White Meat Myths
White Meat Myths
White Meat Myths
cl ci lt
ud pe er
m
£1.90
es s u na
ex si tiv
ci ng es
ti
ng
White meat
myths
Why white meat is not the
healthy option – and guidance
on healthier alternatives
by Amanda Woodvine, BSc Nutrition
Senior Nutritionist, Vegetarian & Vegan Foundation (VVF)
Contents
10 Recipes
Origins of the High-Protein Diets for 15
Protein Gap........................ 4 Weight Loss ....................
Luvverly
Protein Quality.................. 5 Cancer............................. 10 Lunches 15
White Meat The Effect of White
for Athletes?...................... 6 Meat on Cholesterol ...... 11 Main
Courses 18
Protein Over- Food Poisoning............... 11
consumption –
the Hazards ....................... 6 Diabetes ..........................12
Festive
White Meat – the The Acidifying Feasts 24
Low-Fat Choice?................ 7 Effects of
White Meat.....................12
White Meat –
a Superfood? ..................... 8 Ingredients and
14
Stockists .........................
White Meat – © Vegetarian & Vegan Foundation 2009. Recipe Editor: Jane
Essential for
Growing Children? ........... 9 Easton. Published by: Vegetarian & Vegan Foundation, Top Suite,
8 York Court, Wilder Street, Bristol BS2 8QH.
T: 0117 970 5190
E: [email protected] W: www.vegetarian.org.uk
Registered Charity 1037486
Design: The Ethical Graphic Design Company Ltd
White meat
myths Origins of the Protein Gap
In the early 20th century came the belief that we
should all eat more protein – in fact, good health
rather than red meat on the grounds that it
contained less saturated fat and was therefore
White meat – from chicken, ducks, turkey and geese – has depended on generous amounts of the stuff and less damaging to health.
become the meat of choice for many Westerners. The average nothing provided it better than meat. It was
person eats at least 1,226 birds in a lifetime. Chicken is the reckoned that hunger and child malnutrition in Speed up history to the present day and the
most popular, accounting for one third of all meat consumed the developing world was caused by protein shift in nutritional knowledge is astounding.
in Britain. deficiency due to a lack of meat. We now know that the average Brit gets far
too much protein – it makes up 15 per cent of
Recent fears over bird flu, food poisoning, dubious foreign This myth reached epic proportions in the the daily calorie intake when the maximum
imports and chicken meat pumped up with beef protein and 1960s. A UN report recognised there was needed, according to leading
water have all knocked sales. Yet despite all this, white meat’s worldwide protein deficiency and called for a health bodies such as the
‘healthy’ image remains largely untarnished. High-protein, “global strategy to avert the impending World Health
essential for kids’ growth and for muscle in athletes – you can’t protein crisis”. International aid Organisation (WHO), is
get a better marketing image for white meat than that! Sadly, focused on the so-called only eight per cent.
it’s just another of the myths that has bedevilled the national ‘protein gap’ and the USA
diet for decades. subsidised dried milk powder Most foods can provide us
to provide protein for the with this eight per cent, the
world’s poor. exceptions being fruits (only about
five per cent of their energy comes
Next came a report on diet and from protein) and most sweets and junk
heart disease in 1976 by the Royal foods. The WHO’s estimate includes a large
College of Physicians which safety margin so most people’s real needs
encouraged people to eat white meat are even lower than eight per cent.
Protein Quality Animal and soya products are sometimes called It’s relatively easy to eat enough protein if
‘complete’ proteins as they contain plenty of all you’re a vegetarian and especially so if you
Protein plays an important role in the body, of the essential amino acids. Many other plant choose foods from two or more of these three
forming the basis of muscles, hair, nails and proteins have relatively low quantities of one groups in a given day: wholegrains; pulses;
collagen – the connective tissue that holds the or more of the essential amino acids – the so- nuts and seeds.
body together. It also plays a part in regulating called ‘limiting’ amino acid. Pulses such as
the body, causing heart muscle to contract and peas, beans and lentils are a major exception to Says Dr Linda Bacon, nutrition lecturer at City
the body to digest food and is what makes DNA. this general rule and contain good amounts of College of San Francisco: “Plant products will
high-quality protein. Nuts and seeds are rich typically do a better job of meeting your protein
To make protein, plants combine sugars, which protein sources, too. needs than animal products, both because they
they make from sunlight, carbon dioxide and are less concentrated sources of protein, making
water, with nitrogen from the air or soil. The There is a persistent myth that vegetarians need to protein over-consumption less likely, and
end products are protein building blocks called be well educated in order to know which protein because they are more likely to be bundled with
amino acids (‘amino’ simply means nitrogen- foods to choose to make up for the amino acid other great nutrients such as fibre, vitamins,
containing). There are 20 or so different amino deficiencies that one food or the other may minerals, phytochemicals and healthy fats.”
1200
White meat is seen as, and often promoted by Professor Michael Crawford of London
producers as being, a low-fat, healthy food. It Metropolitan University found that chicken 1000
isn’t even close to being so. Chicken and all contains as much fat, gram for gram, as a Big
rising to 38.1 per cent when roasted. Raw more calories and a third less protein. Someone
200
turkey is 13.7 per cent fat in terms of calories. eating a 100 gram portion of chicken would
Nearly half of the calories in roast duck come get 207 calories from fat and only 64 from 0
1942 1947 1952 1957 1962 1967 1972 1977 1982 1987 1992 1997
from fat – and that’s only when the skin and protein – and this wasn’t the breadcrumbed Year
excess fat are discarded. Without that, 80 per type which is even higher in fat. Figure 1: Meat Consumption, 1942 to 2000.
cent of calories come from fat! Roast goose is Data from National Food Survey
not far behind at 63 per cent of calories. This
compares with one per cent fat in a baked a medium-sized chicken
potato and four per cent in baked beans.
contains almost a pint of fat
In fact, meat and meat products, including
chicken and turkey in all their guises, are the Even organic chickens didn’t do much better – Says Professor Crawford: “This focus on rapid
leading source of fat in our diet, including the 154 kilocalories from fat and 74 from protein. growth has changed the lipid [fat] composition
equally unhealthy trans fats. Not only are we This is probably because, despite having more of the chicken meat itself, and you cannot
eating meat in unprecedented amounts (see space than factory-farmed chickens, organic birds escape that – even by removing the skin and
Figure 1) but modern farming methods have are on the same regime of high-energy feed, little scraping away the subcutaneous fat stuck to
ensured that its fat content has doubled. exercise and being bred for rapid weight gain. the meat.”
Photo©Chava Eichner
Avocado & Tomato Wraps
Serves 4 ¸ 5 minutes
Just yummy…
Photo©Chava Eichner
6 Bring to boil, stirring frequently, until sauce starts to
n 2 tbsp white wine OR dry sherry thicken. Add a little more soya milk or stock if sauce is
n 1⁄4 -1⁄2 tsp dried thyme too thick.
n 1⁄2 tsp dried tarragon 7 Simmer for a few minutes then taste and season.
n Small bay leaf 8 If using seitan/vegetarian ‘chicken’, chop into chunks. If
n Pinch ground nutmeg using TVP, drain. Add chunks of choice to the sauce.
n Dash of soya sauce OR Aminos (lower in salt than 9 Leave everything to cook on a low heat (a heat diffuser
soya sauce. Braggs or Marigold brands available in is even better)*, stirring regularly for 20 minutes. Taste
health stores) and add salt and black pepper if necessary. Remove bay
n Salt to taste leaf before serving.
n Lots of freshly ground black pepper 10 Serve with cooked pasta or rice and steamed
vegetables or salad. Also nice with a baked sweet potato.
*Heat diffusers or simmer rings are perforated metal plates (sometimes with a handle) that allow you to simmer liquids
very slowly and gently. They are available from good hardware stores, kitchen stores and the like from around £4. Best
used on gas flames but check the instructions.
Curry: 1 Put the rice on to cook with enough water to just cover Thai Taste curry paste is available in tubs from Tesco,
n 1 pack plain tofu, cut into 8-12 cubes plus a little oil it – top up with boiling water if it starts to stick. Cook Sainsbury and Waitrose, as well as independent health
or low-cal oil spray to fry it OR 1 tin vegetarian until it is slightly sticky and keep warm. stores and delis.
‘chicken’, drained and chopped OR 60g TVP chunks, 2 If using TVP chunks, put them to soak in hot stock
soaked in stock made from 200ml/7fl oz hot water and immediately after the rice goes on. Cover and set aside.
1
⁄2 tsp vegan bouillon powder 3 If using tofu, in a non-stick
n 1 tbsp oil or heavy-bottomed frying pan,
n 1 medium-large onion, chopped fry tofu cubes in the oil until
n 4 cloves garlic, crushed golden on each side. Drain on
n 1-2 dsp Thai Taste red or green curry paste (see below kitchen paper and set aside.
for availability) 4 Now cook the vegetables:
n 1kg/generous 2lbs assorted vegetables: eg French or sauté onion in the oil until it
other long green beans; baby sweetcorn; red pepper cut starts to soften.
into bite-sized pieces; aubergine, cut into 2cm/1 inch 5 Add garlic, rest of vegetables
chunks; broccoli florets and lime leaves and cook for a
further few minutes.
To Serve:
n 200g/7oz brown rice cooked in 450-500ml water
(about 16-18fl oz)
OR a 300g pack wholemeal noodles
Skewers:
n 1 jar of seitan OR 1 tin vegetarian ‘chicken’, drained,
will make approximately 40 medium pieces – 8 skewers n 180ml/61⁄2fl oz hot water smooth and warm gently until thickened. Keep warm.
each containing about 5 pieces OR use 1 packet of n 2 tbsp cider vinegar 4 If using noodles, cook now according to packet
Cauldron marinated tofu pieces n 1 tbsp soya sauce instructions. Rinse and keep warm.
n 8 x 20cm/8 inch wooden skewers n Large pinch chilli powder 5 Thread the seitan, ‘chicken’ or tofu pieces on skewers. If
n Low-cal oil spray or a little oil using seitan or vegetarian ‘chicken’, oil lightly. Place
n Ingredients for large mixed salad of your choice skewers under grill for about 3-4 minutes per side – but
Satay (Spicy Peanut) Sauce: keep a close eye on them so they don’t burn.
n 125ml/8 level tbsp smooth peanut butter 1 If using brown rice, place it and water in a medium pan 6 Make salad if having.
n 1⁄2 tbsp root ginger, grated on the hob to cook first, as it takes about 20-25 minutes. 7 If sauce is too thick, add more hot water but adjust
n 1⁄2 tbsp garlic, crushed (about 2 medium cloves) Bring to boil, then reduce heat to simmer. seasoning to taste.
n 2 tsp date syrup or a little brown sugar 2 Meanwhile, preheat grill to medium. 8 Serve ‘chicken’ skewers on a bed of rice or noodles,
n 2 tsp tomato puree 3 Make the sauce. Mix all sauce ingredients in a pan until topped with sauce.
Photo©Chava Eichner
5 If using tofu, drain off all liquid in packet, then press
n Salt with kitchen paper or a clean tea towel to extract as
much excess liquid as possible. Chop into cubes and
Curry: lightly fry in 2 squirts of low-cal oil spray until each side
n 1 tbsp vegetable oil is golden brown. Set aside.
n 1 medium onion, finely chopped 6 If using TVP chunks, soak in hot stock, cover and set aside.
n 1 small cauliflower, cut into small florets 7 Make curry: in a medium-large pan, heat oil and sauté
n 1 jar of Meridian Korma or other of their mild- onion and cauliflower for 5 minutes.
medium curry sauces, eg Tikka Masala or Dopiaza* 8 Add stock/water, bring to boil then cover and simmer
n 60g/2oz TVP chunks, soaked in 1⁄2 tsp vegan bouillon for about 10 minutes. (Add a little more fluid if necessary *Co-op Balti Cook-in Sauce; Patak’s Balti Sauce in a jar;
and 200ml/7fl oz just boiled water OR 1 tin vegetarian to ensure the cauliflower cooks without sticking.) Patak’s Mild Balti Sauce in a tin; and Iceland Curry sauce
‘chicken’, drained and cut into chunks OR 1 pack plain are also suitable
Recent fears over bird flu, food poisoning, dubious foreign imports and chicken meat pumped up with
beef protein and water have all knocked sales yet despite all this, the bird’s ‘healthy’ image remains largely
untarnished. High-protein, essential for kids’ growth and for muscle in athletes – you can’t get a
Photo©Chava Eichner
better marketing image for white meat than that! Sadly, it’s just another of the myths that has
bedevilled the national diet for decades.
This easy-to-read guide explains why white meat is not the healthy option for adults or children.
It includes some exciting recipes using meat alternatives, including Creamy Mock Chicken,
Avocado & Tomato Wraps, Tasty Tofu Salad, Mock Chicken Satay, and Mock Duck à L’Orange!
ISBN 978-0-9557653-5-3
All of the health information in this guide comes from the VVF’s scientific report White Meat Black Mark.
To order a copy contact the Vegetarian & Vegan Foundation: Top Suite, 8 York Court, Wilder Street, Bristol BS2 8QH.
Tel: 0117 970 5190. E: [email protected]. W: www.vegetarian.org.uk
9 780955 765353