Unlocked Study Guide - The Crucible
Unlocked Study Guide - The Crucible
Unlocked Study Guide - The Crucible
Arthur Miller’s
The Crucible
Written by Vivienne Sawford
TABLE OF CONTENTS
At first, reading or watching a play can seem daunting – but we’re here
to help. In this guide, we’ll cover a range of different topics and provide
you with the information you need to be able to understand, engage
with, and comment upon Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible.
Let’s get started. There’s a lot to cover, so feel free to skip ahead to the
section you’re most interested in – or speak to your teacher to get an
idea of which bits to focus on first.
● Context
● About the Playwright
● Plot Summary
● Characters
● Relationship Map
● Themes
● Language Techniques
● Literary Devices
● Glossary
The Crucible is set in Salem in 1692. At the time, religion was a huge part
of daily life. Salem was a Puritan community and we can see this religion
throughout the play. So – what was Puritanism?
Puritans fled from England due to unfair treatment towards them. They
first arrived in New England in 1630 and roughly 1,000 of them
The events of The Crucible are fictionalized. This means that real
historical events have been adapted by Arthur Miller to tell a story.
However, they are based on the witch trials that took place in Salem,
Massachusetts in 1692–1693.
In the 17th century – remember, that’s the 1600s – there was a global
belief in, and fear of, the supernatural. By supernatural, we mean things
that some people believe are real, but that are not part of nature and
cannot be explained with science. Examples include magic, demons,
devils, and witches. Many people in Salem believed that these things
existed and that they were the reason for any events that could not be
explained. This included strange changes in the weather, destroyed
crops, and the sudden sickness or death of a child.
There were range of punishments for those who were found guilty of
practicing witchcraft. As we see in The Crucible, the most extreme of
these punishments was death and we are told that 20 people die during
the play.
The real Salem of the 17th century was known to be an unhappy and
argumentative community. Historical records show us that many
villagers were in disputes over land, property, farming rights, and church
privileges. This created a tense atmosphere and it is easy to see how
people started to grow resentful and accuse others. The first three
women to be accused of witchcraft in the play were also the three
women to be accused in reality: the black or Indian slave Tituba, the
homeless beggar Sarah Good, and the remarried Sarah Osborne, who
was rarely seen at church. These women were probably thought of as
outsiders because of their race, religion, or lifestyle choices.
Over time, the witch trials began to lose popularity. Fewer and fewer
‘witches’ were brought to the court and those that were, were often
found not guilty. However, it took almost 20 years for the town to accept
that the justice system had failed so many innocent people. In 1711, 22 of
the convicted witches had their guilty verdicts reversed. The following
year, the excommunications of Rebecca Nurse and Giles Corey were
overturned by members of the Salem church.
‘McCarthyism’ is a term you might not be familiar with. For Arthur Miller,
writing The Crucible in the early 1950s, it would have had a very specific
meaning. Let’s begin to think about what was going on politically within
the United States at the time that Miller was writing the play.
When Arthur Miller was writing The Crucible, there was growing tension
between the United States and the Soviet Union. It centered upon how
the two nations ran their economies and led their nations. The United
States was, and still is, a capitalist nation. In a capitalist society, citizens
and not governments own and run companies. The Soviet Union, which
included Russia and several Eastern European states, was a communist
nation. In a communist society, all property is owned by the government.
People work and receive money from the government according to their
needs. It’s clear from this very basic description that the two world
superpowers held very different views on how their countries should be
run.
Each nation feared the other and many were worried that nuclear war
would break out between them. This built into a long-running series of
small conflicts that we now call the Cold War, which ran from 1947–1991.
Americans were very frightened that Russia would force all countries to
become Communist. They saw this as a direct threat to the American
way of living.
As all of this unfolded around him, Miller began reading about the Salem
witch trials of 1692. He realized how powerful the connection between
the witch trials and the trials of his own time might be. The play explores
how quickly accusations grow out of control when they are fueled by
people in power. It shows how innocent people can become the target in
times of fear and how terror can cause people to betray their friends.
These kinds of issues weren’t just a thing of the past. In fact, to Arthur
Miller, they were still a very real part of his present.
There is a lot to be said about Arthur Miller. We’ll provide you with some
basic information here, but remember, DT+ is full of helpful videos to
guide you. We’ve got Arthur Miller covered.
Miller’s first Broadway opening, The Man Who Had All the Luck,
proved not to be so lucky! It did very badly at the box office and
closed after only four performances. This made him consider quitting
writing altogether.
Miller’s personal life was quite turbulent. He was married three times.
His first marriage was to his college sweetheart Mary Grace Slattery.
Miller had two children with Mary but left her for the actress Marilyn
Monroe. In 1956, Miller married Monroe and was catapulted into
celebrity status. They divorced after five years and in 1962, Miller
married Austrian-born photographer Inge Morath. The couple had two
children and remained together until her death in 2002.
ACT 1
Thomas and Ann Putnam arrive with news that their daughter Ruth also
seems to be bewitched. John Proctor comes to see what is wrong with
Betty and speaks with Abigail Williams alone. We learn that Proctor and
Abigail were involved in a romantic affair. This is still a secret in the town
but was discovered by Elizabeth Proctor, John’s wife. Abigail still desires
Proctor and flirts with him, but he forcefully tells her that their
relationship is over.
A week passes. Proctor arrives home and Elizabeth tells him that a court
has been set up to try the women accused of witchcraft. Fourteen
people are already in prison awaiting trial and will be hanged if they do
not confess.
Proctor furiously instructs Mary to come with him to court and to admit
that Abigail was the one who stuck the needle in the poppet. Mary
begins to cry and says that Abigail would kill her and charge Proctor
with “lechery” if they ever did so. Proctor realizes that Mary knows about
his affair with Abigail and that this secret will be made public if he goes
ACT 3
The next day, at court, Francis Nurse and Giles Corey plead with Judge
Hathorne and Deputy-Governor Danforth for the innocence of their
wives. Francis presents a petition of 91 signatures that were given in
support of his, Corey, and Proctors’ wives.
Proctor arrives with Mary and tells Danforth that she will confess that the
girls are lying. Danforth attempts to stop Proctor from proceeding by
telling him truthfully that Elizabeth is pregnant and will not face
execution until the baby is born. However, Proctor continues and Mary
testifies against Abigail and the other girls.
Proctor reveals his affair with Abigail and says that her jealousy of
Elizabeth is the reason for her accusations. Abigail denies the affair.
Danforth decides to determine the truth by summoning Elizabeth, who is
known to be incredibly honest. Danforth asks why Elizabeth fired Abigail
and Elizabeth lies to protect Proctor’s reputation. Danforth condemns
Proctor as a liar.
Abigail and the girls again accuse Mary of bewitching them. As their
hysteria mounts, Mary gives in to the pressure and begins screaming
and accusing Proctor of witchcraft. Proctor protests but he and Giles
Corey are arrested. Hale is disgusted by the proceedings and quits the
court.
In a Salem jail cell, months have passed. It is now the day that Rebecca
Nurse and Proctor are to be hanged, having refused to confess to
witchcraft. Parris enters and explains that Hale has returned to try and
encourage Proctor and Rebecca to confess. This would save their lives
and protect the court from the fury that would follow the hanging of two
respected townspeople. Parris also admits he has been made penniless
after Abigail fled Salem, having stolen all of his money.
There’s a lot to remember in this plot summary! Why not break down the summary into two small arrows per act.
You’ll end up with eight arrows in total that you can use in a flowchart. We’ve started the first one for you.
Girls in Salem have been caught dancing in the forest led by a slave Tituba. The
father of one of the girls – Betty Parris – calls for Reverend Hale, a witchcraft
specialist. We meet Abigail Williams and John Proctor who we learn have had an affair.
JOHN PROCTOR
The play’s protagonist and tragic hero. If you want a great summary,
why not watch Unlocking Character: John Proctor.
Key facts:
Summary:
Proctor values his good reputation above everything else. He does not
want to go to the court because he knows that he would have to be honest
about the affair. However, as the play progresses, Proctor realizes he will
have to be honest about his affair with Abigail if he wants to save his wife
and bring an end to the witch trials. Unfortunately, his decision to confess
comes too late. Elizabeth is charged and Proctor is put in jail.
Look closer:
Proctor is a reluctant leader and speaks for those who oppose Parris and
the Putnams. At first, he only wants to save his wife. Over time, he
realizes how important it is to stand by his moral code and to protect the
Key lines:
“Abby, I may think of you softly from time to time. But I will cut off my
hand before I’ll ever reach for you again. Wipe it out of mind. We never
touched, Abby.” (Act 1)
Write your answers in the following table. Go through the play act by
act.
What does
Proctor want
most in this
act?
Does Proctor
get what he
wants at the
end of the act?
John Proctor’s wife. If you want to develop your learning, why not watch
On Acting: Anna Madeley? Anna performed as Elizabeth Proctor and
can provide some helpful insight into the character.
Key facts:
Summary:
Elizabeth appears in person in Act 2. The audience can quickly spot that
her marriage is struggling. Elizabeth still loves her husband but seems to
find it difficult to move on from her husband’s affair. We know that she
was ill and recovering from childbirth during the affair. We also know
that Elizabeth dismissed Abigail from the house once she found out. It’s
Elizabeth is known in the community for her honesty and John openly
states that she “cannot lie.” This makes her decision to lie about
Proctor’s affair in front of the court even more powerful. Elizabeth loves
her husband and wants to protect his reputation, even if it goes against
everything she stands for. Sadly, her decision to lie to spare Proctor’s
reputation backfires and he is arrested. This is an example of dramatic
irony, where the audience is aware of information that the characters do
not know. The viewer knows that Elizabeth’s lie will condemn her
husband. Elizabeth’s attempt to save him in fact achieves the opposite.
Look closer:
Proctor initially talks about his wife as though she is a cold woman
whose sense of right and wrong is simply unachievable. However, by the
end of the play, after three months of being alone in jail, Elizabeth
decides to place some of the blame for the affair on to herself. She
forgives Proctor completely and tells him that she can no longer judge
him for his affair. She acknowledges that she became distant and that
this would have made things difficult for him. Elizabeth encourages
Proctor to forgive himself and make his own decision on whether or not
he should hang. Ultimately, she stands by her husband’s final decision
and rejects Hale’s requests for her to change his mind.
Key lines:
“He have his goodness now. God forbid I take it from him.”
(Act 4)
Imagine that you’re there when Proctor admits to Elizabeth that he has
been having an affair with Abigail. Write down how you would describe
the scene. Where are they? What time is it? What are they doing before
Proctor speaks? What would Proctor say and why would he choose to
admit to the affair now? How do you think Elizabeth reacts?
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
Key facts:
Summary:
Abigail is very manipulative. She controls the people around her through
fear. When the girls panic at the beginning of the play, she threatens to
By the play’s conclusion, we learn that Abigail has fled from Parris’
home with her friend, Mercy Lewis. She has stolen 31 pounds from her
uncle’s strongbox. This would have been his entire fortune and a huge
amount of money at the time. Parris believes she is aboard a ship. By
this point, she has wreaked chaos across Salem and many of the
townspeople have been accused and hanged for charges of witchcraft.
Look closer:
Using the spider diagram below, pick eight adjectives that describe Abigail. Explain your reasoning and use
direct quotations from the play to justify your choices.
ABIGAIL
WILLIAMS
Key facts:
Summary:
Parris is very unpopular across Salem. Many in the town think that he is
greedy and that he is not behaving in a religious way. Parris has tried to
increase his own salary. He also went against tradition by demanding
the deeds for the house he was gifted when he became a reverend.
Finally, we learn that he replaced the simple pewter candlesticks in
church with golden ones. These little examples provide us with the
image of a man who is greedy and ambitious. He wants all of the
benefits of being a reverend but does not like the responsibility that
comes with the job.
Parris supports the work of the court during the witch trials. However, he
is not as powerful as Hale or Danforth. As time progresses, he becomes
increasingly worried about where the hysteria might lead. This isn’t to
say that he’s concerned about anybody’s wellbeing. In fact, Parris is not
bothered about this at all! Instead, he is very worried about his own
wealth and power. By the end of the play, he begs Danforth to spare
Proctor and Rebecca Nurse. This is because he fears that the death of
such well-respected townspeople would lead to rioting and his position,
home, and life would be at risk.
By the play’s conclusion, Parris admits that Abigail has fled and stolen
all of his money. This is the ultimate punishment for a character who is
so obsessed with his wealth and power. He is left penniless with the
strong possibility of an uprising in the town.
A young minister from Beverly and a known witch hunter. If you want to
develop your learning, why not watch On Acting: Adrian Schiller. Adrian
performed as Hale and can provide some helpful insight into the
character.
Key facts:
Summary:
Look closer:
Write a “what happens next” scene for Reverend Hale. This will be after
the witch trials have happened. Try to imagine where Hale is now. Has
he been prosecuted for his involvement in the trials? Have rioting
townspeople gotten to him? Is he still a reverend? Has he turned to
witchcraft himself?
When you’re done, write a paragraph explaining your choices. Why have
you shown him this way? What evidence can you find in the play that
supports your scene?
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
In this section, we’ll look briefly at some of the key facts of the other
characters in Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible.
Tituba:
Mary Warren:
Deputy Governor-Danforth:
Abigail’s cousin
Giles Corey:
Judge Hathorne:
Marshal Herrick:
Ezekiel Cheever:
FEAR
Fear is a key theme in The Crucible. Many of the characters of the play
are driven by different types of fear: fear of each other, fear of the law,
and fear of God. These different types of fear work together and build to
hysteria and chaos in the community. Let’s look at each type of fear in
turn, and how this relates to the play.
Many of the characters are afraid of what the other characters will do to
them. This sweeps them into a state of hysteria. In Act 1, Betty Parris is
described as being in a coma-like state. However, Abigail is able to
wake her up – suggesting that Betty is not really ill but is pretending to
be unconscious. It’s possible that Betty grew frightened when they were
spotted in the woods. She worried that she would be persecuted or
punished for her actions and fell into a hysterical state. In this way, fear
of punishment directly influences the events of the play.
Abigail uses this fear to her advantage. When Betty accuses Abigail,
yelling that she “drank a charm to kill John Proctor’s wife,” Abigail
replies:
Abigail’s threat frightens the other girls into obedience. They follow her
lead and join her when she begins to accuse women in the town of
witchcraft. This is not the only example of Abigail manipulating other
characters through their fear. Later, when Mary Warren tries to testify in
court against her, Abigail begins to accuse Mary of witchcraft. Mary is
swept into a growing fear that eventually results in her turning against
Proctor. She promises never to betray Abigail again.
There are many characters who use the growing fear to their advantage.
Thomas Putnam is a wealthy landowner looking to build his wealth. He
knows that all of the accusations of witchcraft made by the children are
believed. If a person is accused of witchcraft and hanged, they lose all
their property. This frees up the land for the next wealthy person to buy
Unfortunately, the court does not listen to Giles Corey, who is eventually
killed. Putnam achieves what he wants by taking advantage of the
growing climate of fear.
It’s also important to remember the role of religion. Salem was a very
religious community. The Puritans believed that everybody was born
with sin and had to repent and live a good life to avoid hell. Fear of
going to hell was a real and permanent part of their daily lives. This is
why so many of the girls fall victim to hysteria: they are genuinely
frightened for their souls. The play shows us how dangerous it is to link
the justice system to religion. It easily provides an atmosphere where
fear can grow out of control. The fear for a person’s soul leads to very
harsh punishments for witchcraft in the court. The fear of being punished
by the court leads to hysteria. The hysteria is manipulated by those who
use fear to their own advantage.
Finally, it’s worth mentioning that the noblest characters in the play are
those who can push past their fear. Giles Corey is tortured but refuses to
give in. He refuses to say he is guilty or innocent and, by doing so, is
able to find a loophole in the law. He dies a Christian and his sons are
able to inherit his property. Rebecca Nurse and Proctor also confront
their fears of dying and decide to stand by their morals. They refuse to
plead guilty and accept their fates.
Many characters wrestle with their fears across the play. Let’s focus on
some of the characters we’ve examined in this guide. Write down what
you think their fear is and then find a quote from the play to support your
claim. The first box is filled in for you.
Mary Warren Abigail Williams “She’ll kill me for sayin’ that! […]”
(Act 2)
Reverend
Parris
Reverend
Hale
Elizabeth
Proctor
Ann Putnam
Parris is saying that it has taken him a long time to build his reputation
and to gain respect from the other townspeople. He worries that Betty’s
illness will risk this and ruin him. By introducing this theme so early into
the play, Miller reminds us that Salem is a town in which everybody is
trying their best to seem respectable – even if this isn’t really the case.
For example, the audience learns as the play progresses that Parris is a
weak-willed, greedy, and ambitious man. His interest in protecting his
name is entirely selfish and he shows no concern for those around him.
Reputation is one of the key drivers for Proctor’s behavior across the
play. Proctor is well-respected in the Salem community. He is very quick
to call out the others for their sinful acts. However, in private, Proctor
wrestles with the guilt of committing adultery against his wife. If he had
been honest about his affair from the beginning, his reputation would be
ruined but many of the people accused of witchcraft would have been
spared – including his wife. However, he delays telling the court –
probably because he does not want the town to think badly of him. By
the time he realizes the errors of his ways, it is too late to change the
tragic ending of the play.
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
The audience is quickly made aware of some key lies. In Act 1, we learn
that Abigail is lying to Parris about simply dancing in the forest. They
really did try to conjure spirits and Abigail drank a potion to kill
Elizabeth. Abigail threatens the other girls with violence and forces them
to keep this secret for the duration of the play. We also learn that Proctor
has had an affair with Abigail and that the other townspeople don’t know
about it. In both examples, the main motivation for keeping the secret is
to avoid punishment. Abigail’s game in the woods could result in an
accusation of witchcraft – a very serious accusation which could lead to
her death. Proctor wants to keep his affair secret because if it were made
public, it would completely destroy his reputation in the town.
The court’s role in secrecy and deceit is very interesting. The court is
supposed to be the place where truth is brought to light. The court
officials think they are doing God’s work and that justice will always be
served. Of course, this couldn’t be further from the truth. In Danforth’s
court, the accused are almost always found guilty of witchcraft. If they
are found guilty and they had not confessed to the crime, they are
sentenced to death by hanging.
Try to think about this for a second. It’s helpful to put yourself in their
shoes. Let’s say you were accused of stealing a car. If you confess to the
crime and provide the name of at least one other person who was
involved, you’ll receive one month in prison. If you refuse to confess and
It’s important to note that one of the key moments of the play involves a
lie. In Act 3, Elizabeth is brought in front of the court to defend her
husband. Proctor has admitted to his affair with Abigail, but Abigail
denies it. Danforth asks for Elizabeth to confirm or deny the allegations.
Proctor is pleased about this as he says his wife “cannot lie.” However,
in this crucial moment, Elizabeth chooses to lie to protect her husband’s
reputation.
When you’re done, number the lies in order. Put the most damaging lie
at the top of the list, and the least damaging lie at the bottom. Explain
your reasoning in a brief paragraph.
ORDER LIES
17TH-CENTURY LANGUAGE
So, what does this mean in practice? Let’s look at some examples.
Firstly, Miller uses inverted sentence structures a lot. This means that
the word order is swapped around a little. Let’s look at two examples:
Miller was very deliberate with this style. The vocabulary, rhythms, and
patterns of speech of these characters directly mimics the writing style
Miller also uses double negatives. These are covered in the video on
language, but let’s explore them briefly here. A double negative is any
sentence that includes two negative words. Here’s an example:
This language also helps to remind the audience of the setting. By using
old-fashioned language techniques like inverted sentence structures and
double negatives, we’re reminded that the play takes place in 17th
century Salem. However, the use of modern language as well as the
older phrasing could be a way of showing us that the story still has
modern applications. We can learn from the play and the themes that it
explores are still just as important today.
A character’s language choices can often tell us a lot about them. The
way a character speaks can tell us about their level of education, social
status, and profession. Parris, Hale, and Danforth speak very formally
even if they are outside of the courtroom. Let’s look at an example. In
Act 1, Hale interrogates Parris about Betty’s illness:
The phrase ‘and then she close her book’ is not grammatical – it should
be ‘closes.’ This subtle choice of language reveals to the audience that
the character is uneducated. In fact, this also links to the subject he
discusses – Corey feels intimidated by his wife’s love of reading. In just a
few sentences, we know that Corey isn’t particularly smart.
The first draft of The Crucible was written entirely in verse. This means it
was originally written with rhythm and rhyme, like a poem or a song.
Miller decided this was too artificial and redrafted the play into dialogue,
which is spoken word. However, you can still see a lot of the poetic
language. The play is filled with imagery that supports the themes of the
play. For example, we see the struggle between evil and good through
the repeated imagery of black and white.
The concepts of ‘black and white,’ ‘right and wrong,’ ‘good and evil’ are
very important in the play. Danforth says that people can only be with
the court or against it – there’s no gray area between. Similarly,
reputations are described as perfectly clean or ruined. In Act 1, Parris
asks:
The use of black and white imagery helps the audience to understand
that in Puritan Salem, you are either good or evil, with no space for
anything else. Of course, this isn’t very true to reality. Most people will
do a mix of good and bad things in their lives. Consequently, refusing to
acknowledge that people are rarely wholly ‘good’ or ‘bad’ leads to the
chaotic events of the play. After all, showing even the slightest ‘bad’
behavior could lead to accusations of witchcraft and a death sentence.
Failure to attend church, being homeless, reading books… anything that
isn’t part of Puritan life is framed as being evil.
“I’d not call it sick; the Devil’s touch is heavier than sick. It’s
death, y’know, it’s death driving into them, forked and
hooved.”
(Ann Putnam, Act 1)
Fire and heat are often associated with the Devil in the play. In contrast,
water and cold are often linked to God, purity, and righteousness. In Act
2, Proctor says that he will “fall like an ocean on that court.” This is
another example of a simile. He suggests that he will enter the court
“like an ocean” – with great, crashing power and force. In the same act,
Proctor says that “the wind, God’s icy wind, will blow.” Again and again,
we see religious purity and God’s power through the imagery of water
and ice.
Example 1
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
Example 2
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
Example 4
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
Example 5
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
METAPHOR
A metaphor is when you compare one thing to another without using the
words ‘as’ or ‘like.’ You basically say it is the other thing. In Act 2, the
audience is introduced to Elizabeth. She has a heated conversation with
Proctor, who claims that she still judges him for his previous affair.
Elizabeth says:
SIMILE
A simile is when you compare one thing to another by using the words
‘as’ or ‘like.’ We can see another example of a simile in Act 2, when
Elizabeth comments on Abigail’s growing influence and fame in Salem:
HYPERBOLE
TERM DESCRIPTION