Naomi's Reviews > Reading Lolita in Tehran
Reading Lolita in Tehran
by
by
I read this book while I was down with the flu, which added a dimention to my reading as I was isolated in my room for a couple of days. I read some of the reviews for this book on Good Reads and I must say my experience of this book is quite different from what some other people have reported. Azar's opening two chapters were enough to suck me into her world and engross me. Her reading of Lolita was wonderful and I like the way she able to bring her reading of this book, her reflections on Humbolt into the context of her own experiences in Tehran. One of the criticisms of this book that I read on Good Reads is that her reading material is too western centric - i.e. that she gives too much praise to the literature of America and therefore might give the American reader the impression that their lit is 'better' than Islamic or Iranian literature. I didn't read her book choices in this way. In a way, because America became such a central focus of hatred for the regime in Iran during the revolution she picked this material to demonstrate how biased and myopic this focus was, and how it failed to see the complexity of American life - i.e. that books like Lolita or the Great Gatsby were not recieved with one interpretation in America and that many of the criticisms leveled at those books in the Iranian context were also been discussed in America - i.e. that they were immoral or had flawed heros.
She talks quite considerably about the difficulty of becoming as she calls it 'irrelevant' in her own country. She describes the constant scrutiny that women get on the streets if they are seen to be too alluring or if they wear 'pink socks' or let their nails grow or have a strand of hair fall out from under her head covering. I was thinking of this in the light of my own 'Australian' context. Obviously my life is not as restricted in terms of what I wear or how I choose to adorn or comport myself in public. In fact, these choices are fairly banal and mundane. Yet, for Azar this restriction caused her to examine aspects of herself and her society to work out what really mattered. Because the system made socks important, choosing to wear pink or striped socks became a subversive act. Beyond the immediate existential questions of how an individual is able to deal with having their public and private lives so micro managed, I also enjoyed her questioning of the effects of these policies on society as a whole and especially her understanding of the role of literature in allowing a person to understand complexity in life as a whole.
I must say, when I read her passage about the 'trial' of the novel 'the great Gatsby' in her class, I experienced a different book than I had read. She managed to inject me with a wonderful sense of excitement and a desire to reread Gatsby with new eyes.
She talks quite considerably about the difficulty of becoming as she calls it 'irrelevant' in her own country. She describes the constant scrutiny that women get on the streets if they are seen to be too alluring or if they wear 'pink socks' or let their nails grow or have a strand of hair fall out from under her head covering. I was thinking of this in the light of my own 'Australian' context. Obviously my life is not as restricted in terms of what I wear or how I choose to adorn or comport myself in public. In fact, these choices are fairly banal and mundane. Yet, for Azar this restriction caused her to examine aspects of herself and her society to work out what really mattered. Because the system made socks important, choosing to wear pink or striped socks became a subversive act. Beyond the immediate existential questions of how an individual is able to deal with having their public and private lives so micro managed, I also enjoyed her questioning of the effects of these policies on society as a whole and especially her understanding of the role of literature in allowing a person to understand complexity in life as a whole.
I must say, when I read her passage about the 'trial' of the novel 'the great Gatsby' in her class, I experienced a different book than I had read. She managed to inject me with a wonderful sense of excitement and a desire to reread Gatsby with new eyes.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Reading Lolita in Tehran.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
June 1, 2007
–
Finished Reading
June 9, 2007
– Shelved
June 16, 2007
– Shelved as:
воображение
June 16, 2007
– Shelved as:
мозговая-власть
June 16, 2007
– Shelved as:
история
Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Jul 16, 2009 09:43PM
I am so happy to have found your review! I am reading this book right now, and I am surprised by the reviews I have been reading. I am captivated by this book, and I am enjoying her insights and opinions. I'm happy to see someone else felt the same way.
reply
|
flag
Thanks Laura, I'm glad we had a similar experience. What I like about goodreads is the diverse responses one can encounter from any given book, and this book in particular seems to engender quite polarised debate. Given its subject matter is both understandable and desirable. I hope you enjoy the remainder of the book.
Cheers,
Naomi
Cheers,
Naomi
Thanks for your review, Naomi - I too want to reread Gatsby AND the Henry James books she mentions. I think she is a terrific teacher! And it seems to me that she struggles to be fair to those with whom she disagrees...which I cannot say of some of the reviewers here who disagree with her perceptions...
virgodura wrote: "Have you read dabashi's critique? fatemeh keshavar's book is also worth checking out."
Thanks Virgodura, I will check it out.
Thanks Virgodura, I will check it out.
Naomi, I agree with your review wholeheartedly- I felt I learned something about a time and a culture I didn’t know much of before and was simultaneously inspired to read and reread the works she analyzed with new eyes. But I am also curious and excited to read the critiques mentioned above! The more perspectives the better, right?