MJ Nicholls's Reviews > The Divine Comedy

The Divine Comedy by Dante Alighieri
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2386804
's review

bookshelves: sampled

I propose an extra level in the Inferno for procrastinators and abandoners. I was planning to write a novel where three protagonists commit suicide and end up in Scottish Hell. Since overcrowding has plagued the old Scottish Hell HQ, the protagonists are forced to queue up for weeks on end before arriving at the building for processing. Upon their arrival, their sins are assessed by an administrator to determine which circle of Hell is appropriate for them. But due to cutbacks and financial instabilities, the three suicides are deemed unfit for service in Hell and are returned to their bodies. Back on Earth, the three characters return to their miserable lives, which they want to leave immediately. But before they commit suicide again, they have to break free from their mousy personalities and commit sins grievous enough to secure them a decent place in Hell. As the characters commit petty thefts and minor infelicities, the sin requirements to Hell become tougher and tougher, and they are repeatedly returned to their bodies. They spend their lives building up to larger and larger sins, constantly being returned to their bodies as the world around them becomes increasingly more depraved and violent. When they die, because the notion of “sin” has been completely reclassified to mean the most vile, sickest violations, they are secured a place Heaven for their relatively minor embezzlements, murders and rapes. I started this book but lost impetus halfway through. I was convinced this idea was derivative of other works (the Hell-as-bureaucracy has certainly popped up in British satire) and lost heart. I also lost heart halfway through the Inferno section of this, despite the translation being very fluent and readable. So I am going to the tenth circle, for the procrastinating bolter. (I did read the graphic novel version: partial redemption?)
82 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Divine Comedy.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 2, 2012 – Shelved
April 5, 2016 – Shelved as: sampled

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

Bah. Really need to get around to this.


message 2: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Surprisingly shorter than I expected, only about 450pp (with 250pp of notes!)


message 3: by Antonomasia (last edited Aug 02, 2012 05:03AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Antonomasia Don't read it whilst working in a nightclub cloakroom. Or when at a music festival. These poor choices of reading locations meant I never finished it; in retrospect I'm surprised I got as far as halfway through Purgatorio.


message 4: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Ha, no worries there. I only ever read in complete silence (or, if pushed, on public transport, where human murmurings and train announcements usually drive me mad).


message 5: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Yeah, I've decided to avoid the notes entirely. The poem (so far) isn't so dense with historical and religious allusions that I can't keep up, and the translation seems straightforward, so hopefully I can enjoy it on a wholly aesthetic level.


message 6: by Mateus (new)

Mateus Pinheiro Please write your book. Seems awesome.


message 7: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Thanks, Mateus. Working on something that hopefully will be more awesome.


message 8: by Mary (new)

Mary MJ - I like your plot line and don't see that it makes a difference even if it is derivative. It seems to me to have comedic potential.


message 9: by Carol (new) - added it

Carol I think you should write the book, it sounds excellent. I also think it has a comedic potential - slightly dark humor, of course. Do it! Stop procrastinating :)


message 10: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Only one thing more exhilirating than an author's written books: their unwritten ones.


message 11: by Yolande (new)

Yolande ^That is true, provided that one knows what said writer was planning to write.


message 12: by Carol (new) - added it

Carol If unwritten books are exhilarating, I must be about to burst from excitement.


message 13: by Zatayumni (new) - added it

Zatayumni Zulkiply this sounds like something i'd read! hope you've gotten to finishing this


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

You have got to write that book. I am writing a book myself. I understand the procrastination. Just do it. The rest of the goodreads community seems to agree.


message 15: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Thanks, chaps. I am writing a different novel, maybe one day this idea will ignite.


message 16: by Bart (new)

Bart Van that is one very cool story! I would love to read it. Hopefully one day you would finish it


Biblio Curious Sign me up for reading it also :) What's your current book about?


message 18: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Thanks, Biblio. My current book features a man who moves to a remote island to work his way through the 1001 Books to Read Before You Die list, but his carefully orchestrated plan finds itself horribly derailed, and other semi-amusing antics ensue....


message 19: by Yolande (new)

Yolande One day you should turn your Dante concept into a novella. And since it sounds like a good movie,, it will be turned into a screenplay called 'MJ's misfits from Hell' and be a hit. Move over R.I.P.D. Department! :D


message 20: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Dammit, four readers! I must write this blummin thing then....


message 21: by Yolande (new)

Yolande :D Yes, the people want Scottish Dante!


message 22: by Jacob (new)

Jacob Smullyan You should try Krinst's translation: https://www.krinst.org/works/poetry/d...


message 23: by Zoe (new) - added it

Zoe Pls write this book. Can you please add to the list of sins people who stop very suddenly in the middle of a busy pavement (or sidewalk depending where you reside) to look at their phone


message 24: by Milica (new)

Milica DIY How is your fiction going? Can it be read anywhere?


message 25: by MJ (new) - added it

MJ Nicholls Milica wrote: "How is your fiction going? Can it be read anywhere?"

Excellent question, Milica. Since I wrote this review, I've written a bunch of highly available and astonishingly well-reviewed books. Here they are: M.J. Nicholls.


message 26: by Milica (new)

Milica DIY Thank you for the information. Goodbye.


message 27: by Chelsea (new) - added it

Chelsea This is years late but sign me up for Scottish Dante too. lol


back to top