Lucy's Reviews > A Thousand Splendid Suns
A Thousand Splendid Suns
by
by

** spoiler alert **
For the last two months I have been putting off reading this book. For starters, I bought the book at an airport in Taiwan, which meant it didn't have a due date which meant it took a backseat to many books that I didn't have the luxury of reading whenever.
Additionally, because I've heard so much about this book already, I almost didn't want to read it at all. I've heard that it's depressing, that it's not as good as The Kite Runner, and that it's basically a novel about the brutal treatment of women in Afghanistan.
You know when you read a book or see a film that has had great reviews and you finish feeling disappointed because it didn't live up to the hype? My experience reading this book was the complete opposite. I loved it. I didn't feel the message of the book was one of brutality or depression, but of hope and the toughness of the human spirit.
There are plenty of awful scenes to lend credence to its reputation. While the story's time frame spans thirty years, the main focus of the novel are two woman, a generation apart, whose lives cross as they become the wives of the same man, Rasheed. The elder, Mariam, was born to a servant woman out of wedlock and is raised in banishment, ignorance and eventual rejection during the years the Afghani government was controlled by the communists. She finds herself forced to marry a much older man after her mother commits suicide. Laila, fifteen years younger and raised by intellectual parents, enters the marriage under much different circumstances. Alone after a bomb destroys her home and kills her parents, and pregnant by her childhood love who has fled the country, she marries Rasheed in a desperate attempt to save her unborn child.
The writing engrossed me. Much like the Kite Runner, Hosseini magically puts the reader in the city, neighborhood and house of his characters. Much to his credit, I found myself torn between wanting to yell at Laila to hush up, so that she'd avoid another beating, and kicking Rasheed myself, because he is a despicable brute.
Mariam, one of the most tragic characters in literature, makes this book what it is; a story of love and strenghth. She, who didn't have an easy day in her life, allows herself to be touched by the love of Laila and her children. In return, she performs the ultimate act of love and saves a family.
I appreciate Hosseini's portrayal of a part of the world that is under so much scrutiny lately. Afghanistan, and the city of Kabul where the story takes place, have a long history of wars and occupations which result in a great chasm between different ethnic tribes, Islam, economic classes and gender. Hosseini uses this novel to tell the story of Afghani women and the hardships that face them with each regime change.
As a woman, I feel blessed to have been given confidence and opportunities. I truly cannot imagine what it would be like to live under the conditions the women in this book live under. I am grateful to be born to the family I was born to and in a country which allows me to live the kind of life I choose.
Miram and Laila didn't have the opportunities or support that I have. And yet they survived. They endured and they reached out to others, despite their circumstances. In this, Hosseini redeems all of Afghanistan by showing these two women's humanity. He shows that in a place whose beauty was written about in a 17th century poem, where "One could not count the moons that shimmer on her roofs and the thousand splendid suns that hide behind her walls" is a city that can become illuminated once again.
Additionally, because I've heard so much about this book already, I almost didn't want to read it at all. I've heard that it's depressing, that it's not as good as The Kite Runner, and that it's basically a novel about the brutal treatment of women in Afghanistan.
You know when you read a book or see a film that has had great reviews and you finish feeling disappointed because it didn't live up to the hype? My experience reading this book was the complete opposite. I loved it. I didn't feel the message of the book was one of brutality or depression, but of hope and the toughness of the human spirit.
There are plenty of awful scenes to lend credence to its reputation. While the story's time frame spans thirty years, the main focus of the novel are two woman, a generation apart, whose lives cross as they become the wives of the same man, Rasheed. The elder, Mariam, was born to a servant woman out of wedlock and is raised in banishment, ignorance and eventual rejection during the years the Afghani government was controlled by the communists. She finds herself forced to marry a much older man after her mother commits suicide. Laila, fifteen years younger and raised by intellectual parents, enters the marriage under much different circumstances. Alone after a bomb destroys her home and kills her parents, and pregnant by her childhood love who has fled the country, she marries Rasheed in a desperate attempt to save her unborn child.
The writing engrossed me. Much like the Kite Runner, Hosseini magically puts the reader in the city, neighborhood and house of his characters. Much to his credit, I found myself torn between wanting to yell at Laila to hush up, so that she'd avoid another beating, and kicking Rasheed myself, because he is a despicable brute.
Mariam, one of the most tragic characters in literature, makes this book what it is; a story of love and strenghth. She, who didn't have an easy day in her life, allows herself to be touched by the love of Laila and her children. In return, she performs the ultimate act of love and saves a family.
I appreciate Hosseini's portrayal of a part of the world that is under so much scrutiny lately. Afghanistan, and the city of Kabul where the story takes place, have a long history of wars and occupations which result in a great chasm between different ethnic tribes, Islam, economic classes and gender. Hosseini uses this novel to tell the story of Afghani women and the hardships that face them with each regime change.
As a woman, I feel blessed to have been given confidence and opportunities. I truly cannot imagine what it would be like to live under the conditions the women in this book live under. I am grateful to be born to the family I was born to and in a country which allows me to live the kind of life I choose.
Miram and Laila didn't have the opportunities or support that I have. And yet they survived. They endured and they reached out to others, despite their circumstances. In this, Hosseini redeems all of Afghanistan by showing these two women's humanity. He shows that in a place whose beauty was written about in a 17th century poem, where "One could not count the moons that shimmer on her roofs and the thousand splendid suns that hide behind her walls" is a city that can become illuminated once again.
1568 likes · Like
∙
flag
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
A Thousand Splendid Suns.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 4, 2007
– Shelved
Started Reading
January 1, 2008
–
Finished Reading
October 2, 2013
– Shelved as:
favorites
Comments Showing 1-50 of 65 (65 new)
message 1:
by
Aline
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Mar 02, 2008 07:03PM

reply
|
flag

Lucy, your review was good, but I have to disagree with Mariam as one of the 'most tragic characters in literature' comment, perhaps solely because of the way she treated Laila upon Laila's arrival, and because she's so faceless and characterized as so pitiful, I found it almost hard to empathize with someone so lifeless and accepting of her horrible position in life, enough so to be jealous of Laila and feel she has some right to be the sole female who was mistreated by a despicable man.



Okay, perhaps Mariam is not one of the "most tragic characters in literature," but the cycle of Mariam's "enlightenment" certainly fits the criteria of the heroic journey.
Lucy, Your review was great as was this book. I completely agree with you that this book is not about "brutatlity or depression". Although there is much of that in the book it more about these two women's journey and it shows you how tough women living in that situation have to be and how much we have to admire them. This book is one of my all time favorites.

The only thing that Mariam ever wanted was to love and be loved. She thought she had that for a brief moment when she was married to Rasheed, only to find that his "love" was short lived when she could not have children. Then she meets Laila, who comes into her life and is able to not only gain affection from Rasheed but succeed where she failed as a woman. Her anger stemmed from jealousy. Who can't relate to jealousy?
When Mariam finally finds the love she has been looking for in Aziza and indefinitely Laila, she makes the ultimate sacrifice to protect that love. That to me is a tragic end. She does not go on to live and enjoy the life she wanted as Laila does.
I also think that part of the reason Mariam did not try to leave Rasheed on her own is because of her lack of education. She was not as smart about the outside world as Laiala was. However she was wise in other ways.

Also, I totally disagree with Tom's comments.
And I whole-heartedly agree with Jessica and Lucy that Mariam is a tragic character, and that both Laila and Mariam give us hope that we can endure anything and still find the happiness and love that give meaning to our lives.

no both are excellent books that stand alone

no both are excellent books that stand alone









Bravo!



"Peace comes within the souls of men when they realize their oneness with the Universe, when they realize it is really everywhere, it is within each one of us." Black Elk

Hosseini gave me the opportunity to discover a part of the world, that I can't reach by myself, trough his novel "A thousand splendid suns". As I read the comments, I've been convinced that "the kite runner" will be another triumph that I should read..


The continued harsh treatment of women throughout the world, even in the twenty first century, needs to be told over and over again. Khalid did an excellent job in getting the word out without being preachy.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts.






Nana' love to Miriam , Miriam's love to the 2 children, Laila's love for Miriam, Aziza's love for Miriam and Tariq's love for Miriam.
Miriam faces the ruthless claws of the Sharia Law but she died happily knowing Laila & her children love her much.
