BMWPaper

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/338622347

Bioassay Study of Biomedical Liquid Waste (Treated Effluent) of Bhopal City,


Madhya Pradesh, India

Article · January 2020


DOI: 10.4444/ijrr.1002/1649

CITATION READS

1 662

7 authors, including:

Alok Saxena Ankita Kulshreshtha

30 PUBLICATIONS 222 CITATIONS


Institute for Excellence in Higher Education, Bhopal
36 PUBLICATIONS 183 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE

Vandana Ramnani
Barkatullah University
8 PUBLICATIONS 4 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Vandana Ramnani on 28 January 2020.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


International Journal of Research and Review
Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Website: www.ijrrjournal.com
Original Research Article E-ISSN: 2349-9788; P-ISSN: 2454-2237

Bioassay Study of Biomedical Liquid Waste (Treated


Effluent) of Bhopal City, Madhya Pradesh, India
Reeta Kori, Alok Saxena, Sandhya Mokhle, Vineeta Goutam,
Ankita Kulshreshtha, Vandana Ramnani, Makhan Parmar
Central Laboratory, Madhya Pradesh Pollution Control Board, Paryavaran Parisar, E-5, Arera Colony, Bhopal,
Madhya Pradesh, India
Corresponding Author: Ankita Kulshreshtha

ABSTRACT immunization of human beings or animals


or in research pertaining thereto or in the
Biomedical liquid waste originated from production or testing. [1] Medical care is
hospital, laboratories & research centres has the vital for our life, health and well being but
potential to pose serious threat to the the waste generated from medical activities
environment in terms of spread and
can be hazardous, toxic and even lethal
contagiousness of infectious diseases to the
system. Total fourteen hospitals were selected because of their high potential for diseases
for this study. The study was conducted during transmission. [2] Hospital liquid waste is
April 2018 to March 2019. Monitoring of wastewater generated from all activities of
biomedical liquid waste (Treated Effluent) was the hospital as medical and non medical
performed as per guidelines of Central Pollution activities from the operating, emergency &
Control Board and bioassay test was performed first aid, laboratory, diagnosis, radiology,
as per BIS method, 6582: 2001. Biomedical kitchen and laundry activities. [3-5] Hospital
waste may affected the aquatic life when it liquid waste refer to infectious, non-
discharged in to the surface water. Fish are the hazardous and hazardous liquid waste with
primary bio indicator as they are very sensitive sufficient free liquid arising from dental,
towards the pollution, so this study was based
medical, nursing, pharmaceutical or similar
on toxicity test on fresh water Brachydanio rerio
(Commonly known as Zebra fish). The practice, care, investigation, treatment that
observation based on 90% survival of tested requires additional safety packaging to
fishes at 50% dilution (1:1 ratio of waste water ensure safe transportation, treatment and
to test water by volume) up to 96 hrs, that storage. [6-7] In most developing countries,
represented as toxicity factor one. Further there is lack of technology, skills to
increase in toxicity factor represents increase in implement and monitor hospital waste
toxicity found acute state. This study concluded management programs. [8-10] Hospital
that treated effluents from most of monitored wastewater includes macro- and micro-
hospitals of Bhopal city were found free from pollutants of wide concentration range from
acute lethal toxicity. laboratories, research units, operation
rooms, units, where medicine, nutrition
Key Words: Hospitals, Biomedical Liquid
Waste, Effluent Treatment Plant, Treated solutions are prepared and polyclinics. [11-12]
Effluent, Bioassay Test, Toxicity factor As a result of such consumption, the
wastewater contains significant amounts of
1. INTRODUCTION microorganisms, heavy metals, toxic
Bio-medical waste means any solid chemicals and radioactive elements.
or liquid waste including its container and Hospital originated wastewater is
any intermediate product, which is discharged to city sewage systems in many
generated during the diagnosis, treatment or countries, treated together with domestic

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 164


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

wastewater and discharged to receiving tissues, microbes etc. It is defined as


environments. [13-14] Hospital laboratory estimation or determination of concentration
wastewater is considered a mixture of or potency of a physical, chemical or
pathogen microorganisms. The genetic biological substance (agent) by means of
structure of such microorganisms may be measuring and comparing the magnitude of
altered by the direct or indirect effect of the response of the test with that of standard
wastewater components and lead to bacteria over a suitable biological system under
with high antibiotic resistance. [15] Many standard set of conditions. [21] This study
developed countries required disinfection of was based on bioassay test for analysis of
hospital wastewater before being discharged toxicity of treated effluent from various
into sewage systems. Currently the most hospitals of Bhopal city.
commonly used disinfectants are liquid
chlorine, NaClO, ClO2, and O3. [16- 17] The 2. METHODOLOGY
fact that hospital wastewater contains entero 2.1. Study Area
bacteria and enteric pathogens, poses a risk Bhopal city is the capital of Madhya
for public health. Today, the marked Pradesh which is very well connected to all
increase in antibiotic resistance of infectious the corners of the country situated in the
agent pathogen bacteria seen both in central part of India. Its latitude is 23°25’99
nosocomial and community-acquired N and longitude is 77°.41’26 E. Bhopal is
infections is one of the most important also known as the “Lake City” for its
problems. [18] As a matter of fact, heavy various natural as well as artificial lakes and
metals pose threat to environment and is one of the greenest cities in India. [22]
human health since they are not biologically
degradable pollutants and that they are 2.2. Monitoring Locations
movable pollutant sources. [19-20] Total fourteen hospitals of Bhopal
Bioassay is an assay designed to city were selected for this study which are
analyze any compound by use of a depicted in table no1 and shown in figure 1.
suitable biological system like animals,
Table 1: Monitoring Locations
S.N. Code Monitoring Locations
1. H1 Bansal Hospital Shahapura, Bhopal
2. H2 Bhopal Fracture Hospital & Surgical Centre, Arera Colony, Bhopal
3. H3 Bhopal Memorial Hospital and Research Centre, Bhopal
4. H4 Chirayu Hospital, Bairagarh Kalan, Bairagarh, Bhopal
5. H5 Gastrocare Liver and Digestive Disease Centre, Arera Colony, Bhopal
6. H6 Government Shakir Ali khan(Gas Rahat) hospital, Bhopal
7. H7 Hamidia Hospital, Royal Market, Bhopal
8. H8 Indira Gandhi Mahila And Child Hospital, Bhopal
9. H9 Jawaharlal Nehru Cancer Hospital Idgah Hills, Bhopal
10. H10 J K Hospital & Medical Research Centre in Kolar Road, Bhopal
11. H11 L B S Hospital, Motia Talab Road Bhopal
12. H12 Kamla Nehru Hospital (Gas Rahat), Bhopal
13. H13 People's Hospital Bhanpur, Bhopal
14. H14 Swami Vivekanand Regional Spine Centre, M P Nagar, Bhopal

2.3 Monitoring and Analysis


Monitoring of treated effluents from effluent treatment plant of various selected hospitals was
performed as per guidelines of Central Pollution Control Board and Bioassay test performed
as per BIS method- 6582: 2001. [23]

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 165


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

Figure 1: Monitoring Locations

3. RESULT & DISCUSSION


This study resulted by observations of bioassay test which are depicted in table no 2 to 16. In
table no 2, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all four quarters observation of bioassay
test of treated effluent from Bansal Hospital Shahapura, Bhopal.

Table 2: Bioassay test of treated Effluent from Bansal Hospital (H1), Shahapura, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 6.98 7.02 5.5 3.0 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.10 7.18 4.5 3.2 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 6.82 6.86 5.2 3.1 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 6.85 6.92 5.3 2.8 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should
survive.Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 3, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all two quarters observation of
bioassay test of treated effluent from Bhopal Fracture Hospital & Surgical Centre, Arera
Colony, Bhopal.
Table 3: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Bhopal Fracture Hospital & Surgical Centre (H2), Arera Colony, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- # # # # # # # #
June 2018)
II (July- # # # # # # # #
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 7.25 7.33 5.0 2.9 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 6.95 7.08 4.8 2.5 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive. .
#Monitoring started after second quarter. Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3
gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 166


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

In table no 4, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all four quarters observation of
bioassay test of treated effluent from Bhopal Memorial Hospital and Research Centre,
Bhopal.

Table 4: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Bhopal Memorial Hospital and Research Centre (H3), Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.13 6.99 4.5 3.8 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 6.94 8.18 4.8 2.5 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 8.07 8.12 4.5 4.0 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 6.55 6.81 6.8 5.1 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should
survive.Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 5, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all four quarters observation of
bioassay test of treated effluent from Chirayu Hospital, Bairagarh Kalan, Bairagarh, Bhopal.

Table 5: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Chirayu Hospital (H4), Bairagarh Kalan, Bairagarh, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.68 7.72 5.8 3.1 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.62 7.75 8.2 6.1 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 7.02 7.64 5.4 3.9 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 7.11 7.28 6.9 5.3 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive.
Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 6, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all four quarters of bioassay test
observation of treated effluent from Gastrocare Liver and Digestive Disease Centre, Arera
Colony, Bhopal.

Table 6: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Gastrocare Liver and Digestive Disease Centre (H5), Arera Colony, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.21 7.38 4.1 2.8 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.16 7.19 4.5 2.9 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 6.73 6.77 4.4 3.8 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 7.08 7.18 5.8 2.5 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive.
Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 7, toxicity factor (Tf) was found two during first quarter and one during all other
quarters of bioassay test observation of treated effluent from Government Shakir Ali khan
(Gas Rahat) hospital, Bhopal.

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 167


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

Table 7: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Government Shakir Ali khan (Gas Rahat) hospital (H6), Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 2 1:2 1 6.31 6.45 6.9 5.5 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 8.23 8.38 7.1 6.3 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 7.91 7.93 6.2 5.0 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 7.96 7.99 6.5 5.2 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume
similarly 2 is for 1:2) after 96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium
dichromate, all fish should survive. Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm,
Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 8, toxicity factor (Tf) was found two during third quarter and one during all other
quarters of bioassay test observation of treated effluent from Hamidia Hospital, Royal
Market, Bhopal.

Table 8: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Hamidia Hospital (H7), Royal Market, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.16 7.31 6.3 4.8 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.66 7.69 5.6 4.3 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 2 1:2 1 6.56 6.78 6.2 4.1 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 6.85 6.93 5.8 3.6 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume
similarly 2 is for 1:2) after 96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium
dichromate, all fish should survive. Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm,
Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 9, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all quarters of bioassay test
observation of treated effluent from Indira Gandhi Mahila and Child Hospital, Bhopal

Table 9: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Indira Gandhi Mahila and Child Hospital (H8), Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 6.96 7.18 6.6 3.8 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 6.18 6.25 6.6 3.5 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 5.61 5.71 7.1 6.8 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 7.23 7.31 7.7 6.5 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive.
Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 10, toxicity factor (Tf) was found two during fourth quarter and one during all
other quarters of bioassay test observation of treated effluent from Jawaharlal Nehru Cancer
Hospital Idgah Hills, Bhopal.

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 168


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

Table 10: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Jawaharlal Nehru Cancer Hospital (H9), Idgah Hills, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.96 8.18 4.5 2.0 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.73 7.81 5.8 3.2 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 7.36 7.38 4.1 2.7 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 2 1:2 1 7.15 7.28 4.5 2.8 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume
similarly 2 is for 1:2) after 96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium
dichromate, all fish should survive. Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm,
Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 11, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all quarters of bioassay test
observation of treated effluent from J K Hospital & Medical Research Centre, Kolar Road,
Bhopal.

Table 11: Bioassay test of treated effluent from J K Hospital & Medical Research Centre (H10) Kolar Road, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.23 7.36 5.8 2.5 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 6.99 7.21 6.6 2.8 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 7.11 7.19 5.6 2.3 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 7.28 7.35 6.5 2.9 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive.
Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 12, toxicity factor (Tf) was found four during fourth quarter and one during all
other quarters of bioassay test observation of treated effluent from L B S Hospital, Motia
Talab Road Bhopal.

Table 12: Bioassay test of treated effluent from L B S Hospital (H11), Motia Talab Road Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.09 7.18 6.2 3.8 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.28 7.33 5.6 2.8 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 7.21 7.26 4.7 2.5 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 4 1:4 3 6.51 6.66 5.5 4.5 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume
similarly 2 is for 1:2, 4 is for 1:4) after 96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L
Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive. Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to
0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 13, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all quarters of bioassay test
observation of treated effluent from Kamla Nehru Hospital (Gas Rahat), Bhopal.

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 169


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

Table 13: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Kamla Nehru Hospital (Gas Rahat) (H12), Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- # # # # # # # #
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.46 7.48 5.8 3.2 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 6.85 6.96 7.2 6.1 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 7.52 7.68 7.7 6.8 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive.
#Monitoring started after first quarter. Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm,
Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 14, toxicity factor (Tf) was found one during all quarters of bioassay test
observation of treated effluent from People's Hospital Bhanpur, Bhopal

Table 14: Bioassay test of treated effluent from People's Hospital (H13), Bhanpur, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- 1 1:1 0 7.25 7.28 4.1 2.5 100*
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.86 7.96 4.8 3.2 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 7.47 7.52 5.2 3.1 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 1 1:1 0 6.16 6.25 6.8 5.1 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume) after
96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L Potassium dichromate, all fish should
survive.Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

In table no 15, toxicity factor (Tf) was found two during fourth quarter and one during all
other quarters of bioassay test observation of treated effluent from Swami Vivekanand
Regional Spine Centre, M P Nagar, Bhopal.

Table 15: Bioassay test of treated effluent from Swami Vivekanand Regional Spine Centre (H14), M P Nagar, Bhopal
Quarter Dilution Ratio of Waste Parts of dilution water pH (pH Unit) Dissolve Oxygen %
Factor water to test water to be added to one part (mg/l) Survival
(by volume) of Waste water Before After Before After
(by volume) Test Start 96 hrs Test Start 96 hrs
1 (Apr- # # # # # # # #
June 2018)
II (July- 1 1:1 0 7.28 7.31 5.1 2.5 100*
Sep 2018)
III (Oct- 1 1:1 0 6.56 6.77 4.2 2.8 100*
Dec 2018)
IV (Jan- 2 1:2 1 7.56 7.76 5.6 3.8 100*
Mar 2019)
Remark : *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume
similarly 2 is for 1:2, 4 is for 1:4) after 96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L
Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive. #Monitoring started after first quarter. Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio
rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to 0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

Summary of Bioassay test observations of studied Hospitals of Bhopal city is depicted in


table no 16.

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 170


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

Table 16: Summary of Bioassay test observations of studied Hospitals of Bhopal city.
Code I Quarter II Quarter III Quarter IV Quarter
H1. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H2. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H3. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf)was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H4. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H5. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H6. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found two* found one* found one * one *
H7. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found Two* one *
H8. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H9. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * two*
H10. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H11. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was The toxicity factor (Tf) was
found one* found one * found one * found Four *
H12. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H13. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * one *
H14. Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was Toxicity factor (Tf) was found
found one* found one * found one * two*
Remark: *100% survival seen in observed Toxicity factor = dilution factor ( Tf 1 for 1:1 Ratio of Waste water to test water by volume
similarly 2 is for 1:2, 4 is for 1:4 ) after 96 hrs. Standard Tf =1 represent test condition standard dilution water containing 100 mg/L
Potassium dichromate, all fish should survive.Fish Species used for test: Zebra Fish (Brachydanio rerio) Fish size-30±5 mm and wt- 0.2 to
0.3 gm, Temp: 25±1.0oC.

The observation based on 90 % Besides the above immediate effects,


survival of tested fishes at 50 % dilution harmful substances are adsorbed through the
(1:1 ratio of waste water to test water by gills, skin or intestine, thereby impairing
volume) up to 96 hrs, that represented as physiological functions. These effects may
toxicity factor one. Further increase in ultimately lead to the death of fish.
toxicity factor represents increase in toxicity
found acute state. The fish may not always 4. CONCLUSION
die but their reproductive capacity, Bio-medical waste is generated during
breeding, spawning and development are the diagnosis, treatment or immunization of
adversely affected. In aquatic toxicology human beings, animals or from research
fish have been widely and popularly activities pertaining there to or in the
acclaimed as a test species for evaluating production or testing of biological fluids. It
the potency of toxicants to cause lethacity include wastes like human anatomical
(acute toxicity) or any other sub lethal waste, animal waste, microbiology &
responses, using selected behavioral biotechnology waste, discarded medicines
biochemical or physiochemical and & cytotoxic drugs, soiled waste, solid waste,
hematological responses. Bio medical waste liquid waste, incineration ash, chemical
effluents are complex and can be polluted wastes etc. These wastes are very hazardous
by non-biodegradable end toxic organic because of the potentially infectious in
compounds and are a serious threat to the nature as it may pose a serious threat to
environment. Fish are affected by toxic human health, if its management is
substances chiefly in following two ways: indiscriminate and unscientific. The study
A- Epithelia -absorb toxic substances, concluded that treated effluents from most
getting damaged in this process, for of monitored hospitals of Bhopal city were
instance, the gills stick together or get found free from acute lethal toxicity
congested with mucus and get destroyed. B-

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 171


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

probably due to proper waste management methods for acute toxicity. Water Res.
practices adopted by the hospitals. 1969, 3: 793-796.
11. Verlicchi P, Galletti A, Petrovic M and
5. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Barcelo D. Hospital Effluents as a Source
We acknowledge the help received from of Emerging Pollutants: An Overview of
authorities of monitored hospitals of Bhopal city Micropollutants and Sustainable
and also thankful to the Chairman & Member Treatment Options. J Hydro. 2010, 416-
Secretary, Madhya Pradesh Pollution Control 428.
Board, for encouragement of study work. 12. Sharma P, Mathur N, Singh A And
Bhatnagar P. Physıco-Chemıcal
6. REFERENCES Assessment of Hospıtal Wastewater
1. Bio-Medical Waste Management and Quality. Int J Dev Res. 2014, 9: 1915-
Handling Rule, 1998. 1918.
2. Agarwal R. Status of Alternative Medical 13. Gautam A K, Kumar S and Sabumon P C.
Waste Disposal Technologies in the US, Preliminary Study of Physico-Chemical
A Srishti Extract for aiding health care Treatment Options for Hospital
facilities.1998. Wastewater. J Env Manag. 2007, 83: 298-
3. Kusnoputranto H. Quality of Hospital 306.
Waste and Its Impact on Environment and 14. Altın A, Altın S and Değirmenci M.
Health, Proc. 20th Hospital Seminar on Characteristics and Treatability of
Research Center for Human Resources Hospital (Medical) Wastewaters.
and the Environment, Medical Faculty of Fresenius Envir Bulle. 2003 12, 1098-
Indonesia University, Indonesia. 1993, 1108.
403-412. 15. Pauwels B And Verstraete W. The
4. Majlesinasr M. Study of wastewater treatment of Hospital Wastewater: An
disposal status and effluent quality in Appraisal. J Wat Heal. 2006, 4: 405-416.
hospitals of Shahid Beheshti University of 16. Vieno, N. Occurrence of Pharmaceuticals
Medical Sciences, Iranian J Publ Health. in Finnish Sewage Treatment Plants,
1998, 6(1): 371 – 375. Surface Waters, and Their Elimination in
5. Radha K V. A Case Study of Biomedical Drinking Water Treatment Processes. PhD
Waste Management in Hospitals. Glob J Thesis, Tampere University of
Health Sci. 2009, 1(1): 82 - 88. Technology, Tampere. 2007, 130.
6. Wiafe S, Nooni I K, Appiah B K, Nlasia 17. Berto J, Rochenbach G C, Barreiros, M A
M S, Fianko S K. Clinical liquid waste B, Correa A X R, Peluso-Silva S and
management in three healthcare facilities- Radetski C M. Physico- Chemical
A case study of Sunyani Municipality. B J Microbiological and Ecotoxicological
Environ Sci. 2016, 4: 11-34. Evaluation of a Septic Tank/Fenton
7. Ali M, Wang W, Chaudhry N, Geng Y. Reaction Combination for the Treatment
Hospital Waste Management in of Hospital Wastewaters. Ecotox Env
Developing Countries: A mini review. Safety.2009, 72:1076-1081.
Waste Manag Res. 2017, 35: 581–92. 18. Oyeleke S B, Istifanus N and Manga S B.
8. Hossain M S, Santhanam A, Norulaini N The Effects of Hospital Solid Waste on
N, Omar A M. Clinical solid waste the Receiving Environment. Int J Inte Bio.
management practices and its impact on 2008, 3: 191-195.
human health and environment–A review. 19. Emmanuel E, Pierre M G and Perrodin Y.
Waste Manag. 2011, 31: 754-66. Groundwater Contamination by
9. World Health Organization (WHO), Core Microbiological and Chemical Substances
principles for achieving safe and Released from Hospital Wastewater:
sustainable management of healthcare Health Risk Assessment for Drinking
waste, 2007. Water Consumers. Env Inte. 2009, 35:
10. Sprague J B. Review paper: Measurement 718-726.
of pollutant toxicity to fish 1-Bioassay

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 172


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020
Reeta Kori et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city, Madhya Pradesh,
India

20. Ortega L M, Lebrun R, Blais J F and 22. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal


Hausler R. Removal of Metal Ionsfrom an 23. Bio-assay methods for evaluating acute
Acidic Leachate Solution by toxicity of industrial effluents and
Nanofiltration Membranes. Desalination. wastewaters. Bureau of Indian Standards,
2008, 227: 204-216. IS 16582:2001.
21. Bazrafshan E, Mahvi A H, Nasseri S,
Shaieghi M. Performance evaluation of How to cite this article: Kori R, Saxena A,
electrocoagulation process for diazinon Mokhle S et.al. Bioassay study of biomedical
removal from aqueous environments by liquid waste (treated effluent) of Bhopal city,
using iron electrodes, Iran J Env Heal Sci Madhya Pradesh, India. International Journal
& Eng. 2007, 4(2): 127-132. of Research and Review. 2020; 7(1): 164-173.

******

International Journal of Research and Review (ijrrjournal.com) 173


Vol.7; Issue: 1; January 2020

View publication stats

You might also like