PNM Meeting Held on 24th 25th June 2022
PNM Meeting Held on 24th 25th June 2022
PNM Meeting Held on 24th 25th June 2022
of
between
Railway Board
and
held
MEMBERS PRESENT
S/ Shri S/ Shri
* attended on 06.12.2017 only.
1. V.K. Tripathi 1. Dr. N. Kanniah, President*
Chairman, Railway Board & CEO 2. Shiva Gopal Mishra, Genl. Secy.#
2. Sudhanshu Sharma 3. J.R. Bhosale, Working President
Member(Infra) 4. Ch. Sankara Rao
3. Mohit Sinha 5. K.L. Gupta*
Member(Finance) 6. S.K. Tyagi
4. Dr. Prasanna Kumar
7. C.A. Rajasridhar*
DG/RHS
8. R.C. Sharma
5. Rahul Agarwal
AM/Signal 9. S.N.P. Srivastava
6. R.K. Mangla 10. Amit Kumar Ghosh*
AM/PU 11. R.D. Yadav
7. Smt. Jaya Varma Sinha 12. Venu P. Nair*
AM/Traffic 13. Goutam Mukherjee
8. Smt. Seema Kumar 14. Mukesh Galav
AM/T&C 15. K. Srinivas
9. Smt. Aruna Nayar 16. Ashish Kr. Biswas
PED/Staff 17. P.K. Patsahani
10. Smt. V.G. Bhooma 18. Mukesh Mathur
PED/HR 19. Manoj Kr. Behra
11. Deepak Peter Gabriel 20. V.E. Charkhani
PED/IR 21. L.N. Pathak
12. Atul Gupta
22. Basant Chaturvedi
PED/RS
23. G.S. Puri
13. A.K. Chandra
PED/W&D 24. Smt. Jaya Agarwal*
14. Smt. Roopa Srinivasan 25. Smt. Praveena Singh
PED/Accounts 26. Smt. Champa Verma
15. Dr. A.K. Malhotra 27. P.J. Shinde
EDH/P
16. Ajit Kumar Jha * attended on 24.06.2022 only.
EDCE/G # attended on 25.06.2022 only.
17. Rameshwar Meena
ED/Signal
18. Pankaj Tyagi
ED/L&A
19. M.S. Bhatia
ED/Coaching
i
OFFICIAL SIDE FEDERATION (AIRF)
20. Sanjeet `
EDPC-I
21. Smt. Anvita Sinha
EDPC-II
22. Smt. G. Priya Sudarsani
DF(E)
23. M. M. Rai
DE(N)
24. D. Joseph
DE(N) II
25. M.S. Sunil
DIG/Co-ord.
26. R.K. Sinha
DE/IR
27. N.P. Singh
JDE(P&A)
28.Chhote Lal
JDE(W)
*****
ii
Section – A: Introduction
CRB & CEO as Chairman of the meeting addressed the gathering.
• During the year 2021-22, highest ever loading of 1418 MT was done by Indian
Railways which is 15% higher in comparison to previous year and such percentage
growth in loading considered to be an excellent performance for any organization
in the transportation industry.
• Highest ever Railway electrification of 6366 Kms has been carried out during
2021-22.
• Highest ever Rolling Stock induction of 1110 Electric Locomotives & 6291 LHB
coaches has been done during the year.
• Highest ever Capital investment of `1.90 Lakh Cr. has been made into the system
for creation of infrastructure during 2021-22.
• Best ever scrap sales of `5316 cr was also achieved during the year 2021-22.
• IR have set its own challenges and targets for freight loading and also in other
areas. Railways have to gear up to meet the challenges and achieve the targets to
improve its overall operating ratio.
• This year, IR have kept the target of 1700 MT of loading, 6000 Km of New
Line/Multi Tracking/ Guage Conversion, and 9000 Km of Railway Electrification.
• In rolling stock, we are inducting about one lakh wagons over a period of three
years and this is already underway. Target of 1290 electric locomotives has been
set for 2022-23 and 2023-24.
1
• IR is taking policy decisions like Gati Shakti Cargo Terminal, ‘One Station One
Product’ and also rolled out our indigenous technology of Kavach. A target of roll
out of Kavach over 2000 Kms has been kept for the year 2022-23.
• IR is trying to simplify rules and regulations in the interest of our own Railway
employees and departmental promotions are being expedited.
• Our traffic share is presently about 28%. If we are able to achieve the target of 17
MT of loading, our traffic share will definitely improve.
Chairman, Railway Board congratulated all Railwaymen for their performance and
hard work and also appealed them for even a better performance to achieve the
targets and desired results.
*****
2
Federation (AIRF) raised following points in their opening remarks during the meeting:-
1. Some decisions such as surrender of posts are taken in Board without prior
consultation with Federations. It would be more appropriate that prior
consultation is done with Federations to avoid confusion among the
employees in the field and also implemented properly in the field.
2. The pace of electrification of Railways is very fast and such new Railway
Electrification works require corresponding staff to man the new assets.
6. Regular PNM meetings are not being held by DG/IRISET with the AIRF
office bearers of Branch Union of IRISET in the recent past as it was being
done earlier.
7. Large recoveries are being made from the retirement dues of employees
posted in Construction Organisation on the grounds of wrongful fixation of
pay due to ad-hoc promotion, etc. DOP&T’s orders issued in this matter on
the basis of Supreme Court’s judgment has been circulated by the Ministry of
3
Railways. However, at the field level, such recoveries for wrongful fixation
running into lakhs of rupees are still being made. This needs to be looked into.
Federation cited the case of Shri Ishwar Das.
8. Recruitment in Grade Pay of `1800 against Sports quota has since been
stopped by Zonal Railways for the last three-four years. As a result, we are
not getting young sportspersons who continue to work in Railways and at the
same time, participate in games at National and International Level and bring
laurels for the Railways. Such recruitment in Grade Pay of `1800 against
Sports quota which has since been frozen since 2016-17, needs to be re-
opened.
12. Physiotherapists and Sports trainers play an important role in nurturing the
sportspersons. IR should consider about their progression and incentives.
13. Gurmeet Kaur, sportsperson has already been selected against Scout quota on
NR. However, her recruitment has been held up for want of age relaxation
which is pending in Board’s office.
14. Issue of Passes through HRMS has made the system very cumbersome and
unfriendly. Similarly, HIMS system is also very cumbersome. All such
digitalization needs to be simplified and made friendly for the employees.
15. Unions and Federations should also be included under E-office system.
16. Recruitment is presently being done on Pan India basis which is not
appropriate because selected candidates after joining start seeking inter-zonal
Railway transfer. It should be RRB-wise for the benefit of the local
candidates.
17. 10 years’ time limit laid down for seeking inter-zonal transfer is not
appropriate. This is causing a lot of frustration among the employees. The
earlier instruction of five years’ time limit for inter-zonal transfer needs to be
restored so that employees may go back near their home town. Employees
4
whose NOC for inter-zonal transfer has already been received, should be
relieved on receipt of fresh panels.
20. Quasi Administrative staff are not being given UMID card due to some issue
relating to problems in uploading of their data in HRMS, though their RELHS
cards have been surrendered.
22. The residency period for promotion from Junior Account Assistant to Account
Assistant is 03 years. This needs to be reduced to 02 years on the lines of
other Departments.
24. Higher Grade posts should not be surrendered by the Zonal Railways as it
adversely affects the promotional avenue of Juniors and such surrendered
higher grade posts should immediately be restored back.
25. The ratio for Promotion and Direct Recruitment to the post of Junior
Engineer/SSE in RDSO is at variance with Zonal Railways which needs to be
rectified.
26. Power Cabins, Route Relay Cabins, LC Gates do not have toilet facilities and
drinking water facilities.
29. 30% upgradation from GP 1800 to GP 1900 needs to be pursued as the matter
is struck since long.
5
30. Upgradation of SSEs from 4600 to 4800 pending with Ministry of Finance
also needs to be pursued.
31. LDCE should be kept open for all by way of reducing 10% posts of Direct
Recruitment if the candidates appearing of LDCE possess the qualification
prescribed by RRB for direct recruitment.
32. Report of the Committee for Pointsmen category recommending four Grade
Structure was already submitted, but orders have not been issued so far.
33. Night Duty Allowance issue pending with Ministry of Finance needs to be
pursued.
34. Quasi Administrative staff working with Unions and Federations need to be
regularized.
36. Ban on creation of posts for new assets is not appropriate as matching saving
is not possible in these cases.
38. Trackmen of Kolkata Metro get daily Night duty. Some mechanism should be
developed so that they should get some rest and daily night duty may be
avoided.
40. The prescribed 05 years service for medical decategorisation of staff should
be reduced to 03 years. Further, wards should be given appointment on the
basis of qualification of the candidate.
43. In respect of Ticket Checking Staff, the number of coaches to be inspected has
been increased from 3 to 6 which is not appropriate. The old order for
6
inspection of only three coaches by Ticket Checking Staff needs to be
restored.
44. As per the PRS module modification by CRIS, whosoever cancels the ticket
gets refund. However, this facility is not available for E-pass and E-PTO
holders. E-pass and E-PTO should be valid in case of cancellation of Ticket
before charting.
45. In case of employees who are psychiatric patients, they are considered to unfit
only after 5 years of such ailment. Such an order of Board is not appropriate
and this needs to be reviewed.
47. Residential Card Pass holders should also be allowed to travel in AC coaches
of EMU trains of Mumbai Suburban.
48. Rent, electricity and water charges for Railway Union Offices should be made
free. On some of the Zonal Railways, namely, Southern Railway, notice is
being received towards huge charges running into several lakhs towards rent,
electricity and water charges for union offices. On some other Railways, it is
supplied on commercial rates.
49. AC escorting staff does not have rest room facility like Ticket Checking Staff
and Running Staff.
51. One time exemption for online examination for Appendix-III should be
provided as employees have prepared for examination on the old pattern.
52. Duty of Gateman for ‘C’ class gates of Engineering Department should not
exceed more than eight hours.
54. There is no sitting arrangements for AC escorting staff in coaches. This also
needs to be looked into.
55. PPOs are not getting generated timely under ‘ARPAN’ which needs to be also
looked into.
56. Duty roster of staff of Engineering Department should be eight hours only on
the basis of Job analysis. Without job analysis, no activity should be re-
7
classified from ‘continuous’ to ‘intermittent’.
57. On some zones, persons hired by contractor have been deployed for night
patrolling which is not appropriate.
59. Where both the spouses are working in Railways, any one of them can adopt
RELHS and recovery should not be effected from both.
60. Accident Free Service Award should include other categories also which have
not yet been included so far.
61. Roster for GDCE scheme should be prepared in advance and its vacancies
should be kept separate before giving indent for Direct Recruitment.
62. Line Box for Running Staff needs to be continued enable them to keep a long
list of various tools and essential items including two three sets of dress.
63. Special Duty Allowance for posting in North East Frontier region, Ladakh,
etc. should be exempted from the purview of Income Tax.
64. Nursing Staff /Paramedical staff should be given pay scales at par with
instructions issued by Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. Any
shortcoming regarding qualification, training, experience in respect of Nursing
staff of Railways should be addressed.
65. Crew links in respect of Running Staff should be such that crew may come
back to their base station within 36 hours to improve efficiency.
66. Cadre restructuring of Track Maintainers in Kolkata Metro has not been done
since long. This needs to be expedited.
69. Despite separate meeting with both the Federations regarding merger of
TTEs/ECRC/Booking Clerks, no order has so far been issued by Board. As a
result, selection for the post of CMI is held up on many Zonal Railways.
71. There is no facility of quarters for Running Staff in Talchar. The running staff
is also not getting minimum guaranteed Running Allowance.
8
72. A large number of direct recruitment quota vacancies of CMAs are presently
existing. These vacancies may be filled from promotees fulfilling the
requisite qualification by way of granting one time exemption.
9
Shri Mukesh Mathur, Assistant General Secretary
****
10
SECTION - B: MINUTES
DG(RHS)/ EDH(G)
Federation raised the issue of problems being faced by Railway employees in the
matter of referring of patients for specialised treatments to referral hospitals by Zonal
Railways. Board’s instructions regarding referral facilities for taking treatment from
empanelled hospitals will be reiterated.
14/2014: AVC for the categories where there is no avenue of promotion of Group
‘B’ staff etc.
Issue of yardsticks is under active consideration. This will be finalised within one
month.
Position explained. Feedback in this matter to be taken up from the Zonal Railway.
The item may be treated as finalised.
(Finalised)
A detailed proposal will be submitted by Federation and the same will be considered in
consultation with Finance Directorate.
50/2018: Amendment/withdrawal of the foot notes below the Item No.58 of the
Model SoP 2017(medical matters).
Footnote below Item No. 58 of the Model SoP 2017 is being considered for
amendment. The proposal has been sent to Finance Directorate for concurrence.
The matter will be examined and processed on receipt of proposal from Northern
Railway.
The facilities of empanelling nearby Hospitals and Diagnostic Centres for providing
emergency facilities will be explored.
AM(RS)
Since the decision for closure of five Printing Presses has been deferred till March,
2023, the item will be discussed further.
AM(Signal)
12
AM(T&C)
AM(CE)/ EDCE(G)
49/2018: Working problems of the JE/ SSE(P.Way) over the Indian Railways.
The old inspection schedule and new inspection schedule for important items where
schedule of inspection of JE/ SSE(P.Way) has been revised, has been sent to
Federation on 17.06.2022. Federation demanded separate meeting with Member(Infra),
Railway Board.
PED(Accounts)
The matter has been examined in consultation with Establishment (NG) Dte. The
proposal of the Federation has been agreed. The detailed modalities will be further
worked out in consultation with Establishment Dte.
ED(L&A)
02/2022: Construction of the Railway Quarters for Running Staff at the locations
where new Headquarters of Crew have been created.
Federation was informed that a letter has already been issued in this matter to
Northern Railway on 10.06.2021. A copy of the same was shared with the Federation
during the meeting. The matter is under review.
Position explained. Under Plan Head, `55 crore has already been sanctioned to East
Central Railway and the Zonal Railway can prioritise this work relating to construction
of an Auditorium at Patna.
(Finalised)
13
24/2022 : Provision of drinking water in Dhanbad Division of EC Railway.
East Central Railway have advised that supply of water through pipeline to
Phaphrakund Magardaha and Mirchadhure Stations of Dhanbad Division will be
started within a month.
(Finalised)
ED(Coaching)
EDF(E)
20/2022: Coverage under Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 in place
of National Pension System, of those central government employees whose
selection for appointment was finalized before 01.01.2004 but who joined
government service on or after 01.01.2004
The issue has already been taken up with Ministry of Finance (Department of
Expenditure) and their response is awaited.
EDPC-II
14
ED(T&MPP)
The review of staff requirement on the basis of yardsticks for assessing actual
requirement of staff in all the departments, is already under consideration.
Divisions/Zones have been given power to redistribute posts from those areas from
where posts can be spared. Redeployment of personnel also can be explored. The
matter is under review.
EDE(N)
Federation was advised that the specific case is sub-judice. Federation desired that the
matter be taken up for separate discussion with the Chairman & CEO, Railway Board.
It was decided that special meeting will be convened involving EDE(N) & EDPC-II in
this matter.
A joint meeting of Training & Technical Directorates will be held in this matter within
a period of two months. This is also linked to PNM/AIRF Item No. 30/2022.
11/2016: Selection from Group ‘D’ to Group ‘C’ against 33⅓% quota and 16⅔%
quota in Civil Engineering Bridge Department of N.F. Railway.
15
04/2022: Promotion Policy for the Person with Disability - Case of 07 Persons
with Disabilities of Lower Parel Workshop(Western Railway)
Letter already issued on 23.06.2022 to Western Railway. A copy of the letter was also
shared with Federation during the meeting.
(Finalised)
Under examination.
09/2022: Speed Test for the post of Jr. Clerk/Sr. Clerk - Reg.
Board’s instructions issued earlier in this matter will be reiterated. Instructions issued
regarding periodical verification of service records of Railway servants will also be
reiterated.
The matter has been referred to DOP&T for their advice vide Board’s ID Note dated
08.06.2022.
Sufficient care has been taken while implementing the scheme of periodical transfer.
The single mother employee, if she holds a sensitive post, cannot be exempted from
the scheme. However, as far as possible, she may be shifted to a different seat in the
16
same place/adjoining area to avoid any hardship regarding ward’s school admission,
safety of girl child, mental stress, etc. The instructions already issued in this matter
will be reiterated.
EDPC-I
DE(G)
To be discussed separately.
JDE(W)
Suggestions received from the Zonal Railways as regards colour of uniform of nursing
staff of Railway Hospitals will be shared with Federation to seek their views.
17
23/2022: Provision of Kendriya Vidyalaya with hostel facility at BRKA in
DHN Division of EC Railway
SECTION - C: SUMMARY
18