101641
101641
101641
com
https://textbookfull.com/product/active-imagination-in-
theory-practice-and-training-the-special-legacy-of-c-g-
jung-1st-edition-tozzi/
OR CLICK BUTTON
DOWNLOAD NOW
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-quotable-jung-c-g-jung/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/biota-grow-2c-gather-2c-cook-loucas/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-international-handbook-of-
shipping-finance-theory-and-practice-1st-edition-manolis-g-kavussanos/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/leadership-theory-and-practice-peter-
g-northouse/
textboxfull.com
The Maternal Imagination of Film and Film Theory Lauren
Bliss
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-maternal-imagination-of-film-and-
film-theory-lauren-bliss/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/probability-and-mathematical-
statistics-theory-applications-and-practice-in-r-1st-edition-mary-c-
meyer/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/electrician-training-theory-book-for-
training-1st-edition-dole/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/music-of-the-renaissance-imagination-
and-reality-of-a-cultural-practice-laurenz-lutteken/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/an-analysis-of-c-wright-mills-s-the-
sociological-imagination-1st-edition-ismael-puga/
textboxfull.com
“This remarkable and exciting book brings C.G. Jung’s Active Imagination to
the creative, scientific, spiritual, and transdisciplinary needs of the twenty-first
century. Perspicaciously rooted in Jung, the book reinvents the clinical and provides
essential steppingstones for those taking this practice into art, philosophy and the
synchronistic sciences. With this collection, Chiara Tozzi establishes herself as an
important voice in analytical psychology and its multiple capacities to energize
knowing and being.”
Susan Rowland
“This book offers a series of articles covering a wide scope with the aim of
restoring Active Imagination to its rightful place as a significant method to access
the unconscious and meaning in Jungian analysis. Active Imagination is a method
developed by C.G. Jung which allowed him to access and delve into the images of
his inner world and of the unconscious in order to more clearly understand their
meaning and significance following the painful separation from Freud in 1913.
The images and dialogues that emerged were recorded in the Red Book, which was
kept private till its publication in 2019. The novelty of this method and the unusual
images that emerged initially created concern in those around Jung and led some to
question whether he was not falling into a state of psychosis. In fact, Jung was later
very clear that it was precisely the use of Active Imagination and of the powerful
images and dialogues that emerged as a result that enlightened him and led to a more
profound understanding of the unconscious and of its archetypal contents. One of
the legacies of the history of these early years is that there remains a lingering
skepticism or mistrust with regard to the use and validity of Active Imagination.
As a result, other than in training programs in Zurich, Active Imagination is often
not given much attention. The editor of this book Chiara Tozzi sets out to address
this lacuna and to restore Active Imagination to its rightful place as an invaluable
avenue to access a living experience of psyche and of the unconscious in a personal
manner. She manages this by bringing to the table, contributions from esteemed
Jungian analysts who descrive their use of Active Imagination in clincial practice,
which can include dialogues with dream figures, painting, meditation, body
movement and dance. In addition, she has included voices from the world of the
arts by inviting a director film/critic, a script writer, a professional dancer, a painter,
an author, and a musician to reveal, from their unique and personal perspective, the
central role that Active Imagination played in giving form to their creativity and of
this method as a way of accessing the ephemeral from which meaning can emerge.
The result is a wide-ranging collage of personal testimonies that attest to the
usefulness of Active Imagination as a way to access the creative and the imaginal,
in clinical practice, in ther arts and in our daily lives as an avenue to find meaning.
This book will appeal not only to analysts, therpaists and artists but to everyone
interested in their inner world and in creative expression. I highly recommend this
book and am confident it will nourish many in their search for access to creativity
and meaning in their lives.”
Tom Kelly
“The strength of this book lies in its rich tapestry of voices. It is impressive to learn
about the applicability of Active Imagination in scientific, artistic, and cultural
fields. The editor has masterfully gathered together an exceptional collaboration
of authors that offers a multifaceted exploration of Active Imagination, providing
readers with a treasure trove of insights and perspectives. Across the two volumes
of this book, theory, practice, and research are assembled in a very creative
way that includes research, methodology, theory and practice. Readers will find
references to personal experiences and practical examples that help us understand
the transformative power of Active Imagination as an indispensable attitude
and tool in all creative processes and encounters with the unconscious. Real-
life applications and personal anecdotes add depth and authenticity to this book.
I am sure that Chiara Tozzi’s two-volume book on Active Imagination: Active
Imagination in Theory, Practice and Training: The Special Legacy of C.G. Jung
(vol 1) and Interdisciplinary Understandings of Active Imagination: The Special
Legacy of C.G. Jung (vol 2) is a signigicant contribution that keeps the spark alive
of one of C.G. Jung’s most important legacies.”
Pilar Amezaga
“Chiara Tozzi presents her research on the essential factor in analytical work that
makes Jungians unique. Active Imagination is engagement with the psyche that
speaks in images from within and from without. In this process one is guided by
the wisdom of the Self that moves the development of the personality towards
increased consciousness and wholeness. Tozzi clarifies that it is a process specific
to the individual rather than a “technique”. It furthers engagement with our fears
and the unknown leading to the Transcendent Function that results in profound
changes in our personality. Conversely though, it is this hard work and frightening
engagement that deter many from its use. This book challenges us with a reminder
of C.G. Jung’s deeply effective creative path to healing.”
Nancy Swift Furlotti
Active Imagination in Theory,
Practice and Training
Based on extensive research and developed with the support of the IAAP, this
fascinating new work presents the precious value of the special legacy of C.G.
Jung, which he himself defined as Active Imagination, through a collection of
unpublished contributions by some of the brightest Jungian analysts and renowned
representatives from the worlds of Art, Culture, Physics and Neurosciences.
In addition to presenting the genesis, development and results of Chiara Tozzi’s
research on Active Imagination, this volume on Theory, Practice and Training will
also include the fundamental theoretical aspects of this technique. The book explores
Active Imagination in relation to fundamental contents of Analytical Psychology,
such as Individuation, Transformation and comparison with the Shadow, the
four psychological functions, C.G. Jung’s Red Book, and more. Moreover, the
connections between Active Imagination and Sandplay will also be explored, as
well as the possibilities of applying the technique with adolescent patients, how
it’s considered and proposed in Jungian Training, and some innovative clinical
methodologies of Active Imagination.
Spanning two volumes, which are also accessible as standalone books, this
essential collection will be of great interest to Jungian analysts, psychologists,
psychoanalysts, or anyone interested in discovering more about the fascinating
psychotherapeutic practice of Active Imagination and its interdisciplinary uses.
Index 130
About the Editor
Antonella Adorisio is a Training and Supervising Jungian Analyst with CIPA and
IAAP. Past Director of Programming and Training at CIPA – Institute of Rome.
Past Member of CIPA National executive Board, she was President of the
17th CIPA National Congress in 2016. Antonella is a Registered Psychologist,
Psychotherapist, Dance Movement Psychotherapist and Art Psychotherapist. She
has been internationally teaching Active Imagination for many years. As a teacher
of Authentic Movement, she studied with Janet Adler and Joan Chodorow. She
leads international workshops on Authentic Movement and since 2004 she has
been collaborating with Joan Chodorow as co-leader at the Pre-Congress day on
Movement as a form of Active Imagination at the IAAP international congresses
(Barcelona, Cape Town, Montreal, Copenhagen, Tokyo, vienna). She is the au-
thor of numerous papers on Active Imagination, Authentic Movement, Body/
Psyche connections and the Feminine published in Italy, the uK and the uSA.
She has co-edited several books. She works and teaches mainly in Rome. She has
been invited to lecture and teach in Kiew, Bucharest, Malta, Singapore, Zurich
and in several Italian cities. She is still teaching Authentic Movement at ISAP
Zurich as Guest Teacher. She is working with the IAAP Training Router Program
in Romania. She filmed and edited the film-documentary “Mysterium – A Poetic
Prayer-Testimonials on Body/Spirit Coniunctio”, offered in many countries. The
DvD was distributed by Spring Journal Books.
Gaetana Bonasera, PsyD, is a Jungian Analyst, IAAP and AIPA Member. She
graduated in Psychology from Sapienza university of Rome. She obtained su-
pervised systemic-relational psychotherapy training, a Master’s in hypnosis and
ericksonian Psychotherapy, and a master’s in emergency Psychology and Psy-
chotraumatology. PsyD Bonasera has been working as a private psychotherapist
for more than 20 years. Since 2018, she has been a Member of the DuN-Onlus
Association that provides psychological support to migrants and refugees. She
attended the AIPA Training Seminar on Active Imagination by Chiara Tozzi in
2019. She was also a speaker at the conference on Active Imagination by Chiara
Tozzi: “Who Is Afraid of Active Imagination?” (AIPA, Rome 2019) as well as
in the seminar by Chiara Tozzi “From horror to ethical Responsibility” (AIPA,
Milan 2020).
Contributors xiii
Laner Cassar is a Jungian Analyst (IAAP) from Malta. he is also a registered clini-
cal Psychologist, Psychotherapist and Supervisor working with mental health
services, and currently heads the Psychology Department at the Gozo General
hospital/Steward health Care Malta. he hails from the “essex school of analyti-
cal psychology” of the Centre for Psychoanalytic Studies, university of essex,
uK, where he earned his PhD in Psychoanalytic Studies. he is also an independ-
ent researcher in the history of psychoanalysis, analytical psychology and im-
aginative psychotherapy. Dr Cassar is engaged in various local and international
educational institutions. he has written several publications on his main interest,
namely the use and application of imagination in psychotherapy. his latest book
was published by Routledge in 2020 and is entitled Jung’s Technique of Active
Imagination and Desoille’s Directed Waking Dream Method – Bridging the Di-
vide. he is the President of the Malta Depth Psychological Association, Director
of SITe (Malta) and the International Network for the Study of Waking Dream
Therapy (INSWDT).
Valerio Colangeli, IAAP and AIPA Analyst, is a clinical Psychologist and Psy-
chotherapist. he collaborates with a social cooperative non-profit organisations
as an operator in some residential and semi-residential psychiatric services of
the ASL-RM1, with both adult and adolescent patients. he also has a private
practice. he is the author of publications in Italian and in international journals.
his main fields of research are analytical work in institutions and symbolic play
in adolescence. he attended the AIPA Training Seminar on Active Imagination
by Chiara Tozzi in 2019. he was also a speaker at the conference on Active
Imagination by Chiara Tozzi: “Who Is Afraid of Active Imagination?” (AIPA,
Rome 2019) as well as in the seminar by Chiara Tozzi “From horror to ethical
Responsibility” (AIPA, Milan 2020).
Federico De Luca Comandini is a Jungian IAAP Analyst who graduated from
the C. G. Jung Institute Zurich. he trained under D. Baumann and M. L. von
Franz. he is a Member of the International Association for Analytical Psychol-
ogy (IAAP), International Association of Graduate Analytical Psychologists,
Zurich (AGAP) and Ordinary Member and Teacher at the Associazione Italiana
Psicologia Analitica (AIPA). he holds seminars and participates as a speaker at
conferences in Italy and worldwide. he carries out research on symbolism, in
particular on the psychological processes involved in imagination. he is the au-
thor of many publications, including L’Immaginazione Attiva. Teoria e pratica
nella psicologia di C. G. Jung (2002, curated with R. Mercurio), In dialogo
con l’inconscio (2011) and Quattro saggi sulla proiezione. Riverberi del Sé
nella coscienza (2013), with the contributions of R. Mercurio, D. Ribola and
C. Widmann. he lives and practises in Rome.
Robert Mercurio is a Training Analyst and President of the Association for Re-
search in Analytical Psychology (ARPA). After graduating in philosophy and
then in management, he carried out his post-graduate studies in philosophy and
theology at the Gregorian university in Rome. he then completed the training
xiv Contributors
programme at the C.G. Jung Institute in Zurich where he got his diploma in
Analytical Psychology.
Eva Pattis Zoja is a Jungian Analyst and Sandplay Therapist. She works in private
practice in Milan, Italy. She is the founder of the International Association for
expressive Sandwork (IAeS) and has offered training in Jungian Analysis and
Sandplay Therapy in europe, Asia, Latin America and Africa.
Murray Stein, PhD, is a Training and Supervising Analyst at the International
School of Analytical Psychology Zurich (ISAP-ZuRICh). he was President of
the International Association for Analytical Psychology (IAAP) from 2001 to
2004 and President of ISAP-ZuRICh from 2008 to 2012. he has lectured inter-
nationally and is the editor of Jungian Psychoanalysis and the author of Jung’s
Treatment of Christianity, In MidLife, Jung’s Map of the Soul, Minding the Self,
Outside Inside and All Around, The Bible as Dream and most recently Men Un-
der Construction. he lives in Switzerland and has a private practice in Zurich.
Marta Tibaldi is a Psychologist, Psychotherapist, Jungian Analyst and Training
and Supervising Analyst at IAAP and AIPA. From 2010 to 2019 she was the Li-
aison Person of the IAAP Developing Group in hong Kong (hKIAP) and from
2012 to 2019 an applied visiting Analyst in Taipei, Taiwan. She was an adjunct
Professor of Intercultural Psychology at the university of Siena and a Consult-
ant at the Italian Center of Solidarity “Don Mario Picchi Onlus” in Rome. Since
2008, she has been a teacher at the AIPA’s analytical high School in Rome.
Lecturer in national and international congresses and workshops, and author
of many articles and essays, she has published the books Il mito delle isole fe-
lici nelle relazioni di viaggio del Sette-Ottocento (with G. Mazzoleni, D’Anna,
Messina-Firenze 1975); Oltre il cancro. Trasformare creativamente la malattia
che temiamo di più (Moretti & vitali, Rome 2010); Pratica dell’immaginazione
attiva. Dialogare con l’inconscio e vivere meglio (La Lepre, Rome 2011; en-
larged edition published in Mandarin by PsyGarden Publishing, Taiwan and in
simplified Chinese by Beijing ChenSheng Culture Communication Co. Ltd.);
Transcultural Identities. Jungians in Hong Kong (with T. Chan, M. Chiu, M.
Lee, B. Tam, e.T. Wong, Artemide edizioni, Rome 2016); Jung e la metafora
viva dell’alchimia. Immagini della trasformazione psichica (ed. with S. Massa
Ope and A. Rossi; Moretti & vitali, Bergamo 2020). She is the author of the
blog “C.G. Jung’s Analytical Psychology between Italy and China”, now re-
named “Conoscersi per conoscere”. She also has a website and a video channel
called “Marta Tibaldi. Psicologia analitica in un click”.
Chapter 1
Active Imagination
The Special Legacy of C.G. Jung
Chiara Tozzi
The years when I was pursuing my inner images were the most important in
my life – in them everything essential was decided. It all began then; the later
details are only supplements and clarifications of the material that burst forth
from the unconscious, and at first swamped me. It was the prima materia for a
lifetime’s work.
(Jung, 1961, MDR, cap. VI p. 137)
When I read Memories, Dreams, Reflections for the first time in 1978, it was this
very sentence, and the account of C.G. Jung’s courageous confrontation with the
unconscious, that particularly struck me. In the description of that dialogue and
encounter with obscure and dangerous parts of oneself, which could fascinate but
also instill horror, I found echoed the significant contents and images of the fair-
ytales and legends that had captivated me as much as any other kid in childhood,
regardless of the time and space in which that narration had taken place. And it
was exactly from listening to and reading fairytales that a passion for storytelling
was born in me, both as a mode of communication and as a profession, in literature
and film.
When I started my training to become a Jungian analyst at Associazione Italiana
di Psicologia Analitica (AIPA) in 1996, Dr Bianca Garufi, one of the most im-
portant Italian Jungian analysts, explained to me that this way of confronting the
unconscious, first experimented by Jung on himself, was a real form of therapy,
specific to Jungian clinical practice and referred to as active imagination.
Meeting Bianca Garufi resulted in a friendship that was precious to me. I met
her at the making of the feature film Le parole sono altrove1 (Tozzi et al., 2000)
with the AIPA Cinema Group. Bianca Garufi – with whom I had carried out one
of the interviews needed to be admitted to the AIPA-IAAP Training – was the
one who had invited me to join the AIPA Cinema Group because, although I was
DOI: 10.4324/9781003411369-1
2 Chiara Tozzi
then an AIPA trainee and not yet an AIPA-IAAP member, I had been a scriptwriter
and screenplay teacher for over a decade. Bianca Garufi, in addition to being an
AIPA-IAAP training analyst, was a recognized writer and poet: as a writer, she had
published several books, including a novel written in four hands, including one of
the most important Italian writers, Cesare Pavese (Garufi and Pavese, 1959). Here,
I would like to recall one of her qualities as a poet – as I have done elsewhere:
her splendid poem “Non l’Io” (Not the Ego; Garufi, 2002), referring precisely to
the conversation between the Ego and the unconscious that takes place during the
experience of active imagination. I was thus fortunate to have a first illustration
of the complex and special essence of active imagination precisely through that
“double-meaning” language that Bianca Garufi used spontaneously, and of which
Jung speaks about his way of writing (von Franz, 1988): i.e. giving voice to a har-
monious interaction between consciousness and the unconscious. Bianca Garufi,
as an artist, could express herself and write in such a special way because she
naturally possessed that more permeable diaphragm between consciousness and
the unconscious (Jung, 1916/58), which for Jung is typical of creative people; yet,
that more permeable diaphragm can be reached by anyone through the experience
of active imagination, by virtue of the activation of the transcendent function, that
is, that “movement out of the suspension between two opposites, a living birth that
leads to a new level of being, a new situation” (Jung, 1916/58, par. 189).
The specificity of the therapeutic method Jung had identified and experimented
on himself, i.e. active imagination, seemed to me extraordinary and valuable; at
the same time, the fact that, during the six years of AIPA training and afterwards,
I heard very little about it in the Jungian community was disconcerting.
Over time, I learned that this bizarre scotomization of a legacy that appears to
be not only precious, but Jung’s most specific clinical methodology compared with
other psychoanalytical methods developed by famous scholars of the psyche, was
not only taking place in Italy, but throughout the international Jungian community.
Certainly, the publication of The Red Book (Jung, 2009) and its worldwide dis-
semination necessarily led to recognizing that “first matter for a lifetime’s work”
mentioned by Jung in Memories, Dreams, Reflections. But what else was that “first
matter,” so admirably depicted and described in The Red Book, if not precisely the
contents of the unconscious that sprang from Jung’s courageous experience of ac-
tive imagination? And yet, while such contents and illustrations, after the publica-
tion of The Red Book by Sonu Shamdasani, became the object of in-depth study by
the international Jungian community and anyone interested in the psyche, the same
cannot be said for the dissemination of active imagination, which was also at the
origin of those contents and illustrations. Focusing on one of the special qualities of
The Red Book, namely its ability to symbolically illustrate a complex psychologi-
cal journey through written and visual images that were never saturated, I decided
to refer precisely to that double background used by Jung to explain his expository
peculiarity. I therefore made a video, entitled Un doppio fondo,2 in which I tried
to summarize the affinities between the language of film and those of C.G. Jung’s
analytical psychology.
Active Imagination: The Special Legacy of C.G. Jung 3
The first and meaningful support to represent the approach I believed is most in line
with the meaning given by Jung of active imagination (that is, the second one) came
to me from Gerhard Adler’s description of active imagination, in Studies in Analyti-
cal Psychology (Adler, 1948). In that essay, Gerhard Adler very efficiently clarifies
the difference between the two approaches, arguing that one cannot speak of a
To me, this brilliant and evocative explanation, based both on logic and on the met-
aphorical use of images, translated into a further image: that of “a different way of
being in the world” (Tozzi, 2017), reachable through the individuative experience
4 Chiara Tozzi
At one level, this is a reference to the schools of nuclear physics and analytical
psychology; at another level, it refers to the explanations that science offers and
the meanings that derive from a depth psychological and spiritual orientation.
Here Pauli was stuck.
(Stein, op. cit. p. 50)
What he [Pauli, Ed.] came up with was a marvelous image, the piano, which
with its black and white keys resonates with the Chinese yang-yin system. [. . .]
But then it became a matter of learning “to play the piano,” not only of under-
standing the issues intellectually [. . .]. This was the challenge put to him by
Jung and von Franz.
(Stein, op. cit., p. 50)
After sharing Pauli’s touching and meaningful active imagination, Stein added:
Pauli faces this issue head-on in this “active fantasy.” The piano symbolizes a
possible point of meeting. It represents the transcendent function, a synthetic
mind. Of course, the question is: Can he play the piano? Well, he is learning.
[. . .] At any rate, Pauli has given us in the image of the piano a useful metaphor
for the transcendent function, which may assist our efforts to create a sustained
and sustaining link between time and eternity for ourselves and with our patients.
(Stein, op. cit., pp. 55–56)
Active Imagination: The Special Legacy of C.G. Jung 5
Following this inspiring lecture, when I was back in Rome I decided to write
to Murray Stein, although I did not know him personally. I told him how much
I had appreciated his lecture at Yale and I explained to him that, by presenting
Pauli’s active imagination on “The Piano Lesson,” he had given a symbolic an-
swer to my consideration on the two ways of experiencing and passing on active
imagination. After all, my question on how to explain an attitude of active im-
agination had already been answered in the title of his lecture: it is . . . “A matter
of practice”!
Ever since, all my detailed studies, conferences, and seminars on active imagina-
tion have been focused on trying to pass on to colleagues, patients, and trainees the
meaning of that “different way of being in the world,” given by a true experience
of active imagination, as well as by the fascinating connections between active
imagination and other forms of expression and of human research.
But . . . there is a but!
As I felt the enthusiasm and interest grow within me and received positive feed-
back on active imagination from many IAAP colleagues and trainees, both in Italy
and in other countries I was visiting regularly as IAAP Visiting Professor, the dis-
semination and formation on this special Jungian method was still lacking.
When trainees asked me for a bibliography, I was forced to note there was a
clear lack of publications in the field, especially compared with other topics that
are more followed and analyzed within the Jungian community. I asked myself the
reason for this scotomization, so unequal compared to such unique magnificence
which we possess as Jung’s followers. I came up with a possible answer: that,
in fact, active imagination . . . scares. Nothing weird about that, considering the
complex and delicate journey to undergo to reach a dialogue with the unconscious
in a waking state, as required by active imagination. Yet, although understandable
in patients and trainees, such blind fear is not comprehensible in Jungian analysts
and, actually, seemed to me to be quite concerning. This is how I came up with
the idea of addressing this “troublesome” issue at the 21st IAAP International
Congress to be held in Vienna. I submitted my proposal of this difficult topic and
I am thankful to my IAAP colleagues not only for accepting my presentation, but
for inviting me to present “From Horror to Ethical Responsibility: Carl Gustav
Jung and Stephen King Encounter the Dark Half Within Us, Between Us and in
the World” in a plenary session. I must say that the unexpected and enthusiastic
reaction by colleagues on that occasion was an additional stimulus that pushed me
to go full throttle and even more in-depth: I ventured into a collective research
on active imagination that I could have presented to IAAP colleagues. My video-
interview, “The Lighting of Shadow Images – Interview with Giuseppe Torna-
tore,”5 shot in the projection room of Tornatore’s office in August 2019, in which
Oscar-awarded director Giuseppe Tornatore confronts himself with Jungian active
imagination for the first time, was another important step that pushed me to carry
on with my project.
The final spark came from something else, but I will talk about that at the end
of this chapter.
6 Chiara Tozzi
IAAP Analysts
1 Tozzi, Chiara, AIPA-IAAP, Italy
2 Adorisio, Antonella, CIPA- IAAP, Italy
3 Bonasera, Gaetana, AIPA-IAAP, Italy
4 Cassar, Laner, Malta Jung Developing Group-IAAP, Malta
5 Colangeli, Valerio, AIPA-IAAP, Italy
6 De Luca Comandini, Federico, AIPA-IAAP, Italy
7 Deligiannis, Ana, SUAPA-IAAP, Argentina
8 Fleischer, Karin, SUAPA, IAAP, Argentina
9 Méndez, Margarita, SVAJ-IAAP, Venezuela
10 Mercurio, Robert, ARPA, Italy7
11 Nieddu, Gianfranca, AIPA-IAAP, Italy
12 Pattis Zoja, Eva, CIPA, Italy
13 Renn, Regina, DGAP- IAAP, Germany8
14 Stein, Murray, AGAP-IAAP, Switzerland
15 Tibaldi, Marta, AIPA-IAAP, Italy
18 Cogliati Dezza, Irene, research fellow in the Affective Brain Lab at University
College London and Massachusetts Institute of Technology
19 Contarello, Umberto, scriptwriter, Italy
20 Padroni, Luca, painter, Italy
21 Piperno, Elsa, dancer, choreographer and dance teacher, Italy
22 Puddu, Emiliano, physics professor, Italy
23 Sesti, Mario, critic-journalist, Film Festival Director and Documentary Direc-
tor, Italy
24 Voltolini, Dario, writer, Italy
25 Research Unit RISORSA – Social Research, Organization and Risk in Health –
of DiSSE – Department of Social and Economic Sciences – of the Sapienza
University of Rome, Italy9
Second Phase
During the second phase, the IAAP analysts working on this research were free
to choose whether they wanted to work by themselves on a topic related to active
imagination, or to exchange opinions with myself and/or the other participants.
At the same time, during the second phase, additional contributions were pro-
vided by a neuroscientist and a physics professor, as well as contributions and
amplifications from the world of contemporary culture and art.
8 Chiara Tozzi
The results of the questionnaires and the contributions and knowledge provided
by participants could be shared collectively after I sent them out. This was aimed
at favoring a network of connection and exchange among IAAP analysts taking
part in the research, and among the neuroscientist and physics professor and all
representatives from the world of culture and arts who decided to take part in this
specific research development. This exchange could lead to further contributions
aimed at providing detailed empirical studies as well as new and original content
to corroborate the importance given by C.G. Jung to active imagination. Moreover,
it could help to highlight that active imagination is a unique psychotherapeutic
method, different from all the other methods available and practiced in psychoa-
nalysis and psychotherapy.
The results of the research were collected in a structured database. From the
beginning, a possible outcome of such data and all material produced and collected
was to give life to a publication managed by me, as editor of this research.
The quality of the questionnaire was monitored by the Research Unit RISORSA
of Sapienza University of Rome. I then analyzed the results of the questionnaire
and summarized and interpreted them.
United States 87
China 27
Italy 27
United Kingdom 24
For IAAP training analysts, the highest response was recorded in:
Germany 38
United States 27
Switzerland 17
Total Respondents by Country
COUNTRY N COUNTRY N
Argentina 4 Italy 27
Australia 2 Japan 3
Austria 4 Latvia and Lithuania 1
Belarus 2 Lithuania 1
Belgium 3 Luxembourg 1
Brazil 23 Malta 3
Bulgaria 3 Mexico 2
Canada 12 Netherland 1
Chile 2 Peru 1
China 27 Poland 2
Colombia 1 Portugal 1
Czech republic 1 Romania 5
Denmark 5 Russia 11
Dominican Republic 2 Serbia 3
Estonia 1 South Africa 5
France 8 South Korea 3
Georgia 11 Spain 4
Germany 9 Switzerland 18
Hong Kong 1 UK 24
Hungary 1 Ukraine 6
India 5 Uruguay 2
International 1 USA 87
Ireland 1 Venezuela 2
Israel 2 Total overall 344
The first interesting result is seen in Germany, where only nine IAAP members,
routers, and trainees answered the questionnaire (resulting among the lowest coun-
tries per response rate), while there was a high response rate among IAAP training
analysts, accounting for 38 respondents and therefore positioning itself at the top
of the list. This is an inverted trend compared with the rest of the countries, where
there was a lower response rate among IAAP training analysts than among IAAP
members, routers, and trainees. It is true that there are fewer IAAP training analysts
than IAAP members, routers, and trainees in the different IAAP Associations, but it
would be interesting to assess the results of the high or low number of training ana-
lysts who participated in the questionnaire. For example, in Italy, among all AIPA,
CIPA, and ARPA training analysts – that is, 305 individuals – only 13 answered
the questionnaire, accounting for 4.2 percent of all Italian IAAP training analysts.
It may be useful and interesting for IAAP Associations in the different countries to
calculate ex-post the percentage of training analysts who answered the question-
naire in each country.
Considering the results presented above, it appears that although IAAP members,
routers, and trainees, and IAAP training analysts consider active imagination to be a
meaningful component for C.G. Jung (95.3 percent and 90 percent, respectively) both
at theoretical and clinical level, they are not adequately informed about such practice.
Among those who answered the questionnaire, only 48.7 percent of IAAP train-
ing analysts experienced active imagination as patients, 69 percent experienced it
in training, and yet 81.9 percent use it in their clinical practice, showing that a large
number of IAAP training analysts use active imagination even though they may not
have personally experienced it during their analysis. This leads to a first interesting
question: since many IAAP training analysts use the practice of active imagination
without having experienced it as patients or trainees, are we truly able to provide the
skills necessary to use active imagination in our clinical practice? Are we sufficiently
trained to pass on the knowledge and practice of active imagination to IAAP trainees?
Figure 3 Percentage of IAAP member, router, and trainee respondents who be-
lieve and who do not believe C.G. Jung considered active imagination to
be meaningful and valuable in his clinical practice.
12 Chiara Tozzi
Figure 4 Percentage of IAAP training analyst respondents who believe and who
do not believe C.G. Jung considered active imagination to be meaningful
and valuable in his clinical practice.
Only 38.1 percent and 36.3 percent of all members, routers, and trainees are
familiar with the scientific literature on active imagination in international jour-
nals and in their country’s accredited journals of analytical psychology. For IAAP
training analysts, the percentages account for 54 percent and 50.6 percent, leading
us to think there may be a lack of stimuli on the subject. This seems to once again
confirm that the knowledge on active imagination is not sufficiently widespread
among members, routers, and trainees, nor among training analysts.
Moreover, 55 percent of IAAP training analysts say active imagination is consid-
ered to be an optional component in training.
Of the respondents, 56 percent believe it is seen as a secondary method; how-
ever, in reality, 78.8 percent of IAAP members, routers, and trainees consider it a
fundamental component in training.
The percentage asking for more practical exercises on such content through ex-
periential workshops is 83.7 percent. In addition, 42.2 percent of IAAP members,
routers, and trainees consider active imagination to be a fundamental component
in training, showing a further discrepancy between how individuals perceive active
imagination and how they believe it is considered in the IAAP Association they
are part of. Actually, 78.8 percent of IAAP members, routers, and trainees say that
active imagination is a fundamental component in training, but only 33 percent of
training analysts believe active imagination is considered to be an essential method
in the Association they are part of.
Data analysis validates the research hypothesis highlighting, among others, a
big discrepancy in the confidence shared by Jungian analysts who consider active
Active Imagination: The Special Legacy of C.G. Jung 13
Overall:
No
Yes
No answer
90%
Figure 5 Percentage of IAAP training analyst respondents who believe and who
do not believe active imagination is considered to be an optional com-
ponent in training.
I don’t know
No
Yes
No answer
90%
Figure 6 Percentage of IAAP member, router, and trainee respondents who be-
lieve, who do not believe, and who do not know if active imagination is
considered to be a fundamental component in training.
14 Chiara Tozzi
imagination to be a fundamental practice both for C.G. Jung and for the Jungian
community, and the current lack of knowledge, spread, use, and relevance of such
practice by IAAP Jungian analysts and in IAAP training.
I believe all this material could represent some interesting food for thought on
the relevance given to active imagination within the IAAP, both as theoretical
knowledge and as clinical practice, and as a teaching subject in IAAP training.
I could hope that not one of the large number of persons whom I
address, would ever be subjected to any of the processes of drug-
treatment in so critical a period as pregnancy. The water-treatment I
regard as being so much safer, as well as more effectual, for the
eradication of any and all the diseases to which you may be subject at
this time, as well as others, that I should be very glad if I could say
something to inspire you with a greater degree of confidence in the
new method. But perhaps I am wrong; some of you, at least, have the
fullest confidence in the sanative powers of water, and have no need
of any thing more being said on that point. It is proper, however, that
I say something here respecting the effects of certain drugs and drug-
appliances, in this period.
BLISTERS.
It is the testimony of honest and capable practitioners, that these
are far more liable to do harm in pregnancy than at other times.
Dr. Dewees asserts that he had known two cases of abortion
caused by the use of blisters, although he acknowledged they had, in
some cases, been advantageously resorted to as a means of
preventing that evil. But how, it may be asked, are physicians to
know when to use them, and when not? This no man can tell. Nor
have we any need of blistering at this or any time, because there are
better means, which are entirely safe.
The same able author whom I just quoted, tells us that blisters are
much more likely to produce strangury during pregnancy than in
other cases; and that when this occurs, it is almost sure to be
followed by the most distressing and untoward symptoms. Entire
retention of urine sometimes follows the use of cantharides in these
circumstances, which can only be relieved by the use of the catheter.
There is also, at such times, not unfrequently so distressing an
inclination and violence of effort to void urine, as to be surpassed
only by the agony of labor itself. Bloody urine has sometimes
followed the use of a blister; and a discharge of mucous from the
internal surface of the bladder has continued, as a consequence, for a
long time after. “It is true,” observes a distinguished author, “these
are extreme cases; but they nevertheless occur, and should,
therefore, suggest a great deal of caution in their employment,
especially in the more advanced periods of gestation.”
EMETICS.
These are no more necessary in pregnancy than blisters. Severe
vomiting is sometimes productive of abortion; and who is wise
enough to foretell what may be the effect of a dose of tartar emetic
given to a woman when in this highly impressible state? A single
emetic has caused severe and permanent pain, which has been
removed only after parturition has taken place.
PURGATIVE MEDICINES.
That pregnant women do not bear purging so well as at other
times, is a matter of common observation among medical men.
There is in such practice a great liability of causing abortion,
especially if it be carried too far. It is not difficult to account for the
fact, when we remember how great is the sympathy which exists
between the womb and the bowels.
If you should be obliged, any of you, under such circumstances, to
be purged, I advise you to see to it that you know what medicines you
take. Those particularly which have a powerful effect upon the
bowels should be avoided; aloes, colocynth, scammony, and
gamboge, should on no account be tolerated. These have a particular
effect in exciting the lower part of the alimentary canal, causing
tenesmus or a bearing-down pain in the rectum, which, by sympathy,
is very liable to be communicated to the womb. This is shown by the
fact that dysentery often causes miscarriage.
BLOOD-LETTING.
Not many years since, it was generally supposed that a woman
could not pass through the period of pregnancy safely without being
bled; and although a change has been wrought in the public mind in
regard to this practice, there are yet many who labor under
erroneous impressions in regard to this subject. There are those who
regard it as indispensable to resort to this measure, notwithstanding
there may be no particular symptom that, under other
circumstances, would be considered necessary to warrant a resort to
the measure.
It must be admitted, however, that pregnancy is attended with a
degree of fullness, and a tendency to plethora, which does not obtain
in other states of the system. There is, indeed, always, during
pregnancy, a greater liability to febrile and inflammatory diseases
than is ordinarily experienced. But all this does not prove that blood-
letting should be practiced in all, or in any considerable number of
cases. Besides, also, it is doubted by many honest and able
practitioners of the medical art, as to whether bleeding is ever, under
any circumstances, necessary. There are others, too, who believe in
the comparative necessity of blood-letting under certain conditions
of the system, but who, at the same time, hold that there are better,
safer, and more efficacious means of bringing about the required
object. At all events, physicians very seldom, at the present day,
resort to blood-letting during pregnancy, either in this country or the
old; and in those rare cases in which this measure is resorted to, it is
in answer only to indications of an imperative and decided nature.
Nor is the practice of blood-letting a comparatively harmless one,
as many suppose it to be. “Why,” it is said, “if it is not absolutely
necessary, it can yet do me no harm.” This is a poor recommendation
of a remedy. If a remedy is not capable of doing harm under some
circumstances, it would hardly be possible for it to do good at any
time. The testimony of the strongest advocates for the practice is,
that blood-letting has frequently been known to do serious, and
sometimes irreparable mischief, when practiced during the period
of which we are speaking.
Dr. Eberle gives the following good advice on this subject: “A very
severe and troublesome pain is often experienced in the right
hypochondrium during the latter period of pregnancy; and this
suffering is, almost always, sought to be mitigated or removed by
blood-letting. When decided evidences of plethora accompany this
painful affection, bleeding will occasionally procure considerable
relief; but in the majority of instances, no mitigation whatever is
obtained from this measure. The relief which is sometimes procured
by bleeding is always of short duration, the pain usually returning in
the course of two or three days; and if the bleeding is thus frequently
repeated, as is sometimes done, much mischief is apt to be produced
by the general debility and languor which it tends to occasion. When
the symptoms of vascular turgescence throughout the system are
conspicuous in connection with this pain in the side, it will certainly
be proper to diminish the mass of the circulating fluid by
venesection; but when no indications of this kind are present, blood
ought not to be abstracted, merely on account of this affection, for it
will most assuredly fail of procuring the desired relief, and may,
when not particularly called for, operate unfavorably on the general
health of the patient. Moderation in diet, together with a proper
attention to the state of the bowels, and the use of gentle exercise by
walking, will, in general, do much more toward the removal of this
source of uneasiness and suffering, than will result from blood-
letting, when this evacuation is not specially indicated by the fullness
and firmness of the pulse, or by other manifestations of general
vascular plethora.”
But in these cases, when so careful a practitioner as Dr. Eberle
even, would think it best to resort to the lancet, it is a well-attested
fact, that fasting and prudent abstemiousness are far better, more
effectual, and more permanent in their action upon the system than
blood-letting. The hunger-cure, which I have so often for years past
recommended, is a most valuable remedy in all plethora or over-
fullness of the system, and in all kinds and degrees of pain arising
from such fullness. See, too, how reasonable it looks; for the body, as
you know, is always wasting itself, so that if we stop off the supply,
the over-fullness must by a natural process very soon become cured;
hence I say, do not be bled in pregnancy; and when you have need
FAST.
LETTER XXI.
STERILITY OR BARRENNESS.
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
textbookfull.com