Jaline's Reviews > Ross Poldark

Ross Poldark by Winston Graham
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7234171
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2019-completed, x-favrit-series

There are so many outstanding qualities within this first novel in a series of twelve. Thank you to Goodreads friend Candi for first introducing me to this series with her wonderful reviews. Thank you, too, for the inspiration from Goodreads friend Diane, who decided last year to read this series at the rate of one per month and whose reviews were a monthly reminder to finally start reading this series. I loved the idea of one per month for the entire year, and it became one of my first personal reading goals for 2019.

This novel was first published in 1945 and the last novel of this series was published in 2002. I did not know that this series began so many years ago: it is as fresh and feels as new as if it had been written yesterday. The writing is outstanding in all ways: rich in historical fact, dynamic characters, beautifully descriptive and atmospheric, and rich in its storyline of family, culture, ventures, and adventures.

The novel covers the period of time in Cornwall from 1783 to 1787. It is the time when copper mines and tin mines accounted for a large proportion of the wealth for those in the upper social classes, while fishing, working in the mines, and servitude were the primary occupations of the lower classes. Both classes have a dark side to their ‘occupations’, too. The wealthy indulged themselves in excesses of food and drink (to the detriment of their health) as well as gambling and affairs. The poorer folks’ dark side is more desperate: largely poaching and petty theft to feed hungry bodies.

There is a huge cast of characters in this novel, yet they are introduced so smoothly and with such a strong imprint of their personalities that I ‘knew’ them immediately and intimately from the beginning.

The Poldark family has two branches: (1) Elder brother Charles, the inheritor and caretaker of the ancient family’s lands and mines, his children Francis and Verity, and (2) Younger brother Joshua who dies early, leaving his son Ross the small farm and holdings that Ross returns to after his service in the War of Independence in America. This novel traces the time of transition when control and responsibility pass from the older generation to the younger.

I was especially fascinated with Cornwall as the setting for this novel because it was a part of England that I was particularly drawn to many years ago when I spent a month exploring the English southwest. This book contains a richness of information about the Cornish countryside, its people, and its even more ancient history - all liberally sprinkled throughout the story.

As a family saga, this first of the series sets a tone of time and place that finds me eagerly looking forward to the second novel next month.
171 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Ross Poldark.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 8, 2017 – Shelved
January 15, 2019 – Started Reading
January 15, 2019 –
2.0%
January 16, 2019 –
37.0%
January 17, 2019 –
65.0%
January 18, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 95 (95 new)


Jeannie I hope you are enjoying this!


Jaline Jeannie wrote: "I hope you are enjoying this!"

Thank you, Jeannie! I just now posted my review - and I *loved* this book!! :)


message 3: by Julie (new)

Julie G (I click boxes to no avail) I know Candi loves these, and I'm sitting here, feeling jealous that you started the series and I haven't yet!!


message 4: by Suzy (new) - added it

Suzy Your enthusiastic review might just be the nudge I need to get started on this series. After seeing Diane's book/month project last year, I thought I should at least venture in since I *love* the tv series, but did not act on it. I have the audio of book 1 ready to go. What am I waiting for? :)))


message 5: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen This is a series I need to start!!!! Love your review :))


Diane Barnes Yay, Jaline! I am so happy this first one did not disappoint you, and your review perfectly explains the excellence of this series without giving anything away. Now you have at least one book each month that is a sure bet, when other books don't deliver. Congratulations on getting started!


message 7: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Wonderful review Jaline! I would love to read these books but the BBC tv drama is still quite fresh in my mind. Glad you loved South- West England when you visited ... it’s where I live 😍😊


message 8: by Wyndy (new)

Wyndy Jaline - first, I love your shoutouts to Candi and Diane. I looked forward to each review they wrote and lived vicariously through those reviews to see what happened next with Ross and Demelza 😂 They finally convinced me to add this series to my shelf, and I hope to start #1 late this month. You have confirmed that decision with this outstanding review - thanks!


message 9: by Paromjit (new)

Paromjit Fantastic review, Jaline....and a great series!


Jaline Julie wrote: "I know Candi loves these, and I'm sitting here, feeling jealous that you started the series and I haven't yet!!"

Ahahaha - there is still time, Julie! :) I would love to read your 'take' on this series, too! :)


Jaline Suzy wrote: "Your enthusiastic review might just be the nudge I need to get started on this series. After seeing Diane's book/month project last year, I thought I should at least venture in since I *love* the tv series, but did not act on it. I have the audio of book 1 ready to go. What am I waiting for? :)))"

Good question, Suzy! I have a feeling this series has pretty much done its part to get your full attention - maybe it's time! :) Thank you so much for your great comment! :)


Jaline Jen wrote: "This is a series I need to start!!!! Love your review :))"

Thank you so much, Jen! This one definitely hit all the check marks for me - and I'm not one bit surprised! Some of our best GR friends have adored this series, too! :)


Jaline Diane wrote: "Yay, Jaline! I am so happy this first one did not disappoint you, and your review perfectly explains the excellence of this series without giving anything away. Now you have at least one book each month that is a sure bet, when other books don't deliver. Congratulations on getting started!"

Thank you, dear friend - both for your lovely and encouraging comment, and for the inspiration of beginning this series in January and ending it in December . . . there is just something poetic about that, and it appealed to me in so many ways. The only problem I see is that I will be so busy wishing for the next month to HURRY UP that I will blink and it will be 2020 already! 🤣😂


Jaline Sandra wrote: "Wonderful review Jaline! I would love to read these books but the BBC tv drama is still quite fresh in my mind. Glad you loved South- West England when you visited ... it’s where I live 😍😊"

Really, Sandra? That trip is one of the big highlights of my life. It was when you could still take bicycles with panniers in lieu of luggage on an airplane. My boyfriend and I both had 10 speeds (although I found out half-way through the Cotswolds that my lowest 5 gears were broken) and as we explored we stayed in these lovely B & B cottages along the way. The scenery is far more impressive from a bike than from the train! 😍 Thank you for your awesome comment! 😊


Marialyce Such a terrific book and series. Wonderful review, Jaline!


Jaline Wyndy wrote: "Jaline - first, I love your shoutouts to Candi and Diane. I looked forward to each review they wrote and lived vicariously through those reviews to see what happened next with Ross and Demelza 😂 They finally convinced me to add this series to my shelf, and I hope to start #1 late this month. You have confirmed that decision with this outstanding review - thanks! "

Wyndy, I am so excited that you will also be reading this series in tandem with me through the year!! And I agree that Candi's and Diane's reviews were ones I would hunt for if they didn't show up on my feed. I probably missed some anyway - but I will pick them up as I carry on with the series each month. :) Thank you for your wonderful comment, Wyndy - and I look forward to your review of this first novel, too! 👍😍


Jaline Paromjit wrote: "Fantastic review, Jaline....and a great series!"

Thank you so much, Paromjit - and even though I just started, I can already agree that it is a great series. The writing is just So Good!! 💖


message 18: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Fab review, Jaline! Looks like a great series. It's always great when you find great books from Goodreads friends. Goodreads is amazing! I have read so many books from GR8 friends, books that I would never of read that were so good.


Jaline Marialyce wrote: "Such a terrific book and series. Wonderful review, Jaline!"

Thank you so much for your lovely comment, Marialyce! I am truly impressed with the quality of the writing . . . and wonder how these books escaped me for so long! ;)


message 20: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Fab review Jaline glad you liked this series so far always good to find books from GR friends XO <3 Hugs :)


Terry ~ Huntress of Erudition I love this series! I have to get back to it, only read up to book 5.


Jaline Mary Beth *Traveling Sister* wrote: "Fab review, Jaline! Looks like a great series. It's always great when you find great books from Goodreads friends. Goodreads is amazing! I have read so many books from GR8 friends, books that I would never of read that were so good."

Mary Beth, it is exactly the same for me! In fact, you have actually led me to some great reads as well! As you mentioned, it is one of my favourite aspects of this site - reading reviews and getting a feeling for certain books, for good or for ill. :)

Thank you for your great comment - and I'm so glad you are my friend! :)


Rebecca Huston I first read these back in the seventies, when the first TV series came out, and loved them. Now I reread them last year, and fell in love again.


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Wonderful review, Jaline!


Leila Great review Jaline. Most interesting.


message 26: by Cherie (new)

Cherie I have watched the entire new tv series on PBS Masterpiece. I absolutely love it. I look forward to reading them all too. Great review!


Linda Great review, Jaline. Loved this one, and of course, the PBS series. I'm behind in my reading and must catch up. So good! ;)


message 28: by Debra (new)

Debra Fabulous review, Jaline!


message 29: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Jaline wrote: "Sandra wrote: "Wonderful review Jaline! I would love to read these books but the BBC tv drama is still quite fresh in my mind. Glad you loved South- West England when you visited ... it’s where I l..."

What a wonderful trip 😊. Cotswolds is very pretty, those golden brick villages are almost chocolate boxy . I live even further down, in the county of Devon and about 8 miles from the sea. It’s a lovely area.


message 30: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Five stars for the first of twelve books! An auspicious beginning, Jaline. Charming to read an 18th century piece set in Cornwall. I shall look out for your review of the second book next month!


message 31: by Angela M (new)

Angela M Fantastic review, Jaline. So many of my friends love this series. You’ve tempted me !


message 32: by Ineke (new)

Ineke van Mackelenbergh Definitely a mesmerizing series, that I read years ago. Great review, Jaline. The BBC series is as spellbinding. Hope you enjoy all the books.


Kaitlin Lorelle Fantastic review!


message 34: by KAS (new)

KAS I love the idea of reading one per month of this 12 book series, Jaline ;) Brilliant!! Fantastic review and hope book two you read in February will be just as wonderful!! 😘❤️


message 35: by Antoinette (new) - added it

Antoinette What an interesting goal! Good luck with it. Terrific review. Candi inspired me to add to my TBR list as well- now it’s just a matter of getting to it!


Candi Yessssss! Hold on while I pirouette across the living room! Should I be this excited that you've started these?! I'm so glad you loved it and can't wait to track your progress. Your review captures so well the essence of these books. Thanks so much for the mention too :) Diane is a speed demon, and I wish I could have read at her pace, lol!!


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader What a lovely review, Jaline! I had no idea about the time span in writing the series! And how timeless it has become, too. I need to give it another try. It must have been poor timing on my part. I also am drawn to the Cornwall setting, and while I’ve traveled in England, I’ve not been there - yet.


message 38: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Glad you enjoyed it! Fantastic review!! :)


message 39: by JanB (new)

JanB Jaline, what a great start to a great year of Poldark reading. I love the tv series and I’m sure the books are even better. Great review!


message 40: by Nadia (new)

Nadia Wonderful review, Jaline! I've seen bits of the TV show, but haven't read any of the books, I bet they are all great. Looking forward to your other reviews!


Jaline Lisa wrote: "Fab review Jaline glad you liked this series so far always good to find books from GR friends XO <3 Hugs :)"

Thank you so much for your kind comment, Lisa - I hope that when you get a chance to read these novels that you enjoy them as much as I am! :)


Jaline Terry ~ Huntress of Erudition wrote: "I love this series! I have to get back to it, only read up to book 5."

Thank you for your great comment, Terry! You are almost at the half-way mark - which will be in June for me. I am definitely looking forward to the rest of this series! :)


Jaline Rebecca wrote: "I first read these back in the seventies, when the first TV series came out, and loved them. Now I reread them last year, and fell in love again."

Wow, Rebecca! It is so wonderful to hear from another dedicated fan! It makes me look forward to this series even more! :)


Jaline Marita wrote: "Hmmm, I feel inspired too. I might have to start this sooner than originally planned. Thanks for your tempting review, Jaline."

You are welcome, Marita! I hope you enjoy this series as much as I am so far - and I have a feeling that as I grow more attached to the family over time, I will love it even more. :)


Jaline Meredith wrote: "Wonderful review, Jaline!"

Thank you so much, dear Meredith! :)


Jaline Leila wrote: "Great review Jaline. Most interesting."

Thank you so much, Leila! This is a very interesting and enjoyable series. One of my favourite things in reading is to learn things as well as enjoy a great story - so far, this series has checked both those boxes very effectively! :)


Jaline Cherie wrote: "I have watched the entire new tv series on PBS Masterpiece. I absolutely love it. I look forward to reading them all too. Great review!"

Thank you for your great comment, Cherie! I hope to get the entire series on DVD and watch it a year or so after I have finished the books! :)


Jaline Linda wrote: "Great review, Jaline. Loved this one, and of course, the PBS series. I'm behind in my reading and must catch up. So good! ;)"

Thank you for your kind comment, Linda! One day I will also watch the PBS series but for now, these characters are so 'alive' in my mind's eye that I want to just enjoy them as I see them. :)


Jaline Debra wrote: "Fabulous review, Jaline!"

Thank you so very much, Debra! :)


Jaline JV wrote: "Terrific review, dear Jaline! 😃"

Thank you so much, dear JV! 😍


« previous 1
back to top