For the poet H.D. and the novelist Thomas Pynchon, a personified World War II represents the masculine appropriation of a feminine, reproductive Nature. I argue that Pynchon’s notions of nature and war are partly developed in response to...
moreFor the poet H.D. and the novelist Thomas Pynchon, a personified World War II represents the masculine appropriation of a feminine, reproductive Nature. I argue that Pynchon’s notions of nature and war are partly developed in response to H.D.’s mystical depictions of gender, especially her sense that we must choose between the “resurrections” of nature gods and of modern warfare. Where H.D. in Trilogy conjures a new Eve to resurrect a war-ravaged nature, Pynchon despairs that men will never again reproduce anything but more structures of death.
Pynchon’s Gravity’s Rainbow’s opens with a bitterly ironic paraphrase of a male credo of nature; here Wernher Von Braun, the German rocket engineer, claims: “Nature does not know extinction; all it knows is transformation. Everything science has taught me, and continues to teach me, strengthens my belief in the continuity of our spiritual existence after death.” This nature can not kill, or at least can kill only physical selves, leaving spirit and species abstractly immortal. Even the matter of our bodies can’t be destroyed, but is perpetually converted into new shapes to serve Nature; this process also makes our seemingly intrinsic identities wholly malleable. But these transformations precisely epitomize the function of Pynchon’s demonic war, not H.D.’s benign transcendental nature. As suggested by the source of Pynchon’s opening passage—a designer of weapons—it is war, not nature, that now controls a
“spiritual existence after death,” but not through resurrection, but war recycling. The war, not nature, comes to oversee a ceaseless shuffling of recycled human parts, without creation or extinction. In earlier transcendental American literature, nature had controlled a complex series of transformations, for example animating inanimate matter to life. (We encounter much the same questions we do in Moby-Dick: does nature have a human or inhuman will, and is it worse to be killed by a purposive nature or by blind chance?) In Gravity’s Rainbow, the war usurps this transcendental American function, and like nature it knows no extinction, only the perpetual transformation of its subjects. Pynchon’s war is transcendental because, like Von Braun’s nature, it guarantees death to the individual but immortality to the species. To the war, all matter,
including human bodies, is plastic and can be restructured as anything.