&quot;Giving Reasons. A contribution to Argumentation Theory&quot;

Lilian Bermejo-Luque

"Giving Reasons. A contribution to Argumentation Theory"

Lilian Bermejo-Luque

visibility

…

description

5 pages

link

1 file

In Giving Reasons: A Linguistic-pragmatic-approach to Argumentation Theory (Springer, 2011), I provide a new model for the semantic and pragmatic appraisal of argumentation. This model is based on a characterization of argumentation as a second order speech-act complex. I explain the advantages of this model respecting other proposals within Argumentation Theory, such as Pragma-dialectics, Informal Logic, the New Rhetoric or the Epistemic Approach.

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

Log In

"Giving Reasons. A contribution to Argumentation Theory"

Sign up for access to the world's latest research.

Related papers