Anne's Reviews > What Jane Austen Ate and Charles Dickens Knew: From Fox Hunting to Whist—the Facts of Daily Life in 19th-Century England
What Jane Austen Ate and Charles Dickens Knew: From Fox Hunting to Whist—the Facts of Daily Life in 19th-Century England
by
by
I was excited to read What Jane Austen Ate and Charles Dickens Knew, a non-fiction trip into nineteenth century England once I saw the table of contents. Everything I need to know for better understanding of classic books is found here. It (includes and) goes beyond the typical topics such as social customs, clothing, calling cards, and housing to answer my curiosity on currency and the calendar, rules of Whist and card games, “Crime and Punishment,” “Sex,” occupations, “The Workhouse,” disease, doctors, and death to name a few. There is so much useful and interesting information in this book that it would be a wonderful resource to keep on your shelf. And the vast number of literary references (everything from Jane Austen to the Bronte’s to Trollope) there is sure to be at least some books mentioned that are known to novice and seasoned readers alike. Additionally, the one hundred- and thirty-five-page glossary is quite thorough. Plus, it has an extensive bibliography and index.
Unfortunately, despite this amazing collection of information, the book reads like a textbook and a dry one at that. While I loved the book references, there were so many, and many not only unknown to me but I wasn’t sure what the reference was referring to (whether it was a title, author or a character in the book), that I found it interrupted my reading. While the topics were of interest to me, I ended up skimming sections. The illustrations/maps/charts were either too small to read the content or too dark to appreciate the details. However, as a strict nineteenth century England reference book, it is a great resource to have on hand.
Unfortunately, despite this amazing collection of information, the book reads like a textbook and a dry one at that. While I loved the book references, there were so many, and many not only unknown to me but I wasn’t sure what the reference was referring to (whether it was a title, author or a character in the book), that I found it interrupted my reading. While the topics were of interest to me, I ended up skimming sections. The illustrations/maps/charts were either too small to read the content or too dark to appreciate the details. However, as a strict nineteenth century England reference book, it is a great resource to have on hand.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
What Jane Austen Ate and Charles Dickens Knew.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 20, 2022
– Shelved
May 14, 2022
–
Started Reading
May 17, 2022
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Julie
(new)
May 20, 2022 02:12PM
Interesting review Anne. I’ve read similar comments about other books of this nature. It must be a tricky balance to achieve, presenting the information in a way which keeps the reader engaged.
reply
|
flag
Julie wrote: "Interesting review Anne. I’ve read similar comments about other books of this nature. It must be a tricky balance to achieve, presenting the information in a way which keeps the reader engaged."
I agree that is difficult to strike that balance. Overall, it's a valuable book. However, the literary references are not always clear and too many of them bogged down the sometimes dense content.
I agree that is difficult to strike that balance. Overall, it's a valuable book. However, the literary references are not always clear and too many of them bogged down the sometimes dense content.
Sounds interesting. While a textbook type read doesn't appeal to me. Do you think this would be a helpful book to improve my Jeopardy watching since there is no way I'm ever going to read all these books and some like Crime and Punishment I just couldn't finish.
Oh yikes....this feels like a missed opportunity to present something truly interesting in an enticing way. Kudos for giving it a fair shot & thanks for writing such a diligent review on your experience, Anne :) xx
Laurie wrote: "Sounds interesting. While a textbook type read doesn't appeal to me. Do you think this would be a helpful book to improve my Jeopardy watching since there is no way I'm ever going to read all these..."
I have no idea about it helping you with Jeopardy. 😂 I only watch movies (never T.V.), but I am reference book nerd so that makes it more unfortunate that this book was too dry for me. 😁I haven't tried Crime and Punishment... It is on my TBR list.
I have no idea about it helping you with Jeopardy. 😂 I only watch movies (never T.V.), but I am reference book nerd so that makes it more unfortunate that this book was too dry for me. 😁I haven't tried Crime and Punishment... It is on my TBR list.
Chantel wrote: "Oh yikes....this feels like a missed opportunity to present something truly interesting in an enticing way. Kudos for giving it a fair shot & thanks for writing such a diligent review on your exper..."
Thank you, Chantel! 💛Perhaps a more seasoned classics reader would recognize most of the references in this book. But what then is the purpose of this book if not aimed at the novice?
Thank you, Chantel! 💛Perhaps a more seasoned classics reader would recognize most of the references in this book. But what then is the purpose of this book if not aimed at the novice?
Kay wrote: "A bit of a miss, but a terrific review! 💖"
Thanks, Kay! Yeah, useful in ways but a miss for me. 😐
Thanks, Kay! Yeah, useful in ways but a miss for me. 😐
Barbara wrote: "Oh I'm not a fan of text-book-like novels, even non-fiction ones. Great review though Anne!"
Thank you, Barbara! 💛
Thank you, Barbara! 💛
Meredith wrote: "Fantastic review, Anne! This sounds fascinating--too bad it was a bit of a miss."
Thank you, Meredith! Fascinating for sure, but I am glad I didn't live during that time. 😦
Thank you, Meredith! Fascinating for sure, but I am glad I didn't live during that time. 😦
Julie wrote: "Wonderful review, Anne!! It sounded promising- too bad it wasn't more entertaining. 💖"
Thank you, Julie! It would be useful for reference, just not read straight through. 🙂
Thank you, Julie! It would be useful for reference, just not read straight through. 🙂