WarpDrive's Reviews > The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany
The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany
by
by
This is a classic. A very detailed, almost day-by-day account of this momentous period of World history. Relevant primary sources, including documents used in Nuremberg, are persuasively referenced throughout the account.
The book is an important reference to whoever is interested in the period; however there are a few issues with it:
- you can see that the author was a journalist writing as though he were a historian. On the positive side, this makes for a fresh, vivid and compelling narrative, but on the negative side there is, in parts of the book, a substantial lack of depth and of nuance, and the underlying complex background of economic, cultural, social aspects is not explored at a level that a professional historian would naturally go down to. Thus, rather than a "history" of Nazism, this should probably be described as a "chronicle" of Nazism
- the lack of accompanying maps is really frustrating at times. This is especially relevant when describing particular military events such as the invasion of Norway and of Belgium/Holland/France, where, without the support of an accompanying map, it is close to impossible to gain a real appreciation of the developments of the war.
Overall, however, it is an interesting book recommended to whoever is interested in this period. It might not be the most rewarding book for readers interested in deep historical analysis, but it provides a very interesting, vivid account of this period.
The book is an important reference to whoever is interested in the period; however there are a few issues with it:
- you can see that the author was a journalist writing as though he were a historian. On the positive side, this makes for a fresh, vivid and compelling narrative, but on the negative side there is, in parts of the book, a substantial lack of depth and of nuance, and the underlying complex background of economic, cultural, social aspects is not explored at a level that a professional historian would naturally go down to. Thus, rather than a "history" of Nazism, this should probably be described as a "chronicle" of Nazism
- the lack of accompanying maps is really frustrating at times. This is especially relevant when describing particular military events such as the invasion of Norway and of Belgium/Holland/France, where, without the support of an accompanying map, it is close to impossible to gain a real appreciation of the developments of the war.
Overall, however, it is an interesting book recommended to whoever is interested in this period. It might not be the most rewarding book for readers interested in deep historical analysis, but it provides a very interesting, vivid account of this period.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 15, 2014
–
Started Reading
December 15, 2014
– Shelved
December 15, 2014
– Shelved as:
history_modern
December 30, 2014
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)
date
newest »
Ted wrote: "I've rated the book as you have, Fortunr. Very nice review with the pluses and minuses."
Thank you Ted, I appreciate your feedback :-)
Thank you Ted, I appreciate your feedback :-)
Reading this one now, and already captivated by it. I find that it is helpful to read a chronicle, for a layman like me, before going into historical analysis.
Fine review.
Fine review.
Nandakishore wrote: "Reading this one now, and already captivated by it. I find that it is helpful to read a chronicle, for a layman like me, before going into historical analysis.
Fine review."
Thank you Nandakishore, I am confident that you will enjoy this book. It is quite a riveting account, and well written.
Fine review."
Thank you Nandakishore, I am confident that you will enjoy this book. It is quite a riveting account, and well written.
Thank you Warp, your review makes it a clear and simple decision, just bought it, will read it soon.
Thank you Sabah! :-)
Too many history books tend to neglect this important aspect, unfortunately. At times it can be quite frustrating. Another thing that is frequently missing is an accompanying timeline - equally frustrating.