Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Neural Co-variation of Consciousness: Dual-Aspect Monism

I wish to comment on (Neisser, 2011)'s two proposals: (A) current neural 'correlates' of consciousness (NCC) research program should be replaced with the neural 'causes' of consciousness and (B) only the philosophy of science should be practiced and the philosophy of mind and metaphysics for consciousness research should be abandoned. These proposals seem untenable because of the following reasons: (1) Consciousness research is multi-disciplinary program.

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 BB 6  G # BB.6  < # C  @& BB36  6( E " 1 & 42 & 9 ) 1 ) " ) " & 48 4@ BDB6  4 BB<6 1 45 ) 8 5/> 4' BB.6  4I BB?6  BB?6  5 " 4 G 1 4/ T 5 " & BB.6 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` / & 5Y Y 9 (AT " (C C 5 4D :&" X 1 5 (- 4 6 5 5 H( 5 5 5 2 2 2 , & .<BL..3 1 1 1 " B& % " * ''4 6( ? #?? 4 BB.6 ( + C C 44, " T " " (, & /:4<6( & ) & " & " ( # ''4 6( % 4 " 6 6 5 )R ( :&" T " 6 * (A, (@ 4 <6 , 5 " M% & ''4 6( 3L D; * B# D= 5 H , ## D?#BD ""( T 4 ?6 2 " ! ! & >24 6( # ""( T ( A 8 (' 4 <6 " ( & A436( # ? ""( T ( I C ( ( T (/(8 ('(> ) (I(A (4 =6 2 "# " ## # " " >'4 6( << #<.? ( - #/ 4 <6 M% & ''4 6( ??#?B (4 <6 H (7 " M! % & ''4 6( D #D (> (A ( 5 G 4 BB?6 , " C ) & B& /?4?6( 3< DL3< 3 ) (T 4 36 K 8 ) @& ( 2 9 " @& ( " @& M) = '>4 6( ?B# 3 . (@(A (' - 4 6 * ( & @4 6( < D#< . T ( 4 <6 5 1 " % & ''4 6( D #D= ( 4 D6 # & 2 9 1 @& * ` % = E 688 8 8 89 8122A F )# &# 7 %= 2;2' )?/ <G ;4 6( <B#?3 ( 4 B 6 > # @& *> # ' ) F = 6H F - << E 67 ( 4 688 HF - 1 ; B 6 > 1 8 8 89 8122/ F <G 14?6( #. "2 9 1 @& " # & > # #> #/ ' ) F E 6 8 8 89 8122/ F I HF - 1 @ I = 6H F 7 688 <G 14.6( # < ( 4 B 6 / Q Q* 1 1 ) % & 6& = . *# ,E 67 688 8 8 89 8122/ F 4 HF - 1 '2 <G ':4.6( B# ? ( 4 B 6 5 " * " (5 ( " # T F = 6H F E 7 688 8 8 89 8122/ F = HF - 1 ' <G 14 6( #< ( 4 B 6 # & "2 9 1 @& , #8 / * 8 / # 1 > # : ' ) F = 6H F E 6 688 8 8 89 8122/ F ! 4 4 HF - 1 1 G 14 6( #D. ( 4 6 / $8 * 1 # 9 1 > # ' ) % # JE 6 688 8 8 89 812'2 F = 7 4 ! HF - > ; <G '4=6( =.?#? ? ( 4 6 / " " 9 1 & * 9 9 1 & % = EH 688 8 8 89 8122/ F 4 & 7 HF - > ' <G /4 6( B3# . ( 4 6 : `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` , ) 1 " ( BBB( 1 1 ) ; A2 " ) 1 1 " ( ) !4 ( BDB; 2 A " , " + " " 0( ) " 1 1 " 1 F , " +) " *7 ) ) ( ) " " ! ( 1 ) " 5 " ) 1 " 1 ) 1 " F 1 7 " " ) E ) 6( 1 J " 1 1 5 ( , " , " 5 < & ( K + " 1 " " , 2,2 * + * 7 " ! ) * 45 H A , 9 > " ! ( * 4 <60( ( 60M , & " '# " ) * M <= 3 1 "" ( BBB6 F A 48 " A, 4@ & ) 4I 1 ( ( A 1 ( <6( E <6( E & , ( 6 , ) 6 ) ( <6( E ) " " 4 6 "( ) ( " ( ( 8 ) " " 6 ) ) '# ( # +J0 ) +J0 " 5 H " " ) +J0 2 I ) " " +J0 # " & ( ) " ( " L '# 1 ) ! ) 1 ) " , * ! 5 5 , 1 "" 1 2 I ) ( , ) K ( '# ( "" 1 )( '# ( "" " ( ( '# ) 1 ( " : 5 F 1 # 6 (" 4 " C '# 4 ) ( 1 ( ) ) 4 " "" ( & 1 +J0 , 48 " ) " X2@ " ) ( ) M , 1 4 * 1 " +J0 K " & " " '# " * ) "" " " " 5 # " '# 4 ] 8 " 8 ( BBB6 1 +J0 5 H ) '# " 1 " " C ( +J0 ) & " '# ! 4 ( " ( ( I " * BBD6 ) O "& 1 5 H +J0 & & L ( ( ! ( ) O " 1 9 1 ( ) ) " 1 O & " 1 , ) 1 ! ! ) 1 M ! 1 +J0 " ) ( ) +J0 " 4 ) ( ) 1 "6 ( ) 1 & F <? 4' ( 7 <6( E, 1 ! ) " " 1 " 1 4 " 1 1 6( C ( "# 7 & & ( 1 ! & /# > +J0 : 47 +J0 , ! " " 4 +J0 ( ( 6 ( ) 1 " & 1 1 " !6( ( " 4I ( ) +J0 " 1 " !6( ( " " * 7 7 <6( E:" 1 4 1 ( 9 " 1 +J0 4' ; ) ! 1 4I " " # L ! ( 4/ ! # 7" 4 ( BBD6 2 & " " , 4 # ( 6( ( " BBB6 " " 1 1 " 1 4 " +J0 " ! 6( ) " 7 " ( L " " 1 " " & 1 " " " ! 1 6F ( & ) " # & 9 ( 1 <6( E +J0 " @1 1 7 " , 1 1 A ( 1 1 & 1 F & 1 1 ( " & ( " 9 7" " 1 1 " ( "" % 4T ) A " " 1 ( BB?; , ( 6 " 1 " 6 +J0 " ) 1 1 4I ) A ' ( " ) % * 46 K ( ( " & ) " , , 4I & 9 % 1 7 & " ) " " 6 +J0 , 1 & " ( 4 ) ( ) 1 ( " 1 1 1 4' 9 5 " 6 1 !) % " # F <6 45 H A , ( * 6 " M ) 4 Z ( <645A,6( " M 4 6 ( " ; M 4 16 , ) 7 !M 4 6 > / > " 1 1 () ( ) ! Z "" " E <D 7 5A,6 , ( & ( 1 4 7 & " 1 ) J 8 ( " 1 ) 4 ! ! F 41 6 E, 1 ) 1 ) 1 & , " " 7 7 ) ) " 1 " 9 " " 1 ) " ) 7 " ( " ! 6 ( 5 " 1 " 1 " 4 6 " 5 " 1 & 5 , " " " ) " " 4- A " " " " "" ( +J0 , " 5 5 " 1 ) ! + ! 4 . " 5A,06 ' & 1 ( " = + " 5A,06 F 416 E () < " " ( ) & & " 1 " 4 D + " 5A,06 +J0 " ) L " ( 1 F 41 6 E, 5 " " " 5 " " 1 1 ( " ) 1 L 6 + " 5A,0 F 41 6 E5A, " " " 1 ( 1 ( & " 1 & 4" & " +J0 & & " " " ( ( 1 4 .6 I ) 1 ( 1 " " G ) " 4'' 6 ( 1 +J0 , ) '' ( 1 ( " 1 ) & " 1 ) 1 1 1 (5 H , ( 4 1 ( 4 1 +J0 1 1 9 1 ) 1 +J0 ( " # 1 " 6 F C( <6( E, ) 1 & ) $ O " K 1 " "" 1 ) " ( ) ( " "" 1 " ( " ) ( " 1 4 " " K ( ) " ) ( ) # ) , ( ) 1 ( " " " " "" 1 )( ( " +J0 , C( 6 , 1 " +J0 , & 4 -6 ) 4- " " " 6 1 ) ( " % " < IC ( 2 " ( - A8 4 6 1 <B ) ) ) ( 1 !6 7 1 ) 9 ) , % 4- - 6 ) 6 +J0 1 B P " .P 1 ) " ) ) ( ( 1 ) ) ( ( 1 " ( 1 % 4 7 & ! & & ) I 1 ( ) 1 1 ) " & & 1 ) 5 " ( 7 ( +J0 @1 ) ( ) & ! " , " & " ! 49 ( +J0 ( 7 ") 1 " +J0 K ( 1 ;1 a ) 1 ! 4 & +J0 ' 1 " " #55 ) & ( ) ( % +J0 ' 1 & " " & A 8 ( ( ( " " " ) ) ( " 1 ) 5 ( ( ) F ) <6( E( " #55 " 1 ) "" 4/ " ) " 1 ( ( & & ) ) 1 " " ( + 0 , "" ) " ( <6 K " ) +J0 +J0 8 " " 1 +J0 5 " " 1 1 ) & "" 1 ) 1 " "" & 5 ) ") 9 & 9 " ( 5 +J0 " 9 " ) ) ( " " ( ) )# 1 ; 5 HA, 1 1 6 & & " , ) " ( 1 " ( & ( 1 ) ( 1 " 1 % 1 "" & ( 6 & +J0 I 5 H K ) 1 ) 5 " 1 7 ( ) ( BBD6 " 1 ( ) ) " & ! " " 4 K ( ) ( 5 HA, " C( ( &( " ) 1 M K 1 " ) " 4 +J0 1 1 , ! # 1 1 1 7 " 1 " 4 9 ' 1 ( 5( 5 +J0 2 *( . ( " " 5 +J0 ) $ 1 ( ' " ( 5( " ( ) " / ' 1 ( 5( )" $ " " " 1 " " ) " ( ( " # % 1 & +J0 ( ( ( " ) " " ) * ( 5( ( 4 & ( 7" 1 "" " )6 " !4 " 1 5 1 & <6 . " ) +J0 ( 4 @( " @( 4 6 7' 5( "" 1 ) 46 " "@ " 5! <6 +J0 , # " ) * ( = 6 " " ! 4 .6 +J0 4 " ( " ) 4 & 1 , " 1 1 6 9 ( " " " 1 & ( " " " 1 )( " 1 4 =6 , 1 " " 1 ) +J0 5 H 8 1 1 " ` & , 1 " ( 1 9 1 1 & ( " & & 4 # 1 & & 1 ) " " 1 " & ) " " +J0 " & # " 6( ) 1 ) " & 8 1 ( & ( " " " 1 ) " 1 +J0 , ( " 8 BD3( & ) " " ( ( ) +J0 % 1 ( , " , +J0 5 H 1 # " 1 +J0 4: 6 +J0 1 , & ) , 1 & 1 4 " L " & 1 BB 6 +J0 7 & ? : " & +J0 2 "1 " ` ( . ) 4 4 " " 1 ( ` 1 & " ( 1 +J0 , 1 1 ) 1 & " ) +J0 9 +J0 ' " ` 2 ( 8 " K # ` # " `" (` 1 ) & 1 . & 1 ( ` , ) , ( `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b & ( 6 8 ) ! 1 % ( BBD6 +J0 1 1 ( ) " # ) ) ( " 5 " K ! " 1 8 5 ) 1 "" 1 4-c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he mental aspect of stimuli causes the mental aspect of relevant neural-network and its activities (brain), body, and external environment are apparent causes of experiences (the mental aspect of the NN-state) without making category mistake. The physical aspect of stimuli apparently causes the physical aspect of related NN-state (activities of relevant neural-network, body, and external environment), 4 " ; 1 ( BBD; &) 1 A 1 ( ( BBB6 1 ) " 1 & % 1 ) 4 ( BBD6( EK ) ( ) 1 " ) ' 9 1 )( 1 ) .D 1 ) " & ( " ) & 1 " ) & ) 1 A ( ( 9 & 1 1 " 1 ( ) " " 1 ( "1 BBB6( E " ) 9 ( ( " ) & / ) " 1 1 " 1 , " & 1 1 ) 1 ) 1 " ( " ; " % " 8 1 # ( 1 1 ) F " " 8 1 1 ( ) ) ) ( " & ; ( " , " 1 ) 1 1 " 4 1 1 1 ) C " F . " *$$ ) $) $ = " *$$ ) $) $ .B