Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 2 views

    RIO Comparision

    Uploaded by

    Mahesh Chaudhari

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    RIO Comparision

    Uploaded by

    Mahesh Chaudhari
    2 views1 page

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    2 views1 page

    RIO Comparision

    Uploaded by

    Mahesh Chaudhari

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 1

    Comparison

    color explanation: green = advantage (USP)


    orange = could be a disadvantage
    red = clear disadvantage

    Supplier R. STAHL P+F Turck


    Product name IS1+ FB Excom
    available since: 1999 (IS1) / 2013 (IS1+) 1998 2000
    Mechanical:
    mechnical concept modules modules Eurocards (open PCBs)
    Installation on Standard DIN rail (EN 60715 ) motherboard motherboard
    Installation in enclosures customized and standard customized and standard pre-defined enclosures
    Installation direction vertical & horizontal horizontal horizontal
    Temperature range -20…+65 °C -20…+60 °C -20…+70 °C
    (IS1+: -40…+75 °C) (power calculation required)
    available terminals screw, spring clamp screw, spring clamp screw, spring clamp
    detachable terminals yes yes yes
    max. cable connection 2.5 mm² / 1.5 mm² (non-I.S.) 1.5 mm² 1.5 mm²
    footprint typical system medium - large medium small
    Similar Zone 2 version? yes (I.S & non-I.S. modules) no yes (only I.S. modules)
    Experience system solutions high medium medium
    Available accessories/boxes high medium - high medium
    I/O-Modules
    mixture I.S./non-I.S. modules yes yes no
    hot-swap I/O-modules yes yes yes
    status LEDs line fault per channel, status per line fault per module (1 LED), line fault per channel, status per
    channel (DI/DO), module status (3 module status (1 LED) channel (DI/DO), module status (2
    or 4 LED) LED)
    no. of I/O modules per system 8 (under all conditions) max. 24 (power calculation 16 (under all conditions)
    required)
    max. no. of analog I/O 64 80 64
    max. no. of digital I/O 128 184 128
    Multifunctional modules AI/AO, DI/DO, Temp. no DI/DO
    Accuracy measurement 0.05% 0.10% 0.10%
    Influence ambient temp. 0,03% / 10 K 0,1%/10 K 0,01%/10 K
    Resolution 14,75 bit 12 bit 14 bit
    Analog I/O- modules 8 channels 4 channels 4 channels
    Digital Input modules 16 channels 8 channels 8 channels
    Digital Output modules 4 + 8 channels 4 channels 4 channels
    Pneumatic modules 8 channels no no
    Relay module (230 VAC) 6/8 channels no no
    Frequency signals 8 channels (max. 20 kHz) 1 channel (max. 15 kHz) 2 channels (max. 4 kHz)
    Temperature Input RTD 8 channels 4 channels 4 channels
    Temperature Input TC 8 channels 4 channels 4 channels
    Digital output with plant-stop yes (SIL2) yes (SIL2) no
    Safety I/O-modules yes (AI with SIL2) no no
    Communication & Diagnostics
    Hot-swap CPU & Power yes yes yes
    Hot-swap fieldbus/Ethernet yes no yes
    Fieldbus protocols PROFIBUS DP, PROFIsafe, PROFIBUS DP, Modbus RTU, FF PROFIBUS DP
    Modbus RTU H1
    Explosion protection fieldbus Ex i Ex e Ex i
    Ethernet protocols Modbus TCP, EtherNet/IP, Modbus TCP (max. 10 Mbit) ---
    PROFINET, F-ROM
    Explosion protection Ethernet Ex op is Ex e ---
    Separate ServiceBus yes yes no
    System parameterization GSD, GSDML, DTM, IS Wizard GSD, DTM GSD, DTM
    Ease of configuration easy average easy
    (customer feedback)
    Profibus DP support data exchange, config, HART, data exchange, config, HART, data exchange, config, HART,
    diagnostics diagnostics diagnostics
    Maintenance alarm NE107 yes (blue LED + telegram) no no
    DTM support Communication, Diagnostics, Communication, Diagnostics, Communication, Diagnostics,
    HART, Configuration HART, Configuration HART, Configuration
    Webserver yes no no
    Changes in Run parameters, config (depends on parameters, config (depends on parameters, config (depends on
    DCS & protocol) DCS & protocol) DCS & protocol)
    Certifications
    Ex certifications ATEX, IECEx, EAC, FM (US+CA), ATEX, EAC ATEX, FM (US+CA), EAC,
    IZP, PESO, INMETRO INMETRO

    Ship certifications DNV-GL, LR, BV, ABS, ClassNK, DNV-GL, BV, LR DNV-GL, LR, BV
    RS, RINA, KRS
    Other certifications PROFIBUS DP, PROFINET, FDT --- ---

    Prices
    Standard system price medium medium low
    Manufacturing costs low medium medium
    Market pricing in the past medium medium medium - low
    References
    Couplings with DCS / PLC many many medium
    Installations worldwide high medium - high medium
    Experience with remote I/O 30 years 15 years 15 years
    Experience with DCS Yokogawa, Honeywell, Emerson, Yokogawa, Honeywell, Emerson, Yokogawa, Emerson, Siemens,
    Invensys, Siemens, ABB, Invensys, Siemens, ABB, ABB
    Rockwell, Schneider Rockwell

    13.09.2017 - INTERNAL USE ONLY - 1/1

    You might also like