Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Right to counsel / Azhar Musa

1986

RIGHT TO COUNSEL BY AZHAR BIN ttJSA (ATT) (82803872) SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE DIPLOMA IN LAW AT THE MARA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY SHAH ALAM, SELANGOR. MAY 1986 The right to counsel was not an in,tended topic of my oroject paper until I came across an" interesting article by Ta"n Sri Mohammad Salleh bin Abbas. title "Riqht of an arrested person to consult counsel". When the project paper was imposed on every final year students. and upon spotting the article by Tan Sri Mohanvnad Salleh Abbas. it qive me the interest and idea to write on this topic with the intentio'n of hiqhliqhting the adequacy or otherwise of laws pertaining I Right to Counsell and also to see the extend and developments. problems as well as to look into various ways of over coming problems faced by the arrested person to consul t his counsel. Mara Institute of Technology Shah Alam. May. 1986 Preface Acknow Iedgements Li sts of Cases Table of Statutes ~ Chapter I The nature of the prob Iem - 2 - 5 of the study e~opruP Research methodology Limi tat ions Chapter II Introduction 6 - 16 CIlc1pLer III During InvesLigation 1. Introduction 2. Grounds to refllse vis i t 17 18 - 21 3. Po lice Interrogat i on 21 - 27 4. Conclusion 27 by COUllse I PRESENTING THE PROBLEM 1. The nature of the problem The history of the consideration of human rights may be described as the history of the development of man. It has been the story of man I s emergence from a stage of ignorance and lack of concern about his fellowmen to a stage of high concern. project paper is written in furtherance of this history. the main problem to be discussed is on human rights. This Here By now it must be noticed that a Constitution which 'guarantees I or 'protects I human rights does so in such statements as person shall etc. I Many ph i losophers th i nk that I no rights I are re 1ati ve to the society in which they exist or assumed to exist. I I or something to that effect. Burke, in his, Reflections of the French Revol ution I , cast scorn on the whole notion of natural rights, that is, rights belonging to all men at all times as part of thei r nature. Part II of the Malaysian Consti tution relating to fundamental 1iberties of the individual is an important part of the basis of the constitution. Like all written constitutions of demo- cratic countries the Malaysian Constitution protects and guarantees with certain exceptions the 1iberties of the people. - 1 - One of the virtues of a written constitution is to express protection or guarantees which may be given by the constitution to citizens and other persons. Here different co~ntries may differ in their protection of individual rights and liberties. The question here is whether the I right I has been provided equally and fairly? In considering these questions. it seemed to us.that a convnon naLionJliLy was Lite basis upon. which a unified Malaysian nation was to be created and that under a democratic form of Government it was inherent that all the citizens of Malaysia. irrespective of race. creed or culture. should enjoy certain fundamental rights including equality before the law. We found it difficult. therefore. to reconcile the terms of reference if the protection signified the granting of special privileges. permanently. to one community only and not to others. According to Tunku Abdul Rahman Putra Al Haj: "in an independent Malaysia all nationals should be accorded equal rights, privileges and opportun it ies and there must not be discrimination on grounds of race and creed ... "