Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Water Fountain: a gift to the people

The basic premise of this proposal is to initiate a competition to design a new public artwork based around the idea of a 'contemporary civic drinking fountain'. This new artwork would be located in a major city and would provide free drinking water to the public. The strategy of providing an artwork that combines the practical (free drinking water) with the aesthetic (a unique contemporary design) will challenge notions of public art, civic responsibility and the increasingly corporate nature of public space.

Water Fountain: a gift to the people Stephen Hurrel This document contains my proposal to the Artangel Open fund 2013. Although not selected, I believe the ideas within the proposal will be of interest to others. Therefore it is better that this proposal is out there circulating than being a dead document on my computer. Although it is a proposal within the context of ‘public art’ I expect it will be of interest to a wider field of people, for example; environmentalists, ecologists, thinkers, idealists, as well as other artists and commissioners. You are welcome to use this document (with due credit) as a starting point for discussions around ideas related to, for example; public space, public art, water, plastics, consumerism, etc. Project Summary The basic premise of this proposal is to initiate a competition to design a new public artwork based around the idea of a ‘contemporary civic drinking fountain’. This new artwork would be located in a major city and would provide free drinking water to the public. The strategy of providing an artwork that combines the practical (free drinking water) with the aesthetic (a unique contemporary design) will challenge notions of public art, civic responsibility and the increasingly corporate nature of public space. This project, therefore, takes the form of a provocation camouflaged as a gift. A detailed proposal This proposal exists within a network of conflicting concerns that flow around ‘water’. How did we get to the stage where we are paying up to £1 for half a litre of water in a plastic disposable bottle? What is the journey from ‘free accessible water as a human civic right’ to ‘water as a consumable commercial product’? This narrative of water has become so highly accepted that new generations/consumers don’t even question it, but just accept it as a fact of life. What happened to the multitude of drinking fountains installed by the Victorians in cities and seaside towns around the country? These functional objects, decorated with ornate designs, were a celebration of civic service and engineering of the time; a gift from the city fathers to the working people and their families. A simple, human right. A symbol of both progress into the modern world as well as egalitarianism. Water Fountain: a gift to the people takes advantage of a possible funding opportunity (from Artangel) that will allow the usual public art brief and competition structure to be side stepped. Without the need to respond to a commissioner’s brief - which are becoming more and more restrictive and prescriptive in themselves - I am able to propose my own brief and produce a public artwork that raises questions about our rights as citizens, about what public space can/should be used for, that taps into a wider debate about what is an essential human right and what is a commodity that can be privatized and controlled. Water Fountain: a gift to the people (P. 2) Stephen Hurrel In her book Water Wars, the Indian author Vandana Shiva states “Water must be free for sustenance needs. Since nature gives water to us free of cost, buying and selling it for profit violates our inherent right to nature's gift and denies the poor of their human rights.” When private companies try to make large profits through high water prices, it denies the poor the inalienable right to the most necessary substance for life. This contrasts with a recent public statement by a CEO of Nestle, Peter Brabeck, that “...water is a foodstuff like any other... it should have a market value. Personally I believe it’s better to give foodstuff a value so that we’re aware that it has a price, and then one should take specific measures for the part of the population that has no access to water, and there are many different possibilities there.” These two examples basically signify two different, and diametrically opposed, philosophies. The former based on a ‘gift economy’ and the latter based on a ‘market economy’. The fact that there is such a gulf, not in actual solutions to issues of free water, but in the fundamental underlying philosophies and ethics is, I believe, where the issue has to be addressed. (The riots and protests in Bolivia against the water privatization program - under World Bank guidance - were a very real illustration of where privatization of water can lead). I believe that the proposition of a public artwork that, crucially, already has funding in place and therefore negates the old and familiar ‘what’s it costing us?’ /‘waste of tax-payers money’ -type debates will, instead, get to the heart of the matter. This places the focus on what the implications are of providing free, clean water to people, within a context where there are many commercial outlets selling the same thing for a high price (x 1000 cost of tap water). If a free source of water was available via a publicly accessible contemporary water fountain, this would probably create tensions and conflicts, but it would also lead to people questioning why we pay such a high price for water, and to reflect on why they choose not to drink tap water (a commodity we are already paying for after all). Additionally, the implications of free water would result in people re-using existing plastic bottles, and finding better alternatives, and so would cut down a massive polluter (80% of used plastic bottles end up in land-fill sites and take 1000 years to biodegrade). This project will raise questions about roles of art in a post-capitalist society and will site this artwork within existing debates about the function and possibilities of socially engaged art. It will shine a spotlight on the relationship between ‘natural resource’, ‘supplier’ and ‘consumer’. As this artwork is being proposed / presented as a ‘gift’ it will place the focus on the hidden (and forgotten) relationships, histories and narratives between ‘water’ and ‘people’. There is also the obvious reference to Duchamp’s ‘Water Fountain’ - a different kind of provocation that was right for its time (at the beginning of the twentieth century). My proposed twenty-first century ‘water fountain artwork’, similarly hopes to provoke questions regarding form, function and the meaning of objects within art and society. Water Fountain: a gift to the people (P. 3) Stephen Hurrel STRUCTURE AND FORM One of the most important aspects of this project is the press and publicity behind it. In many ways that is a main ‘site’ of the work. Getting the concept out there will generate debate, raise questions and infiltrate daily lives. Politicians, reporters, mayors, people on the street should be asked for their opinions. The wider media should pick up the story and feature it. Social media networks should be utilized. A design for the water fountain should focus on an iconic object that signifies the whole concept. The process of designing it will require input from an engineer and the ‘iconic’ design will probably emerge from a collaborative team effort. The scope of the project would be extended by a ‘call for design proposals’, advertised internationally. It should be made clear that this is a pilot project and if successful then it could spread to other cities. In this way it challenges those in power to decide if they want to sign up to a challenging, ethical project. In that sense, this proposal uses an innocent object in a public space to subversively frame a highly contentious issue that is currently below the radar of general public awareness. I feel there are different ways to approach, and extend the scope of, this project and I am open to discussion on how it develops. Stephen Hurrel [email protected] April 2013 Water Fountain: a gift to the people (P. 4) Stephen Hurrel Examples of traditional Victorian-style water fountains that used to be common in Glasgow and many other UK cities and seaside towns. Redundant water fountain, Charing Cross, Glasgow Water fountain (in National Museum of Scotland)