2.6 Case Study Subway in China: Not So Easy: Questions

Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 1

2.

6 CASE STUDY
Subway in China: Not so easy
In Beijing, Jim Bryant is known as the Franchise king. His office is decorated with awards for
being subways top international franchise salesperson !!", highest percentage increase in
unit sales #$$#, and most franchises sold in %sia June #$$& to 'arch #$$(. )ubway is the
third largest *.) fast+food chain in ,hina after 'c-onalds and .F,.
/0en though many franchisors ha0e been lured to ,hina by its .& billion people and its
strong economy, the ,hinese market is an especially difficult one. 'any firms 1 including
%23, ,hillis 4rill 2 bar, -unkin -onuts and rainforest caf5 1ha0e closed their stores. %nd
while Bryant has opened ! subway stores in Beijing o0er the past decade, his 6uota for the
time period was &7 stores. Bryant says subway has charged him 8#,$$$ as damages for not
opening the re6uired number of restaurants.
Jim Bryant started doing business in ,hina in the !"$s when he set up a shoe manufacturing
factory in -atong, ,hinas northern coal capital. In !"(, he signed an agreement to be
subways representati0e in ,hina. Bryant would be responsible for recruiting local
entrepreneurs to become subway franchisees and act as a liaison between the franchisee and
)ubway. %s compensation, Bryant would recei0e half of the initial 8$,$$$ franchising fee
and one+third of the 79 royalty fee paid to subway. Bryant also recei0ed the rights to open
his own subway sandwich shops.
%lthough many subway restaurants were immediately popular among %mericans, the
,hinese were confused by the choices. Bryant reduced the confusion by printing signs that
e:plained how to order. 'any locals also did not belie0e that subways tuna fish was made
from a fish since they could not see the fishs head or tail. *nlike other chains such as .F,
that offers shredded carrots, fungus or bamboo shoots, subway did not tailor its menus to
appeal to the ,hinese tastes. %ccording to a subway franchisee, ;)ubway should ha0e at
least one item tailored to ,hinese tastes to show that they are respecting local culture .
<here are a host of other potential difficulties doing business in ,hina. )ome franchisees
refused to adapt to the franchisors re6uirements for consistency. =ne of subways earliest
franchisees decided, for e:ample, to change the restaurants colours and name. ,onstruction
costs were se0erely underestimated on one job. %nd in a third property, the franchisee was
locked out of a location e0en though it had si: months remaining on its lease. %pparently, the
property owner found a new tenant who paid two years rent up front. >ow Bryant will only
sign leases with business entities, not indi0iduals.
Bryant is currently considering whether to sell his stores and the rights to de0elop Beijing.
?ike many entrepreneurs, while he enjoys building business, he does not like his role of
inspecting stores for o0erall cleanliness, recipe consistency and d5cor@ ;I dont like pruning
the tree. I like to plant the seed and watch it grow .
Questions:
. -escribe the pros and cons of a ,hinese business persons in0esting in a )ubway
franchisee.
#. 3hat are the pros and cons of subways de0eloping its own stores 0ersus using franchising
as a means of selling to the ,hina marketA
&. )hould subway modify its menu to meet ,hinese tastesA If yes, howA /:plain your answer.
(. 3hy does a franchisor commonly penaliBe master franchisees such as Bryant when they do
not de0elop sufficient franchises within a gi0en time tableA

You might also like