Case 1
Case 1
Case 1
Global Summit on
GSMC 2016, IIM Raipur
Management Cases
Sandeep Kapoor (Sandeep), Head-HR at MD Solutions, came from a long meeting with the top management
of the company – Manish Bhasin (Manish), Co-Founder and CEO, Avneet Gupta (Avneet), Co-Founder
and Head-Business Development, Jatin Das (Jatin), Co-Founder and Chief Sales and Marketing Officer,
and Renu Bhasin (Renu), Co-Founder and COO. The meeting was called to discuss the growth path of the
company. There were two primary agendas – challenges which lie ahead in terms of sustaining the remarkable
growth; and making preparations to handle the growth.
The management was primarily concerned with loss of some of the clients in the past and was seriously
contemplating on what went wrong – was it in their control or it comes with growth. The issue was not of
losing the customers alone but also of scaling up by inclusion of new customers and maintaining existing
customers. Manish was very much concerned about scaling but not at the cost of quality and profitability.
This meant, he was very serious about issues related to maintaining customers.
The other primary concern was to prepare the organization for handling very high growth. Management
wanted seamless integration between functional and people processes and stressed on human capital as primary
resource as a key enabler of growth without compromising on the quality. This required the HR function to
play a more strategic and central role.
How would Sandeep be able to integrate, align and prepare human resources to meet the growth demands
of the business? Would he be able to create value for the business by equipping HR for better customer
service, even at the times when organization was witnessing more than hundred percent growth (Exhibit I)?
This Case Study was written by Shashank Mittal, Anuj Gupta and Amit Kumar Pandey, Doctoral Students, Indian Institute of Management, Raipur. It
is intended to be used as the basis for classroom discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a management situation. The
case study was compiled from published sources.
© www.etcases.com
No part of this publication may be copied, stored, transmitted, reproduced or distributed in any form or medium whatsoever without the permission
of the copyright owner.
© www.etcases.com
HRM-1-0045 | Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions
2 © www.etcases.com
Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions| HRM-1-0045
1
As per the seventh all India school education survey report of NCERT
© www.etcases.com 3
HRM-1-0045 | Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions
Journey of MD Solutions
The journey of MD Solutions began in January 2008. Founders realized that schools and all the stakeholders
(students, teachers and parents) understand the importance of sports. However, due to constrains and non-
availability of any product or service they were not able to fulfil this demand. MD Solutions which understood
the problem, took this challenge as an opportunity to provide products and services catering to the demand
for sports curriculum in line with academic curriculum in the schools.
Using the prior learning and experience of members, complemented with the ground work done prior to
launch, schools were primarily targeted for such sports based product curriculum. This also included
development of effective sports-based product by incorporating the actual requirements of students, teachers
and parents. This initiative found many takers; physical educators and school leaders were extremely
enthusiastic and optimistic about the product. Such enthusiasm from all corners was the huge moral boost
for the company and thereafter it witnessed one and only one thing, that is touching new milestones every
year and passing ahead of its own expectations.
By the end of financial year 2008-2009, MD Solutions had 26 schools in its customer list. They were
catering to the physical education and sports demand of more than ten thousand students and had 65
members as part of their team. Another year passed and the company saw unprecedented growth and they
had 100 schools as their clients by the end of January 2010. By this time, the company conducted a survey
and released India’s first-ever national health & fitness survey for school children covering 4098 children of
21 schools across 15 cities. The result of the survey further increased MD Solutions’ resolve of continuing to
improve the fitness level through its structured sports and physical education curriculum.2 This increased
understanding guided the improvements in the design of the sports curriculum products.
2
As per the report published in Economic Times dated 14/08/13
4 © www.etcases.com
Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions| HRM-1-0045
Another year, 2010-2011, and the company achieved some more milestones by increasing the number of
schools to 165, catering sports requirement of more than one hundred thousand students with around three
members in its organization. In addition, the company saw heavy buzz among sports enthusiasts, schools
and parents and got ample media attention for its innovative and extremely pertinent product. At this time,
company was exploring the possibilities of setting operations outside India.
By July 2011, the company went global with the launch of its programs in Western Europe and North
America. MD Solutions saw the number of schools as clients getting doubled to 270 from the previous year
and considerable increase in the strength of organizational members to 360. In the year 2013, MD Solutions
catered to more than 400 schools in 85 cities across India and three other countries with more than 550
employees.
Marketing
Way back in 2009, MD Solutions gained large scale attention it was looking for, from schools, parents and
children when it released its first ever survey of sports activities in Indian schools. The survey covered 3000
children, aged between 5 and 14 years pan India. Subsequently, the company published surveys on fitness
every year with each passing year increased the scale of participants covered. The 5th edition of MD Solutions’
survey of sports activities in Indian schools came out in 2013 which covered more than one lakh students
across 319 schools in 79 cities across India. The survey reports highlighted key fitness parameters, which
clearly indicated that large fractions of the school going children lacked in one or the other essential parameters
of fitness. Though, similar surveys were conducted on academic education of children by various government
and non-government agencies but there existed no such surveys in health and fitness of school going children.
As the MD Solutions’ surveys were first of its kind3, they gained attention and reactions from all the corners
of the society be it media, politics or social activists. These surveys could be credited to create awareness on
health and fitness among all the stakeholders, be it schools, parents and children. Jatin said, “Initially, we had
to pitch in bit hard for our services to the schools and the sales drive were also hard. Schools were bit
sceptical of our offerings, even some of them commented that they already had physical trainer. Somewhere,
we felt that there was lack of awareness for health and fitness in the lines of academic education. Though, we
were pitching through our sales and marketing drives but there was lack of base in terms of awareness of the
need of the health and fitness product at first hand. The surveys created this base for us. Subsequently, we
got many inquiries from schools and some of the schools even commented that the demand came directly
from the parents and children.”
The sales and marketing teams ran extensive drives for creating direct awareness. They did seminars and
presentations in schools. The primary focus of the business model was on private schools mainly situated in
3
As per the report published in Economic Times dated 14/08/13
© www.etcases.com 5
HRM-1-0045 | Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions
cities, though the company has covered tier two and tier three cities. In the long-run MD Solutions was
contemplating on including government schools also.
4
The background technology behind product and services of MD Solutions
6 © www.etcases.com
Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions| HRM-1-0045
© www.etcases.com 7
HRM-1-0045 | Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions
The thrust in MD Solutions was to set the alignment of professional goals and values of employees with
company’s goals and values. Earlier, company faced some quality problems at the customer-end. There were
complaints regarding service delivery. Company started making them the instances of cases and figured out
that the exact reason for such behaviour is employee disengagement. If the purpose is not aligned, employees
will get disengaged. This is even more difficult to handle. In the growth stage, organization should be more
focused in getting people who have their vision and values aligned with organization.
In the words of Sandeep, “So there have to be enough right people who will buy up to your vision. In our
case it was extremely difficult to find the people as it is a new idea which is coming forth. Where will I find
these people who are inclined towards this work? Once the pool is identified then all the whys come into
play. Why one should come join your organization. Once you align the purpose of MD Solutions with
employee’s individual purpose, you answer the why. I have the vision of ensuring that kids will play, the
moment this purpose is aligned with employee’s purpose of say as an employee I want to coach people in
basketball. This is very clear alignment of purpose. The moment you have these two in tandem half the
battle is won. Then HR can tweak employee’s requirement and align him/her to the objectives of the
company.”
Talent Acquisition
The company faced challenging situation of hiring. When asked about the biggest impact of growth, the
manager said, “In our industry it is hiring. You have no other option but to add people. If you add people
first of all you need to add right people.”
The primary talent for the company were sports coaches, physical education teachers, and fitness trainers
who are basically highly skilled graduates from sports background. There was also high requirement for
specific skill-based trainers. In the long-run there will be requirements for specific experts in player development
and persons specialized in skills for matches. The company had three levels of managers – one is school-level
manager, second is delivery manager and third is relationship manager or regional operations manager. These
three require technical domain knowledge. Until and unless one knows the nitty-gritties of business one
cannot be promoted or hired for these three levels. So these three roles are promoted up the rank and no
lateral hiring at upper positions take place for these roles. Moreover, there are some departments which need
to have the subject expert. For instance, Product department is the brain behind all the programs so there
only subject expert is needed and promoted. There are roles of sales or business managers which is not
domain specific so for them hiring is mixed-lateral as well as promotion up the ranks.
Managing growth and learning with growth made MD Solutions’ HR shift its hiring strategy in tandem
with the growing demands of business. Earlier they followed the strategy of hiring right at the source. This
strategy began with the requirement that to hire large number of people one need to have bigger pool for
hiring. How you generate bigger pool. Initially, they visited the source itself. But, then they realized this
didn’t work as some good people didn’t come and join. Moreover, quality was not as expected. Then they
revised their hiring strategy accordingly.
Sandeep pointed out, “We tried the model of referral program. First of all it is learning. First time we have
to hire close to hundred employees. From our past experience we have seen 1:9 is the ratio so if we have to
hire hundred employees we have to interview nine hundred people. Where one can get these numbers of
people? What we did was, we went to close to some thirty sports colleges and universities. But, we couldn’t
8 © www.etcases.com
Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions| HRM-1-0045
get the quality resources so we did referral program. Today close to sixty-five percent of the people are
recruited through referral programs. So from zero percent focus on referrals now it is sixty five percent and
from hundred percent focus on campus hiring now it is only fifteen percent. It [Referrals] is already a hit and
we have been doing it for three years. Moreover, referrals stay longer than direct recruits from college.”
© www.etcases.com 9
HRM-1-0045 | Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions
[team support] are the people who are experienced, have seen at least one life cycle at school, they are best
performers and highly motivated. So these highly trained and highly motivated people are not in the school
but they are outside the school as team support. First we identify team support, who can take the lead role.
Then we gradually move them to managers. Layer which is your team support is the catchment area for
identifying managers. So, instead of identifying manager from the pool of hundred and fifty people, we
have reduced the pool. Now, we have fifteen people [among team support] from whom we need to identify
as manager. In the first year what we did is these are best performers so make them managers. From there we
shifted to – these are the best performers so move them to the band called team support, where they already
do partial job of managers.”
Triple E Model of Engaged, Enabled and Energized Employees for Empowered Decision
Making
Earlier the company faced some quality problems at the customer-end. There were complaints regarding
service delivery. Company started making them the instances of cases and figured out that the exact reason
for such behaviours is employee disengagement. If the purpose is not aligned then what will happen that
employee will get disengaged. This is difficult to handle. In the growth stage, organization should be more
focused in getting people who remains engaged and motivated. Now, company has dedicated manager who
takes care of implementation of three E’s. This shows how much company is serious about three E’s model.
Engagement is the state of cognitive and emotional engagement. Company has detailed engagement plan
which is actually a detailed “ask” list. HR introduced two steps to address this situation. First is the introduction
of employee engagement survey and second is providing opportunities for individual growth through mastery.
Employee engagement survey helps HR to identify disengaged employees, reasons for disengagement and
possible measures for making employees engaged. For second, mastery over sports is always the objective of
technical and techno-managerial employees being the sports persons. HR provides them enough avenues to
master their sports and align this with business objective of playing with children. This keeps them engaged.
Enabling is done by facilitating managers to take decision. As Sandeep explained, “There are three things for
manager to take right decisions at right time – first, he needs to have domain knowledge, second, you need
to give him adequate training to decide which is correct and which is not and third is to give him right and
space to make choice. You extend your step and say how the decision is to be taken. Over the period of time,
managers will be enabled to take those decisions and his productivity and performance will increase. This
becomes extremely important at the time of tremendous requirement to grow. Taking decisions to tweak
service requirements are must for responsiveness to customers’ ever evolving requirements.”
Third is keeping employees energized, so that they take one extra step and are happy to contribute to
business. This is done by creating happy employees through sense of belongingness and sense of contribution
to the organization. MD Solutions keeps its employees energized by creating comprehensive award mechanism.
Speaking about the mechanism, Sandeep explained, “People need to be appreciated. We created an atmosphere
wherein people are appreciated and they are good for each other. We developed a comprehensive award
mechanism which is in line with business. It is not that somebody appreciated you, and you take this award.
So that award has to be in line with the business goal. Therefore, we developed the comprehensive star
awards. We call it star awards. The moment, person is appreciated and told he did these-these things; this
creates the culture of appreciation which is contagious. But one has to be objective and specific in terms of
10 © www.etcases.com
Organizational growth: Integrating Business and HR at MD Solutions| HRM-1-0045
what job the appreciated person has done. Unless this is specific and quantifiable, appreciation will be
looked upon as biased.”
Way forward
Accepting the challenges of growth, MD Solutions look to maintain and grow its customer base and employee
base. Five years down the line, company aims to more than triple its customer base. Founders know that
aligning business strategy of growth with requirements of external customers (clients) and capital of internal
customers (human resource) is the key. Although lot has been done for aligning business with HR, still lot
needs to be done; this is where the challenge lies for Sandeep.
© www.etcases.com 11