Piyangie's Reviews > Candide
Candide
by
by
Piyangie's review
bookshelves: french-lit
Jan 24, 2018
bookshelves: french-lit
Read 2 times. Last read December 1, 2021 to December 27, 2021.
It seems that I haven't known or understood Voltaire enough to appreciate his most acclaimed work. This reading put me straight since I've revisited this with a fair knowledge of Voltaire's life and philosophy.
When I first read this, I found it nonsensical. I didn't know that the whole work was a satirical attack on Leibniz's optimism. Leibniz's philosophy was that we live in the best of possible worlds and that everything happens for the best. Voltaire was highly critical of this theory and argued that if everything happens for the best, then good as well as evil deeds will have to be justified. If so, then there will be no physical or moral progress in the world. Candide was his attempt to ridicule that theory of Leibniz and to counter it with his own that "we must cultivate our own garden". So, what was nonsensical to me at first made perfect sense to me now. And it was quite right for the story to be nonsensical since it was satirizing a far-fetched theory. :)
In addition to Voltaire's criticism of Leibnizian theory, one can also see his pen working against many quarters. The European governments, kings, the wealthy nobility, the rich merchants, the philosophers, the literary men suffer through his critical eye. Voltaire's views thus expressed through the story were both interesting and amusing. And the story of Candide, with his adventures and mishaps, greatly entertained me.
One of the criticisms I had when I first read Candide was that Voltaire's language was unrefined. But having read a fair amount of 18th-century literature, I've come to realize that it was quite the norm at the time. Also, having read this time in French, I found the language was a little less offensive than the English translation that I've read before. And I agree with those GR friends who told me that the translation might have contributed to my disliking the book.
I'm glad I revisited this. It's a book I've misunderstood through my limited knowledge of the purpose of its author. I'm truly pleased that this time around I was able to understand, appreciate and enjoy it.
When I first read this, I found it nonsensical. I didn't know that the whole work was a satirical attack on Leibniz's optimism. Leibniz's philosophy was that we live in the best of possible worlds and that everything happens for the best. Voltaire was highly critical of this theory and argued that if everything happens for the best, then good as well as evil deeds will have to be justified. If so, then there will be no physical or moral progress in the world. Candide was his attempt to ridicule that theory of Leibniz and to counter it with his own that "we must cultivate our own garden". So, what was nonsensical to me at first made perfect sense to me now. And it was quite right for the story to be nonsensical since it was satirizing a far-fetched theory. :)
In addition to Voltaire's criticism of Leibnizian theory, one can also see his pen working against many quarters. The European governments, kings, the wealthy nobility, the rich merchants, the philosophers, the literary men suffer through his critical eye. Voltaire's views thus expressed through the story were both interesting and amusing. And the story of Candide, with his adventures and mishaps, greatly entertained me.
One of the criticisms I had when I first read Candide was that Voltaire's language was unrefined. But having read a fair amount of 18th-century literature, I've come to realize that it was quite the norm at the time. Also, having read this time in French, I found the language was a little less offensive than the English translation that I've read before. And I agree with those GR friends who told me that the translation might have contributed to my disliking the book.
I'm glad I revisited this. It's a book I've misunderstood through my limited knowledge of the purpose of its author. I'm truly pleased that this time around I was able to understand, appreciate and enjoy it.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Candide.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 24, 2018
–
Started Reading
January 24, 2018
– Shelved
January 26, 2018
–
Finished Reading
February 16, 2018
– Shelved as:
french-lit
December 1, 2021
–
Started Reading
December 27, 2021
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Matt
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Jan 24, 2018 02:27PM
I’m currently reading Candide and might agree with your rating.
reply
|
flag
There were good reviews on this, so I picked up thinking I'll like it. I needed a classic starting with letter C for an A-Z challenge. I can't say I like it. But anyway glad to have read it, so I could say that I have read it! :-)
Haaze wrote: "Ah, I loved this book. It is hilarious (even today)! Hmm I need to revisit it!"
There is humor alright, Haaze. But I don't know if it is due to the translation that I'm reading, I find the deliverance a little too crude.
There is humor alright, Haaze. But I don't know if it is due to the translation that I'm reading, I find the deliverance a little too crude.
I've tried to read this book several times! For such a small book, I just could not finish! Hope you do better Piyangie! 🤔
I recently watched the musical version of Candide. It didn't make much sense but the music was fun. In how many musicals is there a song about an Auto-da-fe?
Kudos for reading it through. I gave up after a while (30%? 40? can't remember now). I know it's a great piece of satire and a masterpiece in French literature, blah blah blah, but I just couldn't stand it a minute more.
Marina (Sonnenbarke) wrote: "Kudos for reading it through. I gave up after a while (30%? 40? can't remember now). I know it's a great piece of satire and a masterpiece in French literature, blah blah blah, but I just couldn't ..."
Thank you, Marina. It was a great effort on my part to see it through. I never give up a book once I started reading. That is the only reason that kept me going.
Thank you, Marina. It was a great effort on my part to see it through. I never give up a book once I started reading. That is the only reason that kept me going.
Interesting review Piyangie, I plan to read this, it was going to be this year but, well, ummm one day :)
Inkspill wrote: "Interesting review Piyangie, I plan to read this, it was going to be this year but, well, ummm one day :)"
Thank you, Inkspill. :) I think the best thing is to read the original version of the book, if one can read french.
Thank you, Inkspill. :) I think the best thing is to read the original version of the book, if one can read french.
Hmm, I think Candide was a fantastic book! I found it hilarious! Very funny indeed! I guess we all have different perspectives. After all, that is the beauty about reading and writing! :)
Haaze wrote: "Hmm, I think Candide was a fantastic book! I found it hilarious! Very funny indeed! I guess we all have different perspectives. After all, that is the beauty about reading and writing! :)"
Yes, Haaze, there is a comic side to it. I'm sure that is what pulled me through.
Yes, Haaze, there is a comic side to it. I'm sure that is what pulled me through.
Curious, where and how did you come about to learning more about Leibniz theory? It sounds like that became the key to rediscovering this classic.
Irina wrote: "Curious, where and how did you come about to learning more about Leibniz theory? It sounds like that became the key to rediscovering this classic."
Read online as preliminary after getting to know his influence on Candide. :)
Read online as preliminary after getting to know his influence on Candide. :)