Some Remarks on Economic Benefits of TANAP for Turkey

/7$#4+<"*#5#018 !"# !"#$%&$#'&(!%")% $*")"#+*%,$)$-+.!%"-% .')'/%-"&%.0&($1 #0,'&+2%3'!')"4 !$)+"&%-$55"67%*$).$&%")%$)$&81%')9%$*")"#17%3'!$) !"#$%&'%()*+,%-'.%+')&#-')#/)0121!)*-) 3"#4+()567)89):*;;*#+<)04"=*->)&#.?3+*%-) 3"%)%@?%&'%()'#):%)A"3+'%()B#"=-)B#"'>) -#.%)567)CDE):*;;*#+)/#")-4??;F)#/)?*?%-)3+() &#+-'"4&'*#+)B#"=-<) !"#$%&'(")'&%*+$,%&"-' &..&#-/'$.'-("(* 2øæª̋˚ß̋¸"ƺ©̋œßŒ̋ºß"˚æœß"æ̨"6#0#2" Æœ"̇øæ­º¸"75&"なに"̈ÆØØÆæº "0̇ß­ø̇ØØ " 19/.,458$89/A"25.,$+5::$<.$52B9:B.1$ 52$5/A:./.24"4592$9@$+9-0,$621.-$ ß̶Æœ"ıøæª̋˚ß "6­øŁÆœ̶"˚æŒı̇ºÆ̋œ"̇ø̋" .CA.84.1$49$<.$=-"24.1$+9-0,$+9-47$ œæŒ̋"75&"の は"̈ÆØØÆæº"̨æø"œ­ııØ "æ̨" A5A.,$"21$892,4-684592$+9-0,>$?2$"13 154592'$"889-152=$49$,9/.$.,45/"4.,$ "<964$)D>&&&$15-.84$"21$4.2,$9@$47963 ,"21,$9@$5215-.84$E9<,$+5::$<.$8-."4.1$ 16-52=$47.$892,4-684592$A7",.>$F6-3 47.-/9-.'$47.$A-9E.84$+5::$8-."4.$A.-3 /"2.24$15-.84$E9<,$47-96=7964$:5@.$9@$ 47.$A5A.:52.>$ 6­øŁ̋ " ¬ÆØØ" ̇Øœæ" ̶̇©̋" ı̋øŒ̇º̋ºß" ,4."/$9@$5289/.$@-9/$9A.-"4592$9@$ ß̶̋"ıÆı̋Øƺ̋"̇œ"œß̇ß̋ 欺̋¸"$16#¢" ̶æظœ"ぬどガ"œ̶̇ø̋"ƺ"6#0#2 "#œœ­Œ3 52=$ 47"4$ 4-"2,/5,,592$ 8"A"854#$ 9@$ 6#0#2"ø̋̇˚̶̋œ"ßæ"ぬな"̈˚Œ ̋̇ø"̈ " にどには " ßæß̇Ø" º̋ß" ƺ˚æŒ̋" æ̨" $16#¢" @-9/$9A.-"4592$9@$47.$A5A.:52.$/"#$ ø̋̇˚̶"ßæ"75&"なば"̈ÆØØÆæº"ƺ"ø̋̇Ø"ß̋øŒœ" 45::$47.$A.-591$(&*D>$ )(D %#52+#0"4'2146 "524+0)"にどなね !"#$%&'$(&)*$+",$-./"-0.1$",$"2$ ÆŒıæøß̇ºß"¸̇ß̋"ƺ"ß̶̋"6­øŁÆœ̶"̋º̋ø̌ " œ̋˚ßæø "6­øŁÆœ̶"º̇ßÆæº̇Ø"ı̋ßøæØ̋­Œ" ˚æŒı̇º " 62#1" ßææŁ" æ©̋ø" 6æß̇Ø œ" などガ"œß̇Ł̋"ƺ"ß̶̋"5̶̶̇"&̋ºÆ "%溜æø3 456/$"21$476,$528-.",.1$494":$,7"-.$ ßæ"なひガ "1º"ß̶̋"œ̇Œ̋"¸̇ "6­øŁ̋ œ" º̇ßÆæº̇Ø"ıÆı̋Øƺ̋"æı̋ø̇ßæø"$16#¢"ƺ3 ˚ø̋̇œ̋¸"̶̋ø"œ̶̇ø̋"ƺ"6#0#2"ßæ"ぬどガ " 6̶̋œ̋"¸̋©̋ØæıŒ̋ºßœ"¬ÆØØ"˚̋øß̇ÆºØ " ˚æºßøÆ̈­ß̋"ßæ"6­øŁ̋ œ"Øæº̌ œß̇º¸Æº̌" ;6.,4$49$<.89/.$"$-.=592":$.2.-=#$ ̶­̈"̇º¸"̈øƺ̌"œÆ̌ºÆピÆ˚̇ºß"̋˚æºæŒÆ˚" ="52,>$?2$475,$294.$+.$@986,$92$5/A9-3 ß̇º˚̋"æ̨"ß̶̋"6#0#2"̨æø"6­øŁÆœ̶"̋º3 ̋ø̌ "Œ̇øŁ̋ß"̇º¸"̋˚æºæŒÆ˚"̈̋º̋ピÆßœ" æ̨"ß̶̋"ıøæª̋˚ß"̨æø"6­øŁ̋ " 6̶̋œ̋" ̇ø̋" ¸Æø̋˚ß" ̇º¸" æ̈œ̋ø©̇̈Ø̋" ̈̋º̋ピÆßœ"æ̨"ß̶̋"ıøæª̋˚ß"̨æø"ß̶̋"6­øŁ3 5,7$.8929/#>$G687$"$76=.$52@-",4-683 ß­ø̋"ƺ©̋œßŒ̋ºß"¬ÆØØ"¸̋ピƺÆß̋Ø "̌̋º3 .-"4.$.29-/96,$.8929/58$"845B54#$ 47-96=7964$892,4-684592$A7",.$"21$ +5::$8924-5<64.$49$A.-/"2.24$.893 ºæŒÆ˚"̌øæ¬ß̶"æ̨"6­øŁ̋ "ƺ"ß̶̋"Øæº̌" -62$47-96=7$47.$/6:45A:5.-$.@@.84>$H83 89-152=$49$96-$A-.:5/52"-#$.,45/"4.,'$ ß̶̋" 6#0#2" ıøæª̋˚ß" Œ̇ " ƺ˚ø̋̇œ̋" ̌ø朜" ¸æŒ̋œßÆ˚" ıø渭˚ß" )&2 " æ̨" 6­øŁ̋ "̈ "̇ııøæ®ÆŒ̇ß̋Ø "75&"ぬば"̈ÆØ3 ØÆæº"̈ "にどにひ "6̶Æœ"ÆŒıØÆ̋œ"ß̶̇ß")&2"æ̨" 6­øŁ̋ "¬ÆØØ"̈̋"75&"ぬば"̈ÆØØÆæº"̶Æ̶̌̋ø" $%&'()$%*(+,%*,-./(0*12("3"4(5'$.( &126%*$7(,1(8$9$8+(5'-&'(51:87(;$( %,,%-.$7(5-,'1:,(-268$2$.,%,-1.(10( ,'$(6*1<$&,=(>%,:*%88)?(,'-+(-.&*$%+$( ƺ")&2"¬ÆØØ"̇Øœæ"˚æºßøÆ̈­ß̋"ßæ"̋Œ@ ıØæ Œ̋ºß"̇œ"¬̋ØØ "1­ø"˚̇Ø˚­Ø̇ßÆ溜" œ­̌̌̋œß"ß̶̇ß"ß̶̋"6#0#2"ıøæª̋˚ß"Œ̇ " &*$%,$(:6(,1(%77-,-1.%8("A4=4!B(6$*@ Œ̇º̋ºß"ªæ̈œ"ƺ"6­øŁ̋ "ƺ"ß̶̋"Øæº̌" *:.=( !""!#$%&'"&$()(*&')&$+,-.%/& )($+,(0&1(%&2(,-!$ /7$#4+<"*#5#018 6­øŁ̋ "¬ÆØØ"ı­ø˚̶̇œ̋"̇¸¸ÆßÆæº̇Ø"は" ;&2( 10( .%,:*%8( /%+( 6$*( )$%*( 0*12( # ̋ø̈̇ƪ̇º"©Æ̇"6#0#2"%­øø̋ºßØ "6­ø@ C$)(-261*,+(.%,:*%8(/%+(0*12(D:++-%?( +ø̇º"̇º¸"# ̋ø̈̇ƪ̇º"©Æ̇"ıÆı̋œ"̇º¸"ƺ" ,'$(01*2(10(E>F(0*12(9%*-1:+(&1:.@ ,*-$+=( G8,'1:/'( -261*,( 6*-&$+( %*$( ºæß"¸Æœ˚Øæœ̋¸"æ̨ピÆ˚Æ̇ØØ "̇˚˚æø¸Æº̌"ßæ" +12$($+,-2%,$+(-261*,(6*-&$+(%*$( ̇øæ­º¸"75&"ねぱど"ı̋ø"ß˚Œ"̨æø"+ø̇ºÆ̇º" ̌̇œ "75&"ねどど ß˚Œ"̨æø"4­œœÆ̇º"̌̇œ" ̇º¸"75&"ぬねど ß˚Œ"̨æø"̌̇œ"̨øæŒ"# ̋ø@ ̈̇ƪ̇º "6̶̋ø̨̋æø̋ "̈ "ÆŒıæøßƺ̌"Œæø̋" º̇ß­ø̇Ø"̌̇œ"̨øæŒ"# ̋ø̈̇ƪ̇º "6­øŁ̋ " 5-88(;$(%;8$(,1(*$7:&$(,1,%8(/%+(-2@ 61*,(;-88=( !"# *æ¬̋©̋ø " ß̶̋" ¸Æ̨̨̋ø̋º˚̋" ̈̋߬̋̋º" -261*,(6*-&$+(71$+(.1,(6*19-7$(,'$( 0:88(6-&,:*$(10(,1,%8($&1.12-&(;$.@ ̋ピÆßœ"æ̨"6­øŁ̋ "̨øæŒ"ÆŒıæøßƺ̌"Œæø̋" º̇ß­ø̇Ø"̌̇œ"̨øæŒ"# ̋ø̈̇ƪ̇º "1ı̋º@ ƺ̌"æ̨"6#0#2"¬ÆØØ"ƺ˚ø̋̇œ̋"œ­ııØÆ̋œ" æ̨"º̇ß­ø̇Ø"̌̇œ"ßæ"6­øŁ̋ "̇º¸"̶̋º˚̋" -.&*$%+$(&126$,-,-1.(-.(,'$(2%*C$,=( 1º˚̋"6#0#2"̈̋˚æŒ̋œ"æı̋ø̇ßÆæº̇Ø " 6­øŁ̋ "¬ÆØØ"ƺ˚ø̋̇œ̋"̶̋ø"̈̇ø̌̇ƺƺ̌" 615$*(%/%-.+,(1,'$*(+:668-$*+(%+(,'$( 6­øŁÆœ̶"º̇ß­ø̇Ø"̌̇œ"Œ̇øŁ̋ß"¬ÆØØ"̈̋@ ˚æŒ̋"Œæø̋"˚æŒı̋ßÆßÆ©̋ "6̶̋ø̨̋æø̋ " 1,'$*(+:668-$*+(5-88(;$(01*&$7(,1(&:,( ß̶̋Æø"ıøÆ˚̋œ"¬̶̋º"6#0#2"æı̋ºœ "1­ø" &%8&:8%,-1.+(+://$+,(,'%,($9$.(-0(%88( +:668-$*+(&'%*/$7(,'$(+%2$(6*-&$(01*( .%,:*%8(/%+?($H,*%(+:668)(10(#(;&2( ı̋ø" ̋̇ø"©Æ̇"6#0#2"¬æ­Ø¸"ø̋¸­˚̋" ßæß̇Ø"ÆŒıæøß"ıøÆ˚̋œ"̈ "̇øæ­º¸"75&" IJ@KA(6$*(!(,'1:+%.7(&:;-&(2$,$*=( 6̶Æœ"ÆŒıØÆ̋œ"̇øæ­º¸"75&"な は ぬ ぬ"̈ÆØ@ !"#$%$&'!(')*$*"'+%,,'%$-.#*/#'/0"",%#/'!(' $*)0.*,'&*/')!')0.1#2'*$3'4#$-#'%$-.#*/#' -!5"#)%)%!$'%$')4#'5*.1#)6' 8-1.(*$7:&,-1.(-.(,1,%8($H6$.+$+(1.( -261*,+(10(.%,:*%8(/%+(6$*()$%*(+,%*,@ -./(0*12("3!J=(D$7:&,-1.(-.(-261*,( ;-88(5-88(7$6$.7(1.(%&,:%8(-261*,(918@ ­Œ̋œ ")̇ƺœ"æ̨"6­øŁ̋ "¬ÆØØ"̈̋"Œ­˚̶" '-/'$*(-.(,'$(018815-./()$%*+(%+(-,(-+( $H6$&,$7(,'%,(-261*,(10(.%,:*%8(/%+( ¬ÆØØ"ƺ˚ø̋̇œ̋"˚æºßƺ­̇ØØ "6æß̇Ø"̌̇ƺœ" æ̨"6­øŁ̋ "¸­øƺ̌"ß̶̋"ı̋øÆæ¸"ßÆØØ"にどねの" Œ̇ "ø̋̇˚̶"ßæ"75&"ひね ぱ"̈ÆØØÆæº"ƺ"ø̋̇Ø" ,$*2+=( L.(%77-,-1.?(:.8-C$(1,'$*(/%+@-261*,( ̇̌ø̋̋Œ̋ºßœ "6­øŁ̋ "¬ÆØØ"̶̇©̋"ß̶̋" *-/',( ,1( *$@$H61*,( .%,:*%8( /%+( -2@ ıæøß̋¸"©Æ̇"6#0#2"6̶̋ø̨̋æø̋ "6­øŁ̋ " 5-88('%9$(,'$(1661*,:.-,)(,1($%*.( $H,*%(-.&12$(;)(*$@$H61*,-./(,'-+( ©æØ­Œ̋"æ̨"º̇ß­ø̇Ø"̌̇œ"ßæ"'­øæı̋̇º" &1:.,*-$+=( .2*',$()#!&'"&$()(*&"',& $+,-!34%&(25.$.')&$'&5!#'2!& ()&!)!,13&/+5 6­øŁ̋ " ̶̇œ" ̇" Øæº̌ œß̇º¸Æº̌" ̇Œ̈Æ@ ,-1.( ,1( ;$&12$( %( *$/-1.%8( $.$*/)( ̶­̈ "6#0#2"ø̋ıø̋œ̋ºßœ"æı̋ºÆº̌"æ̨" ,'$( M1:,'$*.( F%+( N1**-71*( OMFNP( ,'%,(5-88(7$8-9$*(.%,:*%8(/%+(0*12( ß̶̋"%̇œıÆ̇º"$̇œÆº"̇º¸"/Ƹ¸Ø̋"'̇œß" !"#$"$#%&'(')*$+% *,%-./.0%1(*2'&34 #œ" ¬̋" Œ̋ºßÆæº̋¸" ̇̈æ©̋ " 6­øŁÆœ̶" œß̇ß̋ 欺̋¸"æÆØ"˚æŒı̇º "62#1"ƺ2 ˚ø̋̇œ̋¸"Æßœ"œß̇Ł̋"ƺ"ß̶̋"5̶̶̇"&̋ºÆ " ?0,+0*%-1.& %0& !BCA& D,& $33-%-0,/& ˚溜Ƹ̋øƺ̌" ß̶̋" ̨̇˚ß" ß̶̇ß" 6­øŁ̋ " <-44&'$5(&%'(&*-6'%&%0&*(2(9)0*%&%'(& 5041.(&07&,$%1*$4&6$+&+1))4-(3&1,2 ¸̋ø"6#0#2 "ßæß̇Ø"©æØ­Œ̋"æ̨"º̇ß­ø̇Ø" ̌̇œ"ß̶̇ß"6­øŁ̋ "˚̇º"̋®ıæøß"¬ÆØØ"øÆ˚̶" ßæ" など ばの" ̈˚Œ" ̈ " にどには "6̶̋ø̨̋æø̋ " 6#0#2"̌Æ©̋œ"6­øŁ̋ "ºæß"æºØ "ß̶̋"æı2 )0*%1,-%;&%0&8(:0.(&$&.$E0*&%*$,+-%& :01,%*;/&81%&$&.$E0*&)4$;(*&-,&%'(&8-6& ̋º̋ø̌ "̌̇Œ̋"ƺ"ß̶̋"'­øæı̋̇º"Œ̇øŁ̋ß " !"#!$%&'"#& +º" ß̶Æœ" ºæß̋" ¬̋" ̈øÆ̋ピØ " ¸Æœ˚­œœ̋¸" ÆŒıæøß̇º˚̋"̇º¸"̋˚æºæŒÆ˚"̈̋º̋ピÆßœ" æ̨"6#0#2"̨æø"6­øŁ̋ "6#0#2"æı̋ºœ" %'(&=>?&<'-:'&<-44&8(&$&.$E0*&%*$,+-%& :0**-30*&70*&3(4-5(*-,6&,$%1*$4&6$+& ̨øæŒ"ß̶̋"%̇œıÆ̇º"$̇œÆº"̇º¸"/Ƹ¸Ø̋" '̇œß" ßæ" '­øæı̋ " 6̶­œ" 6­øŁ̋ " ¬ÆØØ" '$5(&%'(&0))0*%1,-%;&%0&8(:0.(&$& .$E0*&%*$,+-%&:01,%*;&$+&<(44&$+&$&+-62 ºÆピÆ˚̇ºß"ıØ̇ ̋ø"ƺ"ß̶̋"'­øæı̋̇º"̋º2 ̋ø̌ "Œ̇øŁ̋ßœ "1­ø"̇º̇Ø œÆœ"œ­̌̌̋œßœ" ß̶̇ß"6#0#2"¬ÆØØ"ºæß"æºØ "ƺ˚ø̋̇œ̋" œßø̇ß̋̌Æ˚"ÆŒıæøß̇º˚̋"æ̨"6­øŁ̋ "̈­ß" <-44&$4+0&8*-,6&(,0*.01+&(:0,0.-:& ̈̋º̋ピÆßœ"̨æø"6­øŁ̋ "6̶̋ø̨̋æø̋"6­ø2 F(;&.1+%&6-5(&7144&+1))0*%/&-A(A/&)04-%-2 :$4/&(:0,0.-:&$,3&)184-:&+1))0*%&%0& -.)4(.(,%$%-0,&07&%'(&)*0E(:%A !"# %#52+#0"4'2146 "524+0)"にどなね ßæ" '­øæı̋̇º" %æ­ºßøÆ̋œ " #Øß̶æ­̶̌" æºØ "# ̋ø̈̇ƪ̇º"̶̇œ"˚挌Æßß̋¸"ßæ" œ­ııØ "º̇ß­ø̇Ø"̌̇œ"ß̶øæ­̶̌"6#0#2" $%&%'(&)*(+(,%&%-.(/&%'-+&*01%(&)*02 ©Æ¸̋œ"ß̶̋"Œæœß"˚æœß ̨̋ピÆ˚Æ̋ºß"¬̇ "æ̨" 3(4-5(*-,6&,$%1*$4&6$+&7*0.&%'-+&*(2 ̌Ææº"ßæ"'­øæı̋ "6̶̋ø̨̋æø̋ "Æß"˚̇º"ø̋̇2 +0,$84(&8(&(9)(:%(3&%'$%&0%'(*&6$+2 *-:'&:01,%*-(+&-,&%'(&*(6-0,/&,$.(4;& 6­øŁŒ̋ºÆœß̇º "+ø̇º "+ø̇ł"̇º¸"+œø̇̋Ø" <-44&:0,+-3(*&%0&1+(&%'-+&:0**-30*&70*& ßø̇ºœŒÆßßƺ̌"º̇ß­ø̇Ø"̌̇œ"ßæ"'­øæı̋ " #œ" ß̶̋" '­øæı̋̇º" %挌ƜœÆæº̋ø" ̨æø"'º̋ø̌ ")­ºß̶̋ø"1̋ßßƺ̌̋ø"æº˚̋" +%$%(3/&%0%$4&%*$,+.-++-0,&:$)$:-%;& 07&%'(&=>?&.$;&*($:'&%0&!@@&8:.&)(*& ̋̇ø"ƺ"ß̶̋"̨­ß­ø̋ "6̶­œ "6#0#2"Œ̇ " ßø̇ºœ̨æøŒ" 6­øŁ̋ " ßæ" Œ̇ƺ" ßø̇ºœÆß" :01,%*;A&