Mining Guidelines Manual For EIA Preparation
Mining Guidelines Manual For EIA Preparation
Mining Guidelines Manual For EIA Preparation
MINING OF MINERALS
Prepared by
February 2010
Environmental
Impact Assessment Guidance Manual
for
Mining of Minerals
Siripurapu K. Rao
M.A. (Cantab), Ph.D. (Cantab)
DIRECTOR GENERAL
Acknowledgements
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is a planning tool generally accepted as an integral component
of sound decision-making. EIA is to give the environment its due place in the decision-making process by
clearly evaluating the environmental consequences of the proposed activity before action is taken. Early
identification and characterization of critical environmental impacts allow the public and the government
to form a view about the environmental acceptability of a proposed developmental project and what
conditions should apply to mitigate or reduce those risks and impacts.
Environmental Clearance (EC) for certain developmental projects has been made mandatory by the Ministry
of Environment & Forests through its Notification issued on 27.01.1994 under the provisions of Environment
(Protection) Act, 1986. Keeping in view a decade of experience in the Environmental Clearance process
and the demands from various stakeholders, the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) issued
revised Notification on EC process in September 2006 and amended it in December 2009.It was considered
necessary by MoEF to make available EIA guidance manuals for each of the development sector.
Accordingly, at the instance of the MoEF, the Administrative Staff College of India, with the assistance of
experts, undertook the preparation of sector specific Terms of Reference (TOR) and specific guidance
manual for Mining of Minerals. I wish to thank Mr. J. M. Mauskar, IAS, Additional Secretary, Govt. of
India MoEF for his continuing support during the preparation of the manuals. I wish to place on record
also my sincere thanks to Dr. B. Sengupta, former Member Secretary, Central Pollution Control Board
and Chairman of the Core Committee for his help in the preparation of the manuals. His suggestions
helped us a great deal in improving the technical quality of the manuals. Mr M. Parabrahmam, Former
advisor MoEF and Chairman of the Peer Committee II for this project, has given constant guidance to the
ASCI project team. His vast experience has been immensely helpful in preparing these manuals. I would
like to thank the officials of the Ministry, Dr. Nalini Bhat and Dr. T. Chandini, for coordinating the
project from the Ministry side and for providing guidance whenever needed My thanks are also due to
Dr. S. K. Aggarwal of MoEF for the valuable inputs they had given during our interactions with the
officials at Delhi and Hyderabad.
I thank Dr. D. K. Behera, Senior scientist, Orissa Pollution Control Board, resource person, who, drawing
on his vast experience in the sector, prepared the EIA guidance manual on Mining of Minerals along
with Dr. Valli Manickam, Member of Faculty of ASCI. The efforts put in by both of them are commendable.
I would like to thank all the Peer and Core Committee members for having given a valuable feed back in
the preparation of the manual. I hope the manuals would prove to be useful to the community at large
and to the experts working in this area in particular.
26 February, 2010
S.K. Rao
CONTENTS
Chapter No.
Title
Page no.
Foreword
Acknowledgements
Team
Core Committee
Peer Committee II
Abbreviations
List of Tables
Lists of Annexures
List of Figures
About the Manual
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
vi
Introduction
1.0 Preamble
1.1 General Information on Mining of Minerals
1.2 Environmental Clearance
1.3 Terms of Reference (TOR)
1.4 Post Environmental Clearance Monitoring
1.5 Transferability of Environmental Clearance
1.6 Generic Structure of Environmental Impact
Assessment Document
1.7 Details of Project Proponent
1.8 Brief Description of Project
viii
ix
x
xi
xii
xiii
xiv
xv
1
1
10
15
15
15
16
16
16
Project Description
2.0 General
2.1 Description of the Project
2.2 Location Details
2.3 Leasehold Area
2.4 Geology
2.5 Quality of Reserves
2.6 Types of Mining
2.7 Manpower requirements
2.8 Project implementation schedule
19
19
20
20
20
20
22
22
22
Analysis of Alternatives
3.0 General
23
Description of Environment
4.0 General
4.1 Land Environment
4.2 Water Environment
4.3 Air Environment
4.4 Noise Environment
4.5 Biological Environment
4.6 Socio-Economic Environment
4.7 Public Utilities
4.8 Site Specific Features
25
25
26
27
28
28
29
30
30
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Chapter 7
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
31
32
33
36
39
41
41
42
44
47
47
Additional Studies
7.0 General
7.1 Items identified by the proponent
7.2 Items identified by the regulatory authority
7.3 Items identified by the public and other stakeholders
7.4 Risk Analysis and Disaster Management Plan
7.5 Natural Resource Conservation
7.6 Rehabilitation & Resettlement (R&R)
51
51
51
51
51
55
55
Project benefits
8.0 General
Environmental Management Plan
9.0 General
9.1 Subsidence
9.2 Acid Mine Drainage
9.3 Air Pollution Control
9.4 Water Management and Water Pollution Control
9.5 Noise Control
9.6 Control of Vibration and Fly Rock Generation during Blasting
9.7 Biological Management
9.8 Landuse Planning and Mine Closure
9.9 Occupational Safety & Health
9.10 Socio-Economic Conditions of the Region
Disclosure of consultants
11.0 General
Bibliography
Tables
Annexures
Questionnaire
57
59
59
60
61
62
62
63
63
66
66
65
69
71
73
75
83
125
vii
Team
Project Coordination
Ministry of Environment
& Forests
Dr. B Sengupta
Former Member Secretary, CPCB
Shri. M. Parabrahmam
Former Advisor, MoEF
Prof. VS Chary
Director
Centre for Energy, Environment
Urban Governance, and Infrastructure Development,
Administrative Staff College of India
Shri. G Bala Subramanyam
Advisor,
Environment Area, ASCI, Hyderabad
Dr. Valli Manickam
Area Chairperson
Environment Area, ASCI
& Project Coordinator
Resource Persons
Dr. DK Behera
Senior Environment Scientist,
Orissa Pollution Control Board,
Orissa.
Dr. Valli Manickam
Environment Area
Administrative Staff College of India
Hyderabad.
viii
Core Committee
Dr. B. Sengupta
Former Member Secretary
Central Pollution Control Board, New Delhi
Chairman
Shri. M. Parabrahmam
Former Advisor, Ministry of Environment & Forests, New Delhi
Chairman
Karnataka Pollution Control Board
Dr. M. S. Narayanan
Former Chairman, Coal India, New Delhi
Dr. S. R. Wate
Head, EIA Division NEERI, Nagpur
Prof. P. G. Sastry
Former Chairman EAC (River Valley Projects), MoEF
Member Secretary
Rajasthan Pollution Control Board
Mrs. Rohini Devi
Director, HTCC, Sg -'G' ASL
Representative of DRDO, Hyderabad
Dr. M. Irulappan
General Manager (Com),
Representative of Airport Authority of India, New Delhi
Shri. V. K. Sharma
Head, Environment Division,
Representative of NHAI, New Delhi
Shri A. K. Debnath
CG M, Central Mine Plan & Design Institute, Ranchi
Ms. Sarita Sawhny
Representative of Confederation of Indian Industry, New Delhi
ix
Peer Committee II
Shri. M. Parabrahmam
Former Adivsor-MoEF, GoI
Chairman
Prof. M. A. Ramulu
Ex-Head, Dept. of Mining Engg
IIT, Khargpur
Dr. S. P. Vivek Chandra Rao
General Manager Occupational Health
Hyderabad Industries Limited, Hyderabad
Dr. G. Suryanarayana
I/C Head (EE&M), Environmental Protection Training Research Institute
(EPTRI), Hyderabad.
Mr. P. Sharath Kumar
Office of CGM (Proj. Planning)
The Sigareni Collories Co. Ltd., Kothagudem
Dr. S. Ramakrishna Rao
AP State Expert Appraisal Committee
Dr. J. A. Kamalakar
Manager CNV (Environment) NMDC Ltd, Hyderabad
ABBREVIATIONS
ASCI
CPCB
CRZ
CSR
CGWB
EAC
EIA
EC
ETP
EMP
DMP
IA
MoEF
RO
R&R
SPCBs
STP
TOR
xi
List of Tables
Table No.
Title
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.7
2.8
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
4.7
4.8
4.9
4.10
4.11
4.12
4.13
4.14
4.15
4.16
4.17
4.18
4.19
5.1
5.2
5.3
6.1
10.1
10.2
xii
Page No.
1
2
3
3
4
9
10
75
75
75
75
76
76
76
76
77
77
77
77
77
78
78
78
78
79
79
79
79
80
80
80
80
80
81
81
81
81
82
82
82
List of Annexures
Annexure No.
Title
Page No.
Annexure 1
83
Annexure 2
98
Annexure 3
99
Annexure 4
101
Annexure 5
102
Annexure 6
104
Annexure 7
106
Annexure 8
Parameters of Impacts
107
Annexure 9
108
Annexure 10
109
Annexure - 11
110
Annexure 12
112
Annexure 13
113
Annexure 14
Annexure 15
115
Annexure 16
117
Annexure 17
118
Annexure 18
119
Annexure 19
120
Annexure 20
121
Annexure 21
124
xiii
List of Figures
Figure No.
Title
Page No.
1.1
13
14
37
1.2
1.3
5.1
xiv
xv
assess the impacts where pertinent should be elaborated in this chapter. It should give the details
of the impacts on the baseline parameters, both during the construction and operational phases
and suggests the mitigation measures to be implemented by the proponent.
Chapter 6: Environmental Monitoring Program
This chapter should cover the planned environmental monitoring program. It should also include
the technical aspects of monitoring the effectiveness of mitigation measures.
Chapter 7: Additional Studies
This chapter should cover the details of the additional studies required in addition to those
specified in the ToR and which are necessary to cater to more specific issues applicable to the
particular project.
Chapter 8: Project Benefits
This chapter should cover the benefits accruing to the locality, neighbourhood, region and nation
as a whole. It should bring out details of benefits by way of improvements in the physical
infrastructure, social infrastructure, employment potential and other tangible benefits.
Chapter 9: Environmental Cost Benefit Analysis
This chapter should cover on Environmental Cost Benefit Analysis of the project.
Chapter 10: Environmental Management Plan
This chapter should comprehensively present the Environmental Management Plan (EMP), which
includes the administrative and technical setup, summary matrix of EMP, the cost involved to
implement the EMP, both during the construction and operational phase and provisions made
towards the same in the cost estimates of project construction and operation. This chapter should
also describe the proposed post-monitoring scheme as well as inter-organizational arrangements
for effective implementation of the mitigation measures.
Chapter 11: Summary and Conclusions
This chapter gives the summary of the full EIA report condensed to ten A-4 size pages at the
maximum. It should provide the overall justification for implementation of the project and should
explain how the adverse effects have been mitigated.
Chapter 12: Disclosure of Consultants
This chapter should include the names of the consultants engaged with their brief resume and
nature of consultancy rendered.
The contents of the manual are to be considered as version 1.0 (2010). The ministry as per the
requirements will take up an updating /revision of the manual. In case of interpretation of
any question related to law, the provisions of the original laws and the Rules made thereunder
with various Government directions /resolutions will have to be read and followed. In case of
amendment to the original Act /Rules /Notifications made thereunder, the provisions as
amended from time to time shall be applicable. Any obligations of international conventions,
where GoI is a signatory and accepted for implementation are also to be followed.
xvi
1
INTRODUCTION
1.0 Preamble
Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) is a process, used to identify the environmental, social
and economic impacts of a project prior to decision-making. It is a decision-making tool, which
guides the decision makers in taking appropriate decisions for proposed projects. It aims
predicting environmental impacts at an early stage of project planning and design, find ways
and means to reduce adverse impacts, shape projects to suit the local environment and present
the predictions and options to decision makers. By using EIA, both environmental and economic
benefits can be achieved. EIA systematically examines both beneficial and adverse consequences
of the proposed project and ensures that these impacts are taken into account during the project
design. By considering environmental effects and mitigation early in the project planning cycle,
there are many benefits, such as protection of the environment, optimum utilization of resources
and saving overall time and cost of the project. Properly conducted EIA also lessens conflicts by
promoting community participation, informs decision-makers, and helps lay the base for
environmentally sound projects.
The Ministry of Environment & Forests, Govt. of India, made environmental clearance (EC) for
certain development projects mandatory through its notification of 27/01/1994 under the
Environment Protection Act, 1986. Keeping in view of the experience gained in environmental
clearance process over a period of one decade, the MoEF came out with Environment Impact
Notification, SO 1533(E), and dt.14/09/2006. It has been made mandatory to obtain environmental
clearance for different kinds of developmental projects (Schedule-1 of notification).
The notification has classified projects under two categories-A and B. Category-A Projects
(including expansion and modernization of existing projects) require clearance from Central
Government (Ministry of Environment and Forest, Govt. of India) while category-B projects should
be considered by State Level Environmental Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA), constituted
with the approval of MoEF.
Number
All minerals
2854
Fuel minerals
569
Metallic minerals
676
Non-metallic Minerals
1609
Source: Ministry of Mines GOI, www.mines.nic.in.
Out of 2954 reporting mines, 433 were located in Gujarat followed by Andhra Pradesh (406),
Madhya Pradesh (298), Jharkhand (298), Rajasthan (252), Orissa (236), Karnataka (230), Tamil
Nadu (159), Maharashtra (154), Chhattisgarh (150) and West Bengal (113). These 11 states together
accounted for 92.38 % of total number of mines in the country in 2008-09. During 2008-09, mineral
production was reported from 23 States and Union Territories of which the bulk of value of
mineral production of about 78.99% was confined to 8 States (Including offshore areas) only.
Offshore areas continued to be in leading position, in terms of value of mineral production in
the country and had the share of 19.36% in the national output. Next in order was Orissa with a
share of 14.70% followed by Chhattisgarh (11.61%), Jharkhand (8.94%), Madhya Pradesh (7.83%),
Andhra Pradesh (6.46%), Gujarat (5.09%), Karnataka (5.00%), Maharashtra (4.39%), Goa (3.35%),
Assam (3.14%) and West Bengal (3.11%) in the total value of mineral production. Remaining 11
States/Union Territories having individual share of less than 3% together accounted for 7.02% of
total value during the year under review (www.mines.nic.in).
Indias ranking in 2007-08 in world production was 2nd in barytes, chromite and talc/steatite/
pyrophillite, 3rd in coal & lignite and bauxite, 4th in iron ore and kyanite/sillimanite, 5th in
manganese ore and steel (crude), 7th in zinc and 8th in aluminium. The statistics on indigenous
and world production of principal minerals and metals are given in Table 1.2.
Table 1.2 Contribution and rank of India in World Production of Principal Minerals & Metals, 2007
Commodity
Mineral Fuels
Coal & Lignite
Petroleum (crude)
Metallic Minerals
Bauxite
Chromite
Iron ore
Manganese ore
Industrial Minerals
Barytes
Kyanite, andalusite &
sillimanite
Magnesite
Apatite & Rock phosphate
Talc/Steatite/Pyrophllite
Mica
Metals
Aluminium
Copper (refined)
Steel (crude/liquido)
Lead (refined)
Zinc (slab)
Unit of
Quantity
Million tones
Million tonnes
000 tones
000 tones
Million tonnes
000 tones
000 tones
000 tones
000 tones
000 tones
000 tones
tonnes
000 tones
000 tones
Million tones
000 tones
000 tones
Production
World
India
Contributio%
Indias rank in
Order of Quantum
of production
6357
3885
491
34
7.7
0.9
3rd
24th
213000
24000
2043
33800
23084
4798
206
2550
10.8
20.0
10.0
7.5
3rd
2nd
4th
5th
1072
47
13.2
11.7
2nd
4th
23500
159000
8600
310000
248
1866
1031
4583
1.0
1.2
12.0
1.5
11th
13th
2nd
11th
38200
20900
1344
8100
11300
1240
501
54@
58
457
3.2
2.4
4.0
0.7
4.0
8th
11th
5th
25th
7th
8100
400(e)**
Source: World mineral production data compiled from World Mineral Production, 2003-2007, British Geological Survey.
* Figures relate to 2007-08.
** Mineral Commodity Summaries, 2009, US Geological Survey.
@ JPC data (March 2009)
Introduction
Mineral-wise analysis revealed that building stone had the largest share of 24.5% to the value of
minor minerals followed by brick-earth 20.9%, road metals 17.1%, marble 12.1%, ordinary sand
6.4%, quartzite & sandstone 5.2%, limestone 3.6%, gravel 3.3%, murrum 1.8%, kankar 1.5%,
ordinary earth 1.4% and ordinary clay 1.1%. The remaining minerals together contributed 1.1%
of value of minor minerals. The proven geological resources of coal in India are given in Table
1.3. The coal production in India during 2008-2009 is presented in Table 1.4
Table 1.3 Inventory of Geological Resources of Coal in India
Type of Coal
As on
Prime Coking
Indicated
Inferred
Total
01/04/2008
4,614
699
5,313
01/04/2009
4,614
699
5,313
01/04/2008
12,308
12,136
1,880
26,324
01/04/2009
12,448
12,064
1,880
26,393
Blendable /
01/04/2008
482
1,003
222
1,707
Semi Coking
01/04/2009
482
1,003
222
1,707
Non Coking
(including High
Sulphur)
01/04/2008
01/04/2009
84,425
88,275
110,378
109,704
38,388
35,819
231,191
233,798
Total
01/04/2008
101,829
124,216
38,490
264,535
01/04/2009
105,820
123,470
37,921
267,211
Medium Coking
Table 1.4 Coal Production (in Million Tonnes) in India during 2008-09
Sl. No. Company
Target
Production
Achievement
Achievement %
1.
405.00
403.73
99.7
2.
41.50
44.54
107.3
3.
Others
50.79
44.68
88.0
Total
479.29
492.95
99.1
Source : Provision Coal Statistics (2008-09), Coal Controller Organisation, Ministry of Coal, Govt. of India
Primary step of mining of minerals is the removal of the deposits from the ground. Once the
minerals / ore is removed, additional preparation process is required to isolate the valuable
minerals from their waste gangue minerals. There are two basic method of mining of minerals
opencast and underground mining. The choice of method depends on the geologic, hydrological,
geo-technical, geographic, economic, technological, environmental, safety, socio -political and
financial considerations. Table 1.5 gives a classification of the prevalent mining methods.
The major purpose of mine development is to provide auxiliary and support facilities for
physically opening a surface or underground, or mine and bringing it to full production is to be
planned. The facilities will not contribute directly to the production operation. It is a period of
intensive and diversified activity on the project site with environmental impacts, which are usually
different in nature from operational impacts, which are crucial for successful environmental
management.
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
Deposit
Surface Mining
Quarrying
Opencast Mining (incl. Strip mining)
Auger/High wall mining
Placer mining (mineral and mining)
Hydraulicking
Dredging
Solution Mining
Borhole mining
In-Site leaching
Underground Mining
Unsupported / minimum supported
- Room and pillar /
Bord and pillar mining
- Stope and pillar mining
- Shrinkage stopping
- Sub level stopping
- Hydraulic mining
Supported (with fill)
- Cut and fill stoping
- Longwall mining
- Room-and-pillar mining
- Sub-level mining
Caving
- Longwall mining
- Sub-level / caving
- Block caving
Nonmetallic
Coal, Metal, Non-metallic
Coal
Metal, Non-metallic
Metal, Non-metallic
Non-metallic
Metal
The surface facilities unique to underground mining are mine main entries (shafts, declines and
adits) head frame(s), heap; stead, storage bins, hoist houses, etc. the additional underground
facilities may consist of secondary and tertiary openings for providing access haulage and
ventilation and various other facilities such as transportation, crusher stations, power distribution
equipment and numerous other installations.
In surface mines if the deposit does not outcrop, advanced stripping is required before mineral
production can begin. Development is carried out according to a carefully designed plan which
is to be outlined in the feasibility report. Scheduling of the entire mine development work is to
be clearly indicated by bar charts.
Introduction
life needs to be mentioned. Further a general description of mode of mine main entry (shaft,
declines adits) general mine development with multiple headings (main, secondary and tertiary)
in coal to layout the seam in room and pillar or longwall panels and to provide for haulage and
ventilations are to be given.
There are several variants of room-and-pillar or long-wall mining methods. Factors in selection
of a suitable room-and-pillar or long-wall mining methods are number and thickness of seams,
dip their contiguity, strength of roof and floor, depth, gassiness of seam, liability to spontaneous
heating, presence of dirt bands, method of roof control, percentage recovery, effect on mine
surface due to subsidence, water influx, efficiency, productivity, safety and environment,
availability of matching equipment, Capital and operating costs are to be estimated.
In the conventional room-and-pillar mining, the production cycle consists of fundamental unit
operations rate, cut, drill, blast, haul which are closely associated with equipment. With continuous
mining, production cycle consists of the operations mining (break and load) and haul. The method
of roof control is by caving or non-caving methods.
Underground metal mining
In this method of mining, the amount of underground development required to achieve desired
production rate depends on the shape and size of the ore body (length, width and thickness, dip,
grade and reserves of the deposit, strength and structure of the stoping method selected. The
mine development effort in steeply inclined deposits generally consists of several horizontal
levels at specified vertical intervals, sub levels between main levels, drifts, crosscuts, connecting
ramps ore passes etc for ore handling.
Factors that must be considered for the selection of a suitable stoping method are shape and size
of the deposit in the mineralized zone (s), deposit characteristics, productivity dilution with
waste rock and ore losses, variation of metal content in the ore body, regularity, irregularity of
discontinuity ore body, blasting techniques, use of selective mining, applicability of mechanization
effective ventilation and safety.
There are many approaches to the management of mining-related environmental problems. There
are also many agencies involved in enforcement of various legislations, dealing with
environmental protection. Environmentally sound mining technologies and practices should be
adopted in all phases of mining and the related activities. Best management practices should be
adopted to minimize environmental degradation. Environmental considerations are an integral
component of mining operations, from the planning stage to mine closure. The general
recommended approach is integration of environmental concerns into every mining activity.
Subsidence due to underground mining
Excavation operations of underground mines either for minerals or coal may result in disturbing
the surface land and the natural features and valuable surface assets. Subsidence in mine is a
movement of ground surface due to failure of the underground workings or result of collapse.
Certain times the subsidence can occur concurrently with the mining operations. Such occurrences
can be seen in activities adopting longwall mining or high extraction pillar recovery methods.
Sinkhole subsidence during mining operations can occur in the areas above where the working
6
Introduction
is relatively close the ground surface. This is a fairly localised phenomena and its magnitude is
usually observed by abrupt depression at the ground surface. This is one of the most common
type of subsidence.
Surface subsidence can cause extensive damage/degradation affects. In the unmined areas of
abandoned mines coal pillar of various shapes and sizes are left out. In such a case no one can
predict when subsidence in that area will can occur. Natural surface drainage pattern,
groundwater regime and utilizable land are affected. This can also cause minor / major /
extensive damage to highways, buildings, water supply lines oil/gas pipelines, cable lines
depending on the affected surface area its land use type and magnitude of ground movement
and location of the surface facilities with reference to the center of subsidence trough when the
remaining pillars support downward sag of the over burden or by punching of the pillars into a
soft mine floor or roof. Such a trough subsidence is generally at the center and horizontal ground
movements will usually occur at that time. Structures at the center will bear the brunt of the
subsidence effect whole at the edges they experience the effect caused by the tension or stretching
of the surface. Ground movement will result in a variety of damage to the buildings, roads,
railways, bridges water and oil lines, flow of streams and other utilities. Usually surface cracks
occur at the edges of the trough. Different mining operations in the production of minerals
produce / release a variety of pollutants into environment. Table 1.6 lists typical emissions,
effluents and solid wastes from selected mining activities. A flow diagram showing the sequence
of operation of mining for coal through surface/underground mining is shown in Fig 1.1.
Introduction
Borate
Methane
Carbon dioxide
Carbon monoxide
Sulphur dioxides
Coal dust
Radon gas
Acid Waste alkaline
Sulfuric acid
Trace metals
Waste Rock
Inert silica
Lubricating
Oils
Nitrates /
Ammonium salts
Washery
Rejects
Airborne particulates
Calcination
Particulates
Residual particulates
Calciner offgases
Particulate emissions
from dryers
Crushing ore
particulates
Ore insolubles
Filter aid and carbon
absorbent
Scrubber water
Spent carbon and
Filter wastes
Suspended particulate
mater
Spentbrine
Sulfur dioxide
Particulates
Lead oxides
Iron pyrites
Iron-limestone
sicicate slag
Arsenic
Acid plant blowdown
WWTP effluents
Slag granulation water
Spent furnace brick
Slurried APC dust
Baghouse incineraor ash
Ferrosilicon
Tower blowdown
Geothite
Spent cloths, bags, filters
Synthetic gypsum
Surface impoundment
solids
Trace / heavy metals
Zinc-rich slag
Iron
Sulfur dioxide
Mine water
Spent leaching solution
Sulfuric acid
Waste rock
Spent ore
Filter cake
Gangue
Slag
WWTP sludge
Spent furnace dust
cyanide wastes
Carbon dioxide
Sulfur compounds
Chlorides
Fluorides
Waste rock
Tailings/silicate rock
Copper
APC dust/sludge
Waste contact cooling
water
WWTP liquid effluent
Process wastewaters
Surface impoundment
Waste liquids
Slime/muds
Crud/gunk
Tankhouse/anode slimes
Acid plant blowdown
Waste rock
Tailings
Raffinate or barren
leachate
Spent bleed electrolyte
Discarded furnace and
converer brick
Chamber solids and
scrubber sludge
WWTP sludge
Phosphate
Crushed Rock
Rock dust
Phosphorus
pentoxide
Carbon monoxide
Precipitator slurry
Phossy water
Furnace scrubber
blowdown
Furnace building
washdown
WWTP liquid
Anderson filter media
Slag
Furnace offgas solids
Wet process waste
Streams
Fluorides
Taulings /
Phosphogypsum
Solid waste
Zinc-keab slag
pH
4.5 - 10
0.5 - 6.0
0.5 - 6.0
3.0 - 8.5
4.0 - 9.5
5.0 - 9.2
1.9 - 7.0
2.8 - 6.8
2.0 - 5.0
5.0 - 9.0
Temp., o C
10-37
15-25
10-37
8-37
10-37
25-35
25-35
25-35
55-85
10-45
Aerobic
+
+
+
+
+/_
+
+
+
+
-
Nutrition
autotrophic
heterotrophic
A Category
B Category
= 50 ha of mining
<50 ha = 5 ha of
lease area in respect
mining lease area
of non-coal mine lease in respect of non-coal
mine lease
>150 ha of mining
lease area in respect
of coal mine lease
= 150 ha = 5 ha of
mining lease area
in respect of coal
mine lease
Asbestos mining
irrespective of mining
area
10
General Condition
Introduction
Project
Activity
A Category
B Category
General Condition
Mahabaleswar Panchangi, Matheran,
Pachmarhi, Dahanu, Doon Valley and
(iv) inter-state boundaries and
international boundaries
Provided that the requirement
regarding distance of 10km of the
inter-state boundaries can be reduced
or completely done away with by an
agreement between the respective
states or U.Ts sharing the common
boundary in the case the activity does
not fall within 10 kilometers of the
areas mentioned at item (i), (ii) and (iii)
above The environmental clearance
process for all projects will comprise a
maximum of four stages. These four
stages in sequential order are:
11
12
Introduction
13
Introduction
The projects involving clearance under Coastal Regulation Zone Notification, 1991 shall
submit with the application a CRZ map duly demarcated by one of the authorized
agencies, showing the project activities, w.r.t. C.R.Z (at the stage of TOR) and the
recommendations of the State Coastal Zone Management Authority (at the stage of EC).
Simultaneous action shall also be take to obtain the requisite clearance under the
provisions of the CRZ notification, 1991 for the activities to be located in the CRZ#
The projects to be located within 10km of the National Parks, Sanctuaries, Biosphere
Reserves, Migratory corridors of wild animals, the project proponent shall submit the
map duly authenticated by Chief Wildlife Warden showing these features vis--vis the
project location and the recommendations or comments of the Chief Wildlife Warden
thereon (at the stage of EC) #
For the projects located in critically polluted areas as notified by CPCB, the project
proponent shall make available a copy of their application for the TOR to the concerned
SPCB. The SPCB should either send its representative at the time of consideration of the
proposal by the EAC, at the stage of appraisal of the project for prescribing TOR or
consideration of EC or provide their written comments with respect to pollution load in
terms of ambient air quality, water quality or solid/hazardous waste management ##
15
on application by the transferor or the transferee with a written no objection by the transferor,
to, and by the regulatory authority concerned, on the same terms and conditions under which
the prior environmental clearance was initially granted, and for the same validity period.
Introduction
Project Description
Additional Studies
Project Benefits
Status of Environmental Clearance and compliance for the terms & conditions for the existing
project
16
Introduction
Validity of the Air & Water Consent orders, and Hazardous Waste Authorization (HWA)
from SPCB/ PCC for existing project and their compliance status
Notices/directions issued by the regulatory agencies under section 33(A) of the Water Act,
1974 as amended, under section 31(A) of the Air Act 1981 as amended and any directions
issued under the provisions of the E (P) Act, 1986 during the last one year.
17
2
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
2.0 General
The background of the project gives broad description of the project, project proponent their
detailed address, type of ore deposit(s), locations etc. The downstream use of mineral for value
addition and its importance should also be described. The purpose for which mining is proposed
should be clearly stated (captive use, export, selling etc.). The mineral(s) occurring in the area,
which the proponent intends to mine and the period for which the mine lease is granted, present
or proposed to be applied. Description of linkages, market status (demand, supply) export
potential of finished product, domestic demand of the finished products is to be given. A
description on national and state scenarios and prospect of the mineral should be given.
The background should cover the following:
Location of the project (longitude, latitude, MSL, revenue village, Tehsil, District, State,
nearest railway station, and airport)
Objective of the project (captive mine, standalone etc) whether it is new or expansion (increase
in ML area or Increase in annual production) or modernization. Proposed use of minerals
(sale, use as intermediates or raw materials). Any change in technology proposed
should be specified.
Significance and relevance of the project highlighting the benefit to surrounding area and
economic development of the area local/state/ country.
Deposit conditions such as ore strength, host rock strength, shape, grade, size, uniformity
and depth associated hazards, recoverable resources and recoverable reserves
2.3 Geology
Regional Geology
Regional geology with type of ore formation in the basin should be described. The classification
of lithiology with the extent and type of geological formations in the region should be discussed.
If there are any major faults / seismic zones should be specifically marked.
Local Geology
The local stratigraphic sequence of the mining lease area should be interpreted from geological
mapping, exploration and / or any opened up quarry / mine. The lithiological sequence of the
leasehold area may be interpreted either from existing quarry or trial pits and should be given
for different geological strata. Mineral deposits should be shown in the map. Geological plan
and cross sections layers should be shown in a separate drawing. (1: 50m scale). This is a part of
Mine Plan and brief summary may be given.
Deposit conditions (min., max. average thickness in meters). If there are multiple deposits
to be worked similar details should be given for each of them.
20
Project Description
Mining Plan (height and width of the benches in overburden, ore body, proposed inclination/
side slopes),
Surface plan showing mine working with dumps and other features for 5th year, 10th year,
15th year, 20th year, 25th year, 30th year as per the approved mine plan.
Detail of machineries ( excavators, material handling and processing equipment, inpit crusher and conveyor system if used)
Underground Mining
The mode of mine main entry such as shaft, adit, incline or any other method should be mentioned.
The method of stoping or extraction of ore with machineries to be used should be described. The
effect of subsidence due to ground control on the surface features such as natural drainage pattern,
usable land, houses, water bodies, and infrastructure facilities should be explained.
Deposit conditions
Ventilation system for adequate control of quality and quantity of air underground
21
Separate EIA guidance manual for mineral beneficiation may be referred and the environmental
issues may be taken up combinely, if the beneficiation is carried out in the pithead.
Coastal Zone: If the project is located in coastal area, details of coastal zone classification, Low
Tide Line (LTL), High Tide Line (HTL), characterization of beaches should be described.
Township
The area earmarked for developing / expansion of the township is very important. The number
of houses, sources of water with quantities may be mentioned. The distance from mine and
nearest water bodies should be indicated. A layout map of township with the proposed landuse,
showing built up ores, water supply and sewage disposal points should be presented.
Power, Water Supply and other Infrastructure requirement
The details of total power requirement during development and operational changes with source
should be provided. The source of water supply, type of treatment and break-up for different use
should be given. Other infrastructure such as grid, DG set, workshop etc. should also be mentioned.
Water demand for the project should be presented as in (Table-2.7). Water balance covering water
abstraction, consumption and discharge should also be shown in figure with flowchart.
3
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES (Technology & Site)
3.0 General
Consideration of alternatives to a project proposal is a requirement of EIA process. During the
scoping process, alternatives to a proposal can be considered or refined, either directly or by
reference to the key issues identified. A comparison of alternatives help to determine the best
method of achieving the project objectives with minimum environmental impacts or indicates
the most environmentally friendly and cost effective options.
The consideration of alternatives is most useful when the EIA is undertaken early in the projects
cycle. The type and range of alternatives open for consideration include:
Demand alternatives (e.g. using energy more efficiently rather than building more alternative
generating capacity)
Activity alternatives (e.g. providing public transport rather than increasing road capacity)
Location alternatives (e.g. location of field crusher /beneficiation plant/ tailings dam)
Process alternatives (e.g. use of waste minimizing and energy efficient and efficient process
technologies, use of less toxic chemicals)
Mineral deposits are site specific, and therefore, selection of a mine site has limited alternatives.
However, the activities relating to mine development and exploitation have many alternatives in
terms of choice of mining method, drilling and blasting methodologies, location of waste dumps
etc. Alternatives available in mining activities should be analysed on the basis of:
After analysis of the various factors the most environmentally compatible alternative must be
selected. Reference may be made to available technologies, policy objectives, social attitudes,
environmental and site constraints, projects economic etc. Analysis of alternatives should be
similar to the content of approved mine plan.
4
DESCRIPTION OF ENVIRONMENT
4.0 General
The occurrence of mineral deposits, being site specific, their exploitation, often, does not allow
for any choice except adoption of eco-friendly operation. The methods are required to be selected
in such a manner, so as to maintain environmental equilibrium ensuring sustainable development.
Mining activities invariably affect the existing environmental status of the site. It has both adverse
and beneficial effects. In order to maintain the environmental commensuration with the mining
operation, it is essential to undertake studies on the existing environmental scenario and assess
the impact on different environmental components. This would help in formulating suitable
management plans sustainable resource extraction.
Study Area:
The study area for the mining projects should be defined as follows:
10 km. radius from the boundary limits of the mine lease area of more than 50 hectares
should be the buffer zone.
5km radius from the boundary limits of mine lease area of 5-50 hectares would be buffer
zone.
Maps (appropriate scale) of the study area (core and buffer zones), clearly delineating the
locations of various monitoring stations (air/water/noise/soil), superimposed on locations
of habitats are to be shown.
Indicate 2 km, 5 km distance from the boundary limits of mine lease by appropriate line.
Baseline information is required to be collected by field surveys, monitoring etc. Secondary data
with source should be clearly mentioned. Normally, one season monitoring data (excluding
monsoon) are to be collected. However, Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) may specify collection
of baseline data for a longer period considering the nature, size and location of the project.
Environmental data to be collected in relation to proposed mining would be: (a) land (b) water
(c) air (d) biological (e) noise (f) socio-economic (g) health etc.
Topography of the study area shown in the topographical map should be analyzed to describe
the terrain viz. hill slopes, coastal and inland topography. The physiographical features of the
study area should be explained by using latest satellite imagery. The source and date of the
imagery should be shown in the map. The toposheet should also be used for interpretation of
physiographical features. If the mine is located on hill range, the same may be mentioned. The
slope and local features should be described.
The drainage pattern in the study area can be explained on the basis of topographic features
shown in maps and satellite imagery. Major nallahs, rivulets, rivers in the study area with their
features should to be discussed. The water reservoirs, water flow pattern of water bodies should
also be covered. Perennial streams, if any should be identified and specially mentioned. Drainage
pattern with elevation range should be shown in satellite imagery map. In all the maps the mining
lease area should be distinctly marked. The maps should be prepared in 1:5,000 scale, and clearly
show the sub-water sheds of the proposed mining area of 2 km. radius.
Geology of the area is very important to ascertain seismic sensitivity. The various strata of
geological formation should be described. From this, the soil permeability, possible faults and
fissures should be found out and explained. Soil quality of the study area is one of the important
components of the environment. Soil samples from villages located in the study area should be
collected as per methodology specified in BIS to make them representative and analyzed for
physico- chemical analysis. Samples are collected by hand auger boring and soil pits. Some
samples from agricultural fields (if any) should also be collected. The locations of sampling points
may be presented as in (Table-4.1) and also to be shown in the map of study area. The physical
properties of soil should be presented in (Table-4.2). The chemical properties of soil should be
presented in (Table-4.3). The agricultural crops being grown in the study area should be discussed.
Data may be collected for district statistical handbook for the study area or local agricultural
department and also ground truthing by field survey.
Description of Environment
Groundwater recharge calculation of the study area is one of the most important inputs to baseline
condition. The rainfall infiltration method is one of the best methods suggested in groundwater
assessment methodology by CGWB. The details of method and calculation should be given in
the report. The stages of ground water development are categorized as given in Annexure 4
(Ground Water Estimation Committee report (GC 1997)). The sampling locations and the physicchemical properties are to be presented as shown in Table 4.4 and 4.5.
Surface Water
Sources of surface water in the study area are required to be identified. The sub-water sheds,
where mine lease once is located and comprised of contributing and receiving streams should be
studied for hydrological regime. Physical characteristics of the sub-water shed should be analysed
from the map and presented.
The river flow measurement should also be taken for the streams flowing adjacent to the mine
lease area. Historical data on river flow can also be obtained from Water Resource Dept., Public
Health Dept., Central Water Commission etc.
Water samples from available surface water and groundwater from both core as well as buffer
zone should be collected, representing the study area. Water sampling points are to be selected
from all directions of mine lease area. Grab samples from water survey should be collected. The
description of surface water sampling locations may be given as shown in Table-4.6 and physicchemical properties are to be presented as shown in Table 4.7.
The locations of water sampling stations should also be shown on the map of study area. Samples
of surface water upstream and downstream of the mine lease area must be collected. The
parameters, sampling, frequency and method of analysis is given in Annexure 3.
Interpretation of surface and groundwater quality results for both core and buffer zone should
be done separately by comparing with drinking water specification IS: 10500 and Central Pollution
Control Board Water Quality Criteria for surface water are given in Annexure-6.
27
The monitoring schedule of ambient air quality should be clearly described. The frequency and
methodology followed should be as per the guidelines. Ambient air quality should not be
monitored during rainy season. All the ambient air quality monitoring stations, selected on the
basis of wind direction should be done simultaneously. The wind direction meteorological
conditions are to be considered and correlated during the monitoring. The ambient air quality
monitoring results for all the stations should be presented in (Table-4.9). It may be seen that the
format contains monitoring stations, category (Industrial, Residential & Sensitive), standards
(Annexure 7) and results. The table, therefore, should be useful for data interpretation.
Description of Environment
Distribution
Abundance
Rarity
Species diversity and critical habitat requirements
Migratory and travel routes
Predator prey balance
Habitat residence
The list of wildlife and avifauna found in the study area should be presented in format (Table4.15) and discussed.
29
Holding size distribution of households in the study area should be given in format (Table-4.18).
From the table, necessary interpretation on agricultural status in the study area should be made.
Employment and Income
This is an analysis of occupational structure of the study area. The occupational pattern should
be presented in format (Table-4.19). Data in the table should be analyzed and interpreted.
Description on the findings from these interpretations should be given in the report.
Study Required
Nearness to forest
Nearness to township
30
5
ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT AND
MITIGATION MEASURES
5.0 General
Identification of all potential environmental impacts due to project is an essential step of
Environmental impact Assessment. These are critically examined and major impacts (both
beneficial & adverse) are further studied. The construction, commissioning and expansion of
any type of developmental projects have significant influence on the existing physical, biological
and social components of environment. In case of mining projects, impacts on biodiversity, air
pollution, water pollution, waste management and social issues are significant. The nature and
characteristics of impacts are required to be taken into consideration while evaluating the
magnitude of impacts. Various parameters considered for evaluation of impact are complied in
Annexure 9.
In case of mining projects, the site has little relevance since it is mainly guided by mineral deposits.
Mining activities underground and open cast have different types of impacts with respect to
both magnitude and significance. During the working life of mine, air, water, noise and land use
are likely to be affected due to mining of minerals and associated activities.
Open cast mines, which are more, preferred now for rapid increase is mineral production and
safety reasons, the significant impacts are on land use, drainage, air quality, ecology, noise etc.
Allied operations such as transport of materials, operation of workshop, drilling, blasting etc.
affect the air, water and noise environment. Clearance of natural vegetation adversely affects the
flora and fauna of the areas due to changed environment.
Positive impacts on socio-economic
environment are expected due to creation of
employment opportunities and development of
infrastructure such as roads, schools, hospitals
etc.
Mining activities are normally carried out over
a long period (about 30 yrs or more. This also
encourages downstream industrial development
in the area which adds to environmental
degradation. The identified significant impacts
require detailed analysis for decision- making
and formulating adequate mitigation measures.
The various anticipated impacts and mitigation
measures are discussed in this chapter.
Compensation and rehabilitation of affected / displaced people would reduce the distress
caused by the loss of land and land-based livelihood.
Segregation of wastes based on the environmental risk potential. High-risk potential wastes
should be treated and disposed off in environmentally sound manner.
During the planning stage identification of waste storage yard and topsoil should be done
based on slope and runoff characteristics.
In-pit dumping of mine waste should be promoted wherever possible rather than external
dumping. In case of external dumping, it should be stabilized by suitable plantations.
32
Runoff from the mine and waste dumps should be regulated by constructing check dams
and garland drains.
Mine drainage should be suitably treated to meet the prescribed standard and discharged
in to water bodies and land.
Natural drains or nallahs should not be disturbed as far as possible. In case of diversion;
alignments with natural drainage should be made by constructing artificial drains.
Run-off from mine overburden dump, ore stockpiles etc. should be prevented to avoid
being discharged to surroundings, particularly to agricultural land.
Productive land should not be utilized for waste / ore dumping/ for construction of
structures.
Topsoils should be kept in a designated area and should be given minimum storage time to
prevent nutrient loss.
Mine drainage is to be treated adequately before discharge to stream outside the boundary
of the project area
33
surface water regime are site specific and depends upon the characteristics of the mineral,
hydrogeology and requirement of groundwater for other uses.
The anticipated impact of mining on water resources and their significance is compiled in
Annexure 11.
Following suitable method of estimation, an assessment of impact on ground and surface water
resources should be made. The detail method and calculation should be given in the report.
The impact on hydrogeology of the area can be:
Groundwater inflow into the mine, with subsequent contact with mining related pollutants
Increase in surface and ground water interaction with the mine working because of
subsidence
Loss of surface features such as lakes, streams and ponds through subsidence
Pathways for post closure flow resulting from adits, shafts and overall mine design
Specifically, mine water, groundwater withdrawal and land subsidence can potentially create
environmental problems that cannot be easily corrected. The ground water recharge calculation
including groundwater budgeting should be done following standard methods.
The wastewater quality discharged to water bodies should meet the standard prescribed under
Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 by MoEF, which is given in Annexure 12. There is no separate
standard for mining. Therefore, wastewater discharge standard is applicable. Any other mine
specific standards as per notification of MoEF from time to time are applicable. Recently, the
Central Pollution Control Board has come out with effluent standards for iron ore & coal mines.
These include standards for wastewater discharged from iron ore mining, beneficiation and
associated activities or any other discharges, leaving the mining lease boundary, to natural river,
stream or water bodies. No mine/mineral specific
standards for wastewater are presently available. The
standard for Iron Ore Mine is given in Annexure 13.
Mitigation Measures
The following mitigation measures are suggested for
water management and water pollution control.
However, priority relevance depends on the location
and type of mining and minerals.
Retention Wall
drainage conditions should be maintained to the extent possible so that run off distribution
is not affected.
Garland drains should be constructed on all side of quarries and external dumps. All the
garland drains should be routed through adequately sized catchpits or settling pits to remove
suspended solids from flowing into storm water. The design of catchpits should be calculated
on the basis of silt loading, slope, detention time required.
Retaining walls with weep holes should be built all round the external dumps. The storm
water should pass through weep holes to the garland drains.
The surplus treated mine water should be discharged into local ponds and agricultural
fields which should act like a constant source of recharge to improve the groundwater level
in the area.
Settling Tanks to Treat Mine Water should be stored / dumped / stocked preferably on a
flat area, to reduce the risk of erosion.
Shallow and deeper piezometers should be constructed close to mine area for monitoring
the water levels in the aquifer. The locations of piezometers should be selected in consultation
with Central Ground Water Board (CGW).
Stone barriers across the drain should be constructed to check the water current and arrest
solids.
Stone pitching should be made at suitable location to regulate water flow and prevent soil
erosion.
The vehicles workshop wastewater should be suitably treated for suspended solids and oil
and grease.
Effluents from the canteen, rest areas, township etc. should be adequately treated before
discharge to outside.
A water audit with a water balance diagram should be provided to gtive information on
water use for all aspects of plant operation.
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
35
Water management plan also should be shown in mining plan for 5th, 10th, 15th, 20th, 25th and
30th year till closure of the mine.
Unpaved Surfaces
Dust emissions from unpaved surfaces are caused than from paved surfaces are usually much
greater. Dust emissions can be controlled by using the following methods:
Water sprinkling on unpaved areas during dry wind periods, using a water tanker/or fixed
sprinklers.
Wet suppression of unpaved areas can achieve dust emission reductions of about 70 per
cent or more, and this can sometimes be increased by up to 95% through the use of chemical
stabilisation.
37
Vehicle:
Vehicles travelling over paved or unpaved surfaces tend to crush surface particles and other
debris. Particles are lifted and dropped from the rolling wheels, and the road surface is exposed
to strong air currents due to turbulent shear between the wheels and the surface. Dust particles
are also sucked into the turbulent wave created behind the moving vehicles. The loads carried
by trucks are also potential source of dust, either through wind entrainment or spillages. Mud
and dust carry out from unpaved surfaces is another potential problem. Dust emissions due to
vehicles can be minimized by:
Speed controls on vehicles have an approximately linear effect on dust emissions. In other
words, a speed reduction from 30 km/hr to 15 km/hr will achieve about 50 per cent reduction
in dust emissions.
Material stockpiles
Top soil or overburden is susceptible to wind erosion speeds more than 5 m/sec. Dust emissions
can also occur as material is dropped on the stockpile from a conveyor or during loading or
unload by track / shovel / fornt-end loading by track / shovel / front-end loaded. There are a
number of methods by which dust can be reduced from the stockpiles which are as follows:
Limiting the height and slope of the stockpiles can also reduce wind speed. For example, a flat
shallow stockpile will be subject to less wind turbulence than one with a tall conical shape.
However while designing the stockpile due consideration should be given to the effect of other
site features such as most prominent wind direction. Some of the measures to reduce the dust
impact from the material stockpile are as follows.
38
Use of wind breaks (wind speed) near the pile is the primary factor affecting particle
uptake from stockpiles. Although a large, solid wind break is the most effective
configuration, the windbreaks can also be constructed by rapid vegetation.
Conveyors
Dust emissions from open conveyors can be
caused by wind and during loading, discharge
point, and at transfer points. The following
options should be considered for minimizing
these emissions:
Regular clean up of spillages around the transfer points so that material cannot be picked
up by wind.
5.4 Noise
Anticipated Impact
Noise
Noise level increase due to mining activities such as excavation, drilling, blasting, handling and
transportation of ore and overburden and operation of processing equipment. Impact on noise
level on the nearby village may be predicted by using computerised noise prediction model and
the results may be presented in format. The prediction of impact can be evaluated and discussed
in Table 5.2.
The blasting cause ground vibration. The empirical equation used for assessment of peak particle
velocity (PPV) is:
V= 417.8 {D/(Q0.5)}-1.265
39
Where
V= Peak particle velocity in mm/s
D= Distance between location of blast and gauge point.
Q=Quantity of explosive per blasting
Any other formula for calculating blasting vibration in Indian condition may also be followed.
However, detail reference is to be given.
The calculated vibration values should be presented in format (Table-5.3). The results are to be
compared with the limiting values prescribed by Director General of Mine Safety (DGMS)
(Annexure 18).
Mitigation Measures
The following mitigation measures can be adopted to control noise and vibrate
Engineering noise controls by noise reduction at the source and by interruption of the /
noise path from the source to the receiver.
Combination of one or all of the above control measures which can be technologically
achievable
Engineering noise controls however offer the most effective permanent solution which prevents
occupational heaving loss A few of the noise control measures that may be adopted are:
Selection of new low-noise equipment from the manufactures failing which use of additional
retrofits if available.
Use of noise barriers and total enclosures to block, redirect or reduce the flow of sound
energy from all equipments including DG set and compressor before it reaches the receiver.
When noise reduction at the source and in the transmission path fail to control excessive
noise to the receive, it becomes necessary to develop administrative controls by
40
i)
Altering the work schedule, moving the personnel further from the noise source
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
When all controls fail to reduce the level of noise entering the ear, by use of personal
hearing protection devices
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
Noise and ground vibration from blasting may be mitigated by the following measures:-
i)
By carefully designing a blast hole drilling pattern or blast geometry with appropriate
burden distance, spacing as holes, hole size, hole depth, and stemming height, and
powder factor. Established rules of thumb and experience in similar deposits in other
mines may used.
ii)
Adopting shock tube (non-electrical) initiation system in blasting which allows short
delay blasting using short delay detonators allowing in-hole as well as surface delay
and bottom initiation of blasted rock, and results reduction of fly rock, reductions in
noise and ground vibration levels to with in permissible limits.
A blasting siren and warning notice boards should be used for public warning as safety
measures.
5.6 Socio-economics
Anticipated Impact
The socio-economic impacts of mining are many. The adverse impacts attribute to physical
displacement due to land acquisition, which is followed by loss of livelihood, mental agony,
changes in social structure, and risk to food security etc. People are also directly affected due to
pollution. Social Impact Assessment (SIA) is a process of analysis, monitoring and managing the
social consequences of a project. Social Impact Assessment itself is an exhaustive study and may
be taken up in case of mega project as decided by Expert Appraisal Committee. The major social
impacts associated with mining are compiled in Annexure 20.
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
41
Mitigation Measures
Following mitigation measures are suggested:
A welfare plan with funding from the project proponent should be prepared to provide
assistance to affected people.
The infrastructure facility (Educational Institute, Water Supply, Health Care etc.) developed
by the project should also be extended to people without any cost or minimal cost.
a.
Monetary compensation
b.
Resettlement Plan
c.
Compensation in kind
d.
Training to locals to develop skill should be promoted by the project. All the above should
be exhaustively dealt in the report.
The individual dump should have maximum slope of 37o and an overall slope not exceed
28o.
The external dump should have stretches of retaining wall at suitable locations.
The wall should be constructed with suitable height and top surface. The wall will have
weep holes to drain out water to the garland drain.
The back-filled areas should be levelled to match with adjoining ground level.
The completed dumps and the back-filled areas should be afforested in a planned way to
increase their stability.
Over burden in most cases are not contaminated. However, composition of the leachebility
of heavy metals of over burden and low grade ore dumpsites are very important.
Excavation of new pit should begin only after an existing pit is exhausted. This should
ensure that the over burden and inter burden generated is use for back filling instead of
being dumped elsewhere.
Overburden Dumps
The solid waste from the township should be subjected to aerobic composting or vermi
composting to produce organic manure and the residues should be disposed off in landfill.
The over burden disposal underground mines should be explored for putting it inside the
void. The method of stowing should be worked out.
The mine waste management should be as per the approved mine plan.
43
To create a productive and sustainable after-use for the site, acceptable to mine owners,
regulatory agencies, and the public.
there is no adverse effect of pollutant concentrations exceeding the statutory limits for the water,
soil and air qualities in the area around the closed mine.
Biological Stability
The stability of the surrounding environment is primarily dependent upon the physical and
chemical characteristics of the site, whereas the biological stability of the mine site itself is closely
related to rehabilitation and final land use. Nevertheless, biological stability can significantly
influence physical or chemical stability by stabilizing soil cover, prevention of erosion/wash off,
leaching, etc.
A vegetation cover over the disturbed site is usually one of the main objectives of the rehabilitation
programme, as vegetation cover is the best long-term method of stabilizing the site. When the
major earthwork components of the rehabilitation programme have been completed, the process
of establishing a stable vegetation community begins.
For re-vegetation, management of soil nutrient levels is an important consideration. Additions
of nutrients are useful under three situations.
Where the nutrient level of spread topsoil is lower than material in-situ e.g. for development
of social forestry.
Where it is intended to grow plants with a higher nutrient requirement than those occurring
naturally e.g. planning for agriculture.
Where it is desirable to get a quick growth response from the native flora during those
times when moisture is not a limiting factor e.g. development of green barriers.
The mine closure plan should be as per the approved mine plan.
Stage wise mine closure plan with budget available financial / manpower should be prepared
and implemented. Such plan with the approval of the competent regulatory authority should be
made available to the MoEF and / or concerned State authority giving the environmental
clearance.
45
6
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAMME
6.0 General
This chapter should include details of mitigation measures to be followed. It should also include
the technical aspects of monitoring the effectiveness of mitigation measures (including
measurement methodologies, data analysis, reporting schedules, emergency procedures, detailed
budget & procurement schedules). Guidance for assessment relevance and reliability of analytical
methods and framework used for impact prediction - risk assessment is given in Annexure 22.
It should also include
Compilation and analysis of data, comparison with baseline data and compliance to accepted
norms and reporting system
It shall also cover different statutory returns/ compliance reports to be submitted such as:
Submission of half yearly compliance report in respect of the stipulated prior environmental
clearance terms and conditions in hard and soft copies to the regulatory authority concerned,
on 1st June and 1st December of each calendar year
Submission of environmental statement for the financial year ending 31st March to the
concerned state pollution control board on or before 30th September every year
Format for maintaining records of hazardous waste in Form 3 as per Hazardous Waste
(Management, Handling and Transboundary movement) Rules, 2008
6.1 Activities
Slope Failure
Regular inspection (frequency and mechanism to be established) should be carried out to examine
slope stability, mine faces, overburden benches, ore and waste stockpiles etc. Possible slope
failures by modern slope stability technologies should be monitored. Observations should
also be made by regular checking for land erosion possibility in hill slopes / backfill area and
underground mine voids.
Drainage
The effectiveness of drainage system depends upon proper cleaning of all drains and sumps.
Regular checking should be carried out to find any blockage due to silting or accumulation of
loose materials. The drains should also be checked for any damage in lining / stone pitching
etc.
Blasting Effects
Regular testing and inspection of blasting operations in work zone should be carried out with
respect to noise, fly rock throw, vibration, dust and fume generation. These tests should be
conducted regularly and whenever new patterns of blastings are adopted for rock
fragmentation.
Revegetation and Green Belt Development
Greenbelt development as per the scheduled plan should be reviewed every year. Post plantation
status should also be regularly checked every season. Following plantation related data /
information should be kept and compiled every year.
(a)
(b)
Period of plantation
(c)
Type of plantation
(i)
Tree species
(ii)
Grass
(e)
(f)
(g)
Interval of watering
(h)
(i)
Survival rate
(j)
Pre-mining condition
(ii)
Post-mining conditions
48
Monitoring of quality of water, air, noise, vibration and occupational health status of
project personnel and surrounding habitations.
Hydro-geological monitoring for the entire mine life and restrictive monitoring
during reclamation.
Evaluation and analysis of data, its interpretation (any additional studies to be carried out
if required
A plan for monitoring health of workers and community in vicinity should be drawn
and submitted along with financial allocation.
budgeting
and financial
49
7
ADDITIONAL STUDIES
7.0 General
TOR to be adopted for mining of minerals as commonly applicable is prepared and attached to
this manual as Annexure 1. It may however, be necessary to consider specific issues as applicable
to individual projects. The EIA report and EMP should therefore address such issues also.
To prevent or reduce the incidence and severity of injury during mining operations
Drilling Risks
Drilling is common to the mining of hard rocks / ores. The main hazards associated with are:
The highest risk will occur during the drilling of the first line of holes parallel with the working
edge of the bench. Measures that can be taken to reduce the risk of falling off the edge of the
bench is to provide suitable portable rail fencing which can be erected between the drill and the
edge of the bench and direction by the supervisor fro guidance of the driller.
Face Stability and Loading
Face instability gives rise to rock falls or slides and this can arise because of adverse geological
conditioning or poor work practices. The main hazard associated with excavation / loading is
rock falling on to the driver and falls while gaining access to operating cabins.
Failure of Slope in the Pit
In order to allay dangers due to open cast slope failure, final pit, slope stability estimations have
to be made for the existing mines after determining various physical parameters of the
ground mass like uniaxial compressive strength, triaxial compressive strength, cohesion,
angle of friction, specific gravity of the rock, water pressure etc. Besides, all the structural
discontinuities have been plotted in wedge failure. Even then, factor of safety should be determined
against overall slope failure as well as against individual bench slope by circular failure, planer
failure, and wedge failure. Besides determining factor of safety, the slopes should be monitored
at regular intervals by using real time slope stability radar system, to monitor for any possible
failure. The well-developed drainage system over the lease area should ensure that storm
water does not accumulate in the lease area and therefore hydrostatic pressure remains at a
low level.
Fly Rock and Vibrations Due to Blasting
Trial blasting results of a nearby mine (with similar geo-mining characteristics) may be used to
arrive at the field empirical equations based on which the charge per delay can be regulated to
protect the nearby structures. All precautions related to control of fly rock should be taken during
the blasting operations. Safety zone of 300 m as per statutes should be maintained.
Spillage of High Speed Diesel (HSD) and resultant fire constitutes a potential risk. The quantity
of the maximum oil, which can spill, is not much and can be easily controlled. Sufficient number
of portable fire extinguishers should be provided at strategic locations to take care of any
eventuality. Dry and foam type portable fire extinguishers should be provided at the electrical
substation and control room.
52
Additional Studies
Drilling risks
Scope failure
Storage of explosives
Subsidence
Risk analysis involves systematic identification and assessment of major damage potential credible
risk scenerios to help management to make objective decisions on hazard reduction or avoidance
measures meeting regulatory requirements and develop a structured management framework
for an effective Disaster Management Plan (DMP) including emergency preparedness and
contingency plans.
Advantages of risk analysis include:
Systematic identification of credible risk scenerios, frequency of their failure modes and
fatality consequences.
Estimation of each event frequency by using, relevant historical data, accident statistics
fault tree or event tree analysis techniques. These techniques may be used individually
or jointly.
Technological hazards:
These include disastrous events or hazards occasioned by manor mans impact on the environment
and technical causes.
They may be divided into
1.
Noise hazard from intense noise sources on operating equipment like drilling, excavation /
loading, transportation and processing equipment auxiliary and supporting facilities.
Blasting noise is of very short duration achieving a peak level of 140 dB.
53
2.
Blasting of produces
Ground vibrations
Excessive toxic fumes which may typically include CO, NO, NO2 and NH3 and organics
Fly rock injuries and fatalities in surface mining due to inadequate blast area security
3.
Occupational injuries and fatalities in drilling and rock bolting in underground metal /
non-metal mines
4.
5.
Instability of spoil dumps, tailings, dams, bench/pit and slopes in surface mines which
may cause injuries and fatalities
6.
Flammable and toxic gas emissions as continuous emissions and blowers and gas outbursts
in mines
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Injuries and fatalities during storage and transport of bulk materials to areas by road or rail;
structural failures
14.
Contamination of groundwater quality with water on mine site raw mine drainage, leach
ate from old mine dumps, stockpiles and seepage from setting pond and tailings dams
15.
16.
17.
Injuries and fatalities due to impact and collisions of heavy vehicles due to mechanical and
human failures, pit wall and land slides
54
Additional Studies
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Disaster management plan for safe mining particularly for underground mines where
toxic fumes and other risks are involved.
8.
9.
Any other stipulations made by regulatory agencies for handling emergency situations
that may arise either from natural or manmade
The Indian MIINES RESCUE RULES 1985 under Coal Mines Regulation1975 which may be
referred to prescribe organization for conducting rescue operations at underground mines ensuring
safety of life, property and environment and safe rehabilitation of the affected area.
55
8
PROJECT BENEFITS
8.0 General
This chapter should include benefits accruing to the locality, neighbourhood, region and nation
as a whole. It should bring out details of benefits by way of:
9
ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN
9.0 General
The environmental management must be integrated into the process of mine planning so that
ecological balance of the area is maintained and adverse effects are minimized. Environmental
Management Plan (EMP) requires multidisciplinary approach. EMP can further be modified /
upgraded time to time by taking advice from experts in the respective fields (forests, soil chemistry,
ground water etc.), as the mining of minerals progresses. The changes warranted as per site
specific conditions are to be accounted for during actual implementation.
EMP covers all phases of the project considering the impacts with mitigation measures and
monitoring programme. The plan outlines the measures that will be undertaken to ensure
compliance with environmental legislations and to minimize adverse impact.
EMP should essentially include monitoring programs and management control strategies for
minimizing the adverse impacts:
Subsidence
Air Pollution
Water Pollution
9.1 Subsidence
The damages and consequential effects of subsidence can be alleviated or countered by
undertaking precautionary measures on surface for protecting installation(s) in subsidence prone
areas or by adopting appropriate modifications of the mining method adopted to minimize
deformation of the surface and by filling the abandoned mine/non-working mines where possible
by slowing in a carefully planned manner.
a.
b.
Sites of such structures should be away from natural geological weak points such as faults,
thrusts, fissures or fractures etc.
c.
Structures should be designed in subsidence prone areas taking rigidity, flexibility factors
into consideration.
d.
If the mining in a subsidence prone area is inevitable the operations should be planned to
permit controlled subsidence over the entire overlying ground.
e.
Mine planners can possibly modify extraction methods and sequence(s) of operations to
keep the damage within acceptable limits.
f.
g.
The worked out areas, specially for steeply dipping metalliferous ore bodies, should be
filled with sand or other suitable packing materials.
h.
The procedures and plans drawn for mine closure operations, which is now mandatory,
adequate attention should be given to prevent subsidence of land in underground mine
workings in future.
i.
The magnitude of surface strain, ground movement and slope change can be predicted
with empirical models or with finite element computer simulations. Scientific data for such
models should be collected before the actual mine operations are started.
Fe (OH)3 + 2 SO4 2 - + 4 H +
In the presence of oxygen and water, pyrite oxidizes to form ferric hydroxide, sulphate and
hydrogen ions. The liberation of hydrogen ions lowers the PH and causes increased acidity in
water passing. Prediction of acid mine drainage (AMD) also called acid rock drainage (ARD)
will help the mining operations and planning the strategy to control pollution of ground & surface
waters and entry of TOXIC metallic components in the environment. The mining authorities
should try to prevent formation of acid drainage at source. For this they may adopt modified
mining methods, sealing of mine or a part of it after closure, surface reclamation, water diversion
to prevent he exposure of ground water to sulphide bearing rocks and subsurface dams. Control
of acid generation can be achieved by limiting the availability of at least one of the three essential
components of the acid generating process, namely, sulphide mineral, air or water.
60
The segregation of acid generating material and encapsulation within materials, which
will generate alkalinity will be best alternative.
Blending thoroughly Potentially Acid Forming (PAF) material, with non- acid
consuming (NAC) materials to take advantage of inherent neutralization capacity.
Depending on site conditions wet/dry covers can be utilized to minimize oxygen entry
into the waste body. Water flux through the waste or both. A cover of compacted clay
or dead ore or rock can be used.
Controlled placement and compaction of thin layers can be adopted to achieve high
level of control for dumps in sensitive environment(s). The outer layers of such
compaction will include a compacted oxygen barrier and a single or multi layered revegetation plan.
To employ standard waste water treatment method for neutralization and removal of
dissolved solids. The technique generally adopted followed is lime or limestone
addition during the construction stage and to bring down the PH to below 5.5 use of
bactericides were also practiced to control ARD at some coal mines.
Prevention of ARD should be the primary goal at new mines, collection and treatment
as a mitigation method on a long term basis. The method adopted should include
line/limestone treatment followed by aeration or oxidation process to convert ferrous
iron to ferric iron, neutralization with soda ash, Caustic soda etc reverse osmosis/ion
exchange, evaporation, ozone oxidation, iron sulphide removal and microbial control.
Introducing bactericides that reduce the activity of the catalyzing bacteria utilizing
specialized biotechnological processes for recovery of heavy toxic metals from the
mine drainage water.
The sludge emanating from the treatment being a hazardous waste should be disposed off in an
approved manner.
Wet Drilling
61
c)
d)
e)
f)
Diesel Generator set if any should have accoustic enclosures with adequate stack height.
Regular checking and maintenance of vehicles should be conducted and pollution under
control certificate be obtained.
Since there is always change of location of mine drainage water discharge points, as the
mine progresses, suitable networking for pumping mine drainage water to the treatment
system / plant should be ensured.
A monitoring network of dug wells should be established to monitor the ground water
level. It may be explored if the treated mine drainage water can be utilized for agricultural
purpose in the surrounding.
The wastewater generated from workshop and the colonies should be treated by appropriate
treatment method based on the composition and quantity.
Monitoring of water quality of mine discharge to local river/nallah and domestic water
should be conducted to evaluate the performance of the mitigation measures.
The water management should be worked out and shown in drawings of the mining area.
Noise level should be maintained below 90 dB(A) in workplace (for 8 hour exposure).
Hearing protection devices (Ear plugs and ear muffs) should be provided to the drill machine
operators and dumper drivers.
Blasting should be carried out only during daytime and fly rock not be carried out in storming
and rainy weather or during lightening.
The distribution ratio of cast booster to column charge may be maintained at 1:3.
Maximum permissible charge per delay should be decided on the basis of the distance of
structure to be protected from the blasting.
Stock tubes should be used for connections and initiation of detonation in holes and on the
surface.
Maximum period of blast should preferably be less than 600 ms to minimize cut off.
The number of rows in a blast should not be more than four so that fly rock generation and
ground vibration are reduced.
Attempts should be made to have one large blast with less frequency then to have several
small blasts.
63
soil erosion to great extent. It further improves the aesthetics and beneficially influence the
microclimate of the surrounding. It also helps to stabilize the slope of external overburden dumps.
Many a times, it attract the animals to re-colonize the area when the mine is abandoned. However,
green belts may be developed with plant species suitable to the area. Plant species, selected for
greenbelt should have rapid growth, ever green, large crown volume and small/pendulous leave
with smooth surface. All these characteristics are difficult to get in a single species. Therefore a
combination of these is sought while selecting trees for vegetation cover.
Greenbelt should be developed in following areas:
The species of plantation should be selected considering the soil quality, place of plantation,
chances of survival, commercial value etc. Only indigenous species should be planted. Mixed
plantation should be done keeping optimum spacing between the sapling. The species suitable
and guideline for greenbelt development given in Central Pollution Control Boards publication
Guidelines for Development of Greenbelt CPROBES/75/1999-2000 should be followed. In order
to supply of seedlings for the continuing greenbelt development plan, a nursery may be developed.
Sapling may be done from seeds or seedling collected from nearby forest areas.
Plantation along mining lease boundary
In case of open cost mine, green belt of suitable width
should be developed all along the mining lease
boundary. The row of plants facing mine should be of
smaller species and those facing outside should be of
taller species. Seeds may also be sown in rows for
plants with low survival rate (Example - Sal). In
underground mines, plantation along the boundary of
mine entry should be taken up.
Plantation around Office Building, Colony & Road
Plantation should be done around the built up areas
and space available in the township. Extensive
plantation should also be done along the sides of
connecting roads.
Plantation on external dumps
Plantation on the overburden dumps can only be taken
up after dumping activity is stopped and the site is
Plantation on Overburden Dumps
64
proposed for plantation. A layer of topsoil should be spread over the area and roughly leveled.
Coir net / blanket should be spread and native grass seed mix should be broadcasted uniformly
on prepared slope.
Plantation on Top of Overburden
Trenches of 45cm x 45cm should be dug on the flat top of the dump and excavated materials
should be used to form bund on the dip side of the trenches to retain water during rain. Suitable
benches should be made on the waste dump. Pits of size 60cm x 60cm should be dug on the
benches at 2-3 meters intervals. The pits should be filled with a mixture of top soil, organic manure
and phosphate fertilizer. Saplings should be planted in these pits during monsoon to ensure
maximum survival.
Plantation on Dump Slopes
Plantation on slope of the dump should start after the benches are ready. The terraces on the
slopes should be sloped inward. Pits of size 60cm x 60cm should be dugs at 1.5m interval and
filled with a mixture of topsoil, organic manure and phosphate fertilizer.
The slopes and terraces should be covered with a layer of soil held with coir net blanket. Seeds of
grass and small scrubs of local varieties should be sprinkled on the soil covering the dump slope.
Seedling of the plants should be planted in pit in the slopes.
Plantation on Backfill areas/Mine Benches
Plantation on the mining benches can also be taken up once the active pit is closed for mining.
The abandoned pit, after backfilling and leveling, a layer of top soil should be spread. Grass seed
/ seedlings should be planted on the soil layer to stabilize the soil. Plants selected for plantation
on mining benches should be draught hardy, with fast growth rate and with glabrous/ pendulous
leaves.
Trenches of 60cm x 60cm should be dug on the flat top of the backfilled mine pits. Where backfilling
is not possible (mining in hills), the trenches should be dug on mining benches. The excavated
materials should be utilized to construct bund on the dip sides of the pit to retain water. Contour
trenches at 2-3 meter intervals should be dug on the backfilled mine pits/mining benches for soil
and moisture conservation. The pits should be filled with a mixture of topsoil, organic manure a
phosphate fertilizer.
Masonry drains sloping along the mining benches to facilitate conveying of water from higher
benches to the next lower benches should be constructed. Before the commencement of the
monsoon, the side slopes of mining benches should be covered with a layer of soil by means of
mechanical binders like coir net / blanket and sprinkle with water. Seeds of grass and scrub of
indigenous variety should be sprinkled on the soil covering the bench side slopes.
Phase wise Plantation for afforestation
Stretches of open land in lease area, which are not covered by any activity should also be identified
and afforestation programme should be taken up. Plantation in these locations can start from the
initial year of excavation and plantation should be expected in such areas in progression stages.
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
65
The green belt development plan with the progressive plantation programme and land availability
and requirement of saplings should be shown in maps. This also should be presented in tabular
format (Table-10.1).
Post Plantation Care
Post plantation care is very important and should be an integral part of mine management. A
dedicated cell in the mine should be established for post plantation care, which include, regular
watering, manuring, protective measures etc. Diseased and dead plants should be uprooted and
replaced by fresh saplings. Regular monitoring on survival rate and remedial action should be
done in an organized and planned manner.
Plan for Reduction of Impact on Fauna
The impact on fauna species in the mining area is mostly due to noise vibration and loss of
vegetation cover. The measures proposed to reduce the impact is discussed in the respective
chapters should be strictly followed. The blasting is to be carried out during day time only. The
migrating routes of wild animals should not be disturbed and action should be taken as per the
guideline of State Forest Department. This is also regulated under the Wildlife (Protection) Act,
1972.
The strong light in the project premises during night may cause some disturbance to fauna of
nearby forests. The light posts along the ML boundary should face inwards and downwards
with reflector facing downward, so that light do not spread outside ML area.
Hearing impairment
Skin diseases
Eye diseases
Respirable diseases
Materials like asbestos, silica, chrome dust etc. are hazardous to mine workers.
66
Safety of employees during operation of mines should be as per the mines rules and as per
guideline of Director General of Mines Safety (DGMS). The following measures relating to safety
and health should be incorporated.
Provisions of rest shelter for mine workers with facility of drinking water.
Awareness on safety and ensure using of personal protective equipments (PPE) by workers.
Medical assistance;
Primary education;
Animal husbandry;
Agricultural improvement;
Medical Assistance
Services of health care facilities developed by the mine should be extended to the general public.
Education
In order to improve the educational activities in the area, following assistance may be provided.
Training of personnel
In order to improve the skill and self employment of locals, following promotional activities may
be taken up.
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
67
Agricultural Improvement
The locals in the area should be benefited by following social programme.
Organising, with the help of Agricultural Department, training programs for farmers in
relevant areas such as animal husbandry, dairy development, modern cultivation, scientific
storage of grain, water conservation etc;
Help in arranging in association with nearby agricultural department for soil testing and
technical inputs for increasing yield.
68
10
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
10.0 General
Summary EIA should be a summary of the full EIA report condensed to ten A-4 size pages at the
maximum. It should necessarily cover in brief the following chapters of the full EIA report.
Introduction
Project description
Additional studies
10
11
DISCLOSURE OF CONSULTANTS ENGAGED
11.0 General
The EIA consultants shall have accreditation with Quality Control of India (QCI)/National
Accreditation Board of Education and Training (NABET) as per office memorandum dated 2nd
December 2009 of MoEF. This chapter shall include the names of the consultants engaged with
their brief resume and nature of consultancy rendered. The consultants shall include the copy of
the accreditation certificate and data provided by the other organizations/ laboratories including
their status of approvals etc.
11
Bibliography
BIBLIOGRAPHY
APELL for Mining, Awareness and Preparedness for Emergencies at Local Level, Technical
Report No. 41, UNEP 2001
Final_Lit_Review_AMD_08-22-08.pdf
International Council for Mining and Metals (ICMM), 2006. Good Practice Guidance for
Mining and Biodiversity . London, UK. Available at: http://www.icmm.com/uploads/
1295GPG.pdf
MAC, 2003. Developing an Operations, Maintenance and Surveillance Manual for Tailings
and Water Management Facilities.
Samad, M. A., and E.K. Yanful. (2005). A design approach for selection the optimum water
cover depth for subaqueous disposal of sulfide mine tailings. From http: pubs.nrccnrc.gc.ca/rp/rppdf/t04-094.pdf.
Skousen, J. G., and P.F. Ziemkiewicz (1996). Acid Mine Drainage Control and Treatment.
Second Edition. Morgantown, W.V., West Virginia University and the National Mine Land
Reclamation Center.
U.S. Department of the Interior, Office of Surface Mining. Acid Mine Drainage Prevention
and Mitigation (2007) available at: http://www.osmre.gov/amdpvm.htm
UNEP, 2001. APELL for Mining, Awareness and Preparedness for Emergencies at Local
Level, Technical Report No. 41.
UNEP. (2002). Chronology of Major Tailing Dam Failures. United Nations Environmental Program, Division of Technology, Industry and Economics. From http://
www.mineralresourcesforum.org/incidents/index.htm.
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982) Available at: http://www.un.org/
Depts/los/index.htm
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
73
United States (US) Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 2005. 40 CFR Part 60, Standards
of Performance for New and Existing Stationary Sources: Electric Utility Steam Generating
Units, Clean Air Mercury Rule. Washington, DC: US EPA..
Younger, P. L., S.A. Banwart, and R.S. Hedin (2002). Mine Water: Hydrology, Pollution,
Remediation. NY, NY, Springer Pub.
74
TABLES
Tables
Location
1.
Township
2.
Conveyor
3.
Water reservoir
4.
Magazine
5.
6.
Tailing Dam
7.
8.
Waste dump
9.
10.
11
Haul road
Green belt
Topsoil dump
Area in Ha
Existing Landuse
Canteen
Ore type
Year
1.
First 5 years
2.
5 10 years
3.
10-15 years
4.
15-20 years
5.
20-25 years
6.
25-30 years
Overburden cum
Total
Class
Commercial Name
Quantity stored
1.
2.
3.
4.
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
75
Fuel
Type of Storage
Monthly Requirement
1.
2.
3.
4.
Top
Soil (m3)
Overburden
(m3)
Normal Grade
Ore (Tonnes)
High Grade
Ore (Tonnes)
1
2
3
4
5
Total
Activities
Average Demand
(m3/day)
1.
Mine
a. Drilling and spraying
b. Dust suppression
c. Equipment / Vehicle washing
d. Pit head bath
e. Drinking water at mine site
2.
Township Drinking
3.
4.
Green Belt
5.
Peak Demand
(m3/day)
Category
1.
Administrative
2.
Supervisory
3.
Workers
4.
Security
5.
Others
76
Contractual
Operative Phase
Direct
Contractual
Tables
Location
Project area/
study area
Environmental
Setting
Colour Texture
Water
Holding
capacity (%)
Porosity
(%)
Sand
(%)
Salt
(%)
Bulk
Density
gm/cc
Permeability
ml
S1
S2
S3
Samples
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
pH
Conductivity
Chloride
Sodium Absorption Ratio
Location
Project area/
study area
Environmental
Setting
Parameters
Unit
GW1
Result
GW2
Standards
GW3
77
Location
Project area/
study area
Environmental
Setting
Parameters
Unit
Result
SW2
SW1
Standards
SW3
Location
Station
Code
Zone
(Core/Buffer)
Remarks
78
Residential Area
Industrial Area
Sensitive Area
95 Percentile
Mean
Max.
Min.
95 Percentile
Mean
Max.
Min.
:
:
:
95 Percentile
R I
S
Mean
95 Percentile
Mean
Max.
Min.
95 Percentile
Mean
Max.
:
:
:
:
:
Min.
SPM
RSPM
SO2
NOx
CO
Max.
Category
(R,I,S)
Min.
Monitoring
Stations
Category of Station
Tables
Location
Envron- Average
mental Day noise
Setting* level (dBA)
Average
Night noise
level (dBA)
Day time
(6.00 A.M. to
10.00 P.M)
Standard
(Leq in dBA)
Day time
(10.00 P.M. to
6.00 A.M)
Standard
(Leq in dBA)
Plant species
No.
Abundance
Average
Minimum
Buffer Zone
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Total
Plant species
No.
Abundance
Average
Minimum
Buffer Zone
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Total
Plant
species
Common
Name
Habitant
Family
Average
Abundance
Average
Minimum
1.
2.
3.
79
Direction
1.
2.
3.
Common Name
Local Name
Scientific Name
Polulation
No. of villages
Number of hoseholds
Village-wise
Demographic Feature
1.0
Population
2.0
Households
3.0
Occupation
Study Area
Core Zone
Buffer Zone
Share in total
Population (%)
1.
Marginal (<2.5)
2.
Small (2.5-5.0)
3.
Medium (5.0-10.0)
4.
Large (= 10.0)
80
Household %
Core Zone
Buffer Zone
Tables
Occupation
Percentage
Core Zone
1.
Cultivation
2.
Service
3.
Private Business
4.
Wage Laborer
5.
Others
Buffer Zone
Background
Predicted
Resultant
Air Quality
Concentration Concentration Concentration Standard
in gm /m3
in gm /m3
gm /m3
in gm/m3
Village
Background
Nearest
Distance
in M
Noise Contribution
(dBA)
1.
2.
3.
Village
Nearest
Quarry
Distance in
Meter
PPV
mm/Sec
1.
2.
3.
81
Environmental Parameter
1.0
Air Quality
2.0
Meteorology
3.0
Water Quality
Nos. of Stations
Core Zone
Buffer Zone
Frequency of
Monitoring
a. Surface Water
b. Ground Water
4.
Noise
5.
Vibration
6.
Traffic
7.
Soil Quality
Years of Mining
1.
5th Year
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Available land
for plantation
Area in ha
Requirement of
sapling
Types of
Trees proposed
Mining
1.
5th Year
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
82
Land
Degradation
in ha
ANNEXURES
Annexure 1
1.0 Introduction
This chapter should cover purpose of the project, project proponent, brief description of the project
name, nature, size, location of the project and its importance to the region/country. As per the
EIA notification of 14th September 2006 and its amendment dated 1st December 2009, mining
projects are divided into two categories as mentioned below:
Project
Activity
Mining of
Minerals
A Category
B Category
General Condition
Profile of the Project Proponent, name and contact address, Implementing Organization,
Organizational Chart, Project Consultants etc., should be mentioned clearly.
Land description- plot/ survey / khasra numbers, village, tehsil, district, state and extent of the
land must be mentioned clearly. The project site should conform to the CRZ guideline or
modifications or stipulations made by the Central / State Govt., as applicable.
The proponent should confirm that the project meets all Centre / State / Local regulations and
standards applicable for mining of minerals and allied activities.
Any litigations pending against the proposed project and / or any directions or orders passed by
any court of law/any statutory authority against the project are to be detailed out.
In case of expansion / modernization of the project, the environmental compliance status for
the existing project should be explained.
The EIA-EMP report should be based on maximum mineral extraction capacity and it should be
based on generic structure given in Appendix III of EIA Notification, 2006 for the project or its
expansion based on the proposed maximum mineral extraction capacity.
84
Annexures
The mining projects linked to associated projects such as coal to power plant, limestone to cement
plant etc., located within the impact zone are required to take up integrated EIA.
The report, the page numbers of various chapters, sections and sub-sections, tables, appendices,
drawings and figures, source of data incorporated should be clearly mentioned etc., with titles
should be clearly indicated under the heading contents.
Location of the project ( Longitude, Latitude, revenue village, Tehesil, District, State, nearest
Railway station, airport, and MSL)
Objective of the project (captive mine, standalone etc) whether it is new or expansion (Increase
in ML area or increase in annual production) or modernization. Proposed use of minerals
(sale, use as intermediates or raw materials). Any change in technology proposed should be
specified.
Significance and relevance of the project highlighting the benefit to surrounding area and
economic development of the Local/State/ Country.
Location of National Park, Wildlife sanctuary, migratory routes of wild animals etc. with in
10 km of mine lease area should be authenticated by the Chief Wildlife Warden.
Period of mining lease and calendar programme of ore and waste production.
Status and stages of other regulatory clearances like approval of mining plan, forest clearance,
consent to establish from State Pollution Control Board etc.
Manpower recruitment
85
Environmental data relating to history of natural calamity such as cyclones, storms surges
Coastal areas), tornado, flood, etc. should be discussed,
Reserves and quality of the ore with chemical composition (Grade or Percentage). Associated
minerals, if any, should be mentioned.
Deposit condition such as ore strength, host rock strength, shape, grade, dip, size, uniformity
and depth.
General description of the project with ancillary operations such as crushing, beneficiation
etc.
Surface geological plan in the leasehold area, transverse section of mineral deposits, contour
maps at intervals of not more than 03 meters
Project falling on Coastal Zone for mining in coastal area. Details of Coastal Zone
Classification, Low Tide Line (LTL), High Tide Line (HTL), characteristics of beach
Annexures
Type (Open cast, Underground or Both) and method of mining (Manual, Semi-mechanized
or mechanized)
Hydrology of the area and calculation for mine seepage water and Groundwater drawdown
Deposit conditions
Mining Plan (Height and Width of the benches in overburden, ore body, proposed
inclination/slope of the sides),
Surface plan showing mine working 5rd year, 10th year, 15th year, 20th year, 25th year,
30th year as per the approved mine plan.
Underground Mining
Deposit conditions
Ventilation system for adequate control of quality and quantity of air underground
General Features
Mineral transportation outside mining lease area (road, rail, conveyor, Rope way, waterway,
pipeline, others etc.)
87
Township description, (area, dwelling units, distance from mine, distance of water bodies)
Study area:
Study area for the mining projects should be defined as follows:
10 km radius from the boundary limits of the mine lease area of more than 50 hectares
should be the buffer zone.
5km radius from the boundary limits of mine lease area of 5-50 hectares should be buffer
zone.
Maps (appropriate scale) of the study area ( core and buffer zone), clearly delineating the
locations of various monitoring stations (air/water/noise/soil), superimposed on locations
of habitats are to be shown.
Indicate 2km, 5km distance from the boundary limits of mine lease by appropriate line.
Baseline information is required to be collected by field survey, monitoring etc. Secondary data
with source should be clearly mentioned. Normally, one season monitoring data (excluding
monsoon) are to be collected. However, Expert Appraisal Committee (EPC) may specify collection
of baseline data for a longer period base on the nature, size and location of the project.
Land
Baseline data on land, of mine leased-area is to be described. Total land available and proposed
utilization for different purposes including built-up area be given. Justification of the use of area
is to be given.
88
Annexures
Topography
Topography the study area through topographical maps (1: 50000), showing all relevant details
required for assessment of the proposed activities. Description in relation to following be given
Land use pattern (habitation, cropping, forest cover, ecologically sensitive features etc. by
employing remote sensing techniques (If available)
Geology
Geology of the area is to ascertain seismic sensitivity. It also defines the layers of geological
formations, from which the permeability and possible faults and fissures can be known.
Soil
The study should include
Pre-mining land use pattern, cropping pattern, vegetation cover etc. (remote sensing data)
Climate and meteorology (temperature (max. and min.), relative humidity, and rainfall)
indicate the nearest IMD meteorological station from which climatological data have been
obtained.
Air quality monitoring data in respect of SPM, RSPM, SO2, NOX, CO, Heavy Metals in
SPM (Mineralogical Fe, Mn, Pb etc.), any other project specific pollutants. Monitoring should
cover one full season except monsoon. Frequency and methodology adopted should be as
per CPCB/MOEF guidelines.
Monitoring stations are to be located based on dominating wind directions, habitations and
terrain features in the study area. The monitoring stations should cover upwind, downwind,
crosswind, core zone, habitations and sensitive areas.
89
Surface Water
The study should cover the following;
Locations of representative monitoring stations showing direction and distance from the
mine lease site
Details of rivers, springs, lakes, reservoirs and drains up to first order in study area.
Delineation of water sheds and water drainage pattern in the study area using remote sensing
satellite imageries
Surface water balance (Withdrawal of surface water and release of mine drainage water)
Groundwater
Since the mining is excavation of the earth, the groundwater is affected to a great extent.
The study should include;
Groundwater quality, groundwater potential of the area and its availability, groundwater
table (pre monsoon and post monsoon)
The details of locations of groundwater observation wells with respect to core zone should
be described.
Additional Information
Water bodies existing and water bodies likely to be created due to mining activities
Water requirement and waste water generation from various activities of mine, including
township, beneficiation etc.
Locations of monitoring stations for noise measurements in accordance with the direction
and distance from the sources and habitations.
Vibration and air over pressure, caused due to blasting, transport and process equipments,
wherever applicable
90
Annexures
Detail description of vegetation type in core and buffer zone ( include photograph)
Assessment of plant species with respect to their dominance, density, frequency, abundance,
diversity index, similarity index, importance value Index.
Location of National Parks, Sanctuary, Biosphere Reserve, Tiger Reserve, Elephant Reserve,
wild life migratory routes in core and buffer zones
Fauna
List out endangered and endemic species as per the schedule of the Wildlife Protection Act,
1972
Data on demography, traditional skills, sources of livelihood within the study area
Data relating to historically, culturally and ecologically important places in core as well as
buffer areas
Details of private lands with ownership in the core area indicating financial loss annually
Solid waste from mining and processing operations, their quality and quantity (overburden,
low-grade ore etc.) Quantity and quality of associated minerals and possible recovery
91
Solid waste generation from Effluent Treatment Plant township, hospitals etc.
Any specific inputs which are likely to be added the site and its surroundings. Salient feature of
the area, which require specific study.
Specific Condition
Study Required
Nearness to Forest/
Nearness to Township
Impact on topography, drainage pattern, land use with respect to agriculture, forestry, builtup area etc.
Soil erosion
Subsidence
Mitigation Measures:
Technological measures to prevent soil erosion from core and buffer zones
Annexures
Anticipated Impact:
Emission Inventory of SPM, RSPM, SO2, NOX, and site specific pollutants
Prediction of fugitive dust emissions due to mining activities, crushing and cleaning plants,
loading and unloading, transportation by rail, road or conveyor.
Prediction of impact on ambient air quality using appropriate mathematical model (area, point
and line sources). Description of model, input requirements and reference of derivation. Isopleths
distribution of major pollutants and their analysis and presentation in tabular form/base map.
Mitigation Measures:
Adoption scientific mining methods to reduce dust emission from point and line source
Impact on surface and groundwater quality due to discharges from mining, tailings pond,
workshop, township, leachate from solid waste dumps etc.
Mitigation Measures:
Construction of gully checks, check dams, sedimentation ponds, settling tanks, water weirs,
retaining walls etc. with design and site features for control of run-off
Wastewater treatment for township sewage, workshop(s), tailing pond overflow etc.
93
Impact on ambient noise level due to rock excavation, transportation, processing equipments
and ancilliaries.
Mitigation Measures:
Measures for noise abatement including point source and line source
Selection of low noise equipment failing which use of retrofit for existing equipment
Impact on forest resources, economically important plants, medicinal plants and threat to
rare, endemic and endangered species
Impact on flora and fauna due to air emissions, noise, vibration, illumination, vehicular
movement, waste water discharges, changes in land use, township etc.
Mitigation Measures:
Impact on the cropping pattern and crop productivity in the buffer zone
Annexures
Mitigation Measures:
Employment opportunities and access to other amenities such as education, health care
facilities to be extended to locals
Impact of runoff from overburden, top soil, low-grade ore and other stock piles on water
bodies (siltation, contamination etc)
Mitigation Measures:
Overburden utilization for back-filling and other purposes. Simulation model with 5 years
projection with digitized maps
Monitoring of quality of water, air, noise, vibration and occupational health status of project
personnel and surrounding habitations.
Hydrogeological monitoring for the entire mine life and restrictive monitoring during
reclamation.
95
Analysis of data, its interpretation and evaluation (any additional studies to be carried out
if required)
Mine closure plan along with the fund requirement for implementation of the activities
proposed there under.
Identification and type of risk associated with mining (slope failure, subsidence, fly rock
fragments, fires, toxic / hazardous / flammable gas release / explosion, inundation etc.)
Disaster management plan and emergency response system with proper organizational
setup to deal with such situation.
Disaster management plan for safe mining particularly for underground mines where toxic
fumes and other risks are involved.
Annexures
Institutional arrangements proposed with other organizations/ Govt. authorities for effective
implementation of proposed environmental management plan
Conservation plan for the endangered / endemic flora and fauna found in the study area
and for safety of animals visiting / residing in the study area and also those in the migratory
corridor.
Integrating in the environmental management plan measures for minimising use of natural
resources water, land, energy etc.
Introduction
Additional studies
97
Annexure 2
Level -II
Level -III
1. Built up land
2. Agricultural land
2.1.
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
2.2.
2.3.
Crop land
Kharif
Rabi
Double cropped
Fallow
Plantation
3.1
3. Forest
2.2.1. Fallow
2.3.1. Types of plantation, casuarina,
coconut, tea etc.
3.2. Deciduous
3.3. Degraded scrub land
4. Wastelands
6. Others
6.1.1. Current
6.1.2. Old / abandoned
categories
1:1000,000 scale
Level II
categories
1:250,000 scale
Level III
categories
98
Annexures
Annexure 3
Sampling
A. Air Environment
Network
Meteorological
Wind speed
Wind direction
Maximum
temperature
Minimum
temperature
Relative
humidity
Rainfall
Solar radiation
Cloud cover
Environmental
Lapse Rate
Pollutants
PM (10)
Measurement Method
Frequency
Mechanical/automatic
weather station
Max/Min Thermometer
Hygrometer
1 site in the
project area
1 hourly
continuous
Rain gauge
As per IMD specifications
As per IMD specifications
Nos. of
sampling
location
to be
decided
Remarks
24 hourly
twice a
week
PM (2.5)
@4 hourly.
Twice a
week, One
non
monsoon
season
SO2
8 hourly,
twice a week
Secondary data
from IMD
Mini Sonde/SODAR
CPCB guidelines
Monitoring Network
Minimum one
locations in upwind
side, two sites in
downwind side /
impact zone
All the sensitive
receptors need to be
covered for core
zone and buffer
zone
NOx
Lead in PM
24 hourly,
twice a week
B. Noise
Network
Frequency
Hourly
equivalent
noise levels
Identified
study area
Once in
season
Peak particle
velocity
150-200m
from blast
site
Once
PPV meter
IS:4954-1968 as
adopted by CPCB
99
Attributes
Sampling
Measurement Method
Remarks
C. Water
Parameters for
water quality
pH,
temperature,
turbidity,
magnesium
hardness, total
alkalinity,
chloride,
sulphate,
nitrate,
fluoride,
sodium,
potassium,
salinity
Set of grab
samples for
ground and
surface
water
Total nitrogen,
total
phosphorus,
DO, BOD, COD
Heavy metals
Total coliforms,
faecal coliforms
Phyto plankton
D. Land
environment
Soil
Organic Matter
Texture
pH
Electrical
conductivity
Permeability
Water holding
capacity
Porosity
Sample from
villages (soil
samples be
collected as
One season
per BIS
specifications)
Analysis be done as
per BIS specifications
Adopted from: EIA manual 2001, Ministry of Environment and forests, New Delhi
100
Annexures
Annexure 4
Category
<65%
Safe
>65% to <85%
Semi-critical
>85% to <100%
Critical
>100%
Over exploited
Source:- Report of Groundwater estimation committee, groundwater resource estimation methodology, 1997, Ministry
of Water Resources, Government of India, New Delhi.
101
Annexure 5
Range/Limiting Value
Note
Use with
Use after
only
conventional
disinfection treatment
1. pH
6.5 to 8.5
6.0 to 9.0
< 10
< 50
< 10
< 50
<3
< 10
90-100
80-120
6. BOD, mg/l
<3
<5
Same as above.
7. TKN, mg/l
<1
<3
Same as above.
8. Ammonia, mg/l
< 0.05
<1
Same as above.
< 200
< 2000
< 2000
< 2000
< 300
< 300
< 250
<250
< 0.7
< 1.0
< 50
< 50
< 1.0
< 1.5
< 0.2
< 0.2
5. DO, (%saturation)
Additional Parameters for Periodic Monitoring (Seasonal Only to be done when there are known natural
or anthropogenic sources in the upstream catchment region likely or apprehended to contribute or other
well founded apprehensions)
102
Annexures
Parameters
Desirable
Acceptable
Note
< 0.3
< 0.01
< 0.001
< 0.05
< 0.05
< 0.01
< 0.005
< 0.001
< 0.05
< 0.0002
< 0.5
< 1.0
< 5.0
< 0.05
< 0.005
< 0.05
< 0.05
< 0.01
<0.0005
< 0.001
< 0.05
< 0.0002
< 0.001
< 0.0025
Outdoor bathing
(Organized)
Class of
Criteria
water
A
1. Total Coliforms OrganismMPN/100ml shall be 50
or less
2. pH between 6.5 and 8.5
3. Dissolved Oxygen 6mg/l or more
4. Biochemical Oxygen Demand 5 days 20oC
2mg/l or less
B
1. Total Coliforms Organism MPN/100ml shall
be 500 or less
2. pH between 6.5 and 8.5
3. Dissolved Oxygen 5mg/l or more
4. Biochemical Oxygen Demand 5 days 20oC
3mg/l or less
C
103
Annexure 6
Pollutants
1.
2.
Sulphur Dioxide
4.
5.
Annual*
50
20
24 hours**
80
80
Ultraviolet fluorescence
Annual*
40
30
(NOx), g/m
24 hours**
80
80
Hochhieser (Na-Arsenite)
- Chemiluminescence
Particulate Matter
Annual*
60
60
- Gravimetric
100
100
- TOEM
- Beta Attenuation
40
40
- Gravimetric
60
60
- TOEM
- Beta Attenuation
8 hours**
100
100
- UV Photometric
1 hour**
180
180
- Chemiluminescence
- Chemical method
Annual*
0.50
0.50
24 hours**
1.0
1.0
8 hours**
02
02
- Non-Dispersive Infra
1 hour**
04
04
Annual*
100
100
- Chemiluminescence
24 hours**
400
400
Nitrogen Dioxide
3
Carbon Monoxide
(CO), mg/m
3.
(SO2), g/m
2
Time
Weighted
Average
Ammonia (NH3),
g/m
6.
Benzene (C6H6),
g/m3
Annual*
05
05
- Gas Chromatography
based continuous analyzer
- Adsorption and
Desorption followed by
GC analysis
10
Benzo(O)Pyrene
Annual*
Particulate phae only,
ng/m3
01
01
104
Annexures
11
06
06
12
20
20
Annual*
Annual arithmetic mean of minimum 104 measurements in a year at a particular site taken
twice a week 24 hourly at uniform intervals.
**
Note:
Whenever and wherever monitoring takes place for two corrective days exceeds and the limit as
specified above for the respective category, it shall be considered adequate reason to institute
regular/continuous monitoring for further investigations.
(Source: CPCB notification Dated 18th November 2009)
105
Annexure 7
Category of Area
Industrial area
75
70
Commercial area
65
55
Residential area
55
45
Silence zone
50
40
Note:
1.
2.
3.
Silence zone is an area comprising not less than 100 meters around hospitals, educational institutions,
courts, religious places or any other area, which is declared as such by the competent authority.
4.
Mixed categories of areas may be declared as one of the four above-mentioned categories by the
competent authority.
* dB(A) Leq denotes the time weighted average of the level of sound in decibels on scale A which is
relatable to human hearing.
A decibel is a unit in which noise is measured.
A, in dB(A) Leq, denotes the frequency weighting in the measurement of noise and corresponds to
frequency response characteristics of the human ear.
Leq: It is an energy mean of the noise level over a specified period.
(Source: Noise pollution (Regulation and control) Rules, 2000)
106
Annexures
Annexure 8
Parameters of Impacts
SL. No.
Parameter of Impact
Description
1.
Type
2.
Nature
Direct, Indirect,
3.
Magnitude
4.
Timing
5.
Duration
Temporary/Permanent
6.
Reversibility
Revisable/Irreversible
7.
Significance
107
Annexure 9
Significance
1.
Site Features
Human habitation in core & buffer zone. If human settlement is high, the impact due to
displacement is significant.
2.
3.
Impact is significant
4.
5.
6.
7.
Stripping Ratio
8.
9.
108
Annexures
Annexure 10
Significance
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
9.
109
Annexure - 11
Standards
Inland surface
water
(a)
Public
sewers
(b)
Land for
irrigation
(c)
Marine coastal
areas
(d)
Suspended solids
mg/l, Max
100
600
200
Particle size of
suspended solids
pH Value
5.5 to 9.0
5.5 to 9.0
5.5 to 9.0
Temperature
10
20
10
20
Total residual
chlorine mg/l Max.
1.0
1.0
Ammonical Nitrogen
(as N), mg/l Max.
50
50
50
100
100
10
Free ammonia
(as NH3), mg/l Max.
5.0
5.0
11
Bio-chemical oxygen
demand (3 days at
270 C), mg/l max.
30
350
100
100
5.5 to 9.0
12
Chemical oxygen
demand, mg/l max.
250
250
13
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
14
0.01
0.01
0.01
15
0.1
1.0
2.0
16
2.0
1.0
2.0
110
Annexures
S. No Parameter
Standards
Inland surface
water
(a)
Public
sewers
(b)
Land for
irrigation
(c)
Marine coastal
areas
(d)
17
Hexavalent chromium
(as Cr +6), mg/l max.
0.1
2.0
1.0
18
Total chromium
(as Cr), mg/l max.
2.0
2.0
2.0
19
3.0
3.0
3.0
20
5.0
15
15
21
0.05
0.05
0.05
22
3.0
3.0
5.0
23
0.2
2.0
0.2
0.2
24
2.0
15
15
25
Dissolved phosphates
(as P), mg/l max.
5.0
26
2.0
5.0
27
Phenolic compounds
(as C6H5OH), mg/l max.
1.0
5.0
5.0
28
10-7
10-7
10-8
10-7
10-6
10-6
10-7
10-6
29
Bio-assay test
90% survival
of fish after 96
hours in 100%
effluent
90% survival
of fish after 96
hours in 100%
effluent
90% survival
of fish after 96
hours in 100%
effluent
30
Manganese
(as Mn), mg/l
31
32
0.2
0.2
0.2
33
10
20
* All efforts should be made to remove colour and unpleasant odour as far as practicable
- These standards shall be applicable for industries, operations or processes other than those industries, operations
or process for which standards have been specified of the Environment Protection Rules, 1989
Source: G.S.R 422 (E) dated 19.05.1993 and G.S.R 801 (E) dated 31.12.1993 issued under the provisions of E (P) Act 1986
111
Annexure 12
Parameter
Standards
pH
6.0 9.0
Suspended Solids
50 mg/l
200 mg/l - during monsoon
10 mg/l
Dissolved iron as Fe
2 mg/l
Manganese as Mn
2 mg/l
Source: CPCB, Effluents discharge standards, Comprehensive industry document on Iron ore mining,
comprehensive industry document series CDINDS / -/ 2007-2008
112
Annexures
Annexure 13
Air Pollutants
1.
Drilling
SPM
2.
Blasting
3.
SPM
4.
Haul Road
SPM
5.
Transportation
6.
Crushing of ore
SPM
7.
SPM
8.
DG Set
113
Annexure 14
SPM, RSPM
Significance or importance
Provide picture of ambient air quality
before mining is initiated.
In case of existing project, indicates
whether air quality has improved,
remain constant or deteriorated over a
period of time.
Health survey
Level of
mechanisation
114
Annexures
Annexure 15
Plant Species
Herbs
Low
<10%
Medium
11 to 20 %
Shrubs
Tees
1. Amaranthus
hypchondriceus
(chaluai)
2. Gardenia
Jasminoides (Crape
Jasmine)
3. Cestrum noctumum
(Rat ki Rani)
4. Chrysanthemum
species
1.
2.
3.
4.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
2. Draceana species
3. Halianthus Annus
(Sunflower)
4. Tegetes Patula
(Genda)
5. Pothus areus (Money
plant)
5.
6.
7.
8.
115
Plant Species
Herbs
High
>20%
1. Colocasia
antiquorum
(Elephants Ear)
2. Celocia Argentie
(Cock scomb)
116
Shrubs
1. Hibiscus rosa sinenesis
(Gurhal)
2. Bougainvillea glavra
(Bougainvillea)
Tees
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Annexures
Annexure 16
Control measures
Wet drilling technology or dry drilling fitted with bag
filter.
Driller shall be equipped with closed cabin personal
protective gear to reduce occupational hazard.
Blasting
Loading of material
on dumper
Air emission
Transportation
Crushing of ore
Storage of ore
117
Annexure 17
B.
8-25 Hz
>25 Hz
10
15
10
20
25
10
10
15
25
15
25
50
118
Annexures
Annexure 18
Method of Assessment
This related with climate change The trees act as carbon sink;
they absorb CO2 from the atmosphere and release oxygen.
Detailed accounting of carbon sink potential of forest should be done.
119
Annexure 19
SocioEconomic Issues
1.
Human Habitations
Significance
Impact is High. Well designed
R & R plans will help in
minimizing adverse impacts.
a. Positive impact because of
better job & business
opportunity
b. Negative impact due to
pollution & displacement of
people
2.
Pollution
a.
b.
c.
d.
Air Pollution
Water Pollution
Leachate
Land Degradation
3.
Livelihood
4.
Economic Loss
Negative.
Depends on the location
of villages.
Positive impact on employment
opportunities
120
Infrastructure
Positive impact
Annexures
Annexure 20
GIDC Vapi
Sub-cluster A
Mohan nagar Industrial area
Rajinder nagar Industrial area
Sahibabad Industrial area
Sub-cluster B
Pandav nagar Industrial area
Kavi nagar Industrial area
Bulandshahar Road Industrial area
Amrit nagar
Aryanagar Industrial area
Sub-cluster C
Merrut road Industrial area
Sub-cluster D
Loni Industrial area
Loni Road Industrial area
Roop Nagar Industrial area
Sub-cluster E
Hapur Road Industrial area
Dasna
Phikua
Sub-cluster F (other scattered Industrial areas)
South side of GT road
Kavi Nagar
Tronica city
Anand Nagar
Jindal Nagar
Prakash Nagar
Rural Industrial estate
a)
Bhiwadi (Rajassthan)
CEPI-82.91 (Ac_Wc_Ls)
a)
b)
c)
a)
b)
b)
Sonebhadra (UP)
Dala-Tola
Obra
Renukoot
Anpara
Renusagar
Kakri
Dudhichuwa
Bina
Khadia
Shakti Nagar
Rihand Nagar
Bijpur
Sigrauli (Madhya Pradesh)
Vindhyachal Nagar and Jayant, Nigahi, Dudhichua, Amlohri & Jhingurdah
townships
121
10
Ludhiana (Punjab)
CEPI-81.66 (Ac_Wc_Ls)
11
12
Territorial jurisdiction of :
Noida Phase - 1
Noida Phase - 2
Noida Phase 3
Village-Chhaparaula
13
Dhanbad (Jharkhand)
CEPI-78.63 (Ac_Ws_Lc)
Nirsa
14
Dombivalli (Maharashtra)
CEPI-78.41(Ac_Wc_Ls)
15
Kanpur (UttarPradesh)
CEPI-78.09 (Ac_Wc_Ls)
16
Cuddalore (Tamilnadu)
CEPI-77.45 (As_Wc_Lc)
17
Aurangabad (Maharashtra)
CEPI-77.44 (Ac_Wc_Ls)
18
Faridabad (Haryana)
CEPI-77.07 (Ac_Ws_Lc)
19
20
Manali (Tamilnadu)
CEPI-76.32 (Ac_Ws_Ls)
21
22
Ahmedabad (Gujarat)
CEPI-75.28 (Ac_Ws_Ls)
5 km wide Strip (17.4 x 5.0 km) of industrial area on the southern side
of the confluence point of Rivers Hugli and Rupnarayan, covering
Haldia Municipa Area & Sutahata Block-I and II
GIDC Odhav
GIDC Naroda
23
Jodhpur (Rajasthan)
CEPI-75.19 (As_Wc_Ls)
24
25
26
27
Vatva (Gujarat)
CEPI-74.77 (Ac_Wc_Ls)
122
a)
b)
Industrial areas:
Dada Nagar
Panki
Fazalganj
Vijay Nagar
Jajmau
Sector 27 - A, B, C, D
DLF Phase 1, Sector 31, 32
DLF Phase 2, Sector 35
Sector 4, 6, 24, 25, 27, 31, 59
Industrial area Hatin
Industrial Model town Ship
Annexures
S. No.
28
Ib Valley (Orissa)
CEPI-74.00 (Ac_Ws_Ls)
29
30
31
Pali (Rajasthan)
CEPI-73.73 (As_Wc_Ls)
a)
b)
32
Mangalore (Karnataka)
CEPI-73.68 (Ac_Ws_Ls)
33
Jharsuguda (Orissa)
CEPI-73.34 (Ac_Ws_Ls)
34
35
Bhadravati (Karnataka)
CEPI-72.33 (Ac_Ws_Ln)
36
Tarapur (Maharashtra)
CEPI-72.01 (Ac_Ws_Ls)
MIDC Tarapur
37
Panipat (Haryana)
CEPI-71.91 (As_Ws_sc)
38
Sanwer Road
Shivaji Nagar
Pologround
Laxmibai Nagar
Scheme No. 71
Naviakha,
Pipliya
Palda
Rau
Indore city
39
Bhavnagar (Gujarat)
CEPI-70.99 (As_Ws_Ls)
40
Bowl area
(the area between Yarada hill range in the south to Simhachalam hill
range in the north and sea on the east and the present NH-5 in the
West direcdtion)
41
Junagarh (Gujarat)
CEPI-70.82 (As_Ws_Ls)
Industrial Areas:
Sabalpur
Jay Bhavani
Jay Bhuvneshwari
42
43
Patancheru- -Bollaram
(Andhra Pradesh)
CEPI-70.07 (As_Ws_Ls)
Industrial Area:
Patancheru
Bollaram
Note: Names of identified industrial clusters/ potential impact zones are approximate location based on rapid survey and
assessment and may alter partially subject to the detailed field study and monitoring. Detailed mapping will be made available
showing spatial boundaries of the identified industrial clusters including zone of influence/buffer zone, after in depth field
study.
Aggregated Comprehensive Environmental Pollution Index (CEPI) scores of 70 and above are considered as critically polluted
industrial clusters/ areas.
Source: Ecological Impact Assessment Series: EIAS/5/2009-10
Details of Critically Polluted Industrial Areas and Clusters/ Potential Impact Zone in terms of the Office
Memorandum no. J-11013/5/2010-IA.II(I) dated 13.1.2010
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
123
Annexure 21
Application
EFFECT
HEGADIS
Pathway reliability
and protective system
hazard analysis
Markov models
Vulnerability
Exposure models
Graphical Representation
WHAZAN
Remarks
124
QUESTIONNAIRE
Questionnaire
I.
General Information
1.1
(a)
Mailing Address
Telephone
Fax No.
(b)
Village(s)
(c)
(d)
Tehsil
District
State
New mine
Yes
No
(ii)
Expansion
Yes
No
Increase in ML area
Yes
No
Yes
No
(iii) Renewal of ML
Yes
No
Modernisation
Yes
No
125
(e)
Site Information
(i)
(ii)
1.2
Geographical Location
Latitude
Longitude
Flat
Yes
No
Undulated
Yes
No
Hilly
Yes
No
Environmental sensitivity details within 10 km from the boundary of the project for
applicability of General Condition (GC) as per EIA notification dated 14.9.2006 and
amendments as on date
S.No
Item
Name
126
Questionnaire
1.3 Environmental sensitivity areas as mentioned at column 9(III) of EIA Notification 2006
S.
No
Areas
Name/
Identity
Defense installations
10
11
12
1.4 For projects falling within the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ)
Whether the mineral to be mined is of rare
nature and not available outside CRZ?
Yes
No
if yes, annex a scaled location map showing low tide line (LTL), high tide line (HTL) duly
demarcated by one of the authorized agencies* [ *Director, Space Application Centre, Ahmedabad:
Centre for Earth Sciences Studies, Thiruvananthapuram: Institute of Remote Sensing, Anna
University, Chennai: Institute of Wetland Management & Ecological Designs, KolKata: Naval
Hydrographerss Office, Dehradun: National Institute of Oceanography, Panjim, Goa: and
National Institute of Ocean Technology, Chennai], boundary of mining lease area, distance of
ML area from LTL and HTL CRZ boundary and CRZ classification of the project area as per the
approved Coastal Zone Management Plan, and settlements, sand dunes, mangroves, forest land/
patches, turtles breeding and nesting sites etc., if any, in the project area.
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
127
1.5
Baseline data
Meteorological data
Human Settlement
With in the project site
Population*
No. of villages
Number of households village-wise
128
Questionnaire
1.6 Current land use of the proposed project site Area(in ha) :
Level I
1. Built up land
2. Agricultural land
3. Forest
4. Wastelands
5. Water bodies
6. Others
Total
2.0 Indicate the seismic zone in which ML area falls. In case of zone IV & V,
details of earth quakes in last 10 years.
(a)
(b)
Life
Yes
No
Property
Yes
No
Existing mine
Yes
No
129
130
Overburden / Dumps
Mineral storage
Infrastructure (Workshop,
Administrative Building)
Roads
Railways
Green Belt
Tailings pond
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
TOTAL
Area to be excavated
Purpose
Forest
Others
Government
Agri.
Others
Private
Total
Private
Government
Agri. Others
Private
Area to be acquired
Government
Area acquired
Break-up of mining lease area (in ha.) as per approved conceptual plan:
1.
3.0.
Questionnaire
(b)
(c)
Proved
(b)
Indicated
(c)
Inferred
(d)
Mineable reserves
Yes
No
(b)
Yes
No
(c)
Yes
No
(d)
Faults
Yes
No
(ii)
Dykes
Yes
No
Yes
No
(iv) Folds
Yes
No
(v)
Yes
No
(e)
131
(ii)
1st year
5th year
No
Yes
No
Yes
132
METHOD
Opencast
Manual
Underground
Semi-mechanised
Both
Mechanised
Questionnaire
Existing
(a)
Additional
Opencast mine
(i)
(v)
Minimum
Maximum
Average
Minimum
Maximum
Average
Yes
No
133
(b)
Underground mine
(i) Seam / Ore body Min.Depth (m) Max. Depth (m) Avg. thickness (m)
Rate of dip
in degree
(ii)
Direction of dip
Shaft
Adit
Incline
On surface
At Face
For transportation
Others
(v)
Open
Filled
Shrinkage
Caving
Combination of above
Others (Specify)
Extraction method
Caving
Stowing
Partial extraction
(vi) Subsidence
134
Questionnaire
Yes
No
plan submitted?
Yes
No
Yes
No
(b)
Yes
No
(ii)
Yes
No
(b)
(c)
(d)
135
Existing
(b)
(c)
Yes
No
Manual
Yes
No
(b)
Yes
No
(c)
Yes
No
(d)
Yes
No
(e)
Others (specify).
Yes
No
136
(a)
Road
(b)
Rail
(c)
Conveyors
(d)
Rope way
(e)
Water ways
(f)
Pipeline
(g)
Others (Specify)
Percentage (%)
Questionnaire
Avg. Demand
Peak Demand
A. Mine site
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Mine operation
Land reclamation
Dust suppression
Drinking
Green Belt
Beneficiation
Washeries
Fire Service
Others (specify)
B. Township
1. Green Belt
2. Domestic
3. Other (specify)
Total
m3/day
Source
River (name)
Ground water
[*Annex a copy of sanction letter / permission from the concerned authority (Central
Ground Water Authority in case of ground water abstraction is from notified area / State
Ground Water Board in case of non-notified area / State Irrigation Department for surface
water pumping) for drawing water.]
18.0 Lean season flow in case of pumping from river / nalla (cumecs)
19.0 Ground water potential of the study area
19.1. Ground water availability
(a)
(i)
Pre-monsoon (April/May)
Core Zone
Buffer zone
Administrative Staff College of India, Hyderabad
137
(ii)
(b)
Post-monsoon (November)
Core Zone
Buffer zone
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Usage
Present Consumption
(m3/day)
Surface
1.
Domestic
2.
Irrigation
3.
Industry
Mining
Others (specify)
Ground
Additional
proposed as
per local plan
Surface Ground
Total
(ii)
Lean period
Monsoon period
Workshop
Total
(m3/day)
Surface Ground
Questionnaire
(v)
(c)
Yes
No
(d)
(i)
Percentage
(ii)
m3 /day
Final Point
1.
Surface
(i) Agricultural land
(ii) Waste land
(iii) Forest land
(iv) Green belt
2.
River / nallah
3.
Lake
4.
Sea
5.
Others (specify)
Total
(e)
Human
Yes
No
(ii)
Livestock
Yes
No
(iii) Irrigation
Yes
No
(iv) Industry
Yes
No
(v)
(f)
Others (specify)
(ii)
139
Yes
No
Yes
No
(b)
(c)
21.0 Attach water balance statement in the form of a flow diagram indicating
source (s), consumption (Section-wise) and output.
22.0 Solid Waste
(a)
Composition
Quantity
(m3/month)
Method of disposal
Mining activity*
a. Top Soil
b. Over burden
c. Others (specify)
Effluent Treatment
Plant (sludge)
Total
[* Annex layout plan indicating the dump sites.]
(b)
(i)
Yes
No
Yes
No
heavy metals?
(ii)
(c)
(d)
140
Questionnaire
(e)
(i)
(ii)
Yes
No
Already
accumulated
(A)
To be generated
(B)
% of A & B to be
backfilled
A
B
Over burden
Others (specify)
Land reclamation Plan
(f)
(ii)
Yes
No
(in MW)
Mine Site
Present
Proposed /
additional
Township
Others (specify)
Total
Total
141
(b)
Source of power
(in MW)
S. No.
SEB/Grid*
Present
Proposed
DG Sets
Total
[* Annex a copy of the sanction letter from the concerned authority]
(c)
Details of fuels
S.No.
Fuel
Daily Consumption
(TPD)
Existing
1.
HSD
2.
LSHS
3.
Other
(specify)
Calorific value
(Kcals/kg)
% Ash
% Sulphur
Proposed
Name
1.
Fuels
2.
Explosives
Number of
Storages
Consumption
(in TPD)
Maximum Quantity
at any point of time
142
Buffer Zone
Questionnaire
Area broken up
(ii)
To be broken up
Existing mine
New mine
(c)
(d)
(i)
Existing
(ii)
Proposed
Dumps
Roads
Township
Others
Existing
Month / Year
Survival rate %
(ii)
Avg. height
Proposed
No.of plant species planted
(b)
143
(c)
(ii)
Yes
No
Free silica
Lead**
Proposed
Air
Water
Noise
Solid Waste
b. Expenditure on environmental measures:
S. No
Capital cost
Existing
Pollution control
(provide break-up
separately)
Pollution monitoring
(provide break-up
separately)
Green Belt
Others (specify)
144
Proposed
Proposed
Questionnaire
Yes
No
(b)
Yes
No
closure plan.
(c)
30. Amount earmarked for socio-economic welfare measures for the nearby
villages other than R&R plans.
31. Compliance with environmental safeguards (for existing units)
a.
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
c.
Date of Advertisement
(b)
(c)
145
(d)
(e)
(f)
Response/Commitment of
Project Proponents
Suggestions made by
the Public Hearing Panel
Date ...................................
Name and Signature of the Competent Officer/authority
E-mail:
Phone and Fax nos:
Given under the seal of organization on behalf of whom the applicant is signing
Note:
The project authorities are earnestly advised in their own interest to provide complete information
on points, which they think are relevant to their proposal. Non-supply of required information
may result in considerable delay in according environmental clearance.
All correspondence with MoEF shall be made by the authorized signatory only. The authorized
signatory should also submit a document in support of his claim of being an authorized signatory
for the specific project (refer notification No. SO. 3067 (E) dated 1st December 2009)
146