Screening Screening Ebook
Screening Screening Ebook
Screening Screening Ebook
Guide to Preseason
Screening in Elite
Football
CONSIDERATIONS FOR PROGRAMMING & ISOMETRIC DATA
COLLECTION STRATEGY
EBOOK
1
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Athlete Management at the elite and sub-elite level aims to provide critical
information that allows stakeholders to:
These data sets are used to guide the prescription of training loads throughout
preseason and in season periods, and to support medical management plans in
order to maximise player availability and performance.
2
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Designing Preseason
Profiling - Where to start?
Athlete Profiling requires an understanding Specific measures of hip strength for
of the demands of the sport, the most example, have not only been shown to be
common / costly injuries, the known associated with hip pathology and pain
modifiable risk factors for these injuries, (Mendis 2014, Diamond 2016, Markovic
and knowledge of the known modifiable 2020, De Lang 2022), and lower limb injury
measures shown to be associated with risk (Niemuth 2005) but also running
athletic performance relevant to the sport. performance (Dean et al 2005, Tottori 2018).
Therefore, for athletes involved in locomotor
sports, a comprehensive 3D hip strength
ATHLETE PROFILING REQUIRES profile is often included in preseason
AN UNDERSTANDING OF THE profiling as injury to the lower limb in
FOLLOWING SPORT-SPECIFIC general is a primary focus.
CONSIDERATIONS:
• The most common injuries. Hamstring injury remains the most costly
soft tissue injury in elite football, with rates
• The most costly injuries.
increasing significantly despite a clinical
• Known modifiable risk factors for these and research focus. Over the last 8 years the
injuries. proportion of injury cost due to hamstring
• Knowledge of the known modifiable strains has risen from 12 to 24%, with 18% of
measures shown to be associated with these being recurrences (Ekstrand 2023).
sport-specific athletic performance.
3
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Designing Preseason
Profiling - Where to start?
Due to the multifactorial nature of into existing workflows, minimises demands
hamstring injury, there is no one single on athletes and MDT staff, and delivers
measure of muscular strength that can meaningful and actionable insight. Profiling
predict hamstring injury. However it is outcomes are then communicated to key
widely accepted that profiling posterior stakeholders, to support the management
thigh and hip strength can provide insight and prescription of training loads and
into strength deficits that may contribute to medical treatment plans; This should
hamstring injury risk and provide baselines contribute to an elite sporting environment
for assessment of strength training that mitigates injury risk and augments
outcomes over time. Moreover, monitoring general athletic development
health of the hamstring and other lower
limb musculature over the course of an
athletes pre-season and inseason has been
shown to assist clinical management of
athlete training loads in manner associated
with marked reductions in injury rates
(Wollin et al 2018, 2020).
4
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
5
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
IBRAHIM KEREM
Head of Physiotherapy (women)
Manchester United FC
6
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Detailed musculoskeletal assessment of the Standardised Hop, Jump and Landing tests
athlete by both medical and physiotherapy often used in the field have been shown to
/ athletic training staff is a critical part of be associated with lower limb injury risk.
preseason profiling that provides insight The value of these is markedly improved
into MSK health and function. Combining with the use of motion capture and force
these findings with measures of strength, plate data systems that provide insight into
power, proprioception and movement both the overall performance and quality
efficiency is currently considered the of hip, knee and ankle movement during
cornerstone of pre-seaon profiling in elite these tasks (e.g. Kotsifaki et al 2021).
sport. Combining strength with movement data
Objective assessment of movement (e.g. Maestroni et al 2020) provides greater
provides insight into areas of risk and insight into best practice athlete care pre
baseline data for future reference when and post injury.
monitoring for neuromuscular fatigue and /
or assessing readiness to return to play after
periods of rehabilitation. While functional
movement screens have shown no
7
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Recommendations for
Isometric Screening in
Football.
Muscle injury rates in football have been Identifying, understanding and modifying
well documented with the UEFA Elite muscle injury risk in football players requires
Club Injury Study currently in its 21st a multifactorial approach. While there is
season. A squad of 25 players can expect no single predictive strength test, profiling
about 15 muscle injuries per season and monitoring hamstring and hip strength
which accounts for 27% of the total injury measures associated with injury, movement
absence. (Ekstrand, Hägglund and Waldén assessment, athlete monitoring (off and on
2011) the field), and sound clinical reasoning are
widely accepted as best practice.
Ninety-two per cent of all muscle injuries Based on the known modifiable risk factors
affected the four major muscle groups for the most common injuries across
of the lower limbs: hamstrings (37%), football, the following recommendations
adductors (23%), quadriceps (19%) and calf are made for screening isometric strength
muscles (13%). Sixteen percent of muscle across the hip and anterior/posterior chains
injuries were re-injuries. of the lower limb in football populations.
8
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
HIP ABDUCTION @ 30
Hip Abduction strength tested in a HIP EXTENSION @ 30
functional range specific to locomotor Hip extension tested with the hip at 30
activities. Deficiencies in Hip Abductor degrees is structured to be bias toward
strength have been associated with, and testing strength of the gluteus maximus
on occasions shown to be predictive of, muscle group. It is an indicator of the
increased lower limb injury risk, Hip pain capacity this muscle has to generate
and pathology, knee pain, ACL injury risk, horizontal force during bipedal locomotion
hop performance, achilles tendinopathy and when running in a straight line.
chronic ankle instability.
9
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
10
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Posterior Chain.
Testing capacity of the posterior chain SEATED PLANTAR FLEXION
is commonly undertaken to understand (SOLEUS)
risk around hamstring, calf, hip and back Provides a soleus bias measure of ankle
injury. With regards to hamstring injury plantarflexion strength. By placing the
risk, there is need to target testing toward knee at a 90 degree angle the test is
the lateral hamstring complex (given this selective to the soleus in contrast to the
is injured 85% of the time), and to ensure standing ‘mid-thigh pull’ based test that
testing adequately assesses hip and knee provides a measure of combined soleus
components of the hamstring complex. and gastrocnemius strength across the
ankle joint. These tests have been shown
clinically to differentiate between soleus
KNEE FLEXION H45/K30
and gastroc injury types when pathologies
Provides an assessment of Isometric knee are confirmed by MRI to be localised to
flexion strength bias toward the knee in a the muscle or its associated intramuscular
position, and at a hamstring muscle length, tendon / aponeurosis.
at which hamstring injuries commonly
occur in locomotor sports.
Total test time for testing these 3 elements
of the posterior chain bilaterally is 8
HAMSTRING CLAW H45/K 15 minutes.
Provides a test of integrated hip and thigh
strength with the hamstring group acting
simultaneously across the hip and knee (in
synergy with other hip extensors and knee
flexors). The ‘claw-like’ action is specific to
the terminal swing / early stance phase of
running where many locator hamstring
running injuries occur.
11
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Anterior Chain.
SEATED KNEE EXTENSION 60
Provides an indication of quadricep
muscle strength that can be used to assess
hamstring to quadricep strength ratio as an
indication of the balance of strength within
a limb. This ratio may provide insight into
the relative strength of an athletes posterior
and anterior chain and through this relative
injury risk.
12
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
13
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Preseason Profiling
Outcomes (KangaTech)
KangaTech allows an automated graphical The player demonstrated gross strength
view of an athlete’s strength profile in any deficits in all planes. These are most marked
body region via the KT Chart. The symmetry in the frontal (adduction and abduction)
of strength between limbs and the balance and transverse (ER90 and 0) planes. He
of strength within a limb across regions can is relatively strongest in hip flexion (50th
be understood. percentile).
Data can be normalised to lever length and
body weight, allowing effective comparisons
between individuals and subgroups within
the same team. Moreover, the KT database
allows the athlete to be compared to de-
identified normative KangaTech data sets
from the same or similar sports (e.g. AFL,
NBA, EPL, MLS, MLB).
The 3D hip strength of an elite football
player with a long history of recurrent
groin, hamstring, calf and low back injuries
is presented below (Figure 1). Data in this
case is normalised to lever length and body
weight and presented in a percentile plot
against AFL footballers.
14
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Preseason Profiling
Outcomes (KangaTech)
These results can be used to determine
which isolated strength parameters may be
a priority for development and those that
simply need to be maintained. For example,
if hip Abduction and external rotation
strength are poor, these may be targeted 3
x per week with a combination of complex
/ functional and isolation based exercises.
Conversely, the plan for strength parameters
that are deemed to be sufficient may be to
simply maintain the athletes strength over
the course of a season. As such, training
frequency, intensity and volume may differ.
When strength development is targeted
but there is an associated MSK pathology
and pain when loading a musculotendinous
unit, practitioners may prescribe a
combination of gym based loading
exercises over the course of each week that
are likely to both modulate pain but also
address deficits in muscle strength, cross
sectional area, endurance and / or tendon Figure 1
pathology / pain concurrently.
15
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Preseason Profiling
Outcomes (KangaTech)
The value of accurate and efficient profiling
analysed through the KT chart, supported
by repeat profiling and monitoring over the
course of an athletes season and career is
obvious.
Understanding the training history and
significant pathologies associated with this
athlete’s profile was important to improving
strength training outcomes. Review of
previous strength training history revealed
that these deficits existed despite traditional
strength training and rehabilitation streams
involving double leg triple extension,
multi-directional lunge, standing banded
and Copenhagen and slide board based
adductor loading. Isolated and integrated
isometric and isotonic exercise variations
targeted the hip Abductor, adductor,
external rotation and hip extension, were
progressed to measurable loads sufficient
to maximise strength adaptations. The
changes demonstrated in the follow up KT Figure 2
Chart over a 12 week preseason period are
shown in Figure 2.
16
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Preseason Profiling
Outcomes (KangaTech)
The KT Historical graph (Figure 3) allows
changes in any strength parameter
to be monitored over time and for the
relationship between strength, pain and
load to be better understood. These data
are further supported by electronic PROMS
questionnaires (e.g. Visa-A questionnaire
for achilles tendinopathy) which allow pain,
function and disability to be concurrently
monitored with strength. It is common
for users to automate and rationalise the
collection of Visa and HAGOS questionnaire
results, for example, using KangaTech. Note
the unilateral reduction in R knee flexion
strength (red band) that was associated
with pain on testing that required medical
/ physiotherapy intervention V the bilateral
reduction in knee flexor strength (green
band) that was associated with increased
game loads of high speed running but not Figure 3
any pain on testing.
17
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
Profiling Workflow.
3D Hip Profile
Standard KangaTech protocols for testing However, when profiling an entire list this
maximum voluntary isometric contraction requires more planning. The burden of this
(MVIC) have been designed to elicit maximal testing can be nullified by spreading the
recruitment of the target muscle group/s 6 point testing over a 3 week period with Hip Adduction Hip Abduction Hip Flexion
inorder to provide an accurate measure of athletes undertaking only 2 tests per week ( Neutral )
their peak torque in either mid range or a over the course of a 3 week period.
range specific to injury risk.
1 MIN 1 MIN 3 MIN
Testing can be performed as part of prep
These tests utilise positions that require to train or standard strength development
little skill / learning or stabilisation across sessions. In doing so processes leverage
segments when athletes apply high off the payers already being adequately
level force against a sufficiently stiff high warm to perform the tests effectively and
grade external frame. These increase the the degree to which testing interferes with
likelihood of reliability acquiring an MVIC standard workflows is minimised.
on each test and minimise the time to test.
Detailed athlete profiling of the hip and
Hip Extension Hip ER 90 Hip ER 0
posterior chain can take 25 - 30 minutes.
This time is minimised by planning the test
order to minimise athlete movement and
repositioning of the test unit. 3 MIN 3 MIN 3 MIN
18
A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO PRESEASON SCREENING IN ELITE FOOTBALL
REFERENCES: • Dean R, Chow J, Tillman M, Fournier system: post-match strength testing for KT S U G G E ST E D R E A D I N G :
K. Effects of Hip Flexor Training on secondary prevention in football. British
Sprint, Shuttle Run and Vertical Jump Journal of Sports Medicine 2019; 54: 498-
• Mendis M, Wilson S, Hayes D, Watts M, • Ransom M, Saunders S, Gallo T, Segal
Performance. Journal of Strength and 499
Hides J. Hip flexor muscle size, strength J, Jones D, Milanese S. Reliability of a
Conditioning Research 2005; 19, 3: 615-621
and recruitment pattern in patients portable fixed frame dynamometry
with acetabular labral tears compared to • Chen H, Nosaka K, Pearce A, Chen T. Two system used to test lower limb strength
healthy controls. Manual Therapy 2014; • Tottori N, Suga T, Miyake Y, Tsuchikane R, maximal isometric contractions attenuate in elite Australian Football League players.
19:405-410 Otsuka M, Nagano A, Fujita S, Isaka T. Hip the magnitude of eccentric exercise- Journal of Sports Science and Medicine in
Flexor and and Knee Extensor Muscularity induced muscle damage. Journal of Sport 2020; 23, 9: 826 - 830
are associated with Sprint Performance Applied Physiology 2012; 37: 680 - 689
• Diamond L, Wrigley T, Hinman R, Hodges
in Sprint trained Pre-Adolescent Boys.
P, O’Donnell J, Takla A, Bennell K. • Dunne C, Callaway A, Thurston J,
Human Kinetics Journal 2018; 30, 1: 115 - 123 • Kotsifaki A, Korakakis V, Graham-
Isometric and isokinetic hip strength and Williams J. Validity, reliability, minimal
agonist/antagonist ratios in symptomatic Smith P, Sideris V, Whiteley R. Vertical detectable change, and methodological
femoroacetabular impingement. Journal • Ekstrand J, Bengtsson H, Waldén and Horizontal Hop Performance: considerations for HHD and portable fixed
of Science and Medicine in Sport 2016; M, Davison M, Khan K, Hägglund M. Contributions of the Hip, Knee, and Ankle. frame isometric hip and groin strength
19:696-701 Hamstring injury rates have increased American Orthopedic Society for Sports testing: A comparison of unilateral and
during recent seasons and now constitute Medicine 2021; 13, 2: bilateral testing methods. Physical Therapy
24% of all injuries in men’s professional in Sport 2022; 57: 46 - 52
• Markovic G, Šarabon N, Pausic J, Hadžic
football: the UEFA Elite Club Injury Study • Maestroni L, Read P, Bishop C,
V. Adductor Muscles Strength and
from 2001/02 to 2021/22. British Journal of Papadopoulos K, Suchomel T, Comfort P,
Strength Asymmetry as Risk Factors for • KangaTech KT360 Validation Study - Final
Sports Medicine 2023; 57: 292-298 Turner A. The benefits of strength training
Groin Injuries among Professional Soccer Version. Prepared by Serpiello F, Haycraft J,
Players: A Prospective Study. International on musculoskeletal system health: Bal K. Victoria University 2022.l
Journal of Environmental Research and • Wollin M, Thorborg K, Pizzari T. Monitoring Practical applications for interdisciplinary
Public Health 2020; 17, 14: 4946 the effect of football match congestion care. Journal of Sports Medicine 2020; 50,
on hamstring strength and lower limb 8: 1431 - 1450
flexibility: Potential for secondary injury
• De Lang 2022?
prevention? Physical Therapy in Sport • Ekstrand J, Hägglund M, Waldén M.
2018; 29: 14-18 Injury incidence and injury patterns in
• Niemuth P, Myers M. The role of hip
professional football: the UEFA injury
muscle weakness in lower extremity
• Wollin M, Thorborg K, Drew M, Pizzari T. A study. British Journal of Sports Medicine
athletic injuries. International SportMed
novel hamstring strain injury prevention 2011; 45: 553 - 558
Journal 2007; 8, 4:179-192
19
Mitigate Injury Risk.
KANGATECH.COM
20