Academia.eduAcademia.edu

xHaul Technology and Economics (macro-cell centric)

2022, Cambridge Wireless eMBB SIG

This presentation reviews 5G RAN functional decomposition along with RAN architecture evolution before exploring technical solutions for fronthaul transport. The relative techno-economics are presented along with considerations based on an evolution towards vRAN and Open RAN.

xHaul Technology and Economics (macro-cell centric) Andy Sutton Principal Network Architect BT Networks May 2022 Contents • RAN functional decomposition • RAN architecture • Spectrum, antenna systems and fronthaul interfaces… • Fronthaul transmission and transport network solutions • Techno-economic model • Implications of Open RAN (O-RAN Alliance) • Lab environment, experimentation and testing • Summary 2 gNB and RAN functional decomposition gNB NR (air) interface RU* CPRI eCPRI DU F1 interface CU S1 interface (EPC+) - NSA N2/N3 interfaces (NGC) - SA X2-c & X2-u for NSA Xn-c & Xn-u for SA 3 * RU could be integrated within AAU (mMIMO) or standalone RU (RRU/RRH) with coaxial connections to passive antenna (typically 8T8R) CU control and user plane separation X2-c for NSA Xn-c for SA CU-c NR (air) interface RU* CPRI eCPRI DU N2 (NGC) - SA E1 CU-u X2-u for NSA Xn-u for SA 4 S1-c (EPC+) - NSA * RU could be integrated within AAU (mMIMO) or standalone RU (RRU/RRH) with coaxial connections to passive antenna (typically 8T8R) S1-u (EPC+) - NSA N3 (NGC) - SA 5G RAN functional entities and interfaces Option 8 CU DU Option 7 CU DU RU RU RRC HighRLC PDCP N 2 N 3 LowPHY HighPHY LowMAC HighMAC RF SDAP Option 1 Option 4 Option 3 Option 2 Option 6 Option 5 Option 8 Option 7 RRC HighRLC PDCP SDAP 5 LowRLC F1 LowRLC HighMAC LowMAC HighPHY LowPHY eCPRI & CPRI Open Fronthaul RF RAN functional decomposition - reference points / interfaces Consider the migration from 4G to 5G, same hardware? Dynamic Spectrum Sharing? Lower order MIMO and CPRI interfaces for 5G… RU DU LTE RU LTE BBU LTE RU Radio interface 6 CU LTE DU Fronthaul interface LTE CU Midhaul interface Backhaul interface RAN architecture 1: D-RAN RU 2: C-RAN RU 3: C-RAN RU 4: C-RAN RU DU 1: Distributed RAN (D-RAN), traditional RAN architecture with all functions located at the radio cell site 2: Centralised RAN (C-RAN), common DU-CU/BBU for multiple remote radio units (cell-sectors) 3: Sub-set of C-RAN with centralised CU but distributed DU, this architecture is likely for in-building neutral host (JOTS) - utilises F1/W1 midhaul interfaces 4: Centralised RAN with DU and CU in different locations CU DU CU DU CU DU 7 Note: If decomposed, CU-c & CU-u could be deployed to different locations CU Radio Access Network (RAN) • Public mobile network spectrum is available in the following frequency bands: • • • • 700 MHz (FDD & SDL), 800 MHz (FDD), 900 MHz (FDD) &1400 MHz (SDL) 1800 MHz (FDD), 2100 MHz (FDD) & 2300 MHz (TDD) 2600 MHz (FDD & TDD) & 3600 MHz (TDD) Future 26 GHz (TDD) [FR2] • Channel bandwidths vary considerably, from 5 MHz to 100 MHz in FR1 • A wide range of antenna systems are available, including massive MIMO - systems will very between 2T2R and 64T64R in FR1 • CPRI and eCPRI will coexist in many fronthaul networks for many years! • Open Fronthaul will be added as O-RAN Alliance compliant solutions are rolled-out • A macro-cell will have n x CPRI and/or eCPRI interfaces per cell sector • Fronthaul may need to coexist with backhaul and/or midhaul circuits… 8 Macro cell C-RAN - fronthaul solution with passive DWDM Sync Trusted Network location? Macro cell site # 1 Optical filter RU#2 Optical filter RU#1 RU#n ALM Macro cell site # n RU#n 9 Optical filter RU#2 Optical filter RU#1 BBU DUCU CSG 21C MSE Macro cell C-RAN - fronthaul solution with active DWDM Sync RU#n T X P Optical filter RU#2 D W D W Macro cell site # n RU#1 RU#n 10 D W D W T X P Optical filter RU#2 D W D W T X P BBU DUCU ALM Optical filter RU#1 Optical filter Macro cell site # 1 D W D W T X P CSG 21C MSE Macro cell C-RAN - fronthaul with single ended active DWDM Sync RU#n T X P Optical filter RU#2 D W D W ALM Macro cell site # n RU#1 RU#n 11 T X P Optical filter RU#2 D W D W Optical filter RU#1 Optical filter Macro cell site # 1 BBU DUCU CSG 21C MSE Macro cell C-RAN - fronthaul solution with Radio over Ethernet IEEE 1914.3 defines the encapsulation and mapping of radio protocols for transport over Ethernet frames using Radio over Ethernet (RoE), forming a key part of 5G fronthaul networks - can support CPRI, eCPRI and Open Fronthaul Sync Macro cell site # 1 RU#1 RU#2 R O E n x 100Gbps Carrier Ethernet circuit R O E RU#n BBU DUCU Macro cell site # n RU#1 RU#2 RU#n 12 R O E n x 100Gbps Carrier Ethernet circuit R O E CSG 21C MSE 10 years TCO for macro fronthaul solutions - relative commercials Note: current outcome for small cells is in favour of passive DWDM, future may include aggregation with macro RoE… Significant opportunities for price erosion • Cost of retrofitting coloured optics to existing macro-cells is quite considerable (interesting finding from analysis!)… • Single ended active DWDM is the cheapest solution for today’s C-RAN macro-cell fronthaul requirements • Radio over Ethernet is a more strategic solution given evolution towards open virtualised RAN • Key considerations: £ • • • • • 13 RU - CPRI vs eCPRI / Open Fronthaul Fronthaul interface aggregation vDU interfaces, n x 100G+ ? Dark fibre, optical access or Ethernet? Strategy development, modelling, lab and field testing are on-going… Logical architecture of 5G O-RAN Service management & orchestration framework nonRT-RIC O2 O1 A1 O2 interface to O-Cloud E2 nearRT-RIC O1 interface to all network sub-systems E2 O-CU-c NR (air) interface O-RU Open Fronthaul C, U, S + M plane O-DU E2 E1 O-CU-u 14 N2 (AMF) N3 (UPF) Logical architecture of 5G O-RAN - compute platforms Service management & orchestration framework nonRT-RIC O2 O1 A1 O2 interface to O-Cloud O-RU O-RU E2 nearRT-RIC O-RU O1 interface to all network sub-systems E2 O-CU-c O-RU O-RU O-DU E2 N2 (AMF) E1 O-RU O-RU 15 O-RU How do we optimise the fronthaul interface on a compute platform hosting a vDU? what are the implications for any hardware? O-CU-u N3 (UPF) COTS compute platform(s) X86, ARM, RISC-V? Lab build An evolving test and validation environment 16 Summary • 5G provides significant architectural flexibility across RAN, core and service enablement • RAN functional decomposition exposes fronthaul, midhaul and backhaul interfaces • Radio network optimisation requires the RU to be close to the antenna system, either integrated as in AAU or massive MIMO, or physically very close if an external RU and passive antenna system • Fronthaul solutions must address CPRI, eCPRI and Open Fronthaul • Fronthaul solutions in the purely optical domain may be passive and/or active • Radio over Ethernet is an alternative approach which has the potential to be more cost effective as solutions scale and evolve - but still some work to do to fully understand the pros and cons… • Small cells and macro cells may have different fronthaul solution, this is fine as they are very different cell types, they may converge over time • Open RAN is a longer-term evolution of the RAN, starting with small cells and then evolving to the macro network, consider how this impacts the technoeconomics of fronthaul solutions… 17 © British Telecommunications plc