Jr Bacdayan's Reviews > The Cider House Rules

The Cider House Rules by John Irving
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
16587936
's review

really liked it

In other parts of the world, they love John Green. Here in St. JR's, we love John Irving.

According to my dictionary, Green is of the color of growing foliage, between yellow and blue in the color wheel. While Irving on the other hand, is a genius, hard-working, persevering person who can manage time efficiently; knows how to balance important aspects of life. This has led me to conclude that Irving is a much more suitable name for a writer than Green, and has also solidified my belief that Irving is a much better novelist than Green. It just struck me that the definition of Irving is so close to Irving's nature as a writer. "knows how to balance important aspects of life" So true. John Green, taking nothing away from him, has much to learn from John Irving. The hordes of teens crying because of John Green's melodramatic deaths will benefit much more if they try reading John Irving. I think I'll feel much better about the collective future of the human race if the crazy teenage obsession towards John Green was given to John Irving instead.

Moving on, John Irving's The Cider House Rules is a thought-provoking novel that's both entertaining and affecting. As expected from Irving, the novel is filled with characters to feel for. Characters that have the weirdest backgrounds, the funniest thoughts, the craziest names. Yet they appear more real than the real characters in our lives, the characters we know. It has always been Irving's strength, his characters. Homer Wells, the protagonist, is an orphan boy whose search for identity manifests a richness of the human spirit that is unlike any I have ever read. His story is a marvel to watch as it unfolds. During the first parts of the book, I couldn't help feel that grim aura that enveloped St. Cloud's. That fog-like cloud, that mist that was ever present, that presence of loneliness, of unwantedness, of reckless abandon. That feeling that every orphan felt etched inside their bones. The feeling that every woman had whether their case was that of an abortion or of the orphan conception. I felt it. “Whether I shall turn out to be the hero of my own life, or whether that station will be held by anybody else, these pages must show.” That Homer turned to Dickens and Bronte for guidance was fitting. His several experiences with foster homes made him realize that he belonged in St. Clouds. He learned "to be of use". So he became the assistant to Dr. Larch, the director of the orphanage and also his father figure. The relationship between Dr. Larch and Homer Wells has got to be one of the most touching examples of a father-son relationship in literature albeit not by blood. From St. Clouds he would move to Ocean View Orchard. I'm not going to get into specifics, this is not that kind of a review. You need to discover that on your own. I'm just gonna say that his journey towards finding out who he is ultimately ends in a self-discovery that touches the heart. It's a very special book.

One of the most important if not the most important point of the book has got to do with abortion. Dr. Larch did abortions in St. Cloud's and wanted Homer to follow in his foot-steps. Homer, though he thought abortion should be legalized, didn't want to perform it. He believed that fetuses have souls. “Here is the trap you are in.... And it's not my trap—I haven't trapped you. Because abortions are illegal, women who need and want them have no choice in the matter, and you—because you know how to perform them—have no choice, either. What has been violated here is your freedom of choice, and every woman's freedom of choice, too. If abortion was legal, a woman would have a choice—and so would you. You could feel free not to do it because someone else would. But the way it is, you're trapped. Women are trapped. Women are victims, and so are you.”

“These same people who tell us we must defend the lives of the unborn-they are the same people who seem not so interested in defending anyone but themselves after the accident of birth is complete! These same people who profess their love of the unborn's soul-they don't care to make much of a contribution to the poor, they don't care to offer much assistance to the unwanted or the oppressed! How do they justify such a concern for the fetus and such a lack of concern for unwanted and abused children? They condemn others for the accident of conception; they condemn the poor-as if the poor can help being poor. One way the poor could help themselves would be to be in control of the size of their families. I thought that freedom of choice was obviously democratic-was obviously American!”

“If pride is a sin ... moral pride is the greatest sin.”

I have come out of this book much more aware of my position towards abortion. Before I read this book, I would have said that I was against abortion. I didn't like the thought of killing babies, but I hadn't really reflected on the gravity of the situation. With the insights I've gotten from the book, and after my struggle with my thoughts. I have finally decided that I am against anti-abortion laws. It actually doesn't matter if you believe that it is wrong or not. What matters is that people who think otherwise should have the choice to avail it. If I have learned anything in my short life, it is never to impose my will upon others. And I believe that anti-abortion laws, is just that. Imposition of self-righteousness. I'm not forcing my belief upon you, I'm not starting a debate. I'm just stating my opinion. Nothing else. This book opened my eyes, if not removed that veil of ignorance around it. It's just saddening that abortion is still illegal in my country. Here's to hoping that it'll change soon.

Another important point of the book has to do with rules. The name of the novel, The Cider House Rules, concurs to the idea that rules play a very important role in this novel. Actually, it has more to do with breaking the rules. “We got our own rules.” The words of Mr. Rose, the boss of the apple-picking crew, when Homer asks him why the men don’t follow the rules posted in the cider house. Mr. Rose’s words underscore a major theme of the novel: when the rules don’t make sense, people have to make their own rules. Homer learns this lesson when he begins to perform abortions. Although the procedure is illegal, he feels he must “break the rules” to do what is right. In the end, he chose to be the Hero of his own life. He chose to make his own rules.

As I end, let me leave you with an excerpt that I think greatly encapsulates the message of the book:

“It´s natural to want someone you love to do what you want, or what you think would be good for them, but you have to let everything happen to them. You can't interfere with people you love any more than you're supposed to interfere with people you don't even know. And that's hard, ..., because you often feel like interfering -you want to be the one who makes the plans.”
38 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Cider House Rules.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 20, 2013 – Started Reading
May 20, 2013 – Shelved
May 22, 2013 –
page 71
11.87%
May 22, 2013 –
page 114
19.06%
May 23, 2013 –
page 259
43.31%
May 25, 2013 –
page 411
68.73%
May 26, 2013 –
page 521
87.12%
May 26, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Sublime and sensitive review JR! I agree with you about Irving, his novels are not kind but rewarding in the end, you come to care about the characters so much...
You have captured the essence of the book with that review, you Prince of Maine, you king of New England! ;P ( great movie adaptation and sountrack btw!)


message 2: by Garima (new)

Garima I think I'll feel much better about the collective future of the human race if the crazy teenage obsession towards John Green was given to John Irving instead.

I think the same about many novelists. If nothing else, I'll be really happy if teenage obsession would also be given to writers like Irving. Great review!


message 3: by Xandra (new)

Xandra Aw, now I almost regret watching the movie. Great review!
Is abortion illegal in your country even when it's the result of rape, it endangers the mother's life or the mother is a minor?


message 4: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Dolors wrote: "Sublime and sensitive review JR! I agree with you about Irving, his novels are not kind but rewarding in the end, you come to care about the characters so much...
You have captured the essence of t..."


Yeah, his characters turn my manliness into mush. I always end up teary-eyed with his books. Especially after I read A Prayer for Owen Meany. It's my favorite among Irving's works though I haven't read Garp. I hope to do so soon. I'm also currently downloading the movie. Hope I like it. Thanks, you Princess of Spain, you Queen of Barcelona. ;)


message 5: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Garima wrote: "I think I'll feel much better about the collective future of the human race if the crazy teenage obsession towards John Green was given to John Irving instead.

I think the same about many novelis..."


Hahaha. Thanks, Garima! I was just comparing the two for fun. It had a deep-rooted origin. I actually had this debate with my friend about a week ago on who was better between John Green and John Irving. My friend, never having read Irving before, suggested with all of heaven's self-righteousness that Green was so much better because he apparently "wrecks lives". I dunno about that but I just couldn't understand that she'd say it wholeheartedly with even having read Irving.How can she compare? So that's when the whole teenage obsession about crying etched itself slowly at the back of my brain. Hehe. For what it's worth, John Green's quite good too.


message 6: by Jr (last edited May 27, 2013 11:44PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Xandra wrote: "Aw, now I almost regret watching the movie. Great review!
Is abortion illegal in your country even when it's the result of rape, it endangers the mother's life or the mother is a minor?"


Well, the book still offers a new experience. I think you can still enjoy it even though you've seen the movie. About that, yup. Abortion is illegal with no exceptions. So even with the mother in peril, or you were raped, you still couldn't abort the baby because the doctors wouldn't do it. So that's why most people end up going to the unsafe and illegal places. We're a Catholic country, and the priests have a strong influence on politics. Even the reproductive health bill which constitutes of giving maternal care to mothers and distribution of birth control paraphernalia to the poor for population control was already widely opposed. So maybe we need about 10 more years to advance abortion. Ah, health care. That's why the book's message is still very relevant in my case. Thanks for indulging this, Xandra! :)


Will Byrnes Cider House is one of my all time faves. Dolors is right. The film is very well done (Irving had a lot to do with that) despite taking some liberties. And Rachel Portman's soundtrack is divine.

Excellent review.


message 8: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Will wrote: "Cider House is one of my all time faves. Dolors is right. The film is very well done (Irving had a lot to do with that) despite taking some liberties. And Rachel Portman's soundtrack is divine.

Ex..."


I sure hope so. I'm downloading it right now. Will be watching it soon. Also, I'll be sure look up the soundtrack. Thanks, Will!


Jeffrey Keeten I read this another life time ago. Great review, you brought back some fond memories of the book.


Alexandra Hurst This is beautiful.


message 11: by Jason (new) - added it

Jason Wonderfully written review, Jr.

A fun note - the surname Irving is derived from a Scottish place name meaning (drum roll please) "green water". I concede that 'green' makes you think of green, where as 'green water' conjures up sensory depth far surpassing a simple hue.


message 12: by Mariel (new) - added it

Mariel What's with this unnecessary attack on John Green?


Judith Extraordinary review. Thank you so much..


back to top