Welcome To Evansdale Library!: Noël Kopriva Agriculture, Natural Resources, & Design Librarian 304.293.9747

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 8

WELCOME TO EVANSDALE LIBRARY!

Nol Kopriva Agriculture, Natural Resources, & Design Librarian


304.293.9747 [email protected]

The Science Information Cycle


Researcher has an idea
Researcher articulates idea in a thesis Someone reads it (and quotes it) Researcher designs experiment to test thesis

The popular media summarizes results

Researcher conducts experiment and collects data

Researcher publishes a paper on results


Adapted, with permission, from Linda Blakes Biology 115 LibGuide, located at http://libguides.wvu.edu/biology115.

The Science Information Cycle


Researcher has an idea
Does hormone replacement therapy increase the risk for breast cancer? Womens Health Initiative designs study

Someone reads it (and quotes it)

Results reported on news, Internet, magazines. CQ Researcher article discusses it.

WHI conducts study on trial group of over 16,000 women

Paper published in Journal of the American Medical Association


Adapted, with permission, from Linda Blakes Biology 115 LibGuide, located at http://libguides.wvu.edu/biology115.

Scholarly journals vs. popular magazines

Nobody wins with this approach


Students avoid generally reliable popular resources that they might prefer to use and their citation style is not appropriate or correct

Students use scholarly articles they dont understand and their citation style is not appropriate or correct Student miss out on using scholarly articles they DO understand

Articles in scholarly journals


Are written by professors or researchers (look for a university or laboratory affiliation in the article)
Biotechnical Faculty, Agronomy Department

Have abstracts and reference lists


Abstract

Use discipline-specific language

The rose flower phenolic compounds, especially anthocyanic pigments, have been extensively studied

Have a specialized format (often consisting of an introduction, methodology, results, discussion, and conclusions)

Materials and Methods Section

Articles in Popular Magazines

Have taglines instead of abstracts Are written by journalists Don't use Methods, Discussions, and Results sections Use language understandable by the general public

BOTH KINDS OF SOURCES ARE RELIABLE WHEN:


They are appropriate to the assignment or research project They are carefully evaluated and chosen using guidelines such as CRAAP* or RADCAB* The researcher integrates them into their paper or research project according to professional standards The researcher cites them professionally and ethically
CRAAP = Currency, Relevance, Accuracy, Authoritative, Purpose RADCAB = Relevancy, Appropriateness, Detail, Currency, Authority, Bias

You might also like