Fall/Winter 2016
Volume 39 Number 3/4
A MESSAGE FROM THE EDITOR
Happy New Year to All of You!!
With the start of a New Year, we often reflect on the
events of the past year and look to the future and potential
of the New Year. Change often is a major part of how we
reflect on the good and the bad of the past, present and
future. A change from something comfortable and
familiar to something new and unknown (e.g., the
transition from President Obama to President-Elect
Trump) can be very unsettling and may even cause
concern among some. The Society for Archaeological
Sciences (SAS) also has gone through some recent
changes and more are likely for the future. The torch of
leadership has been smoothly passed from former
President Marc Walton to current President Rachel
Popelka-Filcoff. Likewise a few other positions within
the SAS Executive Board and the SAS Bulletin also have
changed, including the SAS Bulletin Editor.
As the new SAS Bulletin Editor, I want to start by
thanking Vanessa Muros for her wonderful work as SAS
Bulletin Editor since Summer 2013. Kudos to you and
thank you so much for your time and efforts, Vanessa! I
assumed the role of Editor starting this past May, and
almost immediately my life changed in many ways. I
packed all my belongings, which were shipped off and
placed in storage in southern California for 3 months,
while my wife, my 9-month old daughter and I travelled
all over the world and lived out of suitcases in remote
locations for 3 months. Upon the traveling ending, I
immediately had to find a place to live across the country,
locate and unpack all of our belongings and start a new
job within 2 weeks. The work load was unexpectedly
IN THIS ISSUE
A Message from the Editor (T. Fenn)
Maritime Archaeology (N. Ciarlo)
Archaeological Ceramics (C.C. Kolb)
Archaeometallurgy (T. Fenn)
Obituary
Upcoming Conferences
1
2
8
18
26
27
high and finding that balance in life took me a few
months. Needless to say 2016 for me and my family was
filled with many change and shifts from the comfortable
and familiar to the new and unknown. So, this in part is
my apology and excuse for the delay in getting out Issues
3 and 4 of the 2016 SAS Bulletin. As a result, I am
sending out the final issue of 2016 as an enlarged and
combined issue Nos. 3/4 of Volume 39. In 2017 the
normal 4 issues will be back on track with only minor
delays in Issue 1 of the New Year. Again, I apologize
and thank you for your patience in allowing me these
transitions.
Changes can be fast and furious or slow and tortuous, but
they do not always need to be bad or sad (e.g., the loss of
David Bowie). In fact, some changes can be very good
things, and help to provide new and exciting opportunities
and paths to the future. This is absolutely the case with
the SAS Bulletin. We have followed a tried and true
formula for the Bulletin for many years, and long before
my days of contributing, the Bulletin had always been
something I looked forward to receiving in the mail.
Eventually, changes were made and new issues of the
Bulletin were available as both printed issues and PDF
files for download by members, while some of the old
issues also were prepared as PDF files for download.
This routine again changed where members could opt to
receive either printed or electronic issues of the Bulletin,
and many chose the PDF only option as many of us
already are overwhelmed by receiving printed materials,
and the electronic editions made our lives simpler,
transportable and more manageable.
Well, we are again at the crux of potential change with
the SAS Bulletin and you, the members, will help us to
shape these changes and the future vision of the Bulletin.
These changes could include shifting to a four-times-peryear online format for the Bulletin (which could be
downloadable as a PDF), and print-on-demand options
for those who still want the traditional printed version.
Access to these issues will still be restricted on an annual
basis to allow members to have the first access to view
and/or download, before the general public has access.
Likewise, some aspects of contributions to the Bulletin
are time sensitive, and it makes more sense to shift these
PAGE 2
SAS BULLETIN
components to online formats where the membership can
have quicker more timely access. The shift to online
formats and access also will allow for increased color
figures and graphics, which are not economically viable
in the current price structure for the Bulletin.
There are other potential future changes in the works for
the SAS Bulletin, both in its presentation and format, as
well as in its content, and I hope you all will be excited
about the changes in vision and direction expected in the
coming months and years. So, while the future may be
uncertain, it does not have to be frightening and I hope
you will all see some new and wonderful changes in the
SAS Bulletin in 2017 and beyond. Have a happy, healthy
and productive 2017!!
Thomas R. Fenn
SAS Bulletin Editor
MARITIME ARCHAEOLOGY
Nicolás Ciarlo, Associate Editor
39(3/4)
microstructure but the use of a range of diffraction
techniques to determine the crystallographic texture of
copper bolts can identify the methods by which they were
produced and to connect them with a particular
manufacturer even when (as is usual) there are no works
stamps on the bolts. For example, the process patented by
William Collins in 1783 for drawing rather than rolling
bolts produces a very recognizable texture and these
results have now been published.
Parallel documentary research is focused on Admiralty
records and the business archive of William Forbes. This
last is very detailed and covers aspects from the operation
of his rolling mill to the organization of the naval supply
chain. It is possible to link Admiralty orders with the
ledgers itemizing material leaving the works and for what
ships. For a wreck like Impregnable excavated bolts can
be matched with a very complete paper trail.
Peter Northover
Metallurgy and Archaeology, October House, Stonehill Lane,
Southmoor, Abingdon, Oxfordshire
[email protected]
This section contains two notes about ongoing
investigations in maritime archaeology. The first deals
with the determination of manufacturing methods for
copper bolts from early Modern British warships, by
means of crystallographic analysis (P. Northover), while
the second is focused on the application of geophysics for
modeling a 3D image of a First World War’ wreck (J.
Russo & A. Alves Salgado). Besides, an account on
recent papers, books, thesis, previous conferences, and
future courses, is presented.
Creating an analogical 3D model of a Great War loss
from a multibeam record
On March 31, 1917, the German submarine U-35 left the
base of Kattaro (Montenegro), heading to the south of
Portugal. On April 24, she sunk one Danish and two
Norwegian steamers, and an Italian sailing vessel, off
Sagres and Lagos, Portugal. Since 2014, CINAV –
Portuguese Research Centre, has been studying this Great
War episode, both from the historical and archaeological
perspectives.
Current Research
Ships’ sheathing and fastenings
Building on the characterization of copper and brass bolts
and sheathing from three shipwrecks (HMS Impregnable
lost in 1799), HMS Pomone (1811) and Flower of Ugie
(1852) a multi-faceted program of research has been
developed. The first part continues the metallurgical
study of copper and copper alloy components from
wooden ships. A database has been assembled of all
available compositions from around the world which is
helping construct a robust chronology, and to assist in
reassessing ships already studied, confirming the identity
of wrecks or in helping identify unknown wrecks.
Problems still remain with the analysis of brass because
with alloys like Muntz metal part of the structure always
corrodes very quickly and a method of determining the
original alloy content is still being developed.
One of the sunken Norwegian steamers was the 3.715
tons SS Vilhelm Krag, where different methods of wreck
recording were tested, including the classical multibeam
geophysics. Based on the data acquired, the feasibility of
an analogical 3D model of the wreck and its value as an
archaeological resource were tested.
For the crucial period for British ships between, say, 1775
and 1825 the copper is rather uniform in composition and
The archaeological recording by geophysics ―multibeam
in this case― provides researchers with a very useful tool
to interpret a wreck. To brief, debrief and allocate diverse
tasks, a tridimensional analogical tool is sometimes
preferred over a digital one. This is of critical importance
when it comes to efficiency and safety. Bearing this in
mind, the team searched for methods to produce an
analogical 3D model of the SS Vilhelm Krag, in the most
automatic, quick and reliable way possible.
To achieve this goal, data acquired both from
archaeographic and geophysical records was crucial. A
considerable amount of reliable x, y and z data was
FALL/WINTER 2016
SAS BULLETIN
obtained by geophysics (Figure 1.a). From this point
onwards, a quest for ways to transform digital
tridimensional information in analogical data began. The
idea was suggested by a mechanical engineer, Ricardo
Rodrigues, while the printable file (see below) was
elaborated by the project boat skipper, Tiago Dores.
The process consists in using software. This is indeed
very simple, but works well nonetheless. For instance,
with the open source MeshLab, used for processing and
editing
unconstructed
3D
triangular
meshes
(http://meshlab.sourceforge.net/), the multibeam x, y and
z data was transformed in a .stl file, which can be loaded
to any 3D printing software. The .stl file was printed, thus
completing the first step toward an analogical 3D model.
Afterwards, details missed during the impression, such as
rocks, were added. The result was then undercoated and
hand painted, simulating rust and concretion, as well as
marine animal and plant colonization (Figure 1.b).
Figure 1. (a) A multibeam image of the site SS Vilhelm Krag;
(b) A 3D image, after digital processing and editing.
By making the best of an existing pack of data recorded
by multibeam, which optimized and maximized the
technical means applied, it was possible to produce a very
useful analogical 3D model of the wreck of the SS
Vilhelm Krag from a digital 2D record. Thanks to the
resulting model, the research staff was able to plan in
advance the dives and tasks to perform, as well as analyze
PAGE 3
their efficiency. This made possible a better and safer
archaeological practice, providing a method and resource
which is very valuable for research.
Jorge Russo *
Augusto Alves Salgado
* CINAV – Portuguese Navy Research Centre
[email protected]
Recent Publications
International Journal of Nautical Archaeology. From
IJNA 2016, Vol. 45, No. 1: “Discovery of Iron Grapnel
Anchors in Early Modern Ryukyu and Management of
Underwater Cultural Heritage in Okinawa, Japan” (R.
Ono et al.); and “Archaeological Assessment of Second
World War Anti-Torpedo Close Protection Pontoons in
Scapa Flow, Orkney” (A. Christie et al.).
Journal of Archaeological Sciences. From JAS 2016 (up
to June), Vol. 65: “Fishing with lure hooks at the Late
Neolithic site of Vinča – Belo Brdo, Serbia” (E. Cristiani
et al.); Vol. 66: “Detection of shipwrecks in ocean colour
satellite imagery” (M. Baeye et al.); Vol. 67: “Tin ingots
from a probable Bronze Age shipwreck off the coast of
Salcombe, Devon: Composition and microstructure” (Q.
Wang et al.); and Vol. 70: “Distinguishing offshore bird
hunting from beach scavenging in archaeological
contexts: The value of modern beach surveys” (K. M.
Bovy et al.); and “Testing the endurance of prehistoric
adornments: Raw materials from the aquatic
environment” (M. Mărgărit).
Journal of Archaeological Sciences: Reports. From JAS:
Reports 2016 (up to June), Vol. 5: “The nutritional value
of Pacific herring: An ancient cultural keystone species
on the Northwest Coast of North America” (M. L. Moss);
“Extended residence times for foraminifera in a marineinfluenced terrestrial archaeological deposit and
implications for palaeoenvironmental reconstruction” (T.
Nagel et al.); “The archeology, sedimentology and
paleontology of Gray’s Reef National Marine Sanctuary
and nearby hard bottom reefs along the mid continental
shelf of the Georgia Bight” (E. G. Garrison et al.); “Craft
production of large quantities of metal artifacts at the
beginnings of industrialization: Application of SEM–EDS
and multivariate analysis on sheathing tacks from a
British transport sunk in 1813” (N. C. Ciarlo et al.);
“Evolution of Taman Peninsula’s ancient Bosphorus
channels, south-west Russia: Deltaic progradation and
Greek colonization” (M. Giaime et al.); “Wind and wave
modelling for the evaluation of the maritime accessibility
and protection afforded by ancient harbours” (C. Safadi);
and “A study on provenance of marine porcelains from
Huaguangjiao No. 1 after sample desalination” (Y. Chen
et al.); Vol. 6: “Prey selection, size, and breakage
PAGE 4
SAS BULLETIN
differences in Turbo undulatus opercula found within
Pacific Gull (Larus pacificus) middens compared to
Aboriginal middens and natural beach deposits, southeast
Australia” (J. Sherwood et al.); “Windward vs. leeward:
Inter-site variation in marine resource exploitation on
Ebon Atoll, Republic of the Marshall Islands” (M. Harris
et al.); “Refining the chronology for west polynesian
colonization: New data from the Samoan archipelago” (J.
T. Clark et al.); “Scanning the H. L. Hunley: Employing a
structured-light scanning system in the archaeological
documentation of a unique maritime artifact” (M. P.
Scafuri & B. Rennison); and “Identifying prehistoric
trade networks in the Massim region, Papua New Guinea:
Evidence from petrographic and chemical compositional
pottery analyses from Rossel and Nimowa Islands in the
Louisiade Archipelago” (B. Shaw et al.). Furthermore,
this volume contains a special section entitled Aquatic
resource exploitation by prehistoric humans, that includes
a series of articles focused on human management of
different resources associated to aquatic environments
(e.g. fish, shellfish, and birds), as well as on the relevance
of isotopic evidence and other sources of data to evaluate
the consumption of marine and freshwater animals in
island and coastal scenarios. Finally, from Vol. 7:
“Geoarchaeological evolution of Tel Akko’s ancient
harbour
(Israel)”
(C.
Morhange
et
al.);
“Dendrochronological dating of kauri timbers from
Browne’s spar station (1832–1836), Mahurangi,
Auckland, New Zealand” (G. Boswijk et al.); “A ‘North
Atlantic island signature’ of timber exploitation:
Evidence from wooden artefact assemblages from Viking
Age and Medieval Iceland” (D. E. Mooney); “The
environmental context of the Neolithic monuments on the
Brodgar Isthmus, Mainland, Orkney” (C. R. Bates et al.);
and “Indicator groups and effective seasons on the coast:
Zooarchaeology of fish in the lower Suwannee region of
Florida” (A. Palmiotto).
Quaternary International. From Vol. 391: “Maritime
fishing during the Middle Holocene in the hyperarid coast
of the Atacama Desert” (S. Rebolledo et al.); Vol. 401:
“Upper Holocene sea level changes in the West Saronic
Gulf, Greece” (E. Kolaiti & N. D. Mourtzas); “Vertical
land movements and sea level changes along the coast of
Crete (Greece) since Late Holocene” (N. Mourtzas et al.);
and “New insights on the subsidence of Lipari island
(Aeolian islands, southern Italy) from the submerged
Roman age pier at Marina Lunga” (M. Anzidei et al);
Vol. 405 (Part B): “Variation in regional diet and
mandibular morphology in prehistoric Japanese hunter–
gatherer–fishers” (K. C. Hoovera & F. L’Engle
Williams); and Vol. 407 (Part A): “Sedimentological
evidence of an assumed ancient anchorage in the
hinterland of a Phoenician settlement
estuary/SW-Spain)” (T. Klein et al.).
39(3/4)
(Guadiana
Several articles published in the first half of 2016
comprehend archaeometric results that could be useful for
maritime archaeologists: Applied Physics A, Vol. 122,
No. 4: “Texture analysis of Napoleonic War Era copper
bolts” (F. Malamud et al.); Archaeological and
Anthropological Sciences (available online): “Scattered
shipwreck site prospection: the combined use of
numerical modeling and documentary research
(Fougueux, 1805)” (T. Fernández-Montblanc et al.);
Archaeological Research in Asia, Vol. 6: “Glass bead
trade in the Early Roman and Mamluk Quseir ports − A
view from the Oriental Institute Museum assemblage” (J.
Then-Obłuskaa & L. Dussubieux); Archaeometry, Vol.
58, No. 3: “A Box Containing Carpenter’s Accessories
from
The
Akko
1
Shipwreck,
Israel:
Archaeometallurgical Analysis of Surviving Ironwork”
(D. Cvikel et al.); Comptes Rendus Palevol, Vol. 15, No.
5: “Perforation techniques and traces of use on the
Mesolithic adornments of the Trench Area at Cabeço da
Amoreira Shellmidden (Muge, central Portugal)” (L.
André & N. Bicho); Corrosion Science (available
online): “Brass–iron couple and brass–iron–wood ternary
system of metal objects from the Akko 1 shipwreck
(Israel)” (D. Ashkenazi et al); Digital Applications in
Archaeology and Cultural Heritage, Vol. 3, No. 1: “3D
reconstruction of marble shipwreck cargoes based on
underwater multi-image photogrammetry” (C. Balletti et
al.); Geoarchaeology, Vol. 31, No. 3: “Emergence of
Civilization, Changes in Fluvio-Deltaic Style, and
Nutrient Redistribution Forced by Holocene Sea-Level
Rise” (B. T. Pennington et al.); and “A Geoarchaeological
Survey of the Marine Extension of the Roman
Archaeological Site Villa del Pezzolo, Vico Equense, on
the Sorrento Peninsula, Italy” (P. Aucelli et al.);
International Biodeterioration & Biodegradation, Vol.
107: “The effects of wood anisotropy on the mode of
attack by the woodborer Teredo navalis and the
implications for underwater cultural heritage” (A. M.
Eriksen et al.); and Vol. 108: “Impact and colonization
dynamics of the bivalve Rocellaria dubia on limestone
experimental panels in the submerged Roman city of
Baiae (Naples, Italy)” (E. Casoli et al.); ISPRS Journal
of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Vol. 114: “A
structured light method for underwater surface
reconstruction” (A. Sarafraza & B. K. Haus); Journal of
Cultural Heritage, Vol. 17: “A thermophysical study on
the freeze drying of wooden archaeological artifacts” (Z.
Shaozhi et al.); and Vol. 18: “Strontium carbonate
nanoparticles for the surface treatment of problematic
sulfur and iron in waterlogged archaeological wood” (E.
J. Schofield et al.); Journal of Human Evolution, Vol.
FALL/WINTER 2016
SAS BULLETIN
92: “Return rates from intertidal foraging from Blombos
Cave to Pinnacle Point: Understanding early human
economies” (J. C. De Vynck et al.); and Vol. 93: “Earliest
evidence of personal ornaments associated with burial:
The Conus shells from Border Cave” (F. d’Errico & L.
Backwell); L’Anthropologie, Vol. 120, No. 2: “Les
environnements du Vanuatu de l’Holocène à nos jours: un
état des lieux des connaissances” (C. Combettes); Marine
Geology, Vol. 371: “Quantification of bottom trawl
fishing damage to ancient shipwreck sites” (M. L.
Brennan et al.); Metallography, Microstructure, and
Analysis, Vol.5, No. 1: “The Dor 2002/2 Shipwreck,
Israel: Characterization of Surviving Ironwork” (D.
Cvikel & D. Ashkenazi); Microchemical Journal, Vol.
126: “Analytical study of waterlogged ivory from the
Bajo de la campana site (Murcia, Spain)” (M. T.
Doménech-Carbó et al.); Ocean Engineering, Vol. 114:
“Stabilizing control and human scale simulation of a
submarine ROV navigation” (A. Khadhraoui et al.);
Periodico di Mineralogia, Vol. 85, No. 1:
“Archaeometric characterization of Roman volcanic
millstones from Messina territory (Sicily, Italy)” (M. Di
Bella et al.); Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote
Sensing, Vol. 82, No. 3: “Characterizing a Debris Field
Using Digital Mosaicking and CAD Model
Superimposition from Underwater Video” (J. M. Vincelli
et al.); Quaternary Science Reviews, Vol. 136:
“Realising consilience: How better communication
between archaeologists, historians and natural scientists
can transform the study of past climate change in the
Mediterranean” (A. Izdebski et al.); and The Bulletin of
the Australasian Institute of Maritime Archaeology,
Vol. 39 (for 2015): “Understanding the interactive nature
of in-situ processes for management of submerged
cultural heritage material” (T. Winton).
British Archaeological Reports (BAR). The following
book published early on 2016 by Archaeopress is of
particular interest: Water as a morphogen in
landscapes/L’eau comme morphogène dans les paysages
(S. Robert & B. Sittler, eds.), BAR No. 232, viii + 104
pages; illustrated throughout in black and white, ISBN
9781784912871.
This
book
includes
eight
communications of the XVII UISPP World Congress,
which was held on 1st to 7th September 2014 in Burgos,
Spain. These presentations shed light on the relationship
between inhabitants of different periods and places from
Prehistory to recent times, and their surrounding
environment. The common denominator of these papers
is a focus on the role played by water bodies ―mostly
rivers― in people’s settlement, circulation across the
territory, management of resources, and landscape
construction, among the main themes.
PAGE 5
Thesis
Early on 2016, the Ph.D. Dissertation “Innovación
tecnológica y conflicto naval en Europa Occidental,
1751-1815: aportes arqueológicos e históricos al
conocimiento de la metalurgia y sus aplicaciones en los
barcos de guerra”, was presented by Nicolás C. Ciarlo at
the School of Philosophy and Letters, University of
Buenos Aires, Argentina. This thesis deals with the
analysis of technological innovations and conflict of
naval powers from mid-18th to early 19th century, with
focus on the applications of metallurgy to warships. An
array of metal artifacts from British, French and Spanish
shipwrecks from this period was characterized. Ships of
different rates (and unrated) were considered, and special
attention was paid to objects related to structural
fastenings, sheathing, nautical equipment, and ordnance
for specific analysis. The application of different
instrumental techniques such as Light Microscopy,
Scanning Electron Microscopy, Energy Dispersive X-ray
Spectroscopy, Optical Emission Spectroscopy, and
Atomic Absorption Spectrometry, allowed identifying the
materials and methods of manufacture employed. Based
on this technical data and the information recovered from
historical sources and other well studied archaeological
sites, changes in metallurgy and warships of the main
European navies were analyzed. A discussion concerning
technological transfer, the place of empirical techniques
and scientific knowledge, as well as the implications that
war between the mentioned states had on developments,
allow shedding light on the dynamic of the innovation
process during early Modern period.
Previous Meetings and Conferences
49th Annual Conference on Historical and Underwater
Archaeology. A Call to Action: The Past and Future of
Historical Archaeology. This meeting was held from 6th
to 9th January 2016, at the Omni Shoreham Hotel in
Washington, D.C. The following presentations dealt with
the application of geophysical methods for archaeological
survey, the use of digital techniques for recording wrecks
and artifacts, as well as the analysis of samples from ships
and prehistoric sites: “Using Mobile Sonar and 3D
Animated Web Modeling for Public Outreach and
Management of Historic Shipwrecks in Lake Michigan”
(K. Kaufmann); “Initial Deepwater Archaeological
Survey and Assessment of the Atomic Target Vessel US
Independence (CVL22)” (J. P. Delgado et al.); “Recent
Analyses of the Faunal Assemblage from the Submerged
Cave Site of Hoyo Negro: Implications for Late
Pleistocene Human Ecology Research on the Yucatan
Peninsula” (D. Rissolo et al.); “Multiscale Image
Acquisition for Structure-from-Motion (SfM) Modeling
of the Submerged Late Pleistocene Site of Hoyo Negro,
Quintana, Mexico” (A. E. Nava Blank et al.); “The Case
PAGE 6
SAS BULLETIN
of Patrão Lopes Military Ship: The Bio-Sedimentation as
Monitor Element of Underwater Archaeological Sites of
Cascais Sea, Portugal” (J. Freire et al.); “Bed Load: An
Archaeological Investigation of the Sediment Matrix at
the H.L. Hunley Site” (H. Brown); “Can A Picture Save
A Thousand Ships?: Using 3D Photogrammetry to
Streamline Maritime Archaeological Recordation and
Modeling” (C. P. Morris); “The Egadi 10 Warship: From
Excavation to Exhibition” (M. Polakowski); “3D
Digitization of Archaeological Artifacts in Conservation”
(C. Dostal); “Reconstruction of the Pillar Dollar Wreck,
Biscayne National Park, Florida” (W. L. Fleming);
“ROV-Based 3D Modeling Efforts on a Submerged
WWII Aircraft for Museum Display” (M. LickliterMundon & B. Buxton); “Legacies of an Old Design:
Reconstructing Rapid’s Lines Using 3D Modeling
Software” (I. Mollema & J. F. McKinnon); “Shelburne
Shipyard Steamboat Graveyard: Results of the 2015 Field
Season Using Traditional and New Recording
Techniques” (C. Kennedy); “Photogrammetric Recording
of 19th Century Lake Champlain Steamboats: Shelburne
Shipyard Steamboat Graveyard 2015” (K. Yamafune &
D. Bishop); “Analyzing Nineteenth-Century Steamboat
Rudders on Lake Champlain: Using Photogrammetric
Modeling to Aid the Archaeological Process” (D. Bishop
& K. Yamafune); “Mechanical Scanning Sonar: 21st
Century Documentation of 19th Century Shipwrecks” (C.
Sabick); “Efficient and Effective in situ Heritage
Management: Using 3D Photomodels to Document and
Assess a Site’s condition” (K. Yamafune et al.); “Hidden
in Plain Sight: Monitoring Shipwrecks in the Atlantic
Waters of St. Augustine, Florida” (P. B. Burke); “HighResolution 2D and 3D Imaging of the USS Macon Wreck
Site” (M. L. Brennan et al.); “Forensic Archaeological
Investigation and Recovery of Underwater U.S. Naval
Aircraft Wreck Sites: Two Case Studies from Palau and
Papua New Guinea” (R. K. Wills & A. T. Piertruszka);
“Deconcreting the Hunley: Revealing the Surface of the
Submarine for the First Time” (P. Mardikian); “The
Hunley Revealed: 3D Documentation, Deconcretion, and
Recent Developments in the Investigation of the H.L.
Hunley Submarine” (M. P. Scafuri); “Corrosion
Monitoring and Preservation in Situ of Large Iron
Artifacts at the Queen Anne’s Revenge Shipwreck site”
(S. Watkins-Kenney); “USCS Paddle Steamer Robert J.
Walker, 1847-1860: Historical and Archaeological
Research, Diver and Fisher Knowledge, and the Remote
Sensing Search” (J. H. Steinmetz); “Modeling Change:
Quantifying Great Lakes Metal Shipwreck Degradation
Using Structure from Motion 3D Imaging” (C. N. Zant);
“Life Among the Wind and Waves: Examining Living
Conditions on Sailing Vessels Through the Use of
Microscopic Remains” (J. D. Shidner); “Recognizing
Geomagnetic Storms in Marine Magnetometer Data:
39(3/4)
Toward Improved Archaeological Resource Identification
Practices” (B. M. Carrier et al.); and “Directions in
Deepwater Marine Archaeology: Using Technology to
Grow and Synthesize Knowledge on the Deep Frontier”
(E. Swanson et al.).
44th Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods
in Archaeology Conference (CAA 2016). Exploring
Oceans of Data. This meeting was held from March 29th
to April 2nd 2016, at the Museum of Cultural History,
University of Oslo, Norway. The conference was attended
by scholars, specialists and experts in the field of
computing technologies applied to archaeology, and
addressed a multitude of topics. The presentations were
focused on the exploration the oceans of digital
information available from a plethora of archaeological
sites. Regarding maritime heritage, the following case
studies from all over the world are worth mentioning:
from Session No. 3, “Modeling prehistoric maritime
interactions in East Polynesia” (M. Allen et al.);
“Reconstructing and modelling the Stone Age landscape
in Southeastern Norway” (G. Steinskog); “Uncovering
routes to Grenada: Exploring possible routes between
mainland South America and the Southern Lesser
Antilles” (E. Slayton et al.); “Looking for the lost harbor.
Role of non-invasive archaeological methods in the
reconstruction of the seascape of an ancient city Paphos”
(P. Ćwiąkała et al.); “Simulating Pre-Hispanic canoe
navigation in Lake Cocibolca, Nicaragua” (A. K. Benfer);
“Evocative virtual exploration of underwater sites: Issues
and approaches” (M. Ritondale et al.); “A space and time
analysis of the Early Bronze Age Levantine Littoral” (C.
Safadi); “Exploitation of prevailing winds and currents by
the earliest known seafarers, reaching and colonizing
Australasia c 50 000 years ago” (E. K. Kuijjer et al.);
“Using GIS modeling to reconstruct the urban landscape
of the Roman city of Ossonoba” (C. S. Machado Teixeira
et al.); and “The first web based viewer for archaeological
underwater sites in Europe: The Splashcos―Viewer” (M.
Mennenga & H. Jöns); from Session No. 6, “3D
Reconstruction of Koch, Russian rowing/sailing boat of
the 17th century” (M. V. Vavulin et al.); from Session
No. 7, “Creation of an Early 19th century Siberian ship
3D model” (A. A. Pushkarev et al.); and “Underwater
archaeological remains open to the public diving – close
range photogrammetry as a digital preservation and
complex documentations of despairing relicts” (A. M.
Kubicka); from Session No. 11, “Best practices to re-use
remote sensing data coming from marine geophysical
surveys for the 3D reconstruction of underwater
archaeological deep-sites” (M. Ritondale et al.); from
Session No. 13, “Liquid footprints: Water, urbanism, and
sustainability in Roman Ostia” (M. A. Locicero); and
from Session No. 15, “From the largest to the smallest:
FALL/WINTER 2016
SAS BULLETIN
The use of the latest technology in digitalization of the
objects from the collection of the National Maritime
Museum in Gdańsk” (P. Dziewanowski & J. Różycki).
Society for American Archaeology 81st Annual
Meeting. This event was held from 6th to 10th April
2016, at Orlando, Florida. Among the numerous
presentations on the archaeology of maritime cultures, the
following can be highlighted: “Deepwater Shipwrecks
and Oil Spill Impacts: A Multidisciplinary Investigation
of Shipwreck Impacts from the Deepwater Horizon Oil
Spill” (D. Warren et al.); “Gulf of Mexico Shipwreck
Corrosion, Hydrocarbon Exposure, Microbiology, and
Archaeology (GOM-SCHEMA) Project: Did the 2010
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Impact Historic
Shipwrecks?” (M. Damour et al.); and “From Excavation
to the Laboratory: A Multi-faceted Analysis of the
Emanuel Point Shipwrecks” (J. Bratten). See the final
program
at:
www.saa.org/Portals/0/SAA/MEETINGS/2016%20Progr
am/Program_final.pdf
Courses and Seminars
Advanced Practicum in Maritime Archaeology. Flinders
University will host a field school practicum between
21st and 26th November 2016. It will focus on marine
geophysics and 3D modeling in Archaeology, providing
students with opportunities to participate in a professional
work environment. This course will be taught in intensive
mode during one week (6 days) and will focus on the
principles, theory and method of marine geophysics for
archaeology. It will also include a 2-day workshop on the
application of 3D modeling to maritime archaeology. One
day will be spent in the field, to acquire data, while
another will be devoted to the interpretation and
reporting. Theory and taught coursework will cover an
introduction to sidescan, marine magnetometer, subbottom and multi-beam. Field data will be gathered and
interpreted using sidescan data only. If you need further
information about the course please contact Dr Jonathan
Benjamin to
[email protected]
3D Workshop in underwater archaeology. A workshop
on 3D Multi-image Photogrammetry will be taught by
specialists Mr Kevin Edwards (Tempus Archaeology &
Western Australian Museum, Perth & Flinders
University, Adelaide) and Dr Kotaro Yamafune (Texas
A&M University, Texas) during 26th & 27th November
2016. This two day course will precede the opening of the
Sixth International Congress on Underwater Archaeology
(IKUWA6), which will be hosted by the Western
Australian Maritime Museum in Fremantle, Western
Australia, between 28th November and 2nd December.
PAGE 7
For more information about the IKUWA6 and the course,
see: www.aima-underwater.org.au/about-ikuwa6/
Figure 2. The INA new research vessel: Virazon II.
Miscellanea
INA new research vessel: Virazon II. On May 4, The
Institute of Nautical Archaeology (INA) christened a
brand-new custom-built archaeological research vessel in
Istanbul, Turkey (Figure 2). The 25 m-long Virazon II
was designed by NAVTEK naval architecture firm and
built in the MengiYay shipyard in Tuzla, Turkey. She is
powered by twin 405-hp engines, three 108-kw
generators, and a 54-kw bow thruster. She can
accommodate 19 researchers and crew, including two
guests in a VIP cabin with en-suite bathroom. Virazon II
is designed to support underwater surveys and shipwreck
excavations around the world, being equipped with a 5ton A-frame for lifting INA’s two-person submersible
Carolyn, a 500-kg deck crane, two hull-mounted sonar
units, a two-person recompression chamber, and 8 highand low-pressure air compressors for airlifting and tankfilling with Nitrox capability. Virazon II is the first ship in
Turkey to be built and classed by RINA as an
archaeological research vessel; her construction was
made possible by a donation honoring the lifelong
contributions of INA Director and underwater pioneer
Claude Duthuit (1931-2011). She is named after INA’s
first research vessel, the 1953 U.S. Army T-Boat Virazon.
INA has been affiliated with the graduate Nautical
Archaeology Program at Texas A&M University for four
decades. INA owns and operates a research center in
Bodrum, Turkey and works closely with the Bodrum
Museum of Underwater Archaeology, where thousands of
artifacts from five decades of INA shipwreck excavations
are on public display. Following sea trials this summer,
Virazon II will relocate to her permanent berth in
Yalıkavak Marina outside of Bodrum before serving in
her first Turkish shipwreck survey this fall.
PAGE 8
SAS BULLETIN
For further information about the INA’s Bodrum
Research Center, please contact Dr Deborah Carlson to
[email protected]
ARCHAEOLOGICAL CERAMICS
Charles C. Kolb, Associate Editor
This issue contains three topics: 1) Book Reviews on
Ceramics; 2) Previous Professional Meetings; and
Ceramics in the Journal of Archaeological Science:
Reports.
Book Reviews on Ceramics
Ceramics, Cuisine and Culture: The Archaeology and
Science of Kitchen Pottery in the Ancient
Mediterranean World, edited by Michela Spataro and
Alexandra Villing, Oxford and Philadelphia: Oxbow
Books, 2015. Vii + 278 pp., illustrations, index. ISBN:
9781782979470, $75.00 / £50.00 (hardbound); ISBN:
9781782979487 $2.99 (Kindle digital). Print copies are
available from a variety of sources starting at US $45.00.
Michela Spataro is the scientist for ceramics and stone in
the British Museum’s Department of Conservation and
Scientific Research and is a member of the faculty at
University College London in Italian Pre- and
Protohistory. Before joining the Museum in 2007, she
was a Leverhulme Trust Research Fellow at University
College London Institute of Archaeology, studying the
early Neolithic Starčevo-Criş Culture in Romania, Serbia
and Croatia, which produced the earliest pottery in
continental Europe. This project was linked to her Ph.D.
research, also at UCL Institute of Archaeology, on early
and middle Neolithic pottery production and circulation
in the Adriatic region (Italy and Croatia). She has been
conducting natural science research on ceramics at the
British Museum since 2007. Her research interests are
directed to the Neolithic in Southern and Southeastern
Europe with a focus on the technology of ceramic
production and origin of raw materials. She participates
in a project team of the National Institute of Archaeology
with Museum. Spataro is responsible for scientific
analyses of clay and stone artefacts in the Museum
collection. She uses optical microscopy and Scanning
Electron Microscopy to identify raw material sources and
the technological processes used to produce these
artifacts. She is particularly interested in the provenance
of ceramic raw materials (clays and mineral inclusions)
which can indicate where a pot was manufactured, and
therefore shed light on patterns of pottery production and
trade in the past. She has also worked on porcelain, clay
tablets, mosaic tesserae, stoneware, marble and
sandstone, and collaborates with conservators to assess
39(3/4)
changes in the condition of marble or limestone statues.
Classical archaeologist Alexandra Villing is concerned
mainly with ancient Greece and its culture. She is the
Curator of Greek pottery and terracotta figurines at the
British Museum’s Department of Greece and Rome, and
joined the British Museum in 2001 after having studied at
Oxford and worked in Germany and Greece. She was the
academic advisor for the British Museum’s Ancient
Greece website, co-curated a cross-cultural, cross-period
exhibition on Fantastic Creatures (shown in Korea and
Hong Kong), and has long been involved in excavations
in Turkey, at ancient Miletos and Knidos. Her most recent
work includes research with Michela Spataro on the
social and technological aspects of Greek ‘coarse ware’
pottery. Villing is currently preparing publications on
Archaic pottery from Miletos and on Greek-Egyptian
relations at Naukratis, a Greek-Egyptian trading city in
the Nile Delta.
The 23 papers presented in this monograph derive from a
conference which had the same title as this volume that
was held at the British Museum in London in December
2010. These contributions are the products of the
interdisciplinary exchange of ideas and approaches to the
study of kitchen pottery between archaeologists, material
scientists, historians and ethnoarchaeologists. They aim to
set a vital but long-neglected category of evidence in its
wider social, political and economic contexts. Structured
around main themes concerning technical aspects of
pottery production; cooking as socio-economic practice;
and changing tastes, culinary identities and cross-cultural
encounters, a range of social economic and technological
models are discussed on the basis of insights gained from
the study of kitchen pottery production, use and
evolution. Much discussion and work in the last decade
has focused on technical and social aspects of coarse ware
and in particular kitchen ware. The chapters in this
volume contribute to this debate, moving kitchen pottery
beyond the Binfordian ‘technomic’ category and
embracing a wider view, linking processualism, ceramic
ecology, behavioral schools, and ethnoarchaeology to
research on historical developments and cultural
transformations covering a broad geographical area of the
Mediterranean region and spanning a long chronological
sequence. This volume includes contributions spanning
eras from the Bronze Age to the Modern period, although
many of the essays focus on Hellenistic and Roman
subjects. As the table of contents indicates, several essays
consider kitchen wares in Peloponnesian and Greek
contexts near to the Corinthia, including the nearby
Berbati Valley, Laconia, Aegina, and Athens. A majority
of publications on Hellenistic, Roman, and Late Antique
pottery have focused on amphorae (storage and transport
vessels), or fine tableware’s (for dining), material classes