Glenn Sumi's Reviews > East of Eden
East of Eden
by
by
Classics are classics for a reason
I was too busy to write a proper review of this last year after I'd finished it, but let me try now. It's Steinbeck's epic look at two families – the Trasks and the Hamiltons – in the Salinas Valley, California setting of his own childhood. (Steinbeck himself is a minor character in the book.)
There are lots of biblical echoes: Cain and Abel; the sins of the father; etc.
What amazed me was how contemporary the book's language and insights felt. This is not some dusty, fusty classic.
I'm not sure about the character of the depraved Cathy, who seems to have been born simply evil. But she's certainly a powerful figure in the book, and the mystery around her drives a big chunk of the book. Also of interest is the character of Lee, the Chinese-American cook, who speaks in a pidgin English (even though he's well-educated) because he says that's a reality the people can accept.
East Of Eden is like a lot of great art; it feels like it's always been around. When you read it, it will resonate deep in your bones as something essential, true and disturbing.
Note: the famous James Dean movie only covers a fraction of the novel. I tried watching it afterwards, but found it overwrought and unduly melodramatic.
I was too busy to write a proper review of this last year after I'd finished it, but let me try now. It's Steinbeck's epic look at two families – the Trasks and the Hamiltons – in the Salinas Valley, California setting of his own childhood. (Steinbeck himself is a minor character in the book.)
There are lots of biblical echoes: Cain and Abel; the sins of the father; etc.
What amazed me was how contemporary the book's language and insights felt. This is not some dusty, fusty classic.
I'm not sure about the character of the depraved Cathy, who seems to have been born simply evil. But she's certainly a powerful figure in the book, and the mystery around her drives a big chunk of the book. Also of interest is the character of Lee, the Chinese-American cook, who speaks in a pidgin English (even though he's well-educated) because he says that's a reality the people can accept.
East Of Eden is like a lot of great art; it feels like it's always been around. When you read it, it will resonate deep in your bones as something essential, true and disturbing.
Note: the famous James Dean movie only covers a fraction of the novel. I tried watching it afterwards, but found it overwrought and unduly melodramatic.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
East of Eden.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 23, 2018
–
Started Reading
July 23, 2018
– Shelved
July 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
nobel-winners
July 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
guardian-1000
July 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
classics
July 26, 2018
–
36.77%
"Wow this sure isn’t some dusty old-fashioned book. Amazed at how well the language and insights hold up. I guess that’s what is meant by the term “classic.”"
page
221
July 29, 2018
–
74.54%
"“It is one of the triumphs of the human that he can know a thing and still not believe it.”"
page
448
July 29, 2018
– Shelved as:
1900-1960
July 29, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Dianne
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Apr 04, 2019 07:55AM
Yes! On my top ten of all time list!
reply
|
flag
Dianne wrote: "Yes! On my top ten of all time list!"
Thanks, Dianne. When I was thinking of reviewing, I remember thinking: this feels like a story that's been around forever. It seemed so familiar, so grounded, and so true. Like a lot of great art.
Thanks, Dianne. When I was thinking of reviewing, I remember thinking: this feels like a story that's been around forever. It seemed so familiar, so grounded, and so true. Like a lot of great art.
Steinbeck is one of my all time favourite writers , he has never dissappointed me so far. My favourite of all his books is The grapes of wrath
Chris wrote: "Agreed. It's on my top one of all time list. :) Likely it'll remain there forever."
Thanks, Chris! A phenomenal book.
Thanks, Chris! A phenomenal book.
Louiza wrote: "I Love this book! It's from my favorites."
Thanks, Louiza! Understandable.
Pedro wrote: "YES"
Pedro: Nicely put!
Anneta wrote: "Steinbeck is one of my all time favourite writers, he has never dissappointed me so far. My favourite of all his books is The grapes of wrath"
Anneta: The Grapes Of Wrath is next on my Steinbeck list!
Thanks, Louiza! Understandable.
Pedro wrote: "YES"
Pedro: Nicely put!
Anneta wrote: "Steinbeck is one of my all time favourite writers, he has never dissappointed me so far. My favourite of all his books is The grapes of wrath"
Anneta: The Grapes Of Wrath is next on my Steinbeck list!
Glenn wrote: "Dianne wrote: "Yes! On my top ten of all time list!"
Thanks, Dianne. When I was thinking of reviewing, I remember thinking: this feels like a story that's been around forever. It seemed so familia..."
Definitely a story that has been around forever......inspired by the story of Cain and Abel in the first book of the Bible, the Book of Genesis.
Thanks, Dianne. When I was thinking of reviewing, I remember thinking: this feels like a story that's been around forever. It seemed so familia..."
Definitely a story that has been around forever......inspired by the story of Cain and Abel in the first book of the Bible, the Book of Genesis.
Glenn, you may be interested in the 1981 miniseries. It was a much better adaptation. There's a little overacting that is indicative of a tv series of the period, but it stays true to the novel.
Dianne wrote: "Glenn wrote: "Dianne wrote: "Yes! On my top ten of all time list!"
Thanks, Dianne. When I was thinking of reviewing, I remember thinking: this feels like a story that's been around forever. It see..."
Thanks, Dianne. Yup, you can't get much older than those tales ;)
Thanks, Dianne. When I was thinking of reviewing, I remember thinking: this feels like a story that's been around forever. It see..."
Thanks, Dianne. Yup, you can't get much older than those tales ;)
Chris wrote: "Glenn, you may be interested in the 1981 miniseries. It was a much better adaptation. There's a little overacting that is indicative of a tv series of the period, but it stays true to the novel."
Thanks, Chris! I hadn't heard of the '81 miniseries. I'll look it up.
Thanks, Chris! I hadn't heard of the '81 miniseries. I'll look it up.
I think Lee is my favorite and most memorable character from this book.
Least favorite? Um, let's see. . . could it be. . . Cathy?? Ugh, what an awful woman!!
Least favorite? Um, let's see. . . could it be. . . Cathy?? Ugh, what an awful woman!!
Steinbeck is one of my top 10 favorite authors. He gets you not only hooked while you read so that you don’t want to put the book down, but gives you a lot to think about for years afterwards. I’ve always felt that classic means that it transcends time in which it was written to give the reader something no matter what era they read it in. Great review.
Julie wrote: "I think Lee is my favorite and most memorable character from this book.
Least favorite? Um, let's see. . . could it be. . . Cathy?? Ugh, what an awful woman!!"
Thanks, Julie. Right? Lee must have been a revolutionary character at that time in American life and letters. (I don't think he shows up in the movie.) I just wish there had been a bit more complexity to Cathy. She seemed simply born evil.
Least favorite? Um, let's see. . . could it be. . . Cathy?? Ugh, what an awful woman!!"
Thanks, Julie. Right? Lee must have been a revolutionary character at that time in American life and letters. (I don't think he shows up in the movie.) I just wish there had been a bit more complexity to Cathy. She seemed simply born evil.
Sarah wrote: "Steinbeck is one of my top 10 favorite authors. He gets you not only hooked while you read so that you don’t want to put the book down, but gives you a lot to think about for years afterwards. I’ve..."
Thanks, Sarah. Great definition of "classic." This novel really does transcend its time. I can't wait to read more Steinbeck.
Thanks, Sarah. Great definition of "classic." This novel really does transcend its time. I can't wait to read more Steinbeck.
Tammy wrote: "Wonderful review, Glen. I’ve been meaning to re-read this"
Thanks, Tammy. That novel was so powerful I feel like re-reading it myself!
Thanks, Tammy. That novel was so powerful I feel like re-reading it myself!
Marialyce wrote: "It is truly one of the real great classics. Wonderful review!"
Thanks, Marialyce! Definitely moving The Grapes Of Wrath higher up on my TBR list...
Thanks, Marialyce! Definitely moving The Grapes Of Wrath higher up on my TBR list...
Yup - Steinbeck is probably my overall favorite American writer, and "Grapes of Wrath" is near the top of my all-time favorites list; most of the time it's #1, but sometimes I change things up a bit. Your review makes me want to dive in and read all of his novels all over again. Maybe I will! But ah....... so many books, so little time..........
Thanks, Paula. Steinbeck is right up there with the greats. I can’t wait to read more. I think he was pretty prolific. But it will be hard to top this one.
Thanks, Elyse! Yup, my first time reading this book. But I don’t think it will be the last. “Juicy delicious storytelling” is right on. You should be blurbed on the next edition.
Stacey wrote: "I agree about the hot mess of a movie. But the miniseries was SUBLIME!"
Ooo – I didn't know there was a miniseries! Will look it up. Thanks!
Ooo – I didn't know there was a miniseries! Will look it up. Thanks!
Elyse wrote: "🥰Fun to see this again.
Hope life is going well, Glenn... as in ‘your’ favor!"
Aww, thanks Elyse. I miss being more active on here. I seem to be spending all my critical energy at work, these days. Hope you're having a 5-star 2020 so far ;) xoxo
Hope life is going well, Glenn... as in ‘your’ favor!"
Aww, thanks Elyse. I miss being more active on here. I seem to be spending all my critical energy at work, these days. Hope you're having a 5-star 2020 so far ;) xoxo
Steinbeck is a master of his craft. He was way ahead of his time. I read Grapes Of Wrath and loved it. The only reason I read was it to see was it as good as people said it was. It's regarded as the great American novel. I'm only 200 pages into this and I'm thinking this is better.