Academia.eduAcademia.edu

The Image of Palestine in the Palestinian Art Scene after 1948

28 April 2011 Manar Harb: Sample Paper The image of Palestine in the Palestinian Art Scene after 1948 The period between December 1947 and April 1948 marks a major turning point in Palestinian history. During this time, what was Mandate Palestine became the state of Israel and the Palestinians, as a social and political entity, ceased to exist. To the Palestinians, this period, referred to by AlNakba, literally means catastrophe), is marked by violence, loss of a homeland, and a dispersion of an identity. For the focus of this paper, I will look at the image of Palestine in the Palestinian art scene between the period of 1948 and 1967, in terms of theme and style. I am taking this period of time because 1967 marked another turning point in Palestinian history, which had visible effects on the Palestinian art scene. Gannit Ankori, in her book, Palestinian Art (2006), attempts to compile, trace and analyze the Palestinian image through visual art productions, which she examines during various periods in Palestinian history. In this essay, I will attempt to add to her narrative concerning the images that have been produced after 1948. For the period after 1948, Ankori identifies two themes as the dominant subject matters raised in the Palestinian art scene. She notes that, on the one hand, Palestinian visual art, conveyed the harsh predicament of the displaced refugee; on the other, it produced idealized memory images of the distant homeland as a Paradise lost, Ankori, . To illustrate her point, Ankori looks at )smail Shammout’s paintings and uses Whereto? (1953) as her first example of an image produced by Palestinian visual artists, (illus. 1). Whereto?, the painting of a Palestinian man and his children, walking a road alone, without a mother. The facial expressions of the man are very expressive and exhibit feelings of sadness, loss and grief. The children are crying. The road is empty. Besides the landscape, the man and his children are the only human beings in the painting, signifying to the feelings of loneliness and Page 1 of 4 despair. )ndeed, the harsh predicament of the displaced refugee, is conveyed in this painting. 1 Ismail Shammout Whereto?, 1953, oil on canvas. The two themes Ankori discusses in Palestinian visual art appear in the Palestinian novel and literature after 1948. An example can be found in the poetry of Mahmoud Darwish. One illustration is in the following verses: I have a moon at the far edge of words and the blessing of birds and an eternal Olive tree I passed over the land before swords passed over a body transformed into table. I am from there, returning the sky to her mother when the sky weeps with her Mother, I cry so that a returning cloud will play me as music. I learned all words befitting the court of blood in order to break the rules. I learned all words and deconstructed them to build one single word; The homeland . (Darwish, 113) The image of the eternal Olive tree Darwish refers to supports the idealized memory images theme about Palestine. The predicaments of the displaced refugee are conveyed through feelings of agony Darwish describes over the loss of the homeland; we sense the distance of the Palestinian, between himself and the land, when Darwish says, ) am from there, but he is not there, and he weeps, referring to the plight of the Palestinian refugee who is far from his land. On the other hand, another theme in the Palestinian art scene after 1948 existed, which Ankori does not touch base on; it is the theme of the critical and realistic Palestinian addressing the situation and facing himself. If we compare the image of Palestine in Palestinian visual art and that in the Palestinian novel, we will find that the Page 2 of 4 image of Palestine in the Palestinian novel had a more serious and realistic reflection of Palestine after 1948 than the one found in Palestinian visual art. Ghassan Kanafani’s novella, Men in the Sun, is considered to be the first major example of AlNakba literature1. Published in 1962, the story takes place in ’s Palestine, and tells the journey of three Palestinian men in the Diaspora. Driven by poverty and desperation, they try to smuggle their way from Basra Iraq to Kuwait. Abu Qais, an ageing peasant, Assad, a young teacher and Marwan, a teenaged worker represent three generations in Palestinian society. Kanafani voices their concerns as individuals, which were not to go back to the lost paradise, but rather to provide food on the table for their families, to gain an education, and lead a life of relative normalization. Another example of the critical and serious Palestinian in Palestinian art after 194 can be found in Emile (abiby’s The Secret Life of Saeed the Pessoptimist. In this novel, Habiby addresses the Palestinian who remained in Palestine and lived in the state of the enemy. Each character represents a segment of Palestinian reality, and once again, there is less romance in the tone and images, and more down to earth approach to the situation. Perhaps the scope of this paper is not sufficient to draw a thorough analysis about the image of Palestine in the Palestinian art scene after 1948. However, it is evident that the Palestinian visual art has been influenced by the Palestinian novel. As a matter of fact, the Palestinian novel has been a source of influence beyond Palestine. Egyptian director Tawfiq Saleh, for instance, adapted Kanafani’s Men in the Sun into a movie, and the story continues to be played in the Palestinian theatre. Most recently, Men in the Sun was performed at the Freedom Theatre in Jenin in August of 2010. Therefore, another image did exist in Palestinian art after 1948 apart from the two Ankori mentions in her book, and this image, which I identify in its serious and critical approach, entered the Palestinian visual art scene and continues to be displayed in contemporary Palestinian visual art. See Ahmad Harb, The Cultural Effects of the Declaration of Principles in The Palestinian-Israeli Declaration of Principles (Birzeit University Publications, 1995), pp. 52-60. 1 Page 3 of 4 Works Cited Ankori, Gannit. Palestinian Art. London: Reaktion Books LTD, 2006. Darwish, Mahmoud. Al-Diwan 3 (poems). I am from There . Riad El-Rayyes Books S.A.R.L. Beirut, Lebanon. 2005. Habiby, Emile. The Secret Life of Sa’eed The Pessoptimist. Trans. Salma Khadra Jayyousi and Trevor Le Gassic. London: Zed Books Ltd., 1985. Kanafani, Ghassan. Men in the Sun & Other Palestinian Stories. Trans. and Ed. Hilary Kilpatrick. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 1999. Shammout, Ismail. Whereto? 1953. http://desertpeace.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/ismail-shammout-dispossession-towhere_2.jpg Page 4 of 4