What Is Ancient Folklore?: THE CLASSICAL JOURNAL 102.3 (2007) 279-89
What Is Ancient Folklore?: THE CLASSICAL JOURNAL 102.3 (2007) 279-89
What Is Ancient Folklore?: THE CLASSICAL JOURNAL 102.3 (2007) 279-89
280
For definitions of the different types of folklore genres, see Hansen (1988).
281
3
Several handbooks on folklore are available; Oring (1986), esp. Chapter 1,
is concise and easy to follow, and gives many further references.
4
Very few overviews of ancient folklore exist, but Hansen (1988) is a good
start; Hansen (2002) is an excellent complement, as it deals with the history of
research on ancient folklore, beginning with the Grimm brothers. For a broader
survey of the disciplines of history and folklore and their relationship, see Burke
(2004).
5
On this topic, see Scobie (1979); Stadter (1997).
282
283
3.4 Mrchen12
Only one example of a Mrchen, or wonder tale, survives from
antiquity in its own distinctive form, i.e., as a multi-episode narrative with fantastic elements, and that is Apuleius tale of Cupid
and Psyche. It is likely that the wonder tale was a popular form of
narrative among the common people of the ancient world, but the
stories have not been included as wonder tales in the literary texts
that have come down to us. Instead, many have taken the form of
legends. Since the tale of Cupid and Psyche is long, we recommended concentrating on some aspects of it, for example the traits
that mark it as a wonder tale.
3.5 Novellas13
The novella is the more realistic sibling of the wonder tale. It is
sometimes difficult to separate from legend; the story of the
Matron of Ephesus has been identified as both a novella and a
legend. We would suggest leaving this thorny question aside and
focusing on what the narrative can tell us about attitudes toward
widows in ancient Rome.
10
Hdt. 3.3943: the Ring of Polycrates. A number of brief articles have been
written on this topic, but none can be said to be appropriate in this context. There
are, however, a number of papers on Herodotus use of oral traditions and on
Herodotus as a storyteller: Murray (1987/2001); Vignolo Munson (1993); Stadter
(1997); Murray (2001).
11
Lucian VH 2.1116: Schlaraffenland, or the Land of Cockaigne. Hansen
(2002) 37892.
12
Apul. Met. 4.286.24: Cupid & Psyche. Hansen (2002) 10014.
13
Petr. 11112: the Matron of Ephesus. Hansen (2002) 26679; see also Walcot (1991).
284
14
Ael. NA 13.6: octopuses and alligators in the sewers. Urban legends in
antiquity have received a fair amount of scholarly attention, and much of the work
on this subject is listed in Mayor (2000). The legend of the octopus in the sewers
is a new discovery and will be published in a forthcoming paper by Camilla
Asplund Ingemark. For the modern New York legend, see Brunvand (1981) 901.
15
Petr. 51; Plin. Nat. 36.57.195; D.C. 57.21.57: marvellous/suppressed
inventions. Lassen (2001). For its modern counterpart, see Brunvand (1981) 1758.
16
Petr. 612; Marc.Sid. cit., At. 6.11: werewolf stories. Smith (1894); Ogden
(2002) 1758. For werewolves in Greek myth, see Buxton (1987).
17
Plin. Ep. 7.27.512; Lucian Philops. 302: haunted houses. Felton (1999);
Ogden (2002) Chapter 8; see also Johnston (1999).
285
4.2 Riddles19
Riddles were an important part of the oral traditions of antiquity,
and for this class we recommend making a selection from Symphosius collection of riddles. A suitable topic of discussion might
be their relation to objects and phenomena in Roman daily life.
286
287
reconsideration of the meanings of the texts and, if so, why. Attention might be paid to the influence of the notions of an original
master-text vs. variation in the interpretation of ancient texts, and
to the potential moulding of our perception of historical truth in
the light of oral traditions.
Conclusion
Not only did our students find this course interesting, but it
gave them an opportunity to study a wide range of ancient texts
and aspects of ancient social history and mentality. But the most
immediate gain was the introduction of a new key to the understanding of the classical textsfolklorefunctioning as a complement to established linguistic, literary and historical perspectives.
DOMINIC INGEMARK AND
CAMILLA ASPLUND INGEMARK
Lund University, Sweden
bo Akademi University, Finland
WORKS CITED
Baldwin, Barry. 1983. The Philogelos or Laughter-Lover. Amsterdam.
Bell, J.M. 1978. Kimbix kai sophos: Simonides in the Anecdotal Tradition. QUCC 28: 2986.
Bremmer, Jan. 1997. Jokes, Jokers and Jokebooks in Ancient Greek
Culture. In A Cultural History of Humour: From Antiquity to the
Present Day, edited by J. Bremmer and H. Roodenburg, pp. 1128.
Cambridge.
Brunvand, Jan Harold. 1981. The Vanishing Hitchhiker: American Urban
Legends and Their Meanings. New York.
Burke, Peter. 2004. History and Folklore: A Historiographical Survey.
Folklore 115: 1339.
Buxton, Richard. 1987. Wolves and Werewolves in Greek Thought. In
Interpretations of Greek Mythology edited by J. Bremmer, pp. 6079.
London and Sydney.
Campbell, David A. 1991. Greek Lyric III: Stesichorus, Ibycus, Simonides,
and Others. Cambridge, MA and London.
Felton, Debbie. 1999. Haunted Greece and Rome: Ghost Stories from Classical
Antiquity. Austin.
Foley, John Miles. 1991. Immanent Art: From Structure to Meaning in
Traditional Oral Epic. Bloomington and Indianapolis.
Forster, E.S. 1945. Riddles and Problems from the Greek Anthology.
G&R 14: 427.
Graf, Fritz. 1997. Cicero, Plautus, and Roman Laughter. In A Cultural
History of Humour: From Antiquity to the Present Day, edited by J.
Bremmer and H. Roodenburg, pp. 2939. Cambridge.
288
289
Ong, Walter J. 1982. Orality and Literacy: The Technologizing of the Word.
London.
Oring, Elliott. 1986. Folk Groups and Folklore Genres: An Introduction. Logan,
UT.
Page, Denys. 1955. The Homeric Odyssey: The Mary Flexner Lectures Delivered at Bryn Mawr College, Pennsylvania. Oxford.
Pavlovskis, Zoja. 1988. The Riddlers Microcosm: From Symphosius to
St. Boniface. C&M 39: 21951.
Richlin, Amy. 1983. The Garden of Priapus: Sexuality and Aggression in
Roman Humor. New Haven and London.
Russo, Joseph. 1997. Prose Genres for the Performance of Traditional
Wisdom in Ancient Greece. In Poet, Public and Performance in
Ancient Greece, edited by L. Edmunds and R.W. Wallace, pp. 4964.
Baltimore and London.
Scobie, Alex. 1979. Storytellers, Storytelling and the Novel in GraecoRoman Antiquity. RhM 122: 22959.
Shapiro, Susan O. 2000. Proverbial Wisdom in Herodotus. TAPA 130:
89118.
Slater, W.J. 1972. Simonides House. Phoenix 26: 23240.
Smith, Kirby Flower. 1894. An Historical Study of the Werwolf in Literature. Publications of the Modern Language Association of America 9:
142.
Stadter, Philip. 1997. Herodotus and the North Carolina Oral Narrative
Tradition. Histos 1 (www.dur.ac.uk/Classics/histos).
Tzifopoulos, Yannis Z. 1995. Proverbs in Menanders Dyskolos: The
Rhetoric of Popular Wisdom. Mnemosyne 48: 16977.
Vignolo Munson, Rosaria. 1993. Herodotus Use of Prospective Sentences and the Story of Rhampsinitus and the Thief in the Histories. AJP 114: 2744.
Walcot, Peter. 1991. On Widows and their Reputation in Antiquity.
SO 66: 526.