Mitch's Reviews > The Golem and the Jinni

The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
8170554
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: most-memorable

Just this once, I wish I could say 'The Golem and the Jinni is awesome. Trust me.' and just leave it at that. Not only because it is, but also because Helene Wecker's debut novel is a hard book to put into words, full of wonder and meaning, and an experience I don't think any review can fully do justice to. Still, even though I'll probably miss things, here goes...

Chava is a golem. Ahmad is a jinni. This is not a story of their chance encounter and subsequent whirlwind romance among century ago New York's immigrant community. No, this is one of those books. The ones that ponder the meaning of life and examine what it means to be human, to have free will and faith and hope, using the eyes of the least human among us to do so. It's a mix of historical fiction and Gilded Age myth, Jewish mysticism and Arab folklore, combining elements of Frankenstein and Aladdin in a seamless narrative that's both timeless and modern, insightful yet moving.

I'll admit, I didn't think The Golem and the Jinni would be that book when I first started. Helene Wecker’s writing style leans more toward fairy tale than historical, almost as if there’s a surreal quality that makes her book difficult to place in its nineteenth century setting early on, but, as I would later realize, also lends an idealistic, romantic air to a city and a story that very well needed it. It's fantastical when the story needed to feel exotic, restrained when the tone had to be subdued, but always personal and touching. That said, sadly the first chapter is probably also the weakest, explaining Chava’s origins in that no nonsense, fairy tale way that leaves very little to the imagination, compounded by a story that's slow, very slow, if affectionately crafted.

Yet, as the narrative unfolds, as Chava loses her ‘husband’ to appendicitis and finds herself, alone and masterless, in the urban jungle that is New York City even then, it’s obvious that Wecker quickly turns those weaknesses into elements of strength. Chava, desperately trying to pass as human for her own survival, is taken in by the elderly Rabbi Meyer, and although he’s not unkindly towards the golem, the uncertainty, both for him and for her, of whether she can go against her violent nature hangs in the air. And it’s Chava, created to serve the needs of humans yet trying to understand how to behave like one, who forms half the story. There are deep, profound moments about private thoughts and human nature, and whimsical moments with Chava testing the limits of her body, even eating food and trying to figure out where it goes, and the entire effect is that this wonderfully complex, incredibly compelling character slowly emerges, trying to pass for human out of necessity, yes, but also showing what it means to be one, maybe even a bit about the meaning of existence itself. Needless to say, I celebrated her triumphs, felt for her losses, understood her apprehensions, and hoped for her survival, all as she’s trying to find her way in the world.

The other half of the story is Ahmad, a creature very different from, potentially even the opposite, of Chava. Chava is of the earth; Ahmad is a being of fire. Chava is days old, innocent to the world; Ahmad is centuries old, jaded by his imprisonment. Chava doesn’t understand what it means to be human; Ahmad has the wrong ideas. Yet even before they meet, Wecker has created the perfect foil for the golem, a jinni who’s not less than human, but more, someone as wild and eternal as the desert air bound by flesh and blood, now a fraction of who he was. In contrast to the golem’s uncertainty, his is a restless anxiety that chafes at the limits of human freedom, yet I felt his despair at the constraints of humanity as much as I felt Chava’s fear of the limitlessness of humanity. And in a way, their intertwining stories form a reminder, I think, to the rest of us that, like Chava and Ahmad, we’re all trying to find ourselves between these two extremes.

Lest I forget, there is actually a plot. Chava and Ahmad don’t spend the entire book wandering the streets of New York, discussing the human condition while forming the unlikeliest of friendships, even if I guess my review does give that impression. Sure, a lot of it is about fitting in, being human, some of it a celebration of the immigrant experience through culture, faith, community, even the hope of Lady Liberty followed by the realities of working class New York, but connecting Chava and Ahmad’s story is also one Yehudah Schaalman, evil Kabbalist. The suspense of Schaalman’s machinations adds a bit of urgency to a story that otherwise really doesn’t have any, well beyond flashbacks from Ahmad’s point of view slowly revealing his past while forming parallels with his present, but it’s Schaalman, mostly in the background, ominous and foreboding, who brings Chava and Ahmad’s story ultimately to its conclusion. I’m not entirely satisfied with the (somewhat rushed) ending, particularly with Sophia Winston’s role (though I do see how it mirrors Fadwa’s, a character from Ahmad’s past) and I feel Schaalman as the villain is a weaker aspect of the book than the exploration of human nature, but the epilogue ends on such a bittersweet yet hopeful note I still deeply respect what Helene Wecker has done.

In a word, The Golem and the Jinni is a masterful look at the meaning of life through the eyes of two supernatural beings living in nineteenth century New York. Just by their everyday attempts to understand themselves, Chava and Ahmad, their story, says a lot about all of us.
370 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Golem and the Jinni.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 24, 2013 – Started Reading
April 24, 2013 – Shelved
April 25, 2013 –
page 55
11.32% "I feel like I'm reading something deeply allegorical but I can't quite put my finger on the meaning."
April 25, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Valeria Andrea I demand real review soon... er, please.


message 3: by Melissa (new) - added it

Melissa 5?! *closing mouth again*


message 4: by Mitch (last edited Apr 26, 2013 06:28AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mitch Yeah, it's been 9 hours since I finished and I'm still writing gibberish :(

FYI this is like The Diviners and The Lost Girl but better... well than the Diviners anyway.


Ornella Mitch wrote: "Yeah, it's been 9 hours since I finished and I'm still writing gibberish :(

FYI this is like The Diviners and The Lost Girl but better... well than the Diviners anyway."


I still haven't read The Lost Girl D:


message 6: by Melissa (new) - added it

Melissa Hmm saying better than lost girl would be dangerous..
You think this would be smth for me?? Or no clue?

Ornella, I don't even know what to say to that. I'm gonna be wise for a change and shut my mouth
Sigh


Ornella Melissa wrote: "Hmm saying better than lost girl would be dangerous..
You think this would be smth for me?? Or no clue?

Ornella, I don't even know what to say to that. I'm gonna be wise for a change and shut my m..."


Omg, even you read it already! Now I really need to get to it...


message 8: by Melissa (new) - added it

Melissa Even better i read it and LOVED it!! M even called me obsessed at a given moment .. Lol
Yea it definitely belongs to my favos


Mitch Yeah, I'm a sucker for the kinds of book that makes you think about the story after you read it. Had a HUGE smile on my face reading this bc of Chava.


Deniz Mitch wrote: "Yeah, I'm a sucker for the kinds of book that makes you think about the story after you read it. Had a HUGE smile on my face reading this bc of Chava."
oh so am i! im so gonna give this a try!

a really great review!!


Mitch Now if you'd only read the book so I wouldn't feel like I'm gushing to a wall :p


Valeria Andrea :O oh, dear, I'm in love with the review, I think I want to marry it.


Navdha Marking it to-read cause Mitch rated it 5? Hell yeah!


message 14: by Melissa (new) - added it

Melissa I think he wants you to READ it instead of marking it :p lol


Navdha I have...*looks at kindle* more than 50 books demanding my attention. Let's see when I come around to this. :P


Deniz Melissa wrote: "I think he wants you to READ it instead of marking it :p lol"

cant hang with slow mos and expect instant gratification...


Navdha Deniz wrote: "Melissa wrote: "I think he wants you to READ it instead of marking it :p lol"

cant hang with slow mos and expect instant gratification..."


LOL! True words Den.. *high five*


Deniz Navdha wrote: "Deniz wrote: "Melissa wrote: "I think he wants you to READ it instead of marking it :p lol"

cant hang with slow mos and expect instant gratification..."

LOL! True words Den.. *high five*"


*high five* xo


Kristen Exceptional review! It allowed me to determine that this is absolutely a book I need to read and will almost certainly enjoy. Thank you!


Navdha What a brilliant review Mitch! I don't think your review could do more justice to this book.


Mitch Kristen wrote: "Exceptional review! It allowed me to determine that this is absolutely a book I need to read and will almost certainly enjoy. Thank you!"

Thanks, I hope you enjoy it as much as I did when you do read it.

Navdha wrote: "What a brilliant review Mitch! I don't think your review could do more justice to this book."

Have I convinced you to read NOS4A2 next? :p :p


Navdha Psssh.. I downloaded it the day I saw your rating for the book. I started Rose Under Fire. But don't worry, it's next on my list. ;)


Megan Great review! This was on 3 different "favorite" shelves in my local bookstore. Thank you for a well thought out review.


message 24: by CL (new) - rated it 5 stars

CL This was on my Kindle wish list & your review pushed me off the fence I just started it today. When the 1st few pages catch my attention I know it is a book I can read so we will see how it progresses. Thanks for the review. = )


Mitch Megan wrote: "Great review! This was on 3 different "favorite" shelves in my local bookstore. Thank you for a well thought out review."

Yep it's on mine too. Thank you.

Cl wrote: "This was on my Kindle wish list & your review pushed me off the fence I just started it today. When the 1st few pages catch my attention I know it is a book I can read so we will see how it progre..."

Thanks I loved it and hope you will too.


md1979 Great review, you summed it up perfectly - especially your first sentence! I loved this book - great writing, good plot, excellent character development.


Mocha VonBee Excellent review, loved this book too.


Steph I loved that they DO spend so much of their time wandering the city discussing human nature. I read a few books in a row with very underdeveloped characters, and this was such a breath of fresh air to read about creatures that could jump off the page for how well written they were! I was surprised then that the plot worked so well, too. Sometimes it seems it's hard to have both - characters and a well-driven plot. This book nailed it for me. Love your review!
https://schmidtjohnson.wordpress.com/...


message 29: by Raya (new) - rated it 4 stars

Raya Mitch, I just finished this tonight and the story was so compelling, I read it in record time. But like you, I wasn't entirely comfortable with how the resolution at the dance hall played out, and felt it a bit rushed, considering the measured and intricate pace of the rest of the book. It felt like she was under pressure from her publishers to "tie it up already!" That said, the vast majority of the book was sweet, romantic, thoughtful, and mesmerizing. Like The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay, and Middlesex, this one will stay in my daily thoughts long after the last page.


message 30: by Alaa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alaa Because of you, I read the book:)


Sherril I only skimmed your review because I'm only 200 pages into the book and I didn't want anything to be given away. But your description of how you saw the book and the author resounded with me. I am loving it. I think I came upon it through bookbub and I liked the title and it was cheap. Now that I'm reading it, I would gladly spend the worth of the book. I didn't realize it was the author's first novel. That makes me like it all the more. I'm glad I came across your review and I look forward to writing one of my own. However, I want it to be a nice long, slow read.


message 32: by Aqsa (new) - added it

Aqsa Awesome Review!


back to top