Luke's Reviews > The Trial
The Trial
by
by
Luke's review
bookshelves: translated, german, 5-star, reviewed, r-2013, r-goodreads, person-of-everything, antidote-think-twice-all, antidote-think-twice-read, antidote-translated, person-of-translated
Sep 07, 2010
bookshelves: translated, german, 5-star, reviewed, r-2013, r-goodreads, person-of-everything, antidote-think-twice-all, antidote-think-twice-read, antidote-translated, person-of-translated
Has this ever happened to you? You're chugging your way through a book at a decent pace, it's down to the last legs, you've decided on the good ol' four star rating, it's true that it had some really good parts but ultimately you can't say that it was particularly amazing. And all of the sudden the last part slams into your face, you're knocked sprawling on your ass by the weight of the words spiraling around your head in a merry go round of pure literary power, and you swear the book is whispering 'You know nothing, you snot nosed brat' through its pages of magnificence as the author leaves you far behind.
If you haven't, read this book. If you have, and crave more of the same, see the previous.
Now, what did the Goodreads summary call this book again? 'A terrifying, psychological trip'. Yes, I suppose you could say that. I mean, it is terrifying, it is psychological, and it makes for one hell of a ride. But, you see, those three words strung together convey the sense of otherworldliness, some diabolical satire that's made a nightmare of a reality that's usually pretty good about behaving itself. The problem with that is the fact that this story adheres more closely to reality than most books dare to dream of doing. There's no phantasmagorical twisting of the entire face of reality. This is reality. And it needs no aid in inspiring the most abject of terror.
Arrests of innocents. Hazy procedures. Courts obscured by other courts. Files disappearing into the dark.
Look at the Law of the past and more importantly the Law of the present, and tell me none of this applies, in the days where banks are 'too big' to be brought to justice and everything from the individual to the government is held hostage from a better tomorrow by the inane struggles of today.
History repeats itself.
History fucking repeats itself.
Get it? Got it? Good.
Doing something about it is another matter entirely.
If you haven't, read this book. If you have, and crave more of the same, see the previous.
Now, what did the Goodreads summary call this book again? 'A terrifying, psychological trip'. Yes, I suppose you could say that. I mean, it is terrifying, it is psychological, and it makes for one hell of a ride. But, you see, those three words strung together convey the sense of otherworldliness, some diabolical satire that's made a nightmare of a reality that's usually pretty good about behaving itself. The problem with that is the fact that this story adheres more closely to reality than most books dare to dream of doing. There's no phantasmagorical twisting of the entire face of reality. This is reality. And it needs no aid in inspiring the most abject of terror.
Arrests of innocents. Hazy procedures. Courts obscured by other courts. Files disappearing into the dark.
"I see," said K., nodding, "these books are probably law books, and it is an essential part of the justice dispensed here that you should be condemned not only in innocence but also in ignorance." "That must be it," said the woman, who had not quite understood him.Judgment determined by accusation rather than by trial.
"We are only being punished because you accused us; if you hadn't, nothing would have happened, not even if they had discovered what we did. Do you call that justice?Guilty until proven less guilty. Less guilty via the right connections rather than the right evidence. Innocence with an expiration date. Complaints about any of the previous injustices accelerating the inevitable, and for what? The hope that the future might be better? What difference will that make to you, the individual life currently at stake? The invisible pendulum will still be suspended over the more invisible pit, and your every forthright movement will still be swallowed in the obscurity of the Law, and nothing will result but a building sense of anxiety and despair.
Look at the Law of the past and more importantly the Law of the present, and tell me none of this applies, in the days where banks are 'too big' to be brought to justice and everything from the individual to the government is held hostage from a better tomorrow by the inane struggles of today.
"No," said the priest, "it is not necessary to accept everything as true, one must only accept it as necessary."History repeats itself.
History repeats itself.
History fucking repeats itself.
Get it? Got it? Good.
Doing something about it is another matter entirely.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Trial.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 7, 2010
– Shelved
October 8, 2012
– Shelved as:
translated
December 6, 2012
– Shelved as:
german
February 1, 2013
–
Started Reading
February 5, 2013
–
18.88%
""I see," said K., nodding, "these books are probably law books, and it is an essential part of the justice dispensed here that you should be condemned not only in innocence but also in ignorance." "That must be it," said the woman, who had not quite understood him."
page
54
February 5, 2013
–
32.52%
"My god. It's the shaming of rape decriers spiel. No wonder everything's Kafkaesque nowadays."
page
93
February 14, 2013
–
81.82%
""Won't you come down here?" Said K. "You haven't got to preach a sermon. Come down beside me." "I can come down now," said the priest, perhaps repenting of his outburst. While he detached the lamp from its hook he said: "I had to speak to you first from a distance. Otherwise I am too easily influenced and tend to forget my duty.""
page
234
February 15, 2013
– Shelved as:
5-star
February 15, 2013
– Shelved as:
reviewed
February 15, 2013
–
Finished Reading
April 26, 2014
– Shelved as:
r-2013
September 16, 2014
– Shelved as:
r-goodreads
September 6, 2016
– Shelved as:
person-of-everything
September 6, 2016
– Shelved as:
antidote-think-twice-all
September 6, 2016
– Shelved as:
antidote-think-twice-read
February 24, 2018
– Shelved as:
antidote-translated
February 24, 2018
– Shelved as:
person-of-translated
Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Scribble
(new)
Feb 16, 2013 01:34AM
All the words in the damn world and change is still inspired by not pens but drawn swords.
reply
|
flag
Aubrey wrote: "Doing something about it is another matter entirely."
It isn't only governments we must battle, but friends and peers who think we should put up and shut up. Most oppression is voluntarily complied with.
"He has honor if he holds himself to an ideal of conduct though it is inconvenient, unprofitable, or dangerous to do so."
Walter Lippmann
It isn't only governments we must battle, but friends and peers who think we should put up and shut up. Most oppression is voluntarily complied with.
"He has honor if he holds himself to an ideal of conduct though it is inconvenient, unprofitable, or dangerous to do so."
Walter Lippmann
I love how Kafka makes the byzantine court system seem so darned normal, like everyone's just going along with it, despite its obvious corruption. No big deal. All is well here.
Scary.
Scary.
I have had the pleasure of being forced to cope with an insane judicial system. Thankfully not in a criminal matter, but nonetheless..
The Trial held a special place in my consciousness while coping with this madness. It is truer even today than it once was.
The Trial held a special place in my consciousness while coping with this madness. It is truer even today than it once was.
Will wrote: "I have had the pleasure of being forced to cope with an insane judicial system. Thankfully not in a criminal matter, but nonetheless..
The Trial held a special place in my consciousness while copi..."
While not having to deal with an insane judicial system, the run-arounds I'm getting from my phone provider is plenty enough for me. This novel could have been written about Verizon's internet customer service. Truth is sometimes stranger than fiction.
The Trial held a special place in my consciousness while copi..."
While not having to deal with an insane judicial system, the run-arounds I'm getting from my phone provider is plenty enough for me. This novel could have been written about Verizon's internet customer service. Truth is sometimes stranger than fiction.
Rock on, fabulous review. I love endings of books that just kick you right in the head. I'm going to HAVE to read this, this review got me so excited that I want to rush back to work through this terrible snow storm and buy the book ha. Great work, as always.
ps wait, does history repeat itself?
ps wait, does history repeat itself?
@Scribble: And those who write will never feel that their contribution is enough.
@Ian: Yep. There are worse things in this world than social justice blogging. Much worse.
@Newengland: Excellent! I'm very glad to hear that.
@Nick: Wonderful feeling, isn't it.
@Forrest: He was a genius. An amazing genius that felt his writing was horrible and wanted everything to be burnt after his death. It tears at my heart.
@Will: You know what's scarier than the truth of it all? The thought of someone using this book as a life manual for success. *shudders*
@s.penkevich: Yesss. Read it, so you can feel as angry/depressed/conflicted about it as I do!
Wait, that came out wrong.
...
Oh just read it. It's Kafka, you'll get lit cred if nothing else.
@Ian: Yep. There are worse things in this world than social justice blogging. Much worse.
@Newengland: Excellent! I'm very glad to hear that.
@Nick: Wonderful feeling, isn't it.
@Forrest: He was a genius. An amazing genius that felt his writing was horrible and wanted everything to be burnt after his death. It tears at my heart.
@Will: You know what's scarier than the truth of it all? The thought of someone using this book as a life manual for success. *shudders*
@s.penkevich: Yesss. Read it, so you can feel as angry/depressed/conflicted about it as I do!
Wait, that came out wrong.
...
Oh just read it. It's Kafka, you'll get lit cred if nothing else.
Haha, that's alright, I completely understand. The best books are the ones that leave the reader in a bit of a stupor.
Aubrey wrote: "@Ian: Yep. There are worse things in this world than social justice blogging. Much worse."
I'm not sure that I understand your response, Aubrey.
Genuine social justice blogging is part of the solution, not the problem.
"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men [and women] do nothing."
Doing nothing starts when good men and women remain silent and say nothing.
Bad laws and bad governments survive, because 99.99% of people put up and shut up, they conform. They don't resist in thought, word or deed. They say, it's not my problem, who am I to intervene?
There has always been some suggestion that Kafka might have been inspired by The Dreyfus Affair.
There can be no greater social justice blog than Emile Zola's "J'Accuse...!"
http://www9.georgetown.edu/faculty/gu...
"The definitive eulogy for Zola, however, had been given at his burial in 1902, when writer Anatole France declared: 'He was a moment in the conscience of man.' "
I'm not sure that I understand your response, Aubrey.
Genuine social justice blogging is part of the solution, not the problem.
"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men [and women] do nothing."
Doing nothing starts when good men and women remain silent and say nothing.
Bad laws and bad governments survive, because 99.99% of people put up and shut up, they conform. They don't resist in thought, word or deed. They say, it's not my problem, who am I to intervene?
There has always been some suggestion that Kafka might have been inspired by The Dreyfus Affair.
There can be no greater social justice blog than Emile Zola's "J'Accuse...!"
http://www9.georgetown.edu/faculty/gu...
"The definitive eulogy for Zola, however, had been given at his burial in 1902, when writer Anatole France declared: 'He was a moment in the conscience of man.' "
Ian wrote: "Aubrey wrote: "@Ian: Yep. There are worse things in this world than social justice blogging. Much worse."
I'm not sure that I understand your response, Aubrey.
Genuine social justice blogging is ..."
Ah, sorry about that. To clarify, I am in full support of social justice blogging. But recently there's been a growing argument against it, mainly due to the poisonous environment that sometimes results from all the offended people seemingly condemning everyone else for everything. My point was that there are worse environments thing to be in than something like that. Not that SJB is a bad thing because of that one unfortunate side effect.
I'm not sure that I understand your response, Aubrey.
Genuine social justice blogging is ..."
Ah, sorry about that. To clarify, I am in full support of social justice blogging. But recently there's been a growing argument against it, mainly due to the poisonous environment that sometimes results from all the offended people seemingly condemning everyone else for everything. My point was that there are worse environments thing to be in than something like that. Not that SJB is a bad thing because of that one unfortunate side effect.
Thanks, Aubrey.
Conservatism has an amazing ability to paint the complainant as the cause of the problem and their complaint as the poison.
They continue to do it when they demonise "political correctness".
It's also why the media report protest marches as inconveniences to traffic.
Freedom of speech is ideal, as long as we don't use it!
Kafka and Zola wrote prototypical social justice blogs and I admire them for their courage.
Conservatism has an amazing ability to paint the complainant as the cause of the problem and their complaint as the poison.
They continue to do it when they demonise "political correctness".
It's also why the media report protest marches as inconveniences to traffic.
Freedom of speech is ideal, as long as we don't use it!
Kafka and Zola wrote prototypical social justice blogs and I admire them for their courage.
Aubrey wrote: "...Oh just read it. It's Kafka, you'll get lit cred if nothing else. "
I don't know whether to applaud or condemn the basis of that exhortation, though given your review, I'll go for the former. ;)
In a similar vein, I'd also point out that it's quite short (though some of the sentences and paragraphs are not)!
I don't know whether to applaud or condemn the basis of that exhortation, though given your review, I'll go for the former. ;)
In a similar vein, I'd also point out that it's quite short (though some of the sentences and paragraphs are not)!
Cecily, I've spent the majority of my life among people who for the most part have abysmal opinions about reading. The occasional spoon-feeding is a result of that.
And while it is rather short, that does not affect its difficulty in the slightest. Enhances it, rather, as you have less time to become accustomed to the story before it's all over.
And while it is rather short, that does not affect its difficulty in the slightest. Enhances it, rather, as you have less time to become accustomed to the story before it's all over.
I know you weren't criticizing. I just felt the need to explain myself. Bit of self-analyzation, really.
Aubrey wrote: "And while it is rather short"
It's short because, like practically everything Kafka wrote, it was never finished.
The Trial was one of the most important factors in my coming to love books. I read it first when I was 18 or something, at least twice since. Didn't realize literature could make me feel that way and see the world entirely differently, make my actual perceptions work differently with the world until this one and K's stories. Everything by the man is touched by deep, deep prophecy. If the 20th century only created him it would have been done and fulfilled. God I need to revisit his entire body of work. All hail Max Brod, saver of texts from flames!
It's short because, like practically everything Kafka wrote, it was never finished.
The Trial was one of the most important factors in my coming to love books. I read it first when I was 18 or something, at least twice since. Didn't realize literature could make me feel that way and see the world entirely differently, make my actual perceptions work differently with the world until this one and K's stories. Everything by the man is touched by deep, deep prophecy. If the 20th century only created him it would have been done and fulfilled. God I need to revisit his entire body of work. All hail Max Brod, saver of texts from flames!
Geoff wrote: "Aubrey wrote: "And while it is rather short"
It's short because, like practically everything Kafka wrote, it was never finished.
The Trial was one of the most important factors in my coming to lo..."
Preach it. You know, Kafka was one of those authors that I heard about constantly all my life, to the point that I subconsciously resisted believing that he could measure up to his reputation.
It was a joy to be proven wrong.
It's short because, like practically everything Kafka wrote, it was never finished.
The Trial was one of the most important factors in my coming to lo..."
Preach it. You know, Kafka was one of those authors that I heard about constantly all my life, to the point that I subconsciously resisted believing that he could measure up to his reputation.
It was a joy to be proven wrong.
While my point is not to be taken in any comparison to the history of injustice and the countless deaths stamped beneath its boot, the book also works on a smaller but profound metaphorical level. The Trial can also refer to the relentless and inescapable condemnation of the self by the self without the need of evidence or folders, the suffering of those whose guilt cannot be questioned since self inflicted and therefore no defense is to be mounted.
Exellent point, Stephen. I'd never of thought of it on my own, but now that you've mentioned it, I can fully attest to the accuracy of that statement, in light of personal experience.
Aubrey wrote: "Ezxellent point, Stephen. I'd never of thought of it on my own, but now that you've mentioned it, I can fully attest to the accuracy of that statement, in light of personal experience."
In light Aubrey of all our experience, to differing degrees, as human beings. I forgot to mention, great review. Congrats.
In light Aubrey of all our experience, to differing degrees, as human beings. I forgot to mention, great review. Congrats.
That happens to me at the end of most novels I read. Sometimes even to tears. The closing words of a novel seem to me to be one of the most important weapons an author uses to really bring out the emotions in readers. This hit me especially in the closing paragraphs of "The Great Gatsby"
You couldn't have said it any better!! I was ready to give it 4 stars two and then the ending happened.......and I sat there in shock for a few minutes.