Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Social Services and the Ethnic Community

1996, Children and Youth Services Review

Social Services and the Ethnic Community takes a hard look at the history and experience of several long established ethnic minority groups in the United States and critically assesses the majority lens through which they have been viewed thus far. Inglehart and Becerra have undertaken an extremely difficult task-to address the common and unique issues faced by each of several minority groups-and have handled it with insight and sensitivity. They present the history of each group in the United States, the response of the majority to it, the impact of the response on the minority group, the reaction of the social services delivery system and the effects of this system. They discuss the evolution of social work in this century and its relevance for the ethnic community and present a rationale for the development of ethnic social services. The book begins with a recognition that we have long moved from the concept of the "melting pot" to beginning to recognize that the United States is, in fact, a mosaic of different peoples and cultures. The experience that brought these people to this country (or their experience in this country when the early immigrants arrived, in the case of the Native Americans), their values, culture and tradition, in addition to their physical characteristics, set them apart from each other and not only is assimilation not often preferred, it is often not possible. Jnglehart and Becerra discuss the historical context of social work and the provision of services that were grounded in the social milieu of the times and suggest that the services delivered tended to be paternalistic and reinforce racist and isolationist practices. The latter part of the book is devoted to providing practical approaches to ethnic sensitive practice. After presenting a rationale for the book, chapters 2 and 3 discuss the White ethnic groups, African Americans, Native Americans, Mexicans, Japanese and Chinese. In addition to indicating the reasons most of these groups came to the United States the authors discuss the types of discrimination and racial violence each of these groups experienced and their further victimization by law enforcement and the judicial systems. Furthermore, they provide an interpretation of the experience of each of these groups and the response of the well-meaning dominant society, a response

736 Book Reviews Social Services And The Ethnic Community By Alfreda P. Inglehart & Rosina Becerra Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 1995. Social Services and the Ethnic Community takes a hard look at the history and experience of several long established ethnic minority groups in the United States and critically assesses the majority lens through which they have been viewed thus far. Inglehart and Becerra have undertaken an extremely difficult task-to address the common and unique issues faced by each of several minority groups- and have handled it with insight and sensitivity. They present the history of each group in the United States, the response of the majority to it, the impact of the response on the minority group, the reaction of the social services delivery system and the effects of this system. They discuss the evolution of social work in this century and its relevance for the ethnic community and present a rationale for the development of ethnic social services. The book begins with a recognition that we have long moved from the concept of the “melting pot” to beginning to recognize that the United States is, in fact, a mosaic of different peoples and cultures. The experience that brought these people to this country (or their experience in this country when the early immigrants arrived, in the case of the Native Americans), their values, culture and tradition, in addition to their physical characteristics, set them apart from each other and not only is assimilation not often preferred, it is often not possible. Jnglehart and Becerra discuss the historical context of social work and the provision of services that were grounded in the social milieu of the times and suggest that the services delivered tended to be paternalistic and reinforce racist and isolationist practices. The latter part of the book is devoted to providing practical approaches to ethnic sensitive practice. After presenting a rationale for the book, chapters 2 and 3 discuss the White ethnic groups, African Americans, Native Americans, Mexicans, Japanese and Chinese. In addition to indicating the reasons most of these groups came to the United States the authors discuss the types of discrimination and racial violence each of these groups experienced and their further victimization by law enforcement and the judicial systems. Furthermore, they provide an interpretation of the experience of each of these groups and the response of the well-meaning dominant society, a response Book Reviews 737 that did not always serve either the best interest of the minority groups nor was beneficial to them in the long run. Chapter 4 presents the emergence of social work direct practice and its historical application for the different ethnic groups. The chapter identifies the systems and the political-economy perspectives that underlay the profession’s history and the development of the Charity Organization Societies that pre-dated the Settlement House Movement. It critically assesses the delivery of social work services to the ethnic communities. Chapter 5 strongly takes to task the Settlement House Movement, a movement that social workers have usually spoken of with pride! The authors make several important observations about the rationale for establishment of the settlement houses, the attitudes of those who provided the service and those who lived in the settlement house communities, and the continued separation of the migrants/immigrants and the majority service providers. Although there were several social workers who were cognizant of the continuing discrimination and its effects, the overall view of ethnic minorities was supportive of teaching dominant culture values, traditions and religion while maintaining a separation between dominant and minority groups. Chapter 6 discusses the evolution of ethnic services which grew out of minority group needs and the existence of naturally occurring resources such as the extended family or the ethnic bonds within community. Ethnic services were often delivered through groups that originally may have banded together for mutual support, such as the AfricanAmerican churches, clans of Chinese Americans with common ancestry, Voluntary Japanese associations that promoted economic progress and success and Mexican American mutual aid societies. These often ran parallel to, but sometimes away from, services provided by the dominant society, and may have emerged because of perceived deficiencies in the existing social services. Chapters 7 through 9 stress the importance and the necessity of making social work and social welfare services truly responsive to the needs of ethnic minorities in such a way that they take into account not only historical antecedents, but also recognize their effects on current perceptions and interactions between minority and majority groups as well as between minority groups themselves. Focus moves beyond the necessity for worker sensitivity to address the need for sensitivity at the organizational and policy levels in order to effect changes in perception, funding and practice. Book Reviews This book will serve as a valuable resource for social work practitioners and educators. By tracing the history and experience of several established ethnic minority groups, and focusing on people of color, those who do not have the option of completely assimilating into the dominant society because of their distinctive physical characteristics, the authors provide an interesting and provocative birdseye view of a number of issues that are rarely found together in one publication. Discussion of the experience of more recent ethnic minority groups, such as the Cubans, Koreans and Southeast Asians is not available in this book, and which presents a different challenge for the social work profession. However, an understanding of the development of the existing relationships between the dominant and minority societies presented by this book may help social workers and other human services providers to not only be sensitive to the unique needs of the group discussed herein, but also help them to be alert to the importance of truly exploring the experience of more recent immigrants as they begin to plan and deliver services to these populations. I/ma A. Segal University of Missouri-St. Louis