Public Administration: Engr. Sami Ullah Khan Babar
Public Administration: Engr. Sami Ullah Khan Babar
Public Administration: Engr. Sami Ullah Khan Babar
Public administration
Detailed and systematic execution of public law. Every particular
application of general law is an act of administration. ( Woodrow Wilson)
Stage 1
Birth of public administration
Woodrow Wilson – The study of Administration (1887)
Politico-administration dichotomy
“lies outside the proper sphere of politics.”
Goodnow endorsed Wilsonian theory of dichotomy – Politics and
administration (1900)
Politics has to do with policies or expression of the state will and
administration has to do with the execution of these policies.
Dr. L.D. White – introduction to the study of public
administration (1926)
Origin and Growth
Stage 2
Continuation of Politico-administration dichotomy
Scientific Approach to study public administration
Scientific managemnet
FW Tylor
Henry Fayol
Stage 3
Reaction to scientific management
Hawthorne experiments – Elton Mayo
Functions of executive – Chester Bernard
Origin and Growth
Stage 4
Rejection of politico-administrative dichotomy and classical
administration principles
Herbert Simon and Robert Dahl
Widened the scope of public administration by including psychology,
sociology, economics and political science.
Robert Dhal identified the fact that administration is affected to a great
deal by psychology
Stage 5
Post War developments
Public and private administration emerged
FW Riggs – the ecology of public administration (1961)
Origin and Growth
Stage 6
New Public administration
Relevance
Values
Equity
Change
Stage 7
New Public service
Democratic theory
Dialogue about shared values
Role of Public Ad
Managerial view
POSDCORB
LUTHER GULLICK
WILLOUGHBY
Scope od Public Ad
In Bureaucracy, the bureaucrats are elected through established In Democracy, the leaders are elected by the people of the country
procedures or state through free and fair elections.
In Bureaucracy, the bureaucrats are not considered as public In Democracy, leaders are public representatives.
representatives.
In Bureaucracy, the bureaucrats have a fixed tenure, i.e their In Democracy, the elected leaders or representatives have a fixed
tenure is fixed till the age of retirement, although their roles and tenure, after this period they have to contest elections again to get
responsibilities could vary depending on the posting etc. the necessary votes to regain and continue in power.
Bureaucracy does not give too much importance to, or focus much In Democracy, the elected representatives give a lot of importance
on public opinions. to public opinions as they are elected by the public through
elections.
Bureaucracy does not grant freedom of expression. Democracy grants freedom of expression
The mandate of Bureaucracy is to implement the laws. Democracy gives the powers to make the laws.
Bureaucracy is responsible for implementing the policies. Democracy gives the right to elected representatives to make or
formulate the policies.
Bureaucracy gives more accountability Democracy does not necessarily give great accountability. If there
was perfect accountability then corruption would not exist.
Since inputs from electorates are not paid heed to by the In Democracy, consultative approach is used before framing new
Bureaucracy, Directive approach is prevalent. laws, policies etc. Elected representatives takes inputs from their
electorates
In Bureaucracy, hierarchy is extremely important, a top down Democracy is based on the values of Equality, Republicanism,
approach is followed for smooth functioning of any department. Federalism etc.
Bureaucracy also focuses on Centralization.
Democracy versus bureaucracy