MischaS_'s Reviews > The Princess Saves Herself in This One
The Princess Saves Herself in This One (Women Are Some Kind of Magic, #1)
by
by
MischaS_'s review
bookshelves: english, confusing, disappointment, do-not-know-what-to-think, expected-something-else, nevermore, poetry, too-modern-for-my-liking, well-no
Dec 25, 2018
bookshelves: english, confusing, disappointment, do-not-know-what-to-think, expected-something-else, nevermore, poetry, too-modern-for-my-liking, well-no
I love poetry! However, I think that my love for poetry froze at the end of the nineteenth century. I'm not a fan of the poetry from the twentieth century and if this is how poetry looks in the twenty-first century than no, thank you very much.
I'm not going to say this is not poetry though my personal opinion might be different. (If you gave me one page from this and asked me if it was poetry, I would say a hard NO. But, as the author says:
a) poetry is ____________.
- anything you want it to be. )
So, here you have it.
However, in all honesty, I believe that when the calligrams appeared at first many probably thought that this was not poetry as well. I still do not like Calligram poetry, but I can respect it because that's crazy how much the poet has to plan to make it happen! 😲
And now everyone knows this one. ⬆ Maybe in hundred years, Amanda Lovelace will be perceived as the biggest poet of the twenty-first century, who knows!
I also sort of liked what the author was trying to say. I really liked the third part, the Queen.
when you choose
to sit upon a
throne
made up of
lies
&
the bodies
of the people who
mistakenly thought
they could
t
r
u
s
t
you,
the only
thing left
to do
is
f
a
l
l.
However, that was about it.
“no” is short for “fuck off.” No, is not short for anything! NO means NO and nothing else.
The story (I assume that it's the author's life story and for that, I'm sorry because it sounds terrible) however several times I had to disagree with her statements. For me, it was too much pushing her agenda, it tarnished the "poetry" and did not feel genuine.
To conclude, if you like it/love it, I'm happy for you. However, I will stay with my poetry from the nineteenth century or older. Because for me personally this is not something I perceive as poetry.
This would be 1,5/5⭐.
I'm not going to say this is not poetry though my personal opinion might be different. (If you gave me one page from this and asked me if it was poetry, I would say a hard NO. But, as the author says:
a) poetry is ____________.
- anything you want it to be. )
So, here you have it.
However, in all honesty, I believe that when the calligrams appeared at first many probably thought that this was not poetry as well. I still do not like Calligram poetry, but I can respect it because that's crazy how much the poet has to plan to make it happen! 😲
And now everyone knows this one. ⬆ Maybe in hundred years, Amanda Lovelace will be perceived as the biggest poet of the twenty-first century, who knows!
I also sort of liked what the author was trying to say. I really liked the third part, the Queen.
when you choose
to sit upon a
throne
made up of
lies
&
the bodies
of the people who
mistakenly thought
they could
t
r
u
s
t
you,
the only
thing left
to do
is
f
a
l
l.
However, that was about it.
“no” is short for “fuck off.” No, is not short for anything! NO means NO and nothing else.
The story (I assume that it's the author's life story and for that, I'm sorry because it sounds terrible) however several times I had to disagree with her statements. For me, it was too much pushing her agenda, it tarnished the "poetry" and did not feel genuine.
To conclude, if you like it/love it, I'm happy for you. However, I will stay with my poetry from the nineteenth century or older. Because for me personally this is not something I perceive as poetry.
This would be 1,5/5⭐.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Princess Saves Herself in This One.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 31, 2017
– Shelved
December 25, 2018
–
Started Reading
December 25, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Monique
(new)
Dec 26, 2018 04:27AM
Great review! I'm the same, I don't like poetry after the 19th century. Give me any classic over modern poets.
reply
|
flag
Monique wrote: "Great review! I'm the same, I don't like poetry after the 19th century. Give me any classic over modern poets."
Thank you so much. 😊 And yes! I'm a bit old fashioned about my poetry.
Thank you so much. 😊 And yes! I'm a bit old fashioned about my poetry.
Abby♡Books wrote: "And as an English major and person who took many literature classes doesn't poetry usually have to be within a certain rules and such ? I love your honest review . I feel we are sometimes losing th..."
Well, I would like to say "yes", however, it seems to me that today in a quest for something new, all rules are being shattered because why not? Especially in poetry. I, personally, do not like it and do not think that it's poetry. But, I'll try not to be judgy because I think that the first time people saw Calligrams they were probably like "that's not poetry!"
But, I agree with you, what's amazing about poetry. How are you going to get Alliteration, Anaphora, Epistrophe, Assonance and all these goodies in poetry like this? I think I'll need to read some Sonnets from Shakespeare or maybe my favourite Raven to cleanse my poor soul.
Well, I would like to say "yes", however, it seems to me that today in a quest for something new, all rules are being shattered because why not? Especially in poetry. I, personally, do not like it and do not think that it's poetry. But, I'll try not to be judgy because I think that the first time people saw Calligrams they were probably like "that's not poetry!"
But, I agree with you, what's amazing about poetry. How are you going to get Alliteration, Anaphora, Epistrophe, Assonance and all these goodies in poetry like this? I think I'll need to read some Sonnets from Shakespeare or maybe my favourite Raven to cleanse my poor soul.
This is... not how poetry looks in the 21st century, I promise you. Every poet I know who's actually studied poetry has laughed when I showed them these poems. Go check out Kevin Young, Veevee Francis, Danez Smith, Ocean Vuong, and Fatimah Asghar if you want to see what living, breathing, TRAINED poets are doing. Gah, the praise for this book makes me so mad, and it makes me so mad this is the impression people get of what contemporary poetry is! Hope you don't mind, I couldn't resist chiming in.