Document From Indra
Document From Indra
Document From Indra
net/publication/370761802
CITATIONS READS
0 61
3 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohammad Ahmad Abd-erRazik on 14 May 2023.
Background: Cryptoglandular perianal fistulas are a frequent problem, and the traditional surgical procedure
carries a risk of incontinence and recurrence. The ultimate goal of fistula management is to resolve and prevent
sepsis, eradicate the fistula, prevent recurrence, and ensure continence. Laser Ablation of Fistula Tract (LAFT)
offers a viable alternative sphincter-saving modality.
Patient and methods: In this study, we performed a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the safety and
efficacy of laser ablation as a treatment for transsphincteric fistulas. This study was conducted at Ain Shams
University hospitals from June 2019 to June 2022 and included eighty patients with cryptoglandular transsphincteric
fistulas who had undergone previous drainage and seton, they were divided into two groups. The first group (Group
A) underwent fistulectomy with subsequent sphincteroplasty while the second group (Group B) underwent laser
ablation of the fistula tract. Follow-up was scheduled in the outpatient clinic at 1 and 2 weeks and 1, 3, and 6
months postoperatively. The Cleveland Clinic Florida Fecal Incontinence CCF-FI score and the visual analog scale
(VAS) score were recorded at each visit.
Results: The results of the study showed that the laser ablation of the fistula track technique is a safe and effective
sphincter-saving modality for transsphincteric fistula management with acceptable healing rates. The technique
also carries the advantages of a short learning curve, reduced hospital stay, and minimal risk of incontinence.
Conclusion: Our study found that laser ablation is a safe and effective treatment option for transsphincteric
fistulas. Preliminary seton insertion may have a positive impact on postoperative outcome. However, there is a need
for further research to evaluate the long-term outcomes..
Key words: Anal fistulas, laser ablation, fistulectomy, transsphincteric fistulas, incontinence.
Results
Statistical analyses were conducted using SPSS, Postoperative continence was carefully assessed and
IBM. Corp, USA (Version 26.0), and MINITAB, USA recorded using CCF score. No significant statistical
difference was found in both groups.
Table 2: Mean operative time and mean hospital stay in both groups
Group A Group B
Statistical
Fistulectomy and Laser ablation of P value
significance
sphincterolplasty fistulous tracr
Mean operative time 47.025 37.750 0.000 Significance difference
Mean hospital stay 2.00 1.08 0.000 Significance difference
Table 3: Vas scores in the first, first and second week in both groups
Group A Group B
Statistical
Mean VAS score Fistulectomy and Laser ablation of P value
significance
sphincterolplasty fistulous tract
First day 5.18 3.88 0.000 Significance difference
First week 3.85 2.4 0.000 Significance difference
Second Week 2.02 1.5 0.001 Significance difference
(2) 2.5%
(0) 97.5% (0) 100%
Second month 0.317 No significance difference
(1) 2.5%
According to Giamundo et al., the cost of the fistula Terzi and colleagues studied 103 patients with fistula
laser closure technique is higher than other sphincter- disease in a study that evaluated the effectiveness of
saving procedures because of the equipment the laser closure procedure. The average age of the
needed. However, the laser device is portable and patients was 43 years. Out of the 103 patients, 53
has multiple surgical uses, such as treating varicose (52%) had undergone previous surgery for perianal
veins. This allows for multiple specialists to use the fistula repair and 29 (28%) had transsphincteric
equipment in one hospital, which can lower costs. fistulas. The results of the study showed that 41
Additionally, although the cost of laser fibers is patients (40%) experienced complete healing, 38
moderate, it is still less expensive than most fistula (37%) still had persistent drainage with symptoms,
plugs.8 20 (19%) had minor drainage with minor symptoms,
and 4 (4%) had painful symptoms with drainage.15
They found that the fistula laser closure technique
(FiLaC™) is a safe option for treating anal fistulas, Suhardja et al., from their center in Australia,
as it does not require additional surgical procedures evaluated the effectiveness of the fistula laser
to close the internal orifice. The technique has an closure technique FiLaC™ on transsphincteric
acceptable success rate and low complications, fistulas. They determined that FiLaC is a viable
making it a desirable choice for patients with weak option for complex fistulas with benefits such as
sphincters. They recommend using a loose seton to not impacting sphincter function, having a short
prepare the fistula track before the procedure, as learning curve, reducing post-operative hospital
this may improve healing outcomes. Overall, they stay, and having success rates comparable to other
suggest that this technique should be considered as surgical procedures for the management of complex
part of the treatment plan for complex fistulas, as it fistulas.16
preserves continence.8
They proposed that the use of laser ablation to
Wolicki conducted a retrospective study of 83 preserve the sphincter is a viable initial treatment
patients who were treated with Fistula-tract Laser option for complex fistulas, but further evaluation
Closure (FiLaC®), Ceralas® or Leonardo® DUAL 45 of its cost-effectiveness is necessary, particularly in
diode laser for transsphincteric and intersphincteric cases where multiple surgeries may be required due
anal fistulas. The procedure included the closure of to higher recurrence rates.16
the internal orifice using a simple 3-0 Z-stitch and
had a mean follow-up period of 41.99 (± 21.59) In our study, 80 patients with transsphincteric fistulas
months. The results showed that 15.7% of patients who had undergone preliminary seton insertion
had a recurrence, 78.3% had prior abscess drainage were randomly divided into two groups. The first
and seton insertion, and 74.7% experienced primary group underwent fistulectomy with subsequent
healing. 9.6% of patients reported changes in sphincter repair, while the second group underwent
continence, but no major incontinence was reported laser ablation of the fistula tract.
postoperatively.14 Analysis of our results clearly demonstrates a
Lauretta and colleagues conducted a retrospective statistical significance in favor of laser ablation
study on 30 patients with a median age of 52 years procedure in terms of operative time, hospital
who were treated with a laser for transsphincteric stay, postoperative VAS scores, time for complete
anal fistulas. They used a diode laser emitting 12 healing, thus may justify the recorded differences of
watts of energy at a wavelength of 1470 nm. The recurrence rates which were statistically significant
study found that a cure was achieved in 10 patients in favor of fistulectomy and sphicteroplasty. No
(33.3%) and an overall healing rate of 40% (12 out significant statistical difference regarding post-
of 30). Only 4 minor complications occurred, which operative complication and recorded CCF score.
is a rate of 13.3%. No changes in anal continence Laser ablation has a clearly positive impact on
were reported.14 patient’s quality of life which may attract more
attention in further studies. We believe that
Nordholm-Carstensen and colleagues examined progressive improvement in this relatively new
the effectiveness of the FiLaC™ technique in a technique will positively affect the recurrence rate
study of 66 patients with various types of anal especially in the management of this difficult type
1. Ratto C, Grossi U, Litta F, et al: Contemporary 12. Wilhelm A, Fiebig A, Krawczak M: Five years of
surgical practice in the management of anal experience with the FiLaC™ laser for fistula-in-
fistula: Results from an international survey. ano management: Long-term follow-up from a
Techniques in Coloproctology. 2019; 23: 729- single institution.Techniques in Coloproctology.
741. 2017; (21): 269–276.
14. Lauretta A, Falco N, Stocco E, Bellomo R, 16. Suhardja T, Lim J, Duieb Z, Nguyen T, Teoh
Infantino A. Anal Fistula Laser Closure: The W, Chouhan H: How to do a fistula tract Laser
length of fistula is the Achilles’ heel. Tech Closure (FiLaC) for trans-sphincteric fistula-in-
Coloproctol. 2018; 22(12): 933-939. ano. ANZ J Surg. 2021; 91(6): 1292-1294.