Henry Avila's Reviews > Germinal
Germinal
by
by
Emile Zola's acknowledged masterpiece written in 1885, the politics are dated as history has shown, his overemphasis on sex, research and common sense have refuted, this is the 19th century, not the 21st, (trying to sell more books ? "Nana," made the same error) his characters are more symbols than real human beings, with a quite melodramatic plot even, yet Germinal, is a superb novel, which will capture your total interest, the reader will learn much about little known aspects, the dangers , of coal mining in France, ( and the world) ... ironically all have closed now, because of cheap foreign competition...Etienne Lantier, is young, 21, a strong Frenchman, who has just lost his job as a mechanic, the intelligent man, hasn't discovered you don't curse your boss, if you want to keep a job, the too passionate, angry vagabond with a hair-trigger temper, is homeless and hungry , walking in the dark, roaming a coal mining district, near the border of Belgium, sleeping outdoors on the ground, no money , days pass he needs another job soon or starve to death, wondering how his life has come to this sad condition. At last after many rejections for employment, he gets work in the coal mine of Le Vereaux, thanks to the help of Vincent Maheu, a veteran in the industry, the father of seven, his family has been digging deep underground for coal, over a century and losing many members as a result of numerous accidents. They live, the miners in a small company village called Two Hundred and Forty, that's right no name just a number, after spending a short time in a boarding house he moves into Monsieur Maheu tiny home, with his old, sick father, feisty, still attractive wife, seven rambunctious children, a cozy ten people inside, too cozy, they need his salary to survive, ( now eleven) sleeping with others in an ancient bed , no privacy , can't afford that luxury, little to eat, not much heat for the cold winter months.. the poor, uneducated workers are exploited by the mining company. Etienne shortly eyes the pretty teenage daughter of Maheu, Catherine, she seems interested but a complication ensues , another admirer, the good looking brute Chaval, her first love... An infinite talk about a strike, is discussed everywhere , by the miners, below in holes, shafts, a half a mile under the surface, in taverns, in their houses, and walking back home, still Etienne, at first doesn't get involved, he's a new coal miner, learning quickly, though, a natural at it, becomes one of the best . Seeing the appalling situation in the mine, the filthy back breaking work, cramp, uneven black tunnels that go on forever, cave-ins, toxic gases, floods from underground water, the extreme high heat, a miserable low paying job, for what reason ? They die, yet no improvement for the workers... something must be done. His fiery Russian friend, Souvarene, who he met there, at the boarding house, is an anarchist, wanted for murderous crimes back home, fleeing Russia, says destroy, kill almost everything and everyone, begin again , a new , better world will rise. Lantier, starts believing ... he speaks, a great stir of excitement he brings to the miners ... it is called hope, a paradise on Earth soon , no more poverty... a real future, that promises the oppressed, prosperity...what can they lose...the workers will follow him..
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Germinal.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
August 21, 2012
– Shelved
February 18, 2017
–
Started Reading
February 18, 2017
– Shelved as:
to-read
March 3, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Kalliope
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Mar 05, 2017 12:54AM
This was a tough read - read it many years ago.. Depressing but excellent portrayal.
reply
|
flag
This was a good book, Saramago wrote a somewhat similar book “ Raised from the Ground “ which you might find interesting
This was the first Zola novel I read - same translation, too. Apparently, French coal miners revere Zola to this day.
Iluvatar wrote: "This was a good book, Saramago wrote a somewhat similar book “ Raised from the Ground “ which you might find interesting"
Thanks for the info, always like reading Portuguese books.
Thanks for the info, always like reading Portuguese books.
Robert wrote: "This was the first Zola novel I read - same translation, too. Apparently, French coal miners revere Zola to this day."
I understand, no coal mines left in France ironically today.
I understand, no coal mines left in France ironically today.
Henry wrote: "Robert wrote: "This was the first Zola novel I read - same translation, too. Apparently, French coal miners revere Zola to this day."
I understand, no coal mines left in France ironically today."
Only one in Wales, now. Open cast, not deep pit. My grandfather was a South Wales coal miner. When he volunteered for the army in WWII he was refused because mining was a critical industry and deep pit miners were too highly skilled to be easily replaced.
I understand, no coal mines left in France ironically today."
Only one in Wales, now. Open cast, not deep pit. My grandfather was a South Wales coal miner. When he volunteered for the army in WWII he was refused because mining was a critical industry and deep pit miners were too highly skilled to be easily replaced.