements of the journal to which the
manuscript is to be submitted as well as the requirements of this manual.
The Manuscript
Because professional journals have widely varying guidelines for manuscript preparation,
the format and division of the text into sections must correspond to the chosen journal. The
journal and the style must be approved by the thesis or dissertation advisor. The standard
elements of most research reports include an introduction, materials and methods, results,
discussion, literature cited, tables, and figures.
1.
2.
Materials and Methods. This section should be concise. Depending on the individual
field of study, descriptions of materials may or may not be necessary. If included, the
materials section should catalog the important items used in performing the research
along with the source of each item. Items supplied by the same vendor should be
grouped. A common mistake made by beginning authors is simply to list items used
without incorporating them into the text. A materials list is part of the main text and should
follow the same format used for all other parts of the manuscript.
General methodologies used in the study should be described under Materials and
Methods. A sufficient description should be provided to allow the reader to replicate the
work. In some instances it may be appropriate to cite previously reported methods
followed by a description of the modifications employed in the present investigation.
If University Compliance Committee approval was obtained, state this in this section.
Remember to place a copy of the approval letter in the appendices.
3.
Results. In this section the data obtained from research are reported. The results should
be presented in such to describe the project. It is not critical that individual results be
reported in exactly the same sequence as they were obtained. The tables and figures
should be referenced in the text of the results, since they contain the primary data. The
author should avoid duplicating data contained in the tables and figures and should
instead summarize the information in the text. It is critical that the narrative flow from
one result to the next. Solid transitional and topic sentences are essential. The results
section should not include a significant
4.
Discussion. In this section the significance of the work is defined and discussed in the
context of the literature. The discussion section does not report results. Most readers
acquire an impression of the discussion section based upon the material that they read at
the beginning and at the end of the section. Therefore, one should start with the most
important information and end with a positive conclusion concerning the most significant
result from the study.
5.
Literature Cited. The format of this section will vary depending upon the selected.
Special care should be taken to ensure that all citations are correct in terms of authors,
titles, dates, journal, volume and issue numbers, and page numbers.
6.
7.
A)
B)
Column headings must be accurate and include the units for the data
presented.
C)
Figures. Like tables, figures should be constructed in such a way that they have meaning
independent of the text. The purpose of the figure should be readily apparent by visual
inspection. Keeping in mind the guidelines set forth by the chosen journal, the following
generalities should serve as a starting point for the construction of all figures:
A)
B)
C)
D)
E)
Appendices
In addition to the list of discipline- or project-specific appendices listed on pages 13 - 14, the thesis
or dissertation using an alternate format may include appendices to provide additional insight as
to the completeness of the research. The following is a list of suggested appendices that may be
included in the thesis/dissertation. While only the extended literature review is mandatory, the
remaining appendices are strongly recommended and may be required by the committee based
on the nature of the thesis/dissertation. As with the thesis/dissertation written in a chapter format,
the number and type of appendices to be included should be determined by the student in
consultation with the faculty research advisor and the thesis or dissertation committee.
1.
2.
3.
Supplementary Results. Data and information in support of the main body of the thesis
should be presented in this section. Types of information may include the results of
preliminary studies, other supporting experiments, and extended analysis of data presented
in the main text. These may include, but are not limited to, tables representing the results
of statistical analysis, validity and reliability information, and additional tables and
figures.
4.
Doctoral Dissertations
No Charge
No Charge
$55
Masters Theses
No Charge
No Charge
$55
For binding services and fees please contact the UCA Library at 501-450-5252.
COPYRIGHT
Understanding copyright rights as thesis or dissertation author
A copyright is a form of legal protection given to authors of intellectual works. This protection
is provided by federal law to the owners of Original works of authorship fixed in any tangible
medium of expression, now known or later developed, from which they can be perceived,
reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or
device. The Copyright Act of 1976 defines these works as including, but not being limited to,
the following: literary works; musical works, including any accompanying words; dramatic
works, including any accompanying music; sound recordings; motion pictures and other
audiovisual works; pictorial, graphic, and sculptural works; and pantomimes and
choreographic works. Copyright protection does not extend to an idea or concept: it extends
only to the work in which the idea or concept is embodied. The writer of a thesis or
dissertation has created an original work of authorship and is entitled to rights under the
copyright law.
Numerous works produced by the United States Government are not copyrightable. United
States Code Annotated 17-1-105 prohibits copyright protection for federal government works,
including reports written by employees of federal agencies as part of their public function. Works
produced by non-government officials with the aid of federal funding are often considered
federal works produced by federal employees; however, they may or may not be eligible for
copyright protection under this law.
The fact that the author has a federal grant does not automatically put the work in the public
domain. The terms of the grant should be reviewed carefully to determine who may claim the
copyright to the original work. As the law is written, the government agency concerned can
determine in each case whether to allow the grantee to secure copyright in works prepared in
whole or in part with the use of government funds.
The effect of section 105 is intended to place all works of the U.S. Government, published or
unpublished, in the public domain. This means that the employee or grantee who wrote
the work could not secure copyright in it or restrain its dissemination by the government or
anyone else, but it also means that, as far as the copyright law is concerned, the government
could not restrain the employee or grantee from disseminating the work if he or she
chooses to do so. The use of the term work of the United States Government does not mean
that a work falling within the definition of that term is the property of the U.S. Government.
To determine if this Federal Law may apply to a thesis or dissertation, the federal grant
agreement should be reviewed and contact made with the appropriate federal agency if there
are any questions concerning the terms of the grant.
The Protection of a Copyright
The protection of a copyright prevents others from taking credit for or gaining profit from work
without consent of the author. According to the Copyright Act of 1976, the author of the original
work automatically holds copyright protection for the work without making notice or formal
registration. In the case of the thesis or dissertation, the scholarly endeavor immediately
becomes the property of the author and nothing further, such as publication of a copyright notice
or registration with the Copyright Office, is needed to secure the copyright. The authors rights
are protected automatically when the work is created. A work is created as soon as the work is
fixed in a tangible medium for the first time. Once the work is made tangible, the author
controls the right to print, sell, distribute, perform, display, and revise the work. Therefore,
before anyone can copy an authors work, permission must be obtained from the copyright
owner. Failure to do so would be an infringement on the owners rights, allowing the copyright
holder to seek damages against improper use of the original work.
If the work was created on or after January 1, 1978, the copyright protection extends from the
moment the work was created, through the lifetime of the author, plus an additional 50 years
after the authors death.
There are a few factors that limit the copyright owners exclusive rights to the original work. The
concept of Fair Use is one limiting factor on copyright protection. Fair use is a right given to
others whereby they may use copyrighted material in a reasonable manner without consent of the
copyright owner. Others may reproduce portions of the original work, without consent or
permission, for purposes such as scholarly criticism, research, teaching, and news reporting.
Also, in certain circumstances, libraries are allowed to reproduce copyrighted material without
the permission of the copyright owner.
Copyright Registration
Under current law, copyright protection begins from the first moment of its tangible existence
without any formal action required on the part of the original author. As of March 1, 1989, it is
no longer necessary to place a copyright notice on published copies of a work publicly distributed
on or after March 1, 1989 for that work to be entitled to copyright protection. However, there are
certain legal advantages that are available only if formal copyright registration is obtained. It is
strongly recommended that, as the author of an original work, you give public notification and
follow mandatory deposit guidelines to afford your work the highest level of protection under
copyright law.
1.
Advantages of Registration
A)
Registration (before or within five years after the first publication of the
work) is prima facie evidence of the validity of the copyright and of the
facts stated on the registration certificate;
B)
C)
2.
D)
E)
The registration may be recorded with the U.S. Customs Service which will
impound (and possibly destroy) imported infringing copies of the
copyrighted work.
Public Notification
Public notification is the responsibility of the author and requires no advanced
registration or permission from the U. S. Copyright Office. A proper notice should
be fixed in such a way as to give reasonable notice of the copyright claim and
should contain the following elements: (Sample Document page 23)
3.
A)
B)
C)
D)
For example, a proper notification would look like this 2009 Jane L. Doe.
B)
If the deposit is not made, the author could be subject to certain fines and
penalties, none of which, however, would affect the copyright protection. The
Graduate Office strongly encourages students to place notice of
copyright in the thesis or dissertation and to meet the mandatory deposit
guidelines. Complying with these legal formalities will make the copyright a
matter of public record, giving the author more authority over use of the
work. Furthermore, it is necessary that a copyright registration be filed before
an infringement suit can begin. A sample registration packet is located in the
Office of Graduate Studies. For a copyright registration application and
Sample Documents
Dissertation/Thesis Approval
Routing Form
The (dissertation or thesis) of [insert students name here] entitled [insert title of
dissertation/thesis here] has been reviewed and approved by the (Dissertation or Thesis)
committee and all departmental, college, and university policies and procedures have been
followed.
(Date)
Department Chair
(Date)
College Dean
(Date)
Graduate Dean
(Date)