Krystal's Reviews > Jasper Jones

Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18989854
And here we have another favourite that did not do it for me.

I don't know why books set in small Australian towns are so freaking dull. I mean, there's a murder mystery! How do you turn that into boring?

In this case, tell the story from a 13-year old boy's POV, and make him a philosophical little snot. Don't forget to throw in a ton of Aussie slang, and have the dialogue spelt incorrectly to convey a typical Aussie yobbo accent, just for good measure.

What a yawn fest.

The plot: Town pariah, 14-year old Jasper Jones, comes to nerd Charlie's window one night with a secret. Charlie gets drawn in and suddenly finds himself questioning everything in FKN EXISTENCE.

Instead of learning more of the mystery surrounding The Body, we get to hear about the racism directed towards Charlie's best friend, Jeffrey, and his Vietnamese family, and how bitchy Charlie's mum is, and how useless his dad is, and how PERRRRTTY Eliza is (and smells. Yeah buddy, that's not weird at all ...) Also, poor Jasper. And cricket. Don't forget cricket.

It's another one of those novels where there is basically no action. Unless you like cricket. (I myself had no fkn clue what was happening in those scenes ... do I look like the kind of person who follows cricket? Honestly.) There is way too much talking and thinking and Charlie is selfish and petulant and, sure, a typical Aussie teenager really, but he was just really painful to read. Turns out I really don't care for being in the mind of a teenage boy. Go figure.

There are so many themes that it's kind of hard to get a grip on what the point is. I mean, obviously racism is a big thing, but this is more evident in the treatment of Jeffrey and his family, rather than Jasper's being half aboriginal. Tbh, there's like one line regarding the latter and it made very little impact on the story. It seemed to me Jasper was an outcast because of his behaviour, and his home life, more than his ancestry.

I guess to me it felt like this book just bit off too many themes. Then neatly wraps them all together at the end and you're just supposed to magically understand all the Big Ideas that have been thrown at you willy nilly in the past 400-odd pages. Meanwhile my mind is still trying to figure out why Jasper is never referred to by just his first name.

I get that this is a book beyond the story - that this is about ideas, and small people standing up to big people, and small minds in small towns, and injustice, etc etc. I GET IT. But it is BORING to read about if nothing is actually happening. Charlie just asks himself a bunch of questions for pages at a time and it doesn't progress anything. It's just monotonous and dull and it bored me so much.

Even the ending took its sweet ass time.

Did not work for me. I was wise to avoid it for so long.

I read this as book 5 of my #dymocks52challenge refined. You can read more here.
62 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Jasper Jones.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 29, 2017 – Shelved
March 29, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
March 29, 2017 – Shelved as: dymocks-101-club
May 7, 2019 – Started Reading
May 7, 2019 – Shelved as: aussie-authors
May 9, 2019 –
page 96
24.18% "Almost a hundred pages in and I'm only up to chapter 2? This book definitely talks too much."
May 10, 2019 –
page 214
53.9% "This is one of those annoying books where I'm reading it for the mystery but it wants to spend all its time talking about morals and judgements and small-town, small-minded behaviours. I DON'T HAVE THE PATIENCE FOR THIS."
May 11, 2019 – Shelved as: frustration-nation
May 11, 2019 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
May 11, 2019 – Shelved as: literary-fiction
May 11, 2019 – Shelved as: mystery
May 11, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Alex (new) - added it

Alex Cantone 5★ review of a non-starter for me.


Sharah McConville I really struggled with this one too. Took me so many attempts to finally finish it.


Krystal Sharah wrote: "I really struggled with this one too. Took me so many attempts to finally finish it."

Glad I'm not alone! It's more about the atmosphere and themes than any actual story so it really does drag if you're not into that kinda style.


Krystal Shanise wrote: "I thought it was just me as the reviews for it were really good. I also didn't enjoy HoneyBee as much as most either"

I definitely felt left out on this one! Not for me at all! I did actually enjoy Honeybee, though. Was much better than I expected after the disappointment of this one.


Samm I felt the same way! The mystery of the body felt like a minor plot point to the rest of the story, also the cricket match was excessive and so hard to understand. I didn’t even know they were talking about a cricket match until much later in the book when it’s called cricket. There were so many themes in the book that were hard to understand. I’m glad I’m not the only one who felt this way!


Krystal Samm wrote: "I felt the same way! The mystery of the body felt like a minor plot point to the rest of the story, also the cricket match was excessive and so hard to understand. I didn’t even know they were talk..."

Yes! It just seemed to meander all over instead of solving the mystery. I didn't pick this book up to read about cricket lol


Lucie Miller I actually found it really pretentious and forced. It’s too americanised. Kids from mining towns in Australia in the 60s weren’t that deep or cultured, I’m sorry !


Krystal Lucie wrote: "I actually found it really pretentious and forced. It’s too americanised. Kids from mining towns in Australia in the 60s weren’t that deep or cultured, I’m sorry !"

That seems like a fair assessment, Lucie!


Shelley Antila Maybe if you traveled Australia you would understand?


back to top