Anna's Reviews > The Last Thing He Told Me
The Last Thing He Told Me
by
by
I honestly thought this was really bad. The writing was poor and inconsistent, there were tons of grammatical errors, and the story demanded a huge suspension of disbelief.
Hannah’s husband Owen disappears amidst a scandal at his job, and he leaves behind a note that simply says “Protect her.” This note refers to his 16 year old daughter, Bailey. Hannah then spends the entire book on a fact finding mission to determine what happened, and uncovers secrets about his past. Secrets that, in my opinion, weren’t all that interesting. Along the way, she is rude and dismissive to multiple people that have the nerve to try and help her.
I felt that Hannah shouldn’t have been the main character of the story. Nothing really happens TO her - actually, nothing much happens in the present day at all. The majority of the “action” is Hannah finding out about the past. It may have been more interesting to have some chapters from Owen’s perspective, or even to read the entire story from Bailey’s perspective, as she is more closely tied to the main events.
Hannah as the narrator also tended to over explain everything that was going on. It was a lot of “tell, don’t show.”
One random example: “His face softens. “No, it’s fine,” he says. “She’s my sister. And it’s just a little sensitive ’cause she’s not with us anymore…”
His sister. He said she was his sister. And he said she isn’t with them anymore.” Umm yea... we know he said that, Hannah! We were all there.
Hannah also had a tendency to say (as the narrator) “that stops me” after people say something important to her. That stops you from what? She is never actively doing anything when the phrase is used, other than listening to someone else talk.
I could go on, but all in all, don’t understand the overwhelmingly positive reviews for this book. It was not for me at all.
Hannah’s husband Owen disappears amidst a scandal at his job, and he leaves behind a note that simply says “Protect her.” This note refers to his 16 year old daughter, Bailey. Hannah then spends the entire book on a fact finding mission to determine what happened, and uncovers secrets about his past. Secrets that, in my opinion, weren’t all that interesting. Along the way, she is rude and dismissive to multiple people that have the nerve to try and help her.
I felt that Hannah shouldn’t have been the main character of the story. Nothing really happens TO her - actually, nothing much happens in the present day at all. The majority of the “action” is Hannah finding out about the past. It may have been more interesting to have some chapters from Owen’s perspective, or even to read the entire story from Bailey’s perspective, as she is more closely tied to the main events.
Hannah as the narrator also tended to over explain everything that was going on. It was a lot of “tell, don’t show.”
One random example: “His face softens. “No, it’s fine,” he says. “She’s my sister. And it’s just a little sensitive ’cause she’s not with us anymore…”
His sister. He said she was his sister. And he said she isn’t with them anymore.” Umm yea... we know he said that, Hannah! We were all there.
Hannah also had a tendency to say (as the narrator) “that stops me” after people say something important to her. That stops you from what? She is never actively doing anything when the phrase is used, other than listening to someone else talk.
I could go on, but all in all, don’t understand the overwhelmingly positive reviews for this book. It was not for me at all.
2772 likes · Like
∙
flag
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Last Thing He Told Me.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 4, 2021
– Shelved
May 4, 2021
– Shelved as:
to-read
May 7, 2021
–
Started Reading
May 10, 2021
–
30.0%
"The main character just called someone in a different time zone to ask what the Austin football team’s colors are. Is google not a thing in this universe? 🤷🏻♀️"
May 12, 2021
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 284 (284 new)
message 1:
by
Hannah
(new)
-
added it
May 14, 2021 06:39PM
I can’t agree more. You’ve put into words everything I’ve thought while reading this!
reply
|
flag
Totally agree, great review! Another thing that bugged me was all of the he said she said I said after each line of dialogue.
Agree. Also was annoyed how many times she said/thought “she’s not wrong” or “he isn’t wrong” in response to someone else’s comments.
Totally agree, this book was awful. I don't understand how it got such high ratings. The writing was choppy and strange and Hannah's character totally missed the mark.
I’m so glad you said this! I’m 20% through and I’ve been highlighting all the grammatical errors and typos (was there no editor?!) - it’s too distracting and I think I have to stop reading it; too many other well-written books that are worthy of my time!
👏🏼 it’s the “huge suspension of disbelief” for me. That’s spot on. It just got more and more unrealistic as from about 60% to the end.
“Tended to over explain everything…’” this is exactly what started to irritate me with the style. I find the story interesting and how they were finding all these clues about Owen but the constant self analyzing monologue it really is getting too much as the story progresses.
Thank you so much for this I agree with everything you said! I thought I was going crazy with all the 5 star reviews I just did not like the book whatsoever
I’m only half way through the book. It’s so boring!! Feels like the same thing over and over again! Wish it wasn’t our Bookclub pick cause I’d be done with it!
Ugh! No real suspense as far as I could tell. The only suspense I felt was patiently waiting for some surprise to happen. It never did. Many loose ends to the story. Sorry, but couldn’t wait for this story to end.
Yes! Fully agree. Every few pages.. “that stops me” and also, someone is always ‘taking something or someone in’. Constantly.
Thank you for this review. Agree completely, but not at all surprised that this is a book that most people love. How many times can the same thing be said in 5 different ways in the same sentence?
It’s just been put away on my DNF shelf virtually and going back to the library today in reality, so that I do not waste another minute on it!
This will be my last hyped Reese’s Book Club selection for a long while.
There are too many good books to read. Time to move on!!
This will be my last hyped Reese’s Book Club selection for a long while.
There are too many good books to read. Time to move on!!
Not to mention the simple math error! She said there were 73 people in the class, 50 male and 13! female. It's such a silly thing to mess up on but it bugged me.
UGH the constant repetition of phrases drove me crazy. Did the editor not catch this, or did the author not let the editor take them out? I couldn't get past it. I really couldn't get past it. Past it to see the story. The story that Hannah was telling. ;)
Completely agree. And SO much emphasis on a character’s eyes. They darken. They blaze. Etc etc.
Also, why didn’t she look up his high school year book way earlier in the story? She had the year and the name of the school. The unnecessary smashing of her phone was also a super annoying plot device.
Also, why didn’t she look up his high school year book way earlier in the story? She had the year and the name of the school. The unnecessary smashing of her phone was also a super annoying plot device.
Terrible book, I really do not get the hype. The stepdaughter was horrible to the Hannah and so unlikeable. Also, am I the only one wondering how a safe was put in the piggy bank? If it's a piggy bank that has to be smashed to be opened, how was a safe put into the piggy bank? Am I missing something?
Love all these comments. I thought my two star rating was driven by my major dislike of the narrator since I listened to the audio. Nine hours of me moaning and rolling my eyes after every sentence. If I had to hear ‘protect her’ one more time…
Yes. I totally agree with this. There was too much repetition. How many times does Hannah “clock” something? And the piggy bank/safe? I’m still trying to figure that one out.
Completely agree with this review! I read it digitally and didn't check for how long the acknowledgements etc. were. Well, there's a reading group guide plus an interview so I thought there were going to be 20+ more pages when it .... ended. Fortunately it only too a day to read.
I don’t know why it annoyed me so much, but she used the word “photograph” so many times that I groaned every time I saw the word. Definitely lots of repetition!
Yes! The writing honestly really put me off. It reminded me of when you’re trying to meet a certain word count for a school essay.
“He smiled back at me. He smiled, that smile.”
We get it. He smiled!
“He smiled back at me. He smiled, that smile.”
We get it. He smiled!
You hit every single point that bothered me! Down to the repetitive “that stops me.” I found the bitterness between Hannah and Bailey to be exhausting and not realistic. If something this tragic happened, wouldn’t they just cut the crap and work together? Both of the characters were so flat that by the end of the book, I honestly didn’t care what happened to either of them.
I haven’t even finished the book and I agree with everything everyone is saying. I am just so confused about all of the good reviews. The book is so bad. I feel like I could get more interest and thrill out of a children’s book.
Add to everything you’ve mentioned that the Austin details felt like they all came from a Google search entitled “things to see in Austin”.
Farfetched.
Farfetched.
I too am baffled by the rave reviews. The pacing is slow, the characters are poorly developed, and the writing is bland. A completely forgettable book.
Thanks for the review. I’m 100 pages in and dislike both of the female characters, I’m not going to waste anymore of my time.
The comment about grammatical errors is simply untrue. I'm a former English teacher who sees grammatical errors everywhere I look, and there were none in Laura Dave's book as far as I know. I have just finished reading the book, so I'd appreciate your telling me which ones you noted, Anna.
So annoyed that she seemed to completely forget that she knew the name of his high school!! From the guy they ran into that Owen pretended not to know. That one detail would have narrowed down the search greatly.
I am so glad you mentioned the use of repetitive language. I am 60% through the audiobook and I am practically screaming because it seems like it doesn’t matter when an character is asking a question, making a snide comment, making a joke, etc. they are always described as “saying” something. For example, pick any number of times Bailey *asks* Hannah how she knew something it’s always described as, “‘How did you know that?’ she says.” Always. Does no one ask a GD question in this book?! It’s the lack of the command of language that has me rolling my eyes and not that invested in the story.
I agree with your review. I have no idea why this is popular. There's nothing here for me to like.
Agree, I don't even think I can finish this one. I also hate that she keeps repeating the note "Protect her".
Way to be super vague, Owen and simpler say “protect her” why couldn’t he have written then a letter and explained it all -saves us all some time. And *spoiler* who would choose the witness protection to be a family again? I’d gladly start over to be as a family- nice one Hannah