18 1 AV Chandrasekaran
18 1 AV Chandrasekaran
18 1 AV Chandrasekaran
A.V. Chandrasekaran*
Introduction
A maritime country requires a maritime defence and associated maritime
capabilities, and India is no exception to this rule. India by geography is a
maritime country with a coastline that exceeds 7,516 km and touches nine
states. It lies surrounded by the Bay of Bengal in the east, the Indian Ocean
* Gp Capt A.V. Chandrasekaran is a retired officer from the Indian Air Force (IAF), and
in a career spanning 35 years the officer has held varied appointments.
in the south and the Arabian Sea in the west. It has a chain of islands on
both its eastern and western flanks, which serve as a bulwark in ensuring
India’s extended Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). These chains of islands
are India’s most tangible strategic assets. In addition to being both vital and
vulnerable, these can easily be transformed into islands of opportunity. Most
of these assets remain uninhabited and pose certain pressing challenges to
India’s coastal security.
The Indian Ocean is one of the five great oceans of the world, with
its own distinguishing features. It is measuredly predominant due to its
conveyance avenue that accounts for more than 80 per cent of the world’s
seaborne oil and trade transit and the deployment of considerable military
forces. A dynamic security environment in the Indian Ocean Region
(IOR) has brokered a competition for regional influence by regional
and extra regional powers. India’s problems get accentuated due to the
presence of inimical countries that pose challenges to its territorial security
through both conventional and unconventional threats, contesting India’s
dominance in the Indian Ocean.
India is the most capable resident power in the Indian Ocean,
but its expanding military footprint is uneven and reliant on multiple
factors. A serious strategic forecasting is essential to ensure that India’s
maritime vulnerabilities get addressed by the execution of the national
security policy. India is endowed with the Andaman & Nicobar islands
in its eastern flank and the Lakshadweep islands in its western flank.
The eastern flank is militarily well covered, but the same cannot be said
about the western flank. Lakshadweep is a cluster of islands situated in
the Arabian Sea, off the southwestern coast of the Indian mainland. It is
a designated ‘Union Territory’ of India and guards the nation’s maritime
frontiers. However, the island chain of Lakshadweep and Minicoy needs
to be militarily shored up to meet the growing challenges in the region.
This paper aims to discuss the necessity of building a runway on Minicoy
by the Indian Air Force (IAF) and operationalising it to be used as a
dual-purpose runway with accessibility by all the four military services
and commercial aircraft. Additionally, it would support the development
of a military establishment in tandem with the necessary research and
development back up and logistical support. This runway could be geo-
strategically decisive for India.
90 Journal of Defence Studies
constant monitoring of these islands and with the available assets this
would be a difficult task to perform.
• The presence of floating armouries, which are vessels that provide
offshore storage of weapons and security equipment in the Galle
region of Sri Lanka and areas close to our western coast, is a cause
for growing concern. These armouries are used by Private Maritime
Security Companies (PMSC) and are manned by Privately Contracted
Armed Security Personnel (PCASP) who tend to operate without any
governmental oversight and are primarily to provide security to merchant
vessels from any acts of piracy or maritime terrorism. These unregulated
floating armouries carrying combatants of specific countries can pose a
real danger to Indian coastal regions and facilitate terrorist infiltrations,
like the one witnessed during the Mumbai siege. The continued presence
of these armed PCASP can lead to the militarisation of the maritime
domain, with possible adverse consequences for local communities.5 The
killing of two Indian fisherman by Italian marines who mistook them
for pirates in February 2012, and the seizure of the American floating
armoury MV Seaman Guard Ohio off the coast of Tuticorin in Tamil
Nadu in October 2013 are noteworthy for the brazenness of the actions
and the utter disregard for international law. The possibility of these
floating armouries being forcibly taken over by terrorists for carrying out
attacks on Indian installations cannot be ruled out. Furthermore, the
vessels currently being used as floating armouries are not purpose-built as
an armoury, instead they are adapted crafts. As a result, these vessels may
not have safe and secure storage for arms and ammunition and can lead
to mid sea accidents with dangerous consequences.
• The island chain’s adjacency to the Maldives is seen as an extra concern.
Indian security agencies fear that Lakshadweep’s population would be
easy prey for Maldivian anti-national outfits.
• With Mohammed Muizzu, an avowed Chinese backer, at the helm of
Maldivian affairs, there is the possibility of the maritime observatory
station in Makunudhoo being revived, which was put on hold by the
previous government. Maldives is one of the closest islands to India and
its support would enable the Chinese to access the shipping route channel
via the Indian Ocean, potentially facilitating the opening of a maritime
front against India. The northern-most island in the Maldives is just 70
nautical miles away from Minicoy, which is a matter of concern.
• There is also the possibility of China using its presence in the IOR via
the Gwadar Port. The development of Gwadar’s airfield may make it the
92 Journal of Defence Studies
Adversary Approaches
India needs to outline the objective of increasing its ability to defend its
coastal areas, straits and surrounding waters from the Chinese Navy and
also from certain friendly nations who do not hesitate in violating India’s
territorial integrity, as witnessed in April 2021. It was USS John Paul Jones, a
warship belonging to the United States 7th Fleet, that carried out a freedom
of navigation exercise near the Lakshadweep islands without seeking India’s
prior consent. Instead of deterring adversaries this unwarranted action
successfully managed to alienate friends. It makes one wonder whether to
view it as a continuation of America’s gun-boat diplomacy or is it the new
American gun-boat democracy? It was in 1971 that US President Richard
Nixon had despatched the 7th Fleet to the Bay of Bengal to deter India. Not
coincidently, exactly 50 years after this incident, in 2021 a US warship from
the same 7th Fleet violates India’s sovereignty, which is a disquieting puzzle.
Is it a historical message? The 7th Fleet has created an infamous reputation
in India’s strategic consciousness, which cannot be easily erased.6 These
Freedom of Navigation Operations (FONOPs) being carried out by the US
Navy can diminish India’s credibility to deter China’s encroachment into
India’s maritime zone of influence. After all, the legitimacy of India’s position
Militarisation of Minicoy Island 93
hinges on an equal application of the law on all, whether friend or foe, and
may force India not to bring USA in its circle of trust.
The rise of China has altered India’s geopolitical imperative and there is a
necessity to make urgent informed strategic decisions before the effects become
disastrous. It is a known fact that China does not have any fundamental
respect for institutional norms as was evident when it did not bother about
the adjudication by the arbitral tribunal based in Hague in 2016 against it
for violating Philippine’s territories. China has steadfastly begun to assemble
strategic ascendancy in South Asia and the Indian Ocean through a sizeable
programme of security assistance, including military diplomacy and the
construction of infrastructure such as ports. It has rapidly increased its direct
military presence in the region through an ostensible Gulf of Aden antipiracy
task force. The People’s Liberation Army Navy (PLAN) now regularly sails
surface combatants, submarines and oceanographic survey ships through the
Indian Ocean. Given this environment the helipad on Minicoy Island is too
limited to support realistic military activity on the atoll, thus supporting plans
to develop a full-scale military air base with a runway for land-based aircraft.
high degree of adaptability while telegraphing the resolve to use them if the
need so arises, which will improve the prospects for deterring opponents,
and thereby preserving peace.
will enhance the ability to engage hostile elements as far from the Indian
shores as possible. Additionally, electronic monitoring of the IOR could also
be effectively carried out by establishing units with holistic capability on
Minicoy.
Requirement Analysis
The Indian defence budget is a huge guzzler of money and for obvious reasons
involving both conventional and non-conventional threats, India can least
afford to lower its guard in military preparedness. Under such compelling
financial constraints, the investment in airpower through the air base in
Minicoy is low risk because it will leverage both proven capabilities and
performance in operations, training, sustainment and innovation. Its value
for money is diverse from increasing India’s sovereign options to effective
power projection and deterrence. Single investments pay off in multiple areas
and easily bridge the gap between desirability and feasibility.
The problem of land acquisition would not arise as the land lies under
the control of the Indian government and technical parameters such as
approach to the runway, history of wind and weather conditions, the
length of the runway with its run out area, the link and parallel taxi
tracks, aircraft take-off weight, and land for housing the ATC, aprons,
runway lighting, navigational aids and rapid exit taxiways can easily be
identified by domain specialists of the IAF. The necessity of establishing
the techno-economic and financial feasibility of the proposed development
can be looked after by the office of the air force. This should include
environmental concerns of airport operations as well the documentation
of policies and future aeronautical demand with reference to spending
and land use control.
The project can be effectively executed by the Military Engineering
Services (MES), which has decades of experience in construction and
maintenance of runways. The runways on the island chain of Andaman
& Nicobar are testimony to the efficacy of MES maintenance. Materials
required for construction of the runway can be easily shipped from Cochin,
which is one of the major cities in the state of Kerala and is relatively close
to Minicoy Island. Factors of sea erosion, rising sea temperatures, flooding,
sea retaining walls around the airfield, forecast of airport traffic, alternate
airfields in case of emergencies can all be considered for effective completion
of the project.
98 Journal of Defence Studies
Strategic Framework
The key to continued success for the IAF from peace to war is in finding
the right mix and balance of airpower capabilities. Changes in the security
environment after the rise of a belligerent China have helped to shape new
trajectories in Indian airpower to carry out conventional and nonconventional
military operations. The following strategic objectives would be achieved
through dedicated air effort at Minicoy:
1. Permanent military presence on Minicoy Island
2. Strengthened professional capabilities
3. Improved crisis management response
4. Prevention of interference from foreign actors
5. Provision of a more effective platform for furthering our interests in the
IOR
6. Better execution of our strategic objectives
7. Equipped to counter challenges posed by pirates in the IOR
8. Provision of a launch pad during symmetric and asymmetric conflicts
variants of aircraft. The planned transition will facilitate the operation of P-8l
Poseidon reconnaissance aircraft, which currently operate from Arakkonam
in Tamil Nadu.
The use of the P-8I from Agatti will enhance Indian surveillance reach to
as far as South Africa. It will also provide India an extended combat region
and enhance its combat credible posture. The ICG and the naval forces may
not be able to operate efficiently without close air support from the IAF;
Minicoy-based fighters can effectively carry out dual-role sorties thereby
looking after air-to-air and air-to-ground threats. The inter-component
coordination and planning mechanisms for joint air operations will be
effective for a variety of possible demand scenarios and the formulation of
integrated defence strategies.
Necessity of Haste
It has become imperative for India to maintain a striking force in a U
shape, embracing the Andaman & Nicobar group of islands and curving
into the Lakshadweep island chain thus enhancing our higher end joint
warfare capabilities. The island chains on either flank can effectively
function as unsinkable aircraft carriers and Minicoy Island if developed
into a full-fledged military base with a runway capable of taking all kind
of aircraft can be an effective counter against the Chinese and other forces.
In the event of any cross-strait blockade or a naval conflict, India’s main
advantage would be the availability of armed air cover. The availability of
combat aircraft on Minicoy would certainly deter adversaries from taking
any coercive action. This avenue of weakness should be converted into an
outpost of strength.
The island-based airpower can travel at great speeds and can be quickly
deployed to a hot spot to immediately begin combat operations. On the
contrary, even with advance warning the IN and ICG ships will always be
limited by the time it takes them to reach a given point of conflict. The selective
use of land-based airpower affords India a cost effective and quick alternative
to engage an enemy navy or perform a variety of maritime missions. The IAF
operating out of Minicoy would certainly provide the Theatre Commander
commanding the Peninsular Command, probably in Karwar, Karnataka, a
flexible and responsive force. The composition can be a specially tailored
package, which can include support and strike aircraft such as the Maritime
Strike Jaguars and Sukhoi-30 of the IAF, which can be quickly deployed
and be ready for sustained combat operations. Such aircraft can comfortably
engage enemy shipping with the Precision Guided Munitions (PGMs) and
100 Journal of Defence Studies
The dynamic joint operating constructs and agile tactical tools will
provide the necessary supportive framework for our forces to thrive in
complexity, take the right risks and defeat our adversaries cognitively whilst
kinetically project the country beyond its international borders.
Conclusion
With the increased threats of a hegemonic Chinese and a spate of asymmetrical
menace, India can ill afford to sit tight and allow things to escalate. With
favoured holdings in our western flank the Indian effort must be to rapidly
modernise the military presence in the Lakshadweep cluster of islands and
build a runway post haste in Minicoy to mitigate a number of intimidating
factors. Once constructed the runway will prove not only invaluable for
the islanders but also boost India’s muscular posture in the Indian Ocean,
making big powers think twice before attempting provocative gestures. This
in addition to enabling India to extend the arm of protection to smaller,
like-minded countries will allow Lakshadweep to offer a secondary base for
maritime co-operation with Mauritius, Seychelles and the Maldives.
Notes
1. Dr G Shreekumar Menon, ‘Uninhabited Islands of Lakshadweep – A Major Security
Threat’, Chanakya Forum, 9 March 2024, available at https://chanakyaforum.
com/uninhabited-islands-of-lakshadweep-a-major-security-threat/, accessed on 12
October 2023.
2. Government of India, Ministry of MSME, ‘BRIEF INDUSTRIAL PROFILE OF
LAKSHADWEEP’, available at https://dcmsme.gov.in/old/dips/state_wise_dips/
lakshadweep_28316.pdf, accessed on 12 October 2023.
Militarisation of Minicoy Island 103
3. Mritunjay Bose, ‘Rs 3, 000 Crore Plus Drugs Seized by Coast Guard off Minicoy
Island’, Deccan Herald, 17 August 2021, available at https://www.deccanherald.com/
india/rs-3000-crore-plus-drugs-seized-by-coast-guard-off-minicoy-island-966618.
html, accessed on 12 October 2023.
4. Ruki Fernando, ‘Rescued at Sea, Why Do Rohingya Refugees End Up in Sri
Lankan Detention Centres?’, Global Voices, available at https://globalvoices.
org/2023/01/17/rescued-at-sea-why-do-rohingya-refugees-end-up-in-sri-lanka-
detention-centers/#:~:text=the%20Jaffna%20prison.-,It%20is%20not%20
clear%20under%20what%20legal%20provisions%20they%20were,from%20
a%20boat%20in%20distress, accessed on 12 October 2023.
5. Ioannis Chapsos and Paul Holtom, Stockpiles at Sea: Floating Armouries in the
Indian Ocean, available at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334164500.
stockpiles_at_sea_floating_armouries_in_the_indian_ocean, accessed on 12
October 2023.
6. Abhijnan Rej, ‘US Destroyer Carries Out FONOP in Indian EEZ’, The Diplomat, 8
April 2021, available at https://thediplomat.com/2021/04/us-destroyer-carries-out-
fonop-in-indian-eez/, accessed on 06 October 2023.
7. Rakesh K Simha, ‘Carrier-Killer: Why India Needs a Maritime Strike Bomber’,
Raksha Anirveda, 28 July 2022, available at https://raksha-anirveda.com/carrier-
killer-why-india-needs-a-maritime-strike-bomber/, accessed on 26 February 2023
8. Praveer Purohit, ‘Air Power at Sea Requires a Big Boost’, Financial Express, 14 June
2023, available at https://www.financialexpress.com/business/defence-air-power-at-
sea-requires-a-big-boost-3125656/, accessed on 14 October 2023.
9. PK Balachandran, ‘The Strategic Significance of Lakshadweep Islands for India’,
The Citizen, 16 June 2021, available at https://www.thecitizen.in/index.php/en/
NewsDetail/index/6/20495/The-Strategic-Significance-of-Lakshadweep-Islands-
for-India, accessed on 11 October 2023.
10. Mariyam Umna Ismail, ‘Minicoy Was Never Part of Maldives: Aslam’, Atoll Times,
25 August 2022, available at https://atolltimes.mv/post/news/45, accessed on 12
October 2023.
11. Siddharth Roy, ‘Is It a Necessity to Militarize the Lakshadweep Islands?’, The
Sentinel, 29 April 2023, available at https://www.sentinelassam.com/editorial/is-it-
a-necessity-to-militarize-the-lakshadweep-islands-647518